| Transmission of COVID-19 | |
| Synonyms: | Mode of spread of COVID-19 |
| Specialty: | Infection prevention and control |
| Types: | Respiratory droplet, airborne transmission, fomites |
| Prevention: | Face coverings, quarantine, physical/social distancing, ventilation, disinfection, hand washing, vaccination |
The transmission of COVID-19 is the passing of coronavirus disease 2019 from person to person. COVID-19 is mainly transmitted when people breathe in air contaminated by droplets/aerosols and small airborne particles containing the virus. Infected people exhale those particles as they breathe, talk, cough, sneeze, or sing.[1] [2] [3] [4] Transmission is more likely the closer people are. However, infection can occur over longer distances, particularly indoors.[5]
The transmission of the virus is carried out through virus-laden fluid particles, or droplets, which are created in the respiratory tract, and they are expelled by the mouth and the nose. There are three types of transmission: “droplet” and “contact”, which are associated with large droplets, and “airborne”, which is associated with small droplets.[6] If the droplets are above a certain critical size, they settle faster than they evaporate, and therefore they contaminate surfaces surrounding them. Droplets that are below a certain critical size, generally thought to be <100μm diameter, evaporate faster than they settle; due to that fact, they form respiratory aerosol particles that remain airborne for a long period of time over extensive distances.
Infectivity can begin four to five days before the onset of symptoms.[7] Infected people can spread the disease even if they are pre-symptomatic or asymptomatic.[8] Most commonly, the peak viral load in upper respiratory tract samples occurs close to the time of symptom onset and declines after the first week after symptoms begin.[8] Current evidence suggests a duration of viral shedding and the period of infectiousness of up to ten days following symptom onset for people with mild to moderate COVID-19, and up to 20 days for persons with severe COVID-19, including immunocompromised people.[9]
Infectious particles range in size from aerosols that remain suspended in the air for long periods of time to larger droplets that remain airborne briefly or fall to the ground.[10] Additionally, COVID-19 research has redefined the traditional understanding of how respiratory viruses are transmitted.[11] [12] The largest droplets of respiratory fluid do not travel far, but can be inhaled or land on mucous membranes on the eyes, nose, or mouth to infect. Aerosols are highest in concentration when people are in close proximity, which leads to easier viral transmission when people are physically close, but airborne transmission can occur at longer distances, mainly in locations that are poorly ventilated; in those conditions small particles can remain suspended in the air for minutes to hours.[13]
The number of people generally infected by one infected person varies,[14] but it is estimated that the R0 ("R nought" or "R zero") number is around 2.5.[15] The disease often spreads in clusters, where infections can be traced back to an index case or geographical location.[16] Often in these instances, superspreading events occur, where many people are infected by one person.
A person can get COVID-19 indirectly by touching a contaminated surface or object before touching their own mouth, nose, or eyes,[17] though strong evidence suggests this does not contribute substantially to new infections. Transmission from human to animal is possible, as in the first case, but the probability of a human contracting the disease from an animal is considered very low.[18] Although it is considered possible, there is no direct evidence of the virus being transmitted by skin to skin contact. Transmission through feces and wastewater have also been identified as possible.[19] The virus is not known to spread through urine, breast milk, food, or drinking water.[20] It very rarely transmits from mother to baby during pregnancy.
After people are infected with COVID-19, they are able to transmit the disease to other people beginning as early as four to five days before developing symptoms, known as presymptomatic transmission. To reduce such transmission, contact tracing is used to find and alert people who have been in contact with an infected individual in the 48 to 72 hours before they develop symptoms, or before that individual's test date if asymptomatic. Initial reports suggested that this early transmission was restricted to the two-to-three day time window,[21] but an author correction later acknowledged that transmission could begin four to five days before symptom onset.[7]
People are most infectious shortly before and after their symptoms begin[7] —even if mild or non-specific—as the viral load peaks at this time.
