Seat belt laws in the United States explained

Most seat belt laws in the United States are left to state law. However, the recommended age for a child to sit in the front passenger seat is 13. The first seat belt law was a federal law, Title 49 of the United States Code, Chapter 301, Motor Safety Standard, which took effect on January 1, 1968, that required all vehicles (except buses) to be fitted with seat belts in all designated seating positions.[1] This law has since been modified to require three-point seat belts in outboard-seating positions, and finally three-point seat belts in all seating positions.[2] Seat belt use was voluntary until New York became the first state to require vehicle occupants to wear seat belts, . New Hampshire is the only state with no law requiring adults to wear seat belts in a vehicle.

Primary and secondary enforcement

U.S. seat belt use laws may be subject to primary enforcement or secondary enforcement. Primary enforcement allows a law enforcement officer to stop and ticket a driver if they observe a violation. Secondary enforcement means that a peace officer may only stop or cite a driver for a seat belt violation if the driver committed another primary violation (such as speeding, running a stop sign, etc.) at the same time. New Hampshire is the only U.S. state that does not by law require adult drivers to wear safety belts while operating a motor vehicle.

In 15 of the 50 states, non-use of seat belts is considered a secondary offense, which means that a police officer cannot stop and ticket a driver for the sole offense of not wearing a seat belt. (One exception to this is Colorado, where children not properly restrained is a primary offense and brings a much larger fine.) If a driver commits a primary violation (e.g., for speeding) they may additionally be charged for not wearing a seat belt. In most states, seat belt non-use was originally a secondary offense. Many states later changed it to a primary offense, the first being California in 1993. Of the 34 states with primary seat belt use laws, all but California, Connecticut, Hawaii, Iowa, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Oregon, and Washington originally had only secondary enforcement laws.

Thirty-four states, the District of Columbia, American Samoa, Guam, the Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands have primary enforcement laws for front seats.

Laws by state and territory

This table summarizes seat belt use laws in the United States.[3] [4]

Seat belt use laws often do not themselves apply to children. Even so, all 50 U.S. states, the District of Columbia, and all five inhabited U.S. territories have separate child restraint laws. The table shows only the base fine, but not applicable add-on fees in many areas, such as the head injury fund and court security fees, which can increase the total assessed fine by up to a factor of five. These are also "first offense" fines, and subsequent offenses may be much higher.

Twenty-three states, the District of Columbia, Guam, and the Northern Mariana Islands had seat belt usage of 90% or higher in 2017.

