Valuation (geometry) explained
In geometry, a valuation is a finitely additive function from a collection of subsets of a set
to an abelian
semigroup. For example,
Lebesgue measure is a valuation on finite unions of
convex bodies of
Other examples of valuations on finite unions of convex bodies of
are
surface area,
mean width, and
Euler characteristic.
In geometry, continuity (or smoothness) conditions are often imposed on valuations, but there are also purely discrete facets of the theory. In fact, the concept of valuation has its origin in the dissection theory of polytopes and in particular Hilbert's third problem, which has grown into a rich theory reliant on tools from abstract algebra.
Definition
Let
be a set, and let
be a collection of subsets of
A function
on
with values in an abelian semigroup
is called a
valuation if it satisfies
whenever
and
are elements of
If
then one always assumes
Examples
Some common examples of
are
Let
be the set of convex bodies in
Then some valuations on
are
- intrinsic volume (and, more generally, mixed volume)
- the map
where
is the
support function of
Some other valuations are
- the lattice point enumerator
, where
is a lattice polytope
Valuations on convex bodies
From here on, let
, let
be the set of convex bodies in
, and let
be a valuation on
.
We say
is
translation invariant if, for all
and
, we have
.
Let
. The
Hausdorff distance
is defined as
where
is the
-neighborhood of
under some Euclidean inner product. Equipped with this metric,
is a
locally compact space.
The space of continuous, translation-invariant valuations from
to
is denoted by
The topology on
is the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets of
Equipped with the norm
where
is a bounded subset with nonempty interior,
is a
Banach space.
Homogeneous valuations
A translation-invariant continuous valuation
\phi\in\operatorname{Val}(V)
is said to be
-homogeneous if
for all
and
The subset
of
-homogeneous valuations is a vector subspace of
McMullen's decomposition theorem states that
In particular, the degree of a homogeneous valuation is always an integer between
and
Valuations are not only graded by the degree of homogeneity, but also by the parity with respect to the reflection through the origin, namely where
\phi\in
| \epsilon |
\operatorname{Val} | |
| i |
with
if and only if
for all convex bodies
The elements of
and
are said to be
even and
odd, respectively.
It is a simple fact that
is
-dimensional and spanned by the Euler characteristic
that is, consists of the constant valuations on
In 1957 Hadwiger proved that
(where
) coincides with the
-dimensional space of Lebesgue measures on
A valuation
\phi\in\operatorname{Val}(\Rn)
is
simple if
for all convex bodies with
Schneider in 1996 described all simple valuations on
: they are given by
where
is an arbitrary odd function on the unit sphere
and
is the surface area measure of
In particular, any simple valuation is the sum of an
- and an
-homogeneous valuation. This in turn implies that an
-homogeneous valuation is uniquely determined by its restrictions to all
-dimensional subspaces.
Embedding theorems
The Klain embedding is a linear injection of
the space of even
-homogeneous valuations, into the space of continuous sections of a canonical complex line bundle over the Grassmannian
of
-dimensional linear subspaces of
Its construction is based on Hadwiger's characterization of
-homogeneous valuations. If
\phi\in\operatorname{Val}i(V)
and
E\in\operatorname{Gr}i(V),
then the restriction
is an element
and by Hadwiger's theorem it is a Lebesgue measure. Hence
defines a continuous section of the line bundle
over
with fiber over
equal to the
-dimensional space
of
densities (Lebesgue measures) on
Theorem (Klain). The linear map
\operatorname{Kl}:
| +(V)\to |
\operatorname{Val} | |
| i |
C(\operatorname{Gr}i(V),\operatorname{Dens})
is injective.
A different injection, known as the Schneider embedding, exists for odd valuations. It is based on Schneider's description of simple valuations. It is a linear injection of
the space of odd
-homogeneous valuations, into a certain quotient of the space of continuous sections of a line bundle over the partial flag manifold of cooriented pairs
Its definition is reminiscent of the Klain embedding, but more involved. Details can be found in.