Based on current evidence, adults with mild to moderate COVID-19 remain infectious (i.e., shed replication-competent SARS-CoV-2) for up to ten days after symptoms begin, although there are few transmission events are observed after five days.[7] Adults with severe to critical COVID-19, or severe immune suppression (immunocompromised persons), may remain infectious (i.e., shed replication-competent SARS-CoV-2) for up to 20 days after symptoms begin.[22] [9]
Patients who are tested positive to the virus again after recovery, in case they weren't being reinfected, is found to be not transmitting the virus to others.[23]
Nearly a third of people with COVID-19 remain contagious five days after the onset of symptoms or a positive test. This is reduced to 7% for those who test negative twice with rapid tests on days 5 and 6. Without testing, 5% are contagious on day 10.[24] [25]
People who are asymptomatic do not show symptoms but still are able to transmit the virus.[10] At least a third of the people who are infected with the virus do not develop noticeable symptoms at any point in time.[26] [27] [28] Asymptomatic carriers tend not to get tested.[29] [30]
Persons with asymptomatic COVID-19 infection can have the same viral load as symptomatic and presymptomatic cases, and are able to transmit the virus.[8] However, the infectious period of asymptomatic cases has been observed to be shorter with faster viral clearance.[8]
The dominant mode of transmission of the COVID-19 virus is exposure to respiratory droplets (small liquid particles) carrying infectious virus (i.e., airborne or aerosol transmission).[31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [2] [36] [37] Spread occurs when the particles are emitted from the mouth or nose of an infected person when they breathe, cough, sneeze, talk, or sing.[38] [39] Human breath forms a roughly cone-shaped plume of air; in an infected person, the breath carries out the virus-containing droplets. So we expect the highest concentration of virus-containing droplets to be directly in front of an infected person, which suggests that the risk of transmission is greatest within three to six feet of the source of the infection.[31] But breath contains many droplets that smaller than 100 micrometres in size, and these can stay suspended in the air for at least minutes and move across a room.[40] [41] [42] [43] There is evidence that infectious SARS-CoV-2 survives in aerosols for a few hours.[44] There is substantial evidence for transmission events across a room (i.e., over distances larger than a metre or two) that is associated with being indoors, particularly in poorly ventilated spaces, although even indoor air drafts driven by air conditioning systems may contribute to the spread of respiratory sections.[45] [46] This has led to statements that transmission occurs most easily in the "three C's": crowded places, close contact settings, and confined and enclosed spaces.This mode of transmission occurs via an infected person breathing out the virus, which is then carried by the air to a person nearby, or to someone across a room, who then breathes the virus in. Attempts to reduce airborne transmission act on one or more of these steps in transmission.[47] Masks or face coverings are worn to reduce the virus breathed out by an infected person (who may not know they are infected), as well as the virus breathed in by a susceptible person. Social distancing keeps people apart. To prevent virus building up in the air of a room occupied by one or more infected people, ventilation is used to vent virus-laden air to the outside (where it will be diluted in the atmosphere) and replace it with virus-free air from the outside. Alternatively, the air may passed through filters to remove the virus-containing particles. A combination of shielding (protection from large droplet ejection) and air filtering, eliminating aerosols, ("Shield and sink" strategy) is particularly effective in reducing transfer of respiratory materials in indoor settings.[48]
The sneeze resembles a free turbulent jet. The turbulent multiphase cloud contributes critically to increasing the range of the pathogen-bearing drops originating in human coughs and sneezes.[49] The jet's reach is nearly 22 ft in 18.5 seconds and 25 ft in 22 seconds.[50] The shape of the expelled particles is conical, with a spreading angle of 23 degrees.[51] The trajectory of the turbulent jet is inclined due to the inclination angle of the nose. Smaller droplets travel a considerable distance as freely suspended tracers and may still get reflected and follow the turbulent cloud. Droplets with a diameter less than 50 μm remain suspended in the cloud for an extended period of time, which allows the cloud to reach heights of 4 to 6 meters, where ventilation systems can be contaminated.
Because physical intimacy and sex involve close contact, in October 2021, New York City Department of Health discouraged unvaccinated persons, immunocompromised people, people over 65, persons with COVID-19, people with a health condition that increases the risk of severe COVID-19, and people who live with someone from one of these groups from engaging in kissing, casual sex, or other activities, and recommended wearing face mask during sex.