State,
federal district,
or territory
Type of lawDate of first lawWho is coveredBase fine before feesSeat Belt
Usage
(2017)
[5]
Primary EnforcementAll ages in all seats[6] $2592.9%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in all seats$15 ($25 actual)90.1%
American SamoaPrimary Enforcement[7] All ages in front seats $25[8] 84.9%
Secondary Enforcement1All ages in front seats; Under age 16 in all seats$10 ($37.20 actual)86.1%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in front seats; Under age 16 in all seats$2581.0%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in all seats[9] [10] $20 ($162 actual); $50 second offense ($190 actual)696.2%
Secondary Enforcement2
Exception Mountain View where it is a primary violation[11]
All ages in front seats; Under age 18 in all seats$7183.8%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in all seats$9290.3%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in all seats$2591.4%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in all seats$50493.6%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in front seats; Under age 18 in all seats$30 ($116 actual)90.2%
GeorgiaPrimary Enforcement[12] All ages in front seats; Under age 18 in all seats$1597.1%
Primary Enforcement All ages in all seats $100 91.0%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in all seats$45 ($112 actual)96.9%
Secondary Enforcement3All ages in all seats$10 ($51.50 actual)81.2%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in all seats$164 minimum fine93.8%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in all seats$2593.0%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in front seats; Under 18 in rear seats[13] $25 ($127.50 actual)91.4%
Primary Enforcement4Age 14+ in all seats$60 for age 14-17; $10 for 18+82.0%
Primary EnforcementAge 7 and younger and over 57inches in all seats; 8+ in all seats$2586.8%
Primary EnforcementAge 13+ in front seats$2587.1%
Primary EnforcementAge 18+ in all seats$5088.9%
Primary Enforcement4Age 16+ in all seats$8392.1%
Secondary EnforcementAge 13+ in all seats[14] [15] $2573.7%
Primary EnforcementAge 16+ in front seats, under 16 in rear seats $25 ($65 actual)94.1%
Primary Enforcement7 and younger and over 57inches in all seats; 8+ in all seats$25 +$75 fee92.0%
Primary EnforcementAge 7+ in all seats$2578.8%
Secondary Enforcement2Age 16+ in front seats; Age 8-15 in all seats$10 for age 16+; $50 for age 8-1584.0%
Secondary EnforcementAge 6+ in all seats$2078.0%
Secondary EnforcementAge 18+ in front seats$2585.9%
Secondary EnforcementAge 6+ in all seats$2590.6%
None for adults, primary for minors only[16] Age 17 and under in all seats$5067.6%
Primary Enforcement4Age 8+ in all seats$46 per person94.1%
Primary EnforcementAge 18+ in all seats$25491.5%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in all seats$50 ($135 actual after surcharges)[17] 93.4%
Primary Enforcement, Secondary for back seat[18] All ages in all seats$180 for front seat; $10 for rear seat; $266 for the driver if a passenger is under 16[19] 91.4%
Secondary Enforcement3Age 18+ in front seats; Age under 18 in all seats$20 for age 18+; $25 + 1 point on license for under 18479.3%
Northern Mariana IslandsPrimary EnforcementRiders 6+ in age, in all seats$25 92.2%
Secondary EnforcementAge 15+ in front seat; Age 8–14 in all seats$30 for driver; $20 for passenger82.8%
Primary EnforcementAge 13+ in front seats$2086.9%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in all seats$13096.8%
Secondary Enforcement3Age 18+ in front seats; Age 8-17 in all seats$1085.6%
Puerto RicoPrimary EnforcementAge 9+ or 57 inches and over; Seating unspecified$5087.9%
Primary EnforcementAge 8+ in all seats$7588.3%
Primary EnforcementAge 6+ in all seats$2592.3%
Secondary EnforcementAge 18+ in front seats$2574.8%
Primary EnforcementAge 16+ in front seats$2588.5%
Primary EnforcementAge 7 years and younger and 57 inches or taller in all seats; Age 8+ years in all seats$200 if under 17 (driver); $50 if 15+ (driver or passenger)91.9%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in all seats$4588.8%
Secondary Enforcement3All ages in all seats$2584.5%
Virgin Islands (U.S.)Primary EnforcementAll ages in front seats $25 – $250 79.1%
Secondary Enforcement3All drivers; age 18+ in front seats; under 18 in all seats$2585.3%
Wake IslandPrimary EnforcementAll ages?
WashingtonPrimary EnforcementAge 8+ in all seats$12494.8%
Primary EnforcementAll ages in front seats; 8–17 in rear seats$2589.7%
Primary EnforcementAge 8+ in all seats$1089.4%
Secondary EnforcementAge 9+ in all seats$25 for driver; $10 for passenger84.8%
Note: As of 2017, aggregate seat belt usage in road vehicles in the entire United States is 89.7%.

1 Arizona's law is Primary for under the age of 5.

2 Colorado and Missouri's law is Secondary for adults but Primary for those under the age of 16.

3 Idaho, North Dakota, Pennsylvania, Vermont and Virginia's law is Secondary for adults but Primary for under 18.

4 Kansas, Maryland, and New Jersey, law is Secondary Enforcement for rear seat occupants (18+ in Kansas).
5 These states assess points on one's driving record for the seat belt violation.
6 In California, an additional penalty of $29 shall be levied upon every $10 or fraction thereof, of every fine, penalty, or forfeiture imposed by and collected by the court for criminal offenses, including all traffic offenses, except parking offenses as defined in subdivision (i) of Penal Code § 1463. The additional penalty is calculated as follows: $10 state penalty required by PC 1464, $7 county penalty required by GC 76000(e), $5 court facilities construction penalty required by GC 70372(a), $5 DNA Identification Fund penalty required by GC 76104.6 and 76104.7, $2 emergency medical services penalty required by GC 76000.5. Separately, Penal Code § 1465.8 requires an imposition of an additional fee of $40 for court security on every conviction for a criminal offense, including a traffic offense, except parking offenses as defined in Penal Code § 1463. Additionally, GC 70373 requires a $35 criminal facilities conviction assessment.

Damages reduction

A person involved in a car accident who was not using a seat belt may be liable for damages far greater than if they had been using a seat belt. However, when in court, most states protect motorists from having their damages reduced in a lawsuit due to the non-use of a seat belt, even if they were acting in violation of the law by not wearing the seat belt. Currently, damages may be reduced for the non-use of a seat belt in 16 states: Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida (See F.S.A. 316.614(10)), Iowa, Michigan, Missouri, Nebraska, New Jersey, New York, North Dakota, Ohio, Oregon, West Virginia, and Wisconsin.[20]

Effectiveness

Seat belt laws are effective in reducing car crash deaths.[21] One study found that mandatory-seatbelt laws reduced traffic fatalities in youths by 8% and serious traffic-related injuries by 9%, respectively.[22] Primary-seatbelt laws seem to be more effective at reducing crash deaths than secondary laws.[23] [24]

