Sunspot Explained

Sunspots are temporary spots on the Sun's surface that are darker than the surrounding area. They are regions of reduced surface temperature caused by concentrations of magnetic flux that inhibit convection. Sunspots appear within active regions, usually in pairs of opposite magnetic polarity.[1] Their number varies according to the approximately 11-year solar cycle.

Individual sunspots or groups of sunspots may last anywhere from a few days to a few months, but eventually decay. Sunspots expand and contract as they move across the surface of the Sun, with diameters ranging from 16km (10miles)[2] to 160000km (100,000miles).[3] Larger sunspots can be visible from Earth without the aid of a telescope.[4] They may travel at relative speeds, or proper motions, of a few hundred meters per second when they first emerge.

Indicating intense magnetic activity, sunspots accompany other active region phenomena such as coronal loops, prominences, and reconnection events. Most solar flares and coronal mass ejections originate in these magnetically active regions around visible sunspot groupings. Similar phenomena indirectly observed on stars other than the Sun are commonly called starspots, and both light and dark spots have been measured.[5]

History

The earliest record of sunspots is found in the Chinese I Ching, completed before 800 BC. The text describes that a dou and mei were observed in the sun, where both words refer to a small obscuration.[6] The earliest record of a deliberate sunspot observation also comes from China, and dates to 364 BC, based on comments by astronomer Gan De (甘德) in a star catalogue.[7] By 28 BC, Chinese astronomers were regularly recording sunspot observations in official imperial records.[8]

The first clear mention of a sunspot in Western literature is circa 300 BC, by ancient Greek scholar Theophrastus, student of Plato and Aristotle and successor to the latter.[9]

The earliest known drawings of sunspots were made by English monk John of Worcester in December 1128.[10] [11]

Sunspots were first observed telescopically in December 1610 by English astronomer Thomas Harriot.[12] His observations were recorded in his notebooks and were followed in March 1611 by observations and reports by Frisian astronomers Johannes and David Fabricius.[13] [14] After Johannes Fabricius' death at the age of 29, his reports remained obscure and were overshadowed by the independent discoveries of and publications about sunspots by Christoph Scheiner and Galileo Galilei.[15] Galileo likely began telescopic sunspot observations around the same time as Harriot; however, Galileo's records did not start until 1612.[16]

In the early 19th Century, William Herschel was one of the first to equate sunspots with heating and cooling on Earth and believed that certain features of sunspots would indicate increased heating on Earth.[17] During his recognition of solar behavior and hypothesized solar structure, he inadvertently picked up the relative absence of sunspots from July 1795 to January 1800 and was perhaps the first to construct a past record of observed or missing sunspots. From this he found that the absence of sunspots coincided with high wheat prices in England. The president of the Royal Society commented that the upward trend in wheat prices was due to monetary inflation.[18] Years later scientists such as Richard Carrington in 1865 and John Henry Poynting in 1884 tried and failed to find a connection between wheat prices and sunspots, and modern analysis finds that there is no statistically significant correlation between wheat prices and sunspot numbers.[19]

Physics

Morphology

Sunspots have two main structures: a central umbra and a surrounding penumbra. The umbra is the darkest region of a sunspot and is where the magnetic field is strongest and approximately vertical, or normal, to the Sun's surface, or photosphere. The umbra may be surrounded completely or only partially by a brighter region known as the penumbra.[20] The penumbra is composed of radially elongated structures known as penumbral filaments and has a more inclined magnetic field than the umbra.[21] Within sunspot groups, multiple umbrae may be surrounded by a single, continuous penumbra.

The temperature of the umbra is roughly 3000–4500 K, in contrast to the surrounding material at about 5780 K, leaving sunspots clearly visible as dark spots. This is because the luminance of a heated black body (closely approximated by the photosphere) at these temperatures varies greatly with temperature. Isolated from the surrounding photosphere, a single sunspot would shine brighter than the full moon, with a crimson-orange color.[22]

In some forming and decaying sunspots, relatively narrow regions of bright material appear penetrating into or completely dividing an umbra. These formations, referred to as light bridges, have been found to have a weaker, more tilted magnetic field compared to the umbra at the same height in the photosphere. Higher in the photosphere, the light bridge magnetic field merges and becomes comparable to that of the umbra. Gas pressure in light bridges has also been found to dominate over magnetic pressure, and convective motions have been detected.

The Wilson effect implies that sunspots are depressions on the Sun's surface.