The risk of transmission from all size droplets and aerosols is lower in indoor spaces with good ventilation.[52] The risk of outdoor transmission is low.[53] [54]
Transmission events occur in workplaces, schools, conferences, sporting venues, dormitories, prisons, shopping facilities, and ships,[55] as well as restaurants, passenger vehicles,[56] religious buildings and choir practices,[57] and hospitals and other healthcare settings. A superspreading event in a Skagit County, Washington, choral practice resulted in 32 to 52 of the 61 attendees infected.[58] [5]
An existing model of airborne transmission (the Wells-Riley model) was adapted to help understand why crowded and poorly ventilated spaces promote transmission, with findings supported by aerodynamic analysis of droplet transfer in air-conditioned hospital rooms. Airborne transmission also occurs in healthcare settings; long-distance dispersal of virus particles has been detected in ventilation systems of a hospital.[59]
Some scientists criticized public health authorities, including the WHO, in 2020 for being too slow to recognize airborne (aerosol) transmission of COVID-19 and to update their public health guidance accordingly.[60] [61] [62] [63] By mid-2020, some public health authorities had updated their guidance to reflect the importance of airborne transmission.[31] [64] The WHO updated it only by 23 December 2021.[63]
There is concern that some medical procedures that affect the mouth and lungs can also generate aerosols, and that this may increase the infection risk. Some medical procedures have been designated as aerosol-generating procedures (AGPs),[65] but this been done without measuring the aerosols these procedures produce.[66] The aerosols generated by some AGPs have been measured and found to be less than the aerosols produced by breathing.[67] Less virus (strictly speaking, viral RNA) has been found in the air near intensive care unit (ICUs) with COVID-19 patients than near rooms with COVID-19 patients that are not ICUs.[68] Patients in ICUs are more likely to be subject to mechanically ventilation, an AGP. This suggests that in hospitals, areas near ICUs may actually pose less risk of infection via aerosols. This has led to calls to reconsider AGPs. The WHO recommends the use of filtering facepiece respirators such as N95 or FFP2 masks in settings where aerosol-generating procedures are performed, while the U.S. CDC and the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control recommend these controls in all situations related to COVID-19 patient treatment (other than during crisis shortages).[69] [70] [71]
There is a research that suggests that variation in airway resistance, as measured by CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics), may be a useful tool for predicting the forecast of critically ill COVID-19 patients.[72]
A person can get COVID-19 by touching a surface or object that has the virus on it (called a fomite), and then touching their own mouth, nose, or eyes, but it is not the main mode of transmission, and the risk of surface transmission is low.[34] [32] As of July 2020, "no specific reports which have directly demonstrated fomite transmission" although "People who come into contact with potentially infectious surfaces often also have close contact with the infectious person, making the distinction between respiratory droplet and fomite transmission difficult to discern."
Each contact with a surface contaminated with SARS-CoV-2 has less than a 1 in 10,000 chance of causing an infection.[34] Various surface survival studies have found no detectable viable virus on porous surfaces within minutes to hours, but have found viable virus persisting on non-porous surfaces for days to weeks.[34] However, surface-survival studies do not reflect real-world conditions, which are less favorable to the virus.[34] Ventilation and changes in environmental conditions can kill or degrade the virus.[34] For example, temperature, humidity, and ultraviolet radiation (sunlight) all influence reductions in viral viability and infectiousness on surfaces.[31] Fomite transmission risk is also reduced because the virus does not transfer efficiently from the surface to the hands, and then from the hands to the mucous membranes (mouth, nose, and eye).[34]
The initial amount of virus on the surface (i.e., the viral load in respiratory droplets) also affects fomite transmission risk.[34] Hand washing and periodic surface cleaning impede indirect contact transmission through fomites.[34] Fomite transmission can be easily prevented with use of regular household cleaners or disinfection.[34] [73] When surface survival data and factors affecting real-world transmission are considered, "the risk of fomite transmission after a person with COVID-19 has been in an indoor space is minor after 3 days (72 hours), regardless of when it was last cleaned."[34]
Although the COVID-19 virus likely originated in bats, the pandemic is sustained through human-to-human spread, and the risk of animal-to-human spread of COVID-19 is low.[74] [75] COVID-19 infections in non-human animals have included companion animals (e.g., domestic cats, dogs, and ferrets); zoo and animal sanctuary residents (e.g., big cats, otters, and non-human primates); mink in mink farms in multiple countries; and wild white-tailed deer in numerous U.S. states.[74] Most animal infections came after the animals were in close contact with a human with COVID-19, such as an owner or caretaker.[74] Experimental research in laboratory settings also shows that other types of mammals (e.g., voles, rabbits, hamsters, pigs, macaques, baboons) can become infected.[74] By contrast, chickens and ducks do not seem to become infected with, or spread, the virus. There is no evidence that the COVID-19 virus can spread to humans from the skin, fur, or hair of pets. The U.S. CDC recommended that pet owners limit their pet's interactions with unvaccinated people outside their household; advises pet owners not to put face coverings on pets, as it could harm them; and states that pets should not be disinfected with cleaning products not approved for animal use. If a pet becomes sick with COVID-19, the CDC recommends that owners "follow similar recommended precautions as for people caring for an infected person at home."
People sick with COVID-19 should avoid contact with pets and other animals, in the same manner that people sick with COVID-19 should avoid contact with people.
