Rubber-tyred metro explained

Rubber-tyred metro should not be confused with Rubber-tyred tram.

A rubber-tyred metro or rubber-tired metro is a form of rapid transit system that uses a mix of road and rail technology. The vehicles have wheels with rubber tires that run on rolling pads inside guide bars for traction, as well as traditional railway steel wheels with deep flanges on steel tracks for guidance through conventional switches as well as guidance in case a tyre fails. Most rubber-tyred trains are purpose-built and designed for the system on which they operate. Guided buses are sometimes referred to as 'trams on tyres', and compared to rubber-tyred metros.[1]

History

The first idea for rubber-tyred railway vehicles was the work of Scotsman Robert William Thomson, the original inventor of the pneumatic tyre. In his patent of 1846[2] he describes his 'Aerial Wheels' as being equally suitable for, "the ground or rail or track on which they run".[3] The patent also included a drawing of such a railway, with the weight carried by pneumatic main wheels running on a flat board track and guidance provided by small horizontal steel wheels running on the sides of a central vertical guide rail.[3] A similar arrangement was patented by Alejandro Goicoechea, inventor of Talgo, in February 1936, patent ES 141056; in 1973, he built a development of this patent: 'Tren Vertebrado', Patent DE1755198; at Avenida Marítima, in Las Palmas de Gran Canaria.

During the World War II German occupation of Paris, the Metro system was used to capacity, with relatively little maintenance performed. At the end of the war, the system was so worn that thought was given as to how to renovate it. Rubber-tyred metro technology was first applied to the Paris Métro, developed by Michelin, who provided the tyres and guidance system, in collaboration with Renault, who provided the vehicles. Starting in 1951, an experimental vehicle, the MP 51, operated on a test track between Porte des Lilas and Pré Saint Gervais, a section of line not open to the public.

Line 11 ChâteletMairie des Lilas was the first line to be converted, in 1956, chosen because of its steep grades. This was followed by Line 1 Château de VincennesPont de Neuilly in 1964, and Line 4 Porte d'OrléansPorte de Clignancourt in 1967, converted because they had the heaviest traffic load of all Paris Métro lines. Finally, Line 6 Charles de Gaulle – ÉtoileNation was converted in 1974 to reduce train noise on its many elevated sections. Because of the high cost of converting existing rail-based lines, this is no longer done in Paris, or elsewhere. Now, rubber-tyred metros are used in new systems or lines only, including the new Paris Métro Line 14.

The first completely rubber-tyred metro system was built in Montreal, Quebec, Canada, in 1966. The trains of the Santiago and Mexico City Metros are based on those of the Paris Métro. A few more recent rubber-tyred systems have used automated, driverless trains; one of the first such systems, developed by Matra, opened in 1983 in Lille, and others have since been built in Toulouse and Rennes. Paris Metro Line 14 was automated from its beginning (1998), and Line 1 was converted to automatic in 2007–2011. The first automated rubber-tyred system opened in Kobe, Japan, in February 1981. It is the Port Liner linking Sannomiya railway station with Port Island.

Technology

Overview

Trains are usually in the form of electric multiple units. Just as on a conventional railway, the driver does not have to steer, with the system relying on some sort of guideway to direct the train. The type of guideway varies between networks. Most use two parallel roll ways, each the width of a tyre, which are made of various materials. The Montreal Metro, Lille Metro, Toulouse Metro, and most parts of Santiago Metro, use concrete. The Busan Subway Line 4 employs a concrete slab. The Paris Métro, Mexico City Metro, and the non-underground section of Santiago Metro, use H-Shaped hot rolled steel, and the Sapporo Municipal Subway uses flat steel. The Sapporo system and Lille Metro use a single central guide rail only.[4]

On some systems, such those in Paris, Montreal, and Mexico City, there is a conventional railway track between the roll ways. The bogies of the train include railway wheels with longer flanges than normal. These conventional wheels are normally just above the rails, but come into use in the case of a flat tyre, or at switches (points) and crossings. In Paris these rails were also used to enable mixed traffic, with rubber-tyred and steel-wheeled trains using the same track, particularly during conversion from normal railway track. The VAL system, used in Lille and Toulouse, has other sorts of flat-tyre compensation and switching methods.

On most systems, the electric power is supplied from one of the guide bars, which serves as a third rail. The current is picked up by a separate lateral pickup shoe. The return current passes via a return shoe to one or both of the conventional railway tracks, which are part of most systems, or to the other guide bar.