Lifecycle

The appearance of an individual sunspot may last anywhere from a few days to a few months, though groups of sunspots and their associated active regions tend to last weeks or months. Sunspots expand and contract as they move across the surface of the Sun, with diameters ranging from 16km (10miles)[2] to 160000km (100,000miles).[3]

Formation

Although the details of sunspot formation are still a matter of ongoing research, it is widely understood that they are the visible manifestations of magnetic flux tubes in the Sun's convective zone projecting through the photosphere within active regions.[23] Their characteristic darkening occurs due to this strong magnetic field inhibiting convection in the photosphere. As a result, the energy flux from the Sun's interior decreases, and with it, surface temperature, causing the surface area through which the magnetic field passes to look dark against the bright background of photospheric granules.

Sunspots initially appear in the photosphere as small darkened spots lacking a penumbra. These structures are known as solar pores.[24] Over time, these pores increase in size and move towards one another. When a pore gets large enough, typically around 3500km (2,200miles) in diameter, a penumbra will begin to form.

Decay

Magnetic pressure should tend to remove field concentrations, causing the sunspots to disperse, but sunspot lifetimes are measured in days to weeks. In 2001, observations from the Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO) using sound waves traveling below the photosphere (local helioseismology) were used to develop a three-dimensional image of the internal structure below sunspots; these observations show that a powerful downdraft lies beneath each sunspot, forms a rotating vortex that sustains the concentrated magnetic field.[25]

Solar cycle

See main article: Solar cycle.

Solar cycles last typically about eleven years, varying from just under 10 to just over 12 years. Over the solar cycle, sunspot populations increase quickly and then decrease more slowly. The point of highest sunspot activity during a cycle is known as solar maximum, and the point of lowest activity as solar minimum. This period is also observed in most other solar activity and is linked to a variation in the solar magnetic field that changes polarity with this period.

Early in the cycle, sunspots appear at higher latitudes and then move towards the equator as the cycle approaches maximum, following Spörer's law. Spots from two sequential cycles co-exist for several years during the years near solar minimum. Spots from sequential cycles can be distinguished by direction of their magnetic field and their latitude.

The Wolf number sunspot index counts the average number of sunspots and groups of sunspots during specific intervals. The 11-year solar cycles are numbered sequentially, starting with the observations made in the 1750s.[26]

George Ellery Hale first linked magnetic fields and sunspots in 1908.[27] Hale suggested that the sunspot cycle period is 22 years, covering two periods of increased and decreased sunspot numbers, accompanied by polar reversals of the solar magnetic dipole field. Horace W. Babcock later proposed a qualitative model for the dynamics of the solar outer layers. The Babcock Model explains that magnetic fields cause the behavior described by Spörer's law, as well as other effects, which are twisted by the Sun's rotation.

Longer-period trends

Sunspot numbers also change over long periods. For example, during the period known as the modern maximum from 1900 to 1958 the solar maxima trend of sunspot count was upwards; for the following 60 years the trend was mostly downwards.[28] Overall, the Sun was last as active as the modern maximum over 8,000 years ago.[29]

Sunspot number is correlated with the intensity of solar radiation over the period since 1979, when satellite measurements became available. The variation caused by the sunspot cycle to solar output is on the order of 0.1% of the solar constant (a peak-to-trough range of 1.3 W·m−2 compared with 1366 W·m−2 for the average solar constant).[30] [31]

Modern observation

See main article: Solar observatory.

Sunspots are observed with land-based and Earth-orbiting solar telescopes. These telescopes use filtration and projection techniques for direct observation, in addition to various types of filtered cameras. Specialized tools such as spectroscopes and spectrohelioscopes are used to examine sunspots and sunspot areas. Artificial eclipses allow viewing of the circumference of the Sun as sunspots rotate through the horizon.

Since looking directly at the Sun with the naked eye permanently damages human vision, amateur observation of sunspots is generally conducted using projected images, or directly through protective filters. Small sections of very dark filter glass, such as a #14 welder's glass, are effective. A telescope eyepiece can project the image, without filtration, onto a white screen where it can be viewed indirectly, and even traced, to follow sunspot evolution. Special purpose hydrogen-alpha narrow bandpass filters and aluminum-coated glass attenuation filters (which have the appearance of mirrors due to their extremely high optical density) on the front of a telescope provide safe observation through the eyepiece.