The Goodey-Weil embedding is a linear injection of
into the space of distributions on the
-fold product of the
-dimensional sphere. It is nothing but the
Schwartz kernel of a natural polarization that any
\phi\in\operatorname{Val}k(V)
admits, namely as a functional on the
-fold product of
the latter space of functions having the geometric meaning of differences of support functions of smooth convex bodies. For details, see.
Irreducibility Theorem
The classical theorems of Hadwiger, Schneider and McMullen give fairly explicit descriptions of valuations that are homogeneous of degree
and
But for degrees
very little was known before the turn of the 21st century. McMullen's conjecture is the statement that the valuations
span a dense subspace of
McMullen's conjecture was confirmed by
Alesker in a much stronger form, which became known as the Irreducibility Theorem:
Theorem (Alesker). For every
the natural action of
on the spaces
and
is irreducible.
on
is given by
The proof of the Irreducibility Theorem is based on the embedding theorems of the previous section and
Beilinson-Bernstein localization.
Smooth valuations
A valuation
\phi\in\operatorname{Val}(V)
is called
smooth if the map
from
to
is smooth. In other words,
is smooth if and only if
is a smooth vector of the natural representation of
on
The space of smooth valuations
\operatorname{Val}infty(V)
is dense in
; it comes equipped with a natural Fréchet-space topology, which is finer than the one induced from
For every (complex-valued) smooth function
on
where
denotes the orthogonal projection and
is the Haar measure, defines a smooth even valuation of degree
It follows from the Irreducibility Theorem, in combination with the Casselman-Wallach theorem, that any smooth even valuation can be represented in this way. Such a representation is sometimes called a
Crofton formula.
\omega\in\Omegan-1(\Rn x Sn-1)
that is invariant under all the translations
and every number
integration over the
normal cycle defines a smooth valuation:As a set, the normal cycle
consists of the outward unit normals to
The Irreducibility Theorem implies that every smooth valuation is of this form.
Operations on translation-invariant valuations
There are several natural operations defined on the subspace of smooth valuations
\operatorname{Val}infty(V)\subset\operatorname{Val}(V).
The most important one is the product of two smooth valuations. Together with pullback and pushforward, this operation extends to valuations on manifolds.
Exterior product
Let
be finite-dimensional real vector spaces. There exists a bilinear map, called the exterior product,
which is uniquely characterized by the following two properties:
- it is continuous with respect to the usual topologies on
and
\phi=\operatorname{vol}V(\bullet+A)
and
\psi=\operatorname{vol}W(\bullet+B)
where
and
are convex bodies with smooth boundary and strictly positive Gauss curvature, and
and
are densities on
and
then
Product
The product of two smooth valuations
\phi,\psi\in\operatorname{Val}infty(V)
is defined by
where
is the diagonal embedding. The product is a continuous map
Equipped with this product,
\operatorname{Val}infty(V)
becomes a commutative associative graded algebra with the Euler characteristic as the multiplicative identity.
Alesker-Poincaré duality
By a theorem of Alesker, the restriction of the product is a non-degenerate pairing. This motivates the definition of the
-homogeneous
generalized valuation, denoted
| -infty |
\operatorname{Val} | |
| k |
(V),
as
| infty |
\operatorname{Val} | |
| n-k |
(V)* ⊗ \operatorname{Dens}(V),
topologized with the weak topology. By the Alesker-Poincaré duality, there is a natural dense inclusion
| -infty |
\operatorname{Val} | |
| k |
(V)/
Convolution
Convolution is a natural product on
\operatorname{Val}infty(V) ⊗ \operatorname{Dens}(V*).
For simplicity, we fix a density
on
to trivialize the second factor. Define for fixed
with smooth boundary and strictly positive Gauss curvature
There is then a unique extension by continuity to a map
called the convolution.Unlike the product, convolution respects the co-grading, namely if
| infty |
\phi\in\operatorname{Val} | |
| n-i |
(V),
| infty |
\psi\in\operatorname{Val} | |
| n-j |
(V),
then
\phi\ast\psi\in
| infty |
\operatorname{Val} | |
| n-i-j |
(V).