The is no evidence for intrauterine transmission of COVID-19 from pregnant women to their fetuses. Studies have not found any viable virus in breast milk. Breast milk is unlikely to spread the COVID-19 virus to babies.[76] [77] Noting the benefits of breastfeeding, the WHO recommends that mothers with suspected or confirmed COVID-19 should be encouraged to initiate or continue to breastfeed, while taking proper infection prevention and control measures.[77]
No evidence suggests that handling food or consuming food is associated with transmission of COVID-19.[78] [79] The COVID-19 virus had poor survivability on surfaces;[78] less than 1 in 10,000 contacts with contaminated surfaces, including non-food-related surfaces, lead to infection.[34] As a result, the risk of spread from food products or packaging is very low.[79] Public health authorities recommend that people follow practice good hygiene by washing hands with soap and water before preparing and consuming food.[78] [79]
The COVID-19 virus has not been detected in drinking water.[80] Conventional water treatment (filtration and disinfection) inactivates or removes the virus.[80] COVID-19 virus RNA is found in untreated wastewater,[80] [20] [81] but there is no evidence of COVID-19 transmission through exposure to untreated wastewater or sewerage systems.[80] There is also no evidence that COVID-19 transmission to humans occurs through water in swimming pools, hot tubs, or spas.[80]
While SARS-CoV-2 RNA has been detected in the urine and feces of some persons infected with COVID-19, there is no evidence of COVID-19 transmission through feces or urine.[80] COVID-19 is not an insect-borne disease; there is also no evidence that mosquito are a vector for COVID-19.[82] COVID-19 is not a sexually transmitted infection; while the virus has been found in the semen of people who have COVID-19, there is no evidence that the virus spreads through semen or vaginal fluid,[83] however transmission during sexual activities is still possible due to proximity during intimate activities which enable transmission through other paths.[84]
Many people do not transmit the virus, but some transmit to many people, and the virus is considered to be "over dispersed" – the transmission rate has high heterogeneity.[85] "Super-spreading events" occur from this minority of infected people, generally indoors and usually in high-risk venues where people remain in close proximity and poor ventilation for an extended period, such as restaurants, nightclubs, and places of worship.[86] Such crowded conditions enable the virus to spread easily via aerosols, they can create clusters of cases, where infections can be traced back to an index case or geographical location. Another important site for transmission is between members of the same household, as well as hospitals due to the abundance of pathogens present.[87] Traffic vehicles are also a site for transmission, since the control of the pathogen there is harder due to the weak ventilation system and the high density of people. Emergency departments are also great sites for transmission of COVID-19.[88] The dispersion of respiratory droplets can be influenced by various factors, including the ventilation system, the number of infected patients, and their movements, which highlights the importance of proper ventilation and air filtration systems in reducing the spread of COVID-19 within an emergency department setting.
COVID-19 is more infectious than influenza, but less so than measles. Estimates of the number of people infected by one person with COVID-19—the basic reproduction number (R0)—have varied. In November 2020, a systematic review estimated R0 of the original Wuhan strain to be approximately .[89] The R0 of the Delta variant, which became the dominant variant of COVID-19 in 2021, is substantially higher. Among five studies catalogued in October 2021, Delta's mean estimate R0 was 5.08.[90]
Temperature is also a factor that affects the transmissibility of the virus. At elevated temperatures and low virus concentration rates the virus is in its weak state[91] and the spreading of it is strenuously. At low temperatures and excessive virus concentration rates the virus is in its robust state and the spreading of it is unchallenged.
See main article: Source control (respiratory disease). Source control is the principal mode of protection of COVID-19 after receiving the vaccine. There are many types of face masks, including surgical mask, two-layered face mask, face shield, and N95 respirator. A surgical mask is the least effective means of preventing particle leakage since the leaked particles due to a sneeze travelling a distance of 2.5 ft. The combination of a surgical mask with a face shield restricts the forward motion of particles notably. A two-layered face mask has noticeable leakage in the forward direction, but with the addition of a cotton stitch there is significantly less leakage of particles. The combination of a two-layered face mask and a face shield effectively restricts the leakage in the forward direction. The face shield enables particles to escape from below it, and thus it is not recommended for protecting the spreading of the virus. An N95 respirator completely restricts the forward leakage of particles, but in a badly fitting respirator, a significant amount of particles escape through the gap between the nose and the mask.[92] None of the protective face masks and face shields completely block the escape of particles projected by a sneeze, but they all effectively reduce the leakage and reach of the sneeze within 1–3 ft. The N95 respirator is the best face coverage for mitigating the spread because it completely impedes the forward leakage of the particles. The widely accepted safe distance of 6 ft is highly underestimated for sneezing. Researchers strongly recommend using the elbow or hands to prevent droplet leakage even when wearing face masks during sneezing and coughing. Wearing masks in indoor spaces reduces the risk of transmission,[93] but it is recommended to immediately evacuate any space where sneezing has occurred.
The Pfizer-BioNTech, Moderna, AstraZeneca and Janssen COVID-19 vaccines provide effective protection against COVID-19, including against severe disease, hospitalisation, and death, and "a growing body of evidence suggests that COVID-19 vaccines also reduce asymptomatic infection and transmission" as chains of transmission are interrupted by vaccines. While fully vaccinated people can still become infected and potentially transmit the virus to others (particularly in areas of widespread community transmission), they do so at a much lower rate than unvaccinated people.[94] The primary cause of continued spread of COVID-19 is transmission between unvaccinated people.[94]