Application

Due to their correlation with other kinds of solar activity, sunspots can be used to help predict space weather, the state of the ionosphere, and conditions relevant to short-wave radio propagation or satellite communications. High sunspot activity is celebrated by members of the amateur radio community as a harbinger of excellent ionospheric propagation conditions that greatly increase radio range in the HF bands. During peaks in sunspot activity, worldwide radio communication can be achieved on frequencies as high as the 6-meter VHF band.[32]

Solar activity (and the solar cycle) have been implicated as a factor in global warming. The first possible example of this is the Maunder Minimum period of low sunspot activity which occurred during the Little Ice Age in Europe.[33] However, detailed studies from multiple paleoclimate indicators show that the lower northern hemisphere temperatures in the Little Ice Age began while sunspot numbers were still high before the start of the Maunder Minimum, and persisted until after the Maunder Minimum had ceased. Numerical climate modelling indicates that volcanic activity was the main driver of the Little Ice Age.[34]

Sunspots themselves, in terms of the magnitude of their radiant-energy deficit, have a weak effect on solar flux.[35] The total effect of sunspots and other magnetic processes in the solar photosphere is an increase of roughly 0.1% in brightness of the Sun in comparison with its brightness at the solar-minimum level. This is a difference in total solar irradiance at Earth over the sunspot cycle of close to

1.37 W ⋅ m-2
. Other magnetic phenomena which correlate with sunspot activity include faculae and the chromospheric network.[36] The combination of these magnetic factors mean that the relationship of sunspot numbers to Total Solar Irradiance (TSI) over the decadal-scale solar cycle, and their relationship for century timescales, need not be the same. The main problem with quantifying the longer-term trends in TSI lies in the stability of the absolute radiometry measurements made from space, which has improved in recent decades but remains a problem.[37] [38] Analysis shows that it is possible that TSI was actually higher in the Maunder Minimum compared to present-day levels, but uncertainties are high, with best estimates in the range
\pm0.5 W ⋅ m-2
with a

2\sigma

uncertainty range of
\pm1 W ⋅ m-2
.[39]

Sunspots, with their intense magnetic field concentrations, facilitate the complex transfer of energy and momentum to the upper solar atmosphere. This transfer occurs through a variety of mechanisms, including generated waves in the lower solar atmosphere[40] and magnetic reconnection events.[41]

Starspot

See main article: Starspot. In 1947, G. E. Kron proposed that starspots were the reason for periodic changes in brightness on red dwarfs.[5] Since the mid-1990s, starspot observations have been made using increasingly powerful techniques yielding more and more detail: photometry showed starspot growth and decay and showed cyclic behavior similar to the Sun's; spectroscopy examined the structure of starspot regions by analyzing variations in spectral line splitting due to the Zeeman effect; Doppler imaging showed differential rotation of spots for several stars and distributions different from the Sun's; spectral line analysis measured the temperature range of spots and the stellar surfaces. For example, in 1999, Strassmeier reported the largest cool starspot ever seen rotating the giant K0 star XX Trianguli (HD 12545) with a temperature of 3500K, together with a warm spot of 4800K.[5] [42]