Rubber tyres have higher rolling resistance than traditional steel railway wheels. There are some advantages and disadvantages to increased rolling resistance, causing them to not be used in certain countries.

Advantages

Compared to steel wheel on steel rail, the advantages of rubber-tyred metro systems are:

Disadvantages

The higher friction and increased rolling resistance cause disadvantages (compared to steel wheel on steel rail):

Although it is a more complex technology, most rubber-tyred metro systems use quite simple techniques, in contrast to guided buses. Heat dissipation is an issue as eventually all traction energy consumed by the train — except the electric energy regenerated back into the substation during electrodynamic braking — will end up in losses (mostly heat). In frequently operated tunnels (typical metro operation) the extra heat from rubber tyres is a widespread problem, necessitating ventilation of the tunnels. As a result, some rubber-tyred metro systems do not have air-conditioned trains, as air conditioning would heat the tunnels to temperatures where operation is not possible.

Similar technologies

Automated driverless systems are not exclusively rubber-tyred; many have since been built using conventional rail technology, such as London's Docklands Light Railway, the Copenhagen metro and Vancouver's SkyTrain, the Hong Kong Disneyland Resort line, which uses converted rolling stocks from non-driverless trains, as well as AirTrain JFK, which links JFK Airport in New York City with local subway and commuter trains. Most monorail manufacturers prefer rubber tyres.

List of systems

width=125pxCountry/Regionwidth=150pxCity/Regionwidth=250pxSystemwidth=225pxTechnologyYear opened
CanadaMontrealMontreal MetroBombardier MR-73 (Green, Blue, Yellow)
Alstom/Bombardier MPM-10 (Orange, Green)
1966
ChileSantiagoSantiago Metro (Lines 1, 2, and 5)Alstom NS-74 (5)
Concarril NS-88 (2)
Alstom NS-93 (1, 5)
Alstom NS-04 (2)
CAF NS-07 (1)
CAF NS-12 (1)
Alstom NS-16 (2, 5)
1975
ChongqingBishan SkyShuttleBYD Skyshuttle2021
GuangzhouZhujiang New Town Automated People Mover SystemBombardier Innovia APM 1002010
ShanghaiShanghai Metro (Pujiang line)Bombardier Innovia APM 3002018
FranceLilleLille MetroMatra VAL206
Siemens VAL208
1983
LyonLyon Metro (Lines A, B, and D)Alstom MPL 75 (A, B)
Alstom MPL 85 (D)
1978
MarseilleMarseille MetroAlstom MPM 761977
ParisParis Métro (Lines 1, 4, 6, 11, and 14)Michelin / Alstom, between Rollways1958
Paris (Orly Airport)OrlyvalMatra VAL2061991
Paris (Charles de Gaulle Airport)CDGVALSiemens VAL2082007
RennesRennes MetroSiemens VAL208 (A)Siemens Cityval (B)2002
ToulouseToulouse MetroMatra VAL206
Siemens VAL208
1993
GermanyFrankfurt AirportSkyLineBombardier Innovia APM 100 (as Adtranz CX-100)1994
Munich AirportBombardier Innovia APM 3002015
IndonesiaSoekarno–Hatta International AirportSoekarno–Hatta Airport SkytrainWoojin2017
Hong KongAutomated People MoverMitsubishi Crystal Mover
Ishikawajima-Harima
1998
2007 (Phase II)
ItalyTurinMetrotorinoSiemens VAL2082006
JapanHiroshimaHiroshima Rapid Transit (Astram Line)Kawasaki
Mitsubishi
Niigata Transys
1994
KobeKobe New Transit (Port Island Line / Rokkō Island Line)Kawasaki1981 (Port Island Line)
1990 (Rokkō Island Line)
OsakaNankō Port Town LineNiigata Transys1981
SaitamaNew Shuttle1983
SapporoSapporo Municipal SubwayKawasaki1971
TokyoYurikamomeMitsubishi
Niigata Transys
Nippon Sharyo
Tokyu
1995
Nippori-Toneri LinerNiigata Transys2008
Tokorozawa / HigashimurayamaSeibu Yamaguchi LineNiigata Transys1985
SakuraYamaman Yūkarigaoka LineNippon Sharyo1982
YokohamaKanazawa Seaside LineMitsubishi
Niigata Transys
Nippon Sharyo
Tokyu
1989
BusanBusan Subway Line 4K-AGT (Woojin)2011
Uijeongbu, Gyeonggi-doU LineSiemens VAL2082012
SeoulSillim LineK-AGT (Woojin)2022
Taipa, CotaiMacau Light Rapid TransitMitsubishi Crystal Mover2019
MalaysiaKuala Lumpur International AirportAerotrainBombardier Innovia APM 100 (as Adtranz CX-100)1998
MexicoMexico CityMexico City Metro (All lines except A & 12)Michelin, between Rollways1969
SingaporeSingaporeLight Rail TransitBombardier Innovia APM 100 (C801 [as Adtranz CX-100] and C801A) and future APM 300R (C801B)
Mitsubishi Crystal Mover (C810 and C810A)
1999
SwitzerlandLausanneLausanne Metro Line M2Alstom MP 892008
TaipeiTaipei Metro Brown LineMatra/GEC Alsthom VAL 256
Bombardier Innovia APM 256
1996
Taoyuan AirportTaoyuan International Airport SkytrainNiigata Transys2018
ThailandBangkokGold LineBombardier Innovia APM 3002020
Dubai International AirportDubai International Airport Automated People MoverMitsubishi Crystal Mover (Terminal 3)
Bombardier Innovia APM 300 (Terminal 1)
2013
United KingdomGatwick AirportTerminal-Rail ShuttleBombardier Innovia APM 100 (Replaced C-100s)1988
Stansted, Essex (Stansted Airport)Stansted Airport Transit SystemWestinghouse/Adtranz C-100
Adtranz/Bombardier CX-100
1991
Heathrow AirportHeathrow Terminal 5 TransitBombardier Innovia APM 2002008
United StatesChicago, Illinois (O'Hare)Airport Transit SystemBombardier Innovia APM 256 (Replaced VAL256s in 2019)1993–2018 (VAL), 2021 (Innovia)
Dallas/Fort Worth, Texas (DFW Airport)DFW SkylinkBombardier Innovia APM 2002007
Denver, Colorado (DEN Airport)Automated Guideway Transit SystemBombardier Innovia APM 1001995
Houston, Texas (George Bush Intercontinental Airport)SkywayBombardier Innovia APM 100 (as Adtranz CX-100)1999
Miami, FloridaMetromoverBombardier Innovia APM 100 (Replaced C-100s late 2014)1986
Phoenix, Arizona (Sky Harbor International Airport)PHX Sky TrainBombardier Innovia APM 2002013
San Francisco, California (SFO Airport)AirTrain (SFO)Bombardier Innovia APM 1002003
Hartsfield–Jackson Atlanta International Airport (ATL)The Plane Train1980
Washington, D.C. (Dulles International Airport)AeroTrainMitsubishi Heavy Industries Crystal Mover2010

