The Eighty (Vichy France) Explained

The Eighty (Les Quatre-Vingts) were a group of elected French parliamentarians who, on 10 July 1940, voted against the constitutional change that effectively dissolved the Third Republic and established the authoritarian regime of then-Prime Minister Philippe Pétain. Their efforts failed, and Pétain consolidated his regime into the client state of Nazi Germany now known as Vichy France.

Some of the Vichy 80, like Léon Blum, would go on to be imprisoned by regime, while others managed to join the French Resistance, through groups like the Francs-Tireurs et Partisans and the Brutus network. Several of the Eighty, including Vincent Auriol and Paul Ramadier, would play key roles in the establishment of the French Fourth Republic after the end of World War II.

Background

Nazi Germany invaded France on 10 May 1940, and Paris fell a month later. Prime Minister Paul Reynaud was opposed to asking for armistice terms, and upon losing the cabinet vote, resigned. President Albert Lebrun appointed Marshal Philippe Pétain as his replacement. France capitulated on 22 June 1940. Under the terms of the armistice, the northern and Atlantic coast region of France was to be militarily occupied by Germany. The remainder would remain unoccupied, with the French Government remaining at Vichy, remaining responsible for all civil government in France, occupied and unoccupied.

Pétain began a revision of the constitution of the discredited Third Republic. This process was completed with a vote of the combined houses of the parliament on 10 July 1940.

Vote

See main article: French Constitutional Law of 1940. 27 deputies and senators did not take part in the vote. They had fled Metropolitan France on 21 June, from Bordeaux to Algiers, on board the liner SS Massilia, and they are referred to as the Massilia absentees. They were considered traitors by the collaborationist government,[1] although they were seen as heroes after the war.[2]

The result of the vote was a constitutional amendment that created the new French government. The eighty deputies and senators who opposed the change are referred to as the Vichy 80 (French: "les quatre-vingts"), and they are now famous for their decision to oppose the vote.[3]

Most of the eighty votes against the change were lodged by Socialists or Radical-Socialists.[4] Sixty-one communist parliamentarians had previously had their rights to serve as deputies and senators denied to them in January 1940, as the Soviet Union was a co-belligerent of Nazi Germany at the time.[5] Using data collected from the biographies of parliamentarians, Jean Lacroix, Pierre-Guillaume Méon, and Kim Oosterlinck observe that members of a democratic dynasty, defined as a dynasty whose founder was a defender of democratic ideals, were 9.6 to 15.1 percentage points more likely to oppose the act than other parliamentarians.[6]

The historian Richard Vinen has observed that "the implications of supporting Pétain in July 1940 were not clear. This was not, for all its subsequent mythology, a vote that divided Pétaininsts and/or collaborators from resisters." He highlights the cases of Joseph Laniel who voted in favour of Pétain's inauguration but was subsequently a leading member of the French resistance and the Conseil national de la Résistance. Isidore Thrivier, by contrast, who was among the 80 to vote against, subsequently embraced the Vichy regime and became a member of Vichy's National Council.[7]

Vote tally

DeputiesSenatorsTotal
Total544302846
Voting414235649
For357212569
Against572380
Voluntary abstaining12820
Massilia absentees26127
Other abstaining9257149
Not voting11