See also

Further reading

External links

Sunspot data

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Sunspots. NOAA. 22 February 2013.
  2. Web site: How Are Magnetic Fields Related To Sunspots?. NASA. 22 February 2013.
  3. Web site: Sun. 22 April 2009. HowStuffWorks. 22 February 2013.
  4. 1989QJRAS..30...59M Page 60. 2021-06-27. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society. 1989QJRAS..30...59M. Mossman . J. E. . 1989 . 30 . 59 .
  5. Web site: Smallest KPNO Telescope Discovers Biggest Starspots (press release 990610) . K. G. . Strassmeier . 1999-06-10 . . starspots vary on the same (short) time scales as Sunspots do ... HD 12545 had a warm spot (350 K above photospheric temperature; the white area in the picture) . 20 February 2008 . https://web.archive.org/web/20100624105256/http://www.aip.de/groups/activity/presse/pressrelease990610.html . 24 June 2010 . dead .
  6. 10.1016/0146-6364(80)90034-1 . The hexagram "Feng" in "the book of changes" as the earliest written record of sunspot . Chinese Astronomy . 4 . 4 . 406 . 1980 . Xu Zhen-Tao . 1980ChA.....4..406X .
  7. Web site: Early Astronomy and the Beginnings of a Mathematical Science . 2007 . NRICH (University of Cambridge) . 2010-07-14.
  8. The Observation of Sunspots . 1988 . UNESCO Courier . 2010-07-14 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20110702095337/http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1310/is_1988_Oct/ai_6955852/ . 2011-07-02.
  9. "Letter to the Editor: Sunspot observations by Theophrastus revisited", and see Theophrastus' Fragment VI, De Signis Tempestatum, 11.4–5.
  10. Stephenson . F. R. . Willis . D. M. . The earliest drawing of sunspots . Astronomy & Geophysics . 40 . 6 . 1999 . 6.21–6.22 . 1366-8781 . 10.1093/astrog/40.6.6.21. 1999A&G....40f..21S . free .
  11. Stefan Hughes, Catchers of the Light: The Forgotten Lives of the Men and Women Who First Photographed the Heavens, ArtDeCiel Publishing, 2012 p. 317
  12. Vokhmyanin . M. . VArlt . R. . Zolotova . N. . Sunspot Positions and Areas from Observations by Thomas Harriot . Solar Physics . 10 March 2020 . 295 . 3 . 39.1–39.11 . 10.1007/s11207-020-01604-4 . 2020SoPh..295...39V . 216259048 .
  13. Web site: Great Moments in the History of Solar Physics 1. Great Moments in the History of Solar Physics . 2006-03-19 . https://web.archive.org/web/20060301083022/http://web.hao.ucar.edu/public/education/sp/great_moments.html . 1 March 2006.
  14. Book: Vaquero . J.M. . Vázquez . M . The Sun Recorded Through History: Scientific Data Extracted from Historical Documents vol. 361 of the series Astrophysics and Space Science Library . 10.1007/978-0-387-92790-9 . 2009 . 361 . Springer, New York . 978-0-387-92789-3 .
  15. Book: Carlowicz . Michael J. . López . Ramón . Storms from the Sun: The Emerging Science of Space Weather . 2002 . Joseph Henry Press . 1–382 . 978-0309076425 . 19 June 2020.
  16. Vokhmyanin . M. . Zolotova . N. . Sunspot Positions and Areas from Observations by Galileo Galilei . Solar Physics . 5 February 2018 . 293 . 2 . 31.1–31.21 . 10.1007/s11207-018-1245-1 . 2018SoPh..293...31V . 126329839 .
  17. Herschel . William . XIII. Observations tending to investigate the nature of the sun, in order to find the causes or symptoms of its variable emission of light and heat; with remarks on the use that may possibly be drawn from solar observations . Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London . 31 December 1801 . 91 . 265–318 . 10.1098/rstl.1801.0015 . 122986696 . free .
  18. Soon, W., and Yaskell, S.H., The Maunder Minimum and the Variable Sun-earth Connection (World Scientific Press: 2003) pp. 87–88
  19. Love . Jeffrey J. . On the insignificance of Herschel's sunspot correlation . Geophysical Research Letters . 27 August 2013 . 40 . 16 . 4171–4176 . 10.1002/grl.50846 . 2013GeoRL..40.4171L . 1654166 .
  20. Schlichenmaier . R. . Rezaei . R. . Bello González . N. . Waldmann . T. A. . The formation of a sunspot penumbra . Astronomy and Astrophysics . March 2010 . 512 . L1 . 10.1051/0004-6361/201014112. 2010A&A...512L...1S . free .
  21. Mathew . S. K. . Lagg . A. . Solanki . S. K. . Collados . M. . Borrero . J. M. . Berdyugina . S. . Krupp . N. . Woch . J. . Frutiger . C. . Three dimensional structure of a regular sunspot from the inversion of IR Stokes profiles . Astronomy & Astrophysics . November 2003 . 410 . 2 . 695–710 . 10.1051/0004-6361:20031282. 2003A&A...410..695M . free .
  22. Web site: Sunspots. NASA. 1 April 1998. 22 February 2013. 3 April 2013. https://archive.today/20130403033824/http://image.gsfc.nasa.gov/poetry/workbook/sunspot.html. dead.