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Title 49 of the United States Code, Chapter 301, Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 208 - Occupant Crash Protection Passenger Cars . US Department of Transportation National Highway Traffic Safety Administration . January 1, 1968 . May 7, 2014 . May 29, 2014 . https://web.archive.org/web/20140529033515/http://www.nhtsa.gov/cars/rules/import/fmvss/ . dead .
  2. Web site: Title 49 of the United States Code, Chapter 301, Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 208 - Occupant Crash Protection Passenger Cars . US Department of Transportation National Highway Traffic Safety Administration . January 1, 1968 . May 7, 2014 . May 29, 2014 . https://web.archive.org/web/20140529033515/http://www.nhtsa.gov/cars/rules/import/fmvss/ . dead .
  3. Web site: State laws by Issue: Seat Belts . Governors highway safety association . 2019 . 2019-07-03 .
  4. Web site: Safety belt use laws . October 2009. Insurance Institute for Highway Safety . 2009-10-30 .
  5. Web site: Traffic Safety Facts: Seat Belt Use in 2017 – Use Rates in the States and Territories (DOT HS 812 546) . U.S. Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration . June 2018 . 2019-07-25 .
  6. Web site: Alabama changes seat belt law. 27 August 2019.
  7. Web site: A Guide to Seat Belt Laws in the United States . Car laws . 5 April 2015 . July 3, 2019.
  8. Web site: Title 22 Highways and Motor Vehicles — Chapter 03 Rules of the Road — Section 22.0333 Mandatory use of seat belts . American Samoa Bar Association . 2011 . July 3, 2019 .
  9. Web site: California Driver Handbook - Occupant Protection. 2018-12-20.
  10. Web site: California Highway Patrol Child Passenger Safety Laws and Guidelines. 2018-12-20.
  11. 9News Jeremy Jojola on Denver Metro Speed Traps . https://ghostarchive.org/varchive/youtube/20211221/TkZoJvlLwjw . 2021-12-21 . live. 4:55–7:30 . 8 June 2015 . 9News .
  12. 3400197 . 1998 . Cosgrove . L. . Preusser . D. . Preusser . C. . Ulmer . R. . Evaluation of Primary Safety Belt Laws in California, Louisiana, and Georgia . Annual Proceedings / Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine . 42 . 261–275 .
  13. Web site: Iowa Department of Public Safety Iowa Department of Public Safety . dps.iowa.gov . 25 July 2022.
  14. Web site: PartI Title XIV Chapter90 Section 13a . Massachusetts General Laws . 2019 . September 4, 2019.
  15. Web site: Child passenger restraint law . 2019 . Massachusetts General Laws . September 4, 2019.
  16. HB 273-FN Final Version, Chapter 244, 1997 Session, New Hampshire. "244:2 New Paragraph; Safety Belt Required for Drivers Under 18. Amend RSA 265:107-a by inserting after paragraph I the following new paragraph: I-a. No person who is less than 18 years of age shall drive a motor vehicle on any way unless such person is wearing a seat or safety belt which is properly adjusted and fastened." Retrieved on 2020-01-25 from http://www.gencourt.state.nh.us/legislation/1997/HB0273.html.
  17. Web site: vehicle and traffic state mandated surcharges $85 for seat belt . Horseheads.org . 2011-07-16.
  18. Web site: Court costs and fees chart. NCCourts.gov. en. 2018-11-24.
  19. Web site: NCDOT: Click It or Ticket.
  20. Web site: Child restraint/belt use laws . Iihs.org . 2011-07-16.
  21. Cohen. Alma. Einav. Liran. The Effects of Mandatory Seat Belt Laws on Driving Behavior and Traffic Fatalities. Review of Economics and Statistics. November 2003. 85. 4. 828–843. 10.1162/003465303772815754. 7309959.
  22. Carpenter. Christopher S.. Stehr. Mark. The effects of mandatory seatbelt laws on seatbelt use, motor vehicle fatalities, and crash-related injuries among youths. Journal of Health Economics. May 2008. 27. 3. 642–662. 10.1016/j.jhealeco.2007.09.010. 18242744.
  23. Lee. Lois K.. Monuteaux. Michael C.. Burghardt. Lindsey C.. Fleegler. Eric W.. Nigrovic. Lise E.. Meehan. William P.. Schutzman. Sara A.. Mannix. Rebekah. Michael Monuteaux. Motor Vehicle Crash Fatalities in States With Primary Versus Secondary Seat Belt Laws. Annals of Internal Medicine. 4 August 2015. 163. 3. 184–90. 10.7326/M14-2368. 26098590. 25055702.
  24. Rivara. FrederickP.. Thompson. DianeC.. Cummings. Peter. Effectiveness of primary and secondary enforced seat belt laws. American Journal of Preventive Medicine. January 1999. 16. 1. 30–39. 10.1016/S0749-3797(98)00113-5. 9921384.