For instance, let
denote the mixed volume of the convex bodies
If convex bodies
in
with a smooth boundary and strictly positive Gauss curvature are fixed, then
\phi(K)=V(K[i],A1,...,An-i)
defines a smooth valuation of degree
The convolution two such valuations is
where
is a constant depending only on
Fourier transform
The Alesker-Fourier transform is a natural,
-equivariant isomorphism of complex-valued valuations
discovered by Alesker and enjoying many properties resembling the classical Fourier transform, which explains its name.
It reverses the grading, namely
| infty(V) |
F:\operatorname{Val} | |
| k |
\to
| infty |
\operatorname{Val} | |
| n-k |
(V*) ⊗ \operatorname{Dens}(V),
and intertwines the product and the convolution:
Fixing for simplicity a Euclidean structure to identify
\operatorname{Dens}(V)=\Complex,
we have the identity
On even valuations, there is a simple description of the Fourier transform in terms of the Klain embedding:
\operatorname{Kl}F\phi(E)=
| \perp). |
\operatorname{Kl} | |
| \phi(E |
In particular, even real-valued valuations remain real-valued after the Fourier transform.
For odd valuations, the description of the Fourier transform is substantially more involved. Unlike the even case, it is no longer of purely geometric nature. For instance, the space of real-valued odd valuations is not preserved.
Pullback and pushforward
Given a linear map
there are induced operations of pullback
f*:\operatorname{Val}(V)\to\operatorname{Val}(U)
and pushforward
| *\to |
f | |
| *:\operatorname{Val}(U) ⊗ \operatorname{Dens}(U) |
\operatorname{Val}(V) ⊗ \operatorname{Dens}(V)*.
The pullback is the simpler of the two, given by
It evidently preserves the parity and degree of homogeneity of a valuation. Note that the pullback does not preserve smoothness when
is not injective.
The pushforward is harder to define formally. For simplicity, fix Lebesgue measures on
and
The pushforward can be uniquely characterized by describing its action on valuations of the form
\operatorname{vol}(\bullet+A),
for all
and then extended by continuity to all valuations using the Irreducibility Theorem. For a surjective map
For an inclusion
choose a splitting
Then
Informally, the pushforward is dual to the pullback with respect to the Alesker-Poincaré pairing: for
\phi\in\operatorname{Val}(V)
and
\psi\in\operatorname{Val}(U) ⊗ \operatorname{Dens}(U)*,
However, this identity has to be carefully interpreted since the pairing is only well-defined for smooth valuations. For further details, see.
Valuations on manifolds
In a series of papers beginning in 2006, Alesker laid down the foundations for a theory of valuations on manifolds that extends the theory of valuations on convex bodies. The key observation leading to this extension is that via integration over the normal cycle, a smooth translation-invariant valuation may be evaluated on sets much more general than convex ones. Also suggests to define smooth valuations in general by dropping the requirement that the form
be translation-invariant and by replacing the translation-invariant Lebesgue measure with an arbitrary smooth measure.
Let
be an n-dimensional smooth manifold and let
be the co-sphere bundle of
that is, the oriented projectivization of the cotangent bundle. Let
denote the collection of compact differentiable polyhedra in
The normal cycle
of
which consists of the outward co-normals to
is naturally a Lipschitz submanifold of dimension
For ease of presentation we henceforth assume that
is oriented, even though the concept of smooth valuations in fact does not depend on orientability. The space of smooth valuations
on
consists of functions
of the form
where
and
can be arbitrary. It was shown by Alesker that the smooth valuations on open subsets of
form a soft sheaf over
Examples
The following are examples of smooth valuations on a smooth manifold
:
and
were constructed to represent the Euler characteristic. In particular,
is then the
Chern-Gauss-Bonnet integrand, which is the Pfaffian of the Riemannian curvature tensor.
is Riemannian, then the Lipschitz-Killing valuations or intrinsic volumes
are smooth valuations. If
is any
isometric immersion into a Euclidean space, then
where
denotes the usual intrinsic volumes on
(see below for the definition of the pullback). The existence of these valuations is the essence of Weyl's tube formula.
be the
complex projective space, and let
denote the Grassmannian of all complex projective subspaces of fixed dimension
The function
where the integration is with respect to the Haar probability measure on
is a smooth valuation. This follows from the work of Fu.
