Rechargeable lithium metal battery explained

Rechargeable lithium metal batteries are secondary lithium metal batteries. They have metallic lithium as a negative electrode. The high specific capacity of lithium metal (3,860 mAh g−1), very low redox potential (−3.040 V versus standard hydrogen electrode) and low density (0.59 g cm−3) make it the ideal negative material for high energy density battery technologies.[1] Rechargeable lithium metal batteries can have a long run time due to the high charge density of lithium. Several companies and many academic research groups are currently researching and developing rechargeable lithium metal batteries as they are considered a leading pathway for development beyond lithium-ion batteries.[2] Some rechargeable lithium metal batteries employ a liquid electrolyte and some employ a solid-state electrolyte.

History

A rechargeable lithium metal battery was commercialized by Moli Energy (now known as E-One Moli Energy) in the 1980s, but after several cells caught fire, devices using Moli batteries were recalled and the company went into receivership.[3]

Research directions

The primary challenges in developing practical rechargeable lithium metal batteries are low cell life due to low Coulombic efficiency, and poor reliability due to dendrite formation causing a short-circuit. Efforts to improve performance center around the choice of electrolyte, since the electrolyte reaction with lithium dictates Coulombic efficiency, and the separator electrolyte must withstand dendrite formation.

Liquid electrolyte

Research directions include high salt systems, additives or fluorine-containing electrolytes that form solid-electrolyte interface (SEI) layers on lithium, and encapsulating lithium inside protective shells.

In 2023, solvent-free electrolytes based on low-melting molten salt mixtures were shown to have wide electrochemical window (5 V), good compatibility with Li metal anode, and negligible flammability/volatility.[4] [5] They represent a promising direction towards high-performance and safe rechargeable Li metal batteries.

Solid-state electrolyte

Solid polymer electrolytes such as poly-ethylene oxide (PEO) have been researched for decades but require high temperature, low voltage cathodes, and low current densities to reach reasonable cycle life and reliability.[6] Inorganic-polymer composites have been studied to find a processable, flexible system. Many inorganic materials families have been studied, including LiPON, lithium borohydride, glassy, semi-crystalline, and crystalline sulfides, NASICON structured phosphates, perovskites, anti-perovskites, and garnets.

Commercialization

Rechargeable lithium metal batteries have been commercialized by Bolloré in the Bluecar program, and thin film batteries with low energy content were sold by Cymbet and others. Several companies are developing rechargeable lithium metal batteries for applications in consumer electronics devices and electric vehicles. The status of the development efforts that have publicly announced data is summarized in the table below.

Lithium metal cell cycling data summary
Organization Cell size Current density Cycles Pressure Mass loading Temperature Source
Ion Storage Systems 1 layer coin cell 0.2 mA/cm2 25 ? 2.5 mAh/cm2 25 [7]
PolyPlus 1 layer coin cell 0.4 mA/cm2 50 ? 2.6 mAh/cm2 ? [8]
Samsung600 mAh 2 layer 3.4 mA/cm2 100020 atm 6.8 mAh/cm2 60 °C [9]
Sion 1.8 Ah C/1.5 700 ? ? ? [10]
70 mm × 85 mm 10-layer 3.2 mA/cm2 800 3.4 atm 3.2 mAh/cm2 29 °C [11]

Characteristics

Although this type of battery has been available as small coin batteries since the 2000's, attempts to produce larger versions capable of providing large amounts of power have, so far, proved unsuccessful. Lithium metal batteries have very different characteristics to the more common lithium-ion batteries.[12]

Their terminal voltage is lower than lithium ion ranging from 3.1 volts when fully charged to 1.0 volts at full discharge. Unlike lithium ion, the terminal voltage does not steadily fall as discharge proceeds. The voltage falls from 3.1 volts to 2.5  within approximately the first 10% of discharge. From here the terminal voltage remains relatively constant at 2.5 volts until about 10% of the useable charge remains. From here it falls to 1.0 volt at which the battery should not be discharged further as permanent damage will result.

The biggest disadvantage of the current lithium metal battery is that the maximum discharge current is a paltry 0.2% of the capacity. That is for a 5 mAh battery (a typical current size), the maximum discharge current is just 10 μA.[13]

The battery's charging requirements are also very different to the lithium ion type. Just as the maximum discharge current is very low, so is the maximum charge current. The only recommended method is to charge the battery from a voltage supply of exactly 3.1 volts through a current limiting resistor. The resistor value is found by dividing 5 by the mAh capacity of the battery. The downside is that battery must charge over a 30 hour period.