  23. Solanki . Sami K. . Sunspots: An overview . Astronomy and Astrophysics Review . 1 April 2003 . 11 . 2–3 . 153–286 . 10.1007/s00159-003-0018-4. 2003A&ARv..11..153S . 120721248 .
  24. Sobotka . Michal . Vazquez . Manuel . Bonet . Jose Antonio . Hanslmeier . Arnold . Hirzberger . Johann . Temporal Evolution of Fine Structures in and around Solar Pores . The Astrophysical Journal . 20 January 1999 . 511 . 1 . 436–450 . 10.1086/306671 . 1999ApJ...511..436S . 121691780 . 5 January 2022.
  25. News: SOHO reveals how sunspots take stranglehold on the Sun. SpaceFlight Now. 6 November 2001. NASA News Release. 9 March 2013. 17 January 2015. https://web.archive.org/web/20150117214759/http://www.spaceflightnow.com/news/n0111/06sunspots/. dead.
  26. Book: Tribble, A. . 2003. The Space Environment, Implications for Spacecraft Design. Princeton University Press . 15–18.
  27. Hale . G. E. . On the Probable Existence of a Magnetic Field in Sun-Spots . The Astrophysical Journal . 28 . 315 . 1908 . 10.1086/141602. 1908ApJ....28..315H . free .
  28. Web site: Sunspot index graphics . Solar Influences Data Analysis Center . 27 September 2007.
  29. 4. Solanki SK. Usoskin IG. Kromer B. Schüssler M. Beer J . October 2004. Unusual activity of the Sun during recent decades compared to the previous 11,000 years. Nature . 431 . 7012 . 1084–1087. 10.1038/nature02995 . 15510145 . 2004Natur.431.1084S. 4373732.
  30. Web site: Solar Forcing of Climate . Climate Change 2001: Working Group I: The Scientific Basis . 2005-03-10 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20050315081547/http://www.grida.no/climate/ipcc_tar/wg1/244.htm . 15 March 2005.
  31. Web site: Spencer. Weart. The Discovery of Global Warming – Changing Sun, Changing Climate?. Spencer. Weart. American Institute of Physics. 2006. 2007-04-14. 17 June 2006. https://web.archive.org/web/20060617030502/http://www.aip.org/history/climate/solar.htm. dead.
  32. Web site: Sunspots and Propagation. Stu Turner. Ham Radio School.com. 5 January 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20170626024320/http://www.hamradioschool.com/sunspots-and-propagation/. 26 June 2017. dead.
  33. Eddy J.A. . The Maunder Minimum . Science . 192 . 4245 . 1189–1202 . June 1976 . 17771739 . 10.1126/science.192.4245.1189 . 1976Sci...192.1189E . 33896851 . PDF Copy
  34. Owens . M.J. . et al. . October 2017 . The Maunder Minimum and the Little Ice Age: An update from recent reconstructions and climate simulations . J. Space Weather and Space Climate . en . 7 . A25 . 2115-7251 . 10.1051/swsc/2017019 . 37433045 . free . 1708.04904 .
  35. Hudson H . 2008. Solar activity . Scholarpedia. 3. 3. 3967. 10.4249/scholarpedia.3967. 2008SchpJ...3.3967H. free.
  36. Observations of solar irradiance variability . 1981. 1981Sci...211..700W. 10.1126/science.211.4483.700. 17776650. 211. 4483. Science. 700–702. Willson. R. C.. Gulkis. S.. Janssen. M.. Hudson. H. S.. Chapman. G. A..
  37. Kopp . G. . April 2014. An assessment of the solar irradiance record for climate studies. J. Space Weather and Space Climate . en . 4. A14 . 10.1051/swsc/2014012. 2014JSWSC...4A..14K . free .
  38. Kopp . G. . July 2016. Magnitudes and timescales of total solar irradiance variability . J. Space Weather and Space Climate . en . 6 . A30 . 10.1051/swsc/2016025. 1606.05258 . 2016JSWSC...6A..30K . 55902879 .
  39. Lockwood . M. . Ball . W. . May 2020 . Placing limits on long-term variations in quiet-Sun irradiance and their contribution to total solar irradiance and solar radiative forcing of climate . Proceedings of the Royal Society A. en . 476 . 2238 . 20200077 . 1364-5021 . 10.1098/rspa.2020.0077. 32831591 . 7428030 . 2020RSPSA.47600077L .
  40. ((Jess, D. B., Jafarzadeh, S., Keys, P. H., Stangalini, M., Verth, G., Grant, S. D. T.)) . Waves in the lower solar atmosphere: the dawn of next-generation solar telescopes . 20 . 1 . Springer Nature . 19 January 2023 . Living Reviews in Solar Physics . 10.1007/s41116-022-00035-6. 2212.09788 . 2023LRSP...20....1J .
  41. ((Shibata, K., Magara, T.)) . Solar Flares: Magnetohydrodynamic Processes . 8 . 1 . 6 . Living Reviews in Solar Physics . Springer International Publishing . 15 December 2011 . 10.12942/lrsp-2011-6. free . 2011LRSP....8....6S . 2433/153022 . free .
  42. Web site: Derived images showing rotation of cool and warm starspots . Leibniz Institute for Astrophysics . 2013-01-14 . https://web.archive.org/web/20100529200045/http://www.aip.de/groups/activity/pics/DI/12545s4e.gif . 29 May 2010 . dead .