List of the 80

NameHouseDépartementParliamentary group
Marcel AstierSenateArdècheRadical-Socialist
Jean-Fernand AudeguilChamber of DeputiesGirondeSFIO
Vincent AuriolChamber of DeputiesHaute-GaronneSFIO
Alexandre BacheletSenateSeine
Vincent BadieChamber of DeputiesHéraultRadical-Socialist
Camille BedinChamber of DeputiesDordogneSFIO
Émile BenderSenateRhôneRadical-Socialist
Jean BiondiChamber of DeputiesOiseSFIO
Léon BlumChamber of DeputiesAude
Laurent BonnevayChamber of DeputiesRhôneAD
Paul BouletChamber of DeputiesHéraultLJR
Georges BruguierSenateGard
Séraphin BuissetChamber of DeputiesIsèreSFIO
Gaston CabannesChamber of DeputiesGirondeSFIO
Chamber of DeputiesAriègeSFIO
Pierre de ChambrunSenateLozèreIndependent
Auguste Champetier de RibesSenateBasses-PyrénéesIndependent
Pierre ChaumiéSenateLot-et-GaronneRadical-Socialist
Arthur ChaussyChamber of DeputiesSeine-et-MarneSFIO
Chamber of DeputiesVarSFIO
Chamber of DeputiesSeine-InférieureRadical-Socialist
Achille DarouxChamber of DeputiesVendéeRadical-Socialist
Chamber of DeputiesBasses-PyrénéesIndependent Left
SenateRhône
Marx DormoySenateAllier
Chamber of DeputiesRhôneIndependent Left
SenateSeineRadical-Socialist
Émile FouchardChamber of DeputiesSeine-et-MarneUPF
Chamber of DeputiesArdècheSFIO
SenateCorseRadical-Socialist
Justin GodartSenateRhôneRadical-Socialist
Félix GouinChamber of DeputiesBouches-du-RhôneSFIO
Henri GoutChamber of DeputiesAudeRadical-Socialist
SenateVaucluseSFIO
Chamber of DeputiesHaute-SavoieSFIO
Jean HennessyChamber of DeputiesAlpes-MaritimesIndependent Left
Chamber of DeputiesIsèreSFIO
Chamber of DeputiesPas-de-CalaisRadical-Socialist
Chamber of DeputiesAllierUPF
Chamber of DeputiesCorrèzeRadical-Socialist
Chamber of DeputiesRhôneSFIO
François LabrousseSenateCorrèzeRadical-Socialist
Chamber of DeputiesFinistèreRadical-Socialist
Chamber of DeputiesMancheAD
Victor Le GorgeuSenateFinistèreRadical-Socialist
Chamber of DeputiesGirondeSFIO
Augustin MalrouxChamber of DeputiesTarnSFIO
Chamber of DeputiesHautes-PyrénéesRadical-Socialist
Chamber of DeputiesMarneRadical-Socialist
Chamber of DeputiesIsèreSFIO
Chamber of DeputiesLoir-et-Cher
Chamber of DeputiesBasses-PyrénéesRadical-Socialist
Jules MochChamber of DeputiesHéraultSFIO
Chamber of DeputiesCantalIndependent Left
Léonel de MoustierChamber of DeputiesDoubsRépublicain indépendant
Marius MoutetChamber of DeputiesDrôme
René NicodChamber of DeputiesAinUPF
Louis NoguèresChamber of DeputiesPyrénées-Orientales
Jean OdinSenateGirondeRadical-Socialist
Joseph Paul-BoncourSenateLoir-et-CherSocialist Republican Union (USR)
Jean PerrotChamber of DeputiesFinistèreRadical-Socialist
Georges PézièresSenatePyrénées-Orientales
André PhilipChamber of DeputiesRhôneSFIO
Marcel PlaisantSenateCherRadical-Socialist
François Tanguy-PrigentChamber of DeputiesFinistère
Paul RamadierChamber of DeputiesAveyronIndependent
Joseph-Paul RambaudSenateAriègeRadical-Socialist
René RenoutSenateVarRadical-Socialist
Léon RocheChamber of DeputiesHaute-Vienne
Camille RollandSenateRhôneRadical-Socialist
Jean-Louis RollandChamber of DeputiesFinistèreSFIO
Joseph RousChamber of DeputiesPyrénées-OrientalesSFIO
Jean-Emmanuel RoyChamber of DeputiesGirondeRadical-Socialist
Henry SénèsSenateVar
Philippe SerreChamber of DeputiesMeurthe-et-MoselleIndependent Left
Paul SimonChamber of DeputiesFinistèrePopular Democrat
Gaston ThiébautChamber of DeputiesMeuseRadical-Socialist
Isidore ThivrierChamber of DeputiesAllierSFIO
Pierre TrémintinChamber of DeputiesFinistèrePopular Democrat
Michel ZuninoChamber of DeputiesVarSFIO

Further reading

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: 21 juin 1940 : le "Massilia" quitte la France pour Alger. memoire.net. French. 2007-09-10. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20070927034829/http://www.memoire-net.org/article.php3?id_article=144. 2007-09-27.
  2. For the complete list of Massilia's passengers, see Louis-Georges Planes and Robert Dufourg, Bordeaux, Capitale tragique, mai-juin 1940, Loos: Editions Medicis, 4-page unnumbered inset between pages 188 and 189.
  3. Web site: Proposition de Loi n° 729 . French. 2007-09-10.
  4. Book: Judt . Tony . Tony Judt . The burden of responsibility: Blum, Camus, Aron, and the French twentieth century . 1998 . University of Chicago Press . Chicago . 9780226414195.
  5. Web site: Les Quatre-vingts qui dirent non, 10 juillet 1940, France, MJP .
  6. Lacroix. Jean. Meon. Pierre-Guillaume. Oosterlinck. Kim. 2019-07-01. A Positive Effect of Political Dynasties: The Case of France's 1940 Enabling Act. en. Rochester, NY. 3428395.
  7. Book: Vinen . Richard . The unfree French: life under the Occupation . 2006 . Allen Lane . London . 978-0-713-99496-4 . 50.