Prolate spheroidal coordinates explained

Prolate spheroidal coordinates are a three-dimensional orthogonal coordinate system that results from rotating the two-dimensional elliptic coordinate system about the focal axis of the ellipse, i.e., the symmetry axis on which the foci are located. Rotation about the other axis produces oblate spheroidal coordinates. Prolate spheroidal coordinates can also be considered as a limiting case of ellipsoidal coordinates in which the two smallest principal axes are equal in length.

Prolate spheroidal coordinates can be used to solve various partial differential equations in which the boundary conditions match its symmetry and shape, such as solving for a field produced by two centers, which are taken as the foci on the z-axis. One example is solving for the wavefunction of an electron moving in the electromagnetic field of two positively charged nuclei, as in the hydrogen molecular ion, H₂⁺. Another example is solving for the electric field generated by two small electrode tips. Other limiting cases include areas generated by a line segment (μ = 0) or a line with a missing segment (ν=0). The electronic structure of general diatomic molecules with many electrons can also be solved to excellent precision in the prolate spheroidal coordinate system.^[1]

Definition

The most common definition of prolate spheroidal coordinates

(\mu, \nu, \varphi) isx = a \sinh \mu \sin \nu \cos \varphi y = a \sinh \mu \sin \nu \sin \varphi z = a \cosh \mu \cos \nu

where

\mu is a nonnegative real number and \nu \in [ 0 , \pi] . The azimuthal angle \varphi belongs to the interval [ 0 , 2 \pi] .

The trigonometric identity

(z ^{2})/(a ^{2} \cosh ^{2} \mu) + (x ^{2} + y ^{2})/(a ^{2} \sinh ^{2} \mu) = \cos ^{2} \nu + \sin ^{2} \nu = 1

shows that surfaces of constant

\mu form prolate spheroids, since they are ellipses rotated about the axis joining their foci. Similarly, the hyperbolic trigonometric identity(z ^{2})/(a ^{2} \cos ^{2} \nu) - (x ^{2} + y ^{2})/(a ^{2} \sin ^{2} \nu) = \cosh ^{2} \mu - \sinh ^{2} \mu = 1

shows that surfaces of constant

\nu form hyperboloids of revolution.

The distances from the foci located at

(x, y, z) = ( 0 , 0 , \pm a) arer _{\pm} = \sqrt{x ^{2} + y ^{2} + (z \mp a) ^{2}} = a(\cosh \mu \mp \cos \nu).

Scale factors

The scale factors for the elliptic coordinates

(\mu, \nu) are equalh _{\mu} = h _{\nu} = a\sqrt{\sinh ^{2\mu} + \sin ^{2\nu}}

whereas the azimuthal scale factor is

h _{\varphi} = a \sinh\mu \sin\nu,

resulting in a metric of

\begin{align} ds ^{2} & = h ^{2} _{\mu} d\mu ^{2} + h ^{2} _{\nu} d\nu ^{2} + h ^{2} _{\varphi} d\varphi ^{2} \\ & = a ^{2} \left[ (\sinh ^{2\mu} + \sin ^{2\nu)} d\mu ^{2} + (\sinh ^{2\mu} + \sin ^{2\nu)} d\nu ^{2} + (\sinh ^{2\mu} \sin ^{2\nu)} d\varphi ^{2} \right]. \end{align}

Consequently, an infinitesimal volume element equals

dV = a ^{3} \sinh\mu \sin\nu ( \sinh ^{2} \mu + \sin ^{2} \nu) d\mu d\nu d\varphi

and the Laplacian can be written

\begin{align} \nabla ^{2} \Phi = {} & (1)/(a ^{2} (\sinh ^{2} \mu + \sin ^{2} \nu)) \left[ (\partial ^{2} \Phi)/(\partial \mu ^{2}) + (\partial ^{2} \Phi)/(\partial \nu ^{2}) + \coth \mu (\partial \Phi)/(\partial \mu) + \cot \nu (\partial \Phi)/(\partial \nu) \right] \\[ 6 pt] & {} + (1)/(a ^{2} \sinh ^{2} \mu \sin ^{2\nu}) (\partial ^{2} \Phi)/(\partial \varphi ^{2}) \end{align}

Other differential operators such as

\nabla ⋅ F and \nabla x F can be expressed in the coordinates (\mu, \nu, \varphi) by substituting the scale factors into the general formulae found in orthogonal coordinates.