The discharge and charge characteristics dictate that this type of battery is only suitable for applications such as memory backup power or powering a real time clock chip in (say) a camera.

The battery has a temperature characteristic very different to lithium-ion batteries. The official temperature range is -20 to 60 °C. Compared with 20 °C, the battery undergoes about a 15% reduction in available capacity at -20 °C which is not that unusual. However: at 60 °C, the battery exhibits an additional 5-10% capacity.

One big advantage is that the self discharge rate of this battery type is the lowest of any existing rechargeable battery technology. so low, in fact, that the batteries have a shelf life of greater than 10 years.

See also

Notes and References

  1. Xu . Wu . Wang . Jiulin . Ding . Fei . Chen . Xilin . Nasybulin . Eduard . Zhang . Yaohui . Zhang . Ji-Guang . 2014 . Lithium metal anodes for rechargeable batteries . Energy Environ. Sci. . en . 7 . 2 . 513–537 . 10.1039/C3EE40795K . 1754-5692.
  2. Status and challenges in enabling the lithium metal electrode for high-energy and low-cost rechargeable batteries. 2018. 10.1038/s41560-017-0047-2. 2021-02-13. Albertus. Paul. Susan Babinec . Babinec. Susan. Litzelman. Scott. Newman. Aron. Nature Energy. 3. 16–21. 2018NatEn...3...16A. 139241677.
  3. New lessons from the epic story of Moli Energy, the Canadian pioneer of rechargeable lithium battery technology . Electric Autonomy Canada. Emma Jarratt. ArcAscent Inc. . 2020-09-18 . 2021-05-09 .
  4. Phan . An L . Jayawardana . Chamithri . Le . Phung ML . Zhang . Jiaxun . Nan . Bo . Zhang . Weiran . Lucht . Brett L . Hou . Singyuk . Wang . Chunsheng . August 2023 . Solvent-Free Electrolyte for High-Temperature Rechargeable Lithium Metal Batteries . Advanced Functional Materials . en . 33 . 34 . 10.1002/adfm.202301177 . 1616-301X. 1903/30697 . free .
  5. Vu . Minh Canh . Mirmira . Priyadarshini . Gomes . Reginaldo J. . Ma . Peiyuan . Doyle . Emily S. . Srinivasan . Hrishikesh S. . Amanchukwu . Chibueze V. . December 2023 . Low melting alkali-based molten salt electrolytes for solvent-free lithium-metal batteries . Matter . 6 . 12 . 4357–4375 . 10.1016/j.matt.2023.10.017 . 2590-2385.
  6. New Lithium Metal Polymer Solid State Battery for an Ultrahigh Energy: Nano C-LiFePO4 versus Nano Li1.2V3O8. 2015. 10.1021/acs.nanolett.5b00326. 2021-02-13. Hovington. P.. Lagacé. M.. Guerfi. A.. Bouchard. P.. Mauger. A.. Julien. C. M.. Armand. M.. Zaghib. K.. Nano Letters. 15. 4. 2671–2678. 25714564 . 2015NanoL..15.2671H.
  7. 3D lithium metal anodes hosted . 10.1016/j.ensm.2018.04.015 . 103494783 . free .
  8. Web site: ARPA-E IONICS 2020 update. 2021-02-13.
  9. High-energy long-cycling all-solid-state lithium metal batteries enabled by silver–carbon composite anodes . 2020 . 10.1038/s41560-020-0575-z . 2021-02-13. Lee . Yong-Gun . Fujiki . Satoshi . Jung . Changhoon . Suzuki . Naoki . Yashiro . Nobuyoshi . Omoda . Ryo . Ko . Dong-Su . Shiratsuchi . Tomoyuki . Sugimoto . Toshinori . Ryu . Saebom . Ku . Jun Hwan . Watanabe . Taku . Park . Youngsin . Aihara . Yuichi . Im . Dongmin . Han . In Taek . Nature Energy . 5 . 4 . 299–308 . 2020NatEn...5..299L . 216386265 .
  10. Web site: Key EV Battery Performance Requirements. 2021-02-13.
  11. Web site: Quantumscape Q4 2021 Shareholder Letter . 2022-02-21.
  12. Panasonic Lithium Handbook- section entitled "Lithium metal coin batteries" dated August 2005
  13. From Panasonic data sheet for ML621 battery dated August 2005