Filtration
The space
admits no natural grading in general, however it carries a canonical filtration
Here
consists of the smooth measures on
and
is given by forms
in the ideal generated by
where
is the canonical projection.
The associated graded vector space
is canonically isomorphic to the space of smooth sections
where
| infty(TX) |
\operatorname{Val} | |
| i |
denotes the vector bundle over
such that the fiber over a point
is
| infty(T |
\operatorname{Val} | |
| x |
X),
the space of
-homogeneous smooth translation-invariant valuations on the tangent space
Product
The space
admits a natural product. This product is continuous, commutative, associative, compatible with the filtration:
and has the Euler characteristic as the identity element. It also commutes with the restriction to embedded submanifolds, and the diffeomorphism group of
acts on
by algebra automorphisms.
For example, if
is Riemannian, the Lipschitz-Killing valuations satisfy
The Alesker-Poincaré duality still holds. For compact
it says that the pairing
lVinfty(X) x lVinfty(X)\to\Complex,
(\phi,\psi)\mapsto(\phi ⋅ \psi)(X)
is non-degenerate. As in the translation-invariant case, this duality can be used to define generalized valuations. Unlike the translation-invariant case, no good definition of continuous valuations exists for valuations on manifolds.
The product of valuations closely reflects the geometric operation of intersection of subsets.Informally, consider the generalized valuation
\chiA=\chi(A\cap\bullet).
The product is given by
Now one can obtain smooth valuations by averaging generalized valuations of the form
more precisely
is a smooth valuation if
is a sufficiently large measured family of diffeomorphisms. Then one has
see.
Pullback and pushforward
Every smooth immersion
of smooth manifolds induces a pullback map
f*:lVinfty(Y)\tolVinfty(X).
If
is an embedding, then
The pullback is a morphism of filtered algebras.Every smooth proper submersion
defines a pushforward map
f*:lVinfty(X)\tolVinfty(Y)
by
The pushforward is compatible with the filtration as well:
For general smooth maps, one can define pullback and pushforward for generalized valuations under some restrictions.
Applications in Integral Geometry
Let
be a
Riemannian manifold and let
be a Lie group of isometries of
acting transitively on the sphere bundle
Under these assumptions the space
of
-invariant smooth valuations on
is finite-dimensional; let
be a basis. Let
be differentiable polyhedra in
Then integrals of the form
are expressible as linear combinations of
with coefficients
independent of
and
: Formulas of this type are called
kinematic formulas. Their existence in this generality was proved by Fu. For the three simply connected real space forms, that is, the sphere, Euclidean space, and hyperbolic space, they go back to
Blaschke,
Santaló,
Chern, and
Federer.
Describing the kinematic formulas explicitly is typically a difficult problem. In fact already in the step from real to complex space forms, considerable difficulties arise and these have only recently been resolved by Bernig, Fu, and Solanes.[1] The key insight responsible for this progress is that the kinematic formulas contain the same information as the algebra of invariant valuations
For a precise statement, let
be the kinematic operator, that is, the map determined by the kinematic formulas . Let
denote the Alesker-Poincaré duality, which is a linear isomorphism. Finally let
be the adjoint of the product map
The Fundamental theorem of algebraic integral geometry relating operations on valuations to integral geometry, states that if the Poincaré duality is used to identify
with
then
:
.
Bibliography
. S. Alesker. Semyon Alesker. Introduction to the theory of valuations. CBMS Regional Conference Series in Mathematics, 126. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI. 2018. 978-1-4704-4359-7.
. S. Alesker. Semyon Alesker. J. H. G. Fu. Integral geometry and valuations. Advanced Courses in Mathematics. CRM Barcelona.. Birkhäuser/Springer, Basel. 2014. 978-1-4704-4359-7.
- Book: D. A. Klain. G.-C. Rota. Gian-Carlo Rota. Introduction to geometric probability. Lezioni Lincee. [Lincei Lectures]. Cambridge University Press. 1997. 0-521-59362-X.
- Book: Rolf Schneider
. R. Schneider. Rolf Schneider. Convex bodies: the Brunn-Minkowski theory.. Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications, 151.. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, RI. 2014. 978-1-107-60101-7.
Notes and References
- 2