Under construction

width=125pxCountry/Regionwidth=150pxCity/Regionwidth=250pxSystem
BusanBusan Metro Line 5
United StatesLos Angeles, California (LAX Airport)LAX Automated People Mover

Defunct systems

Country/RegionCity/RegionSystemTechnologyYear openedYear closed
FranceLaonCable-driven19892016
JapanKomakiPeachliner19912006

See also

References

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Rubber-Tyred Metro . Rail System . 17 November 2021.
  2. GB . 10990. 10 June 1846.
  3. Book: Tompkins , Eric . The History of the Pneumatic Tyre . 1: Invention . 1981 . Dunlop Archive Project . 0-903214-14-8 . 2–4 . https://archive.org/details/historyofpneumat0000tomp/page/2 .
  4. Web site: Sapporo Subway . UrbanRail.Net . 15 April 2008. dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20080429201618/http://www.urbanrail.net/as/sapp/sapporo.htm . 29 April 2008.
  5. Web site: Sticking with rubber . . 14 September 2005 . 21 December 2011 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20120517031404/http://www.canada.com/montrealgazette/features/metro/story.html?id=c84a8361-0981-403c-b6df-8ce82fc71db2 . 17 May 2012 .
  6. Book: Harrison, Matthew C.. SAE Technical Paper Series. 1 February 1974. Rubber Tire vs. Steel Wheel Tradeoffs. 1. https://www.sae.org/content/740228/. 740228. 10.4271/740228.
  7. Airborne Particulate Debris from Rubber Tires . Pierson . W. R. . Brachaczek . Wanda W. . . 1 November 1974 . 47 . 5 . 1275–1299 . 10.5254/1.3540499.