Alternative definition

An alternative and geometrically intuitive set of prolate spheroidal coordinates

(\sigma, \tau, \phi) are sometimes used, where \sigma = \cosh \mu and \tau = \cos \nu . Hence, the curves of constant \sigma are prolate spheroids, whereas the curves of constant \tau are hyperboloids of revolution. The coordinate \tau belongs to the interval [−1, 1], whereas the \sigma coordinate must be greater than or equal to one. The coordinates \sigma and \tau have a simple relation to the distances to the foci F _{1} and F _{2} . For any point in the plane, the sum d _{1} + d _{2} of its distances to the foci equals 2 a\sigma , whereas their difference d _{1} - d _{2} equals 2 a\tau . Thus, the distance to F _{1} is a(\sigma + \tau) , whereas the distance to F _{2} is a(\sigma - \tau) . (Recall that F _{1} and F _{2} are located at z =- a and z =+ a , respectively.) This gives the following expressions for \sigma , \tau , and \varphi :\sigma = (1)/(2 a) \left(\sqrt{x ^{2+y} ^{2+(z+a)} ^{2}+\sqrt{x} ^{2+y} ^{2+(z-a)} ^{2}\right)} \tau = (1)/(2 a) \left(\sqrt{x ^{2+y} ^{2+(z+a)} ^{2}-\sqrt{x} ^{2+y} ^{2+(z-a)} ^{2}\right)} \varphi = \arctan\left( (y)/(x) \right)

Unlike the analogous oblate spheroidal coordinates, the prolate spheroid coordinates (σ, τ, φ) are not degenerate; in other words, there is a unique, reversible correspondence between them and the Cartesian coordinates

x = a \sqrt{(\sigma ^{2} - 1 ) ( 1 - \tau ^{2)}} \cos \varphi y = a \sqrt{(\sigma ^{2} - 1 ) ( 1 - \tau ^{2)}} \sin \varphi z = a \sigma \tau

Alternative scale factors

The scale factors for the alternative elliptic coordinates

(\sigma, \tau, \varphi) areh _{\sigma} = a\sqrt{ (\sigma ^{2} - \tau ^{2})/(\sigma ^{2} -1) }h _{\tau} = a\sqrt{ (\sigma ^{2} - \tau ^{2})/(1- \tau ^{2}) }

while the azimuthal scale factor is now

h _{\varphi} = a \sqrt{\left( \sigma ^{2} - 1 \right) \left( 1 - \tau ^{2} \right)}

Hence, the infinitesimal volume element becomes

dV = a ^{3} (\sigma ^{2} - \tau ^{2)} d\sigma d\tau d\varphi

and the Laplacian equals

\begin{align} \nabla ^{2} \Phi = {} & (1)/(a ^{2} (\sigma ^{2} - \tau ^{2)}) \left\{ (\partial)/(\partial \sigma) \left[ \left( \sigma ^{2} - 1 \right) (\partial \Phi)/(\partial \sigma) \right] + (\partial)/(\partial \tau) \left[ ( 1 - \tau ^{2)} (\partial \Phi)/(\partial \tau) \right] \right\} \\ & {} + (1)/(a ^{2} (\sigma ^{2} -1 ) ( 1- \tau ^{2)}) (\partial ^{2} \Phi)/(\partial \varphi ^{2}) \end{align}

Other differential operators such as

\nabla ⋅ F and \nabla x F can be expressed in the coordinates (\sigma, \tau) by substituting the scale factors into the general formulae found in orthogonal coordinates.

As is the case with spherical coordinates, Laplace's equation may be solved by the method of separation of variables to yield solutions in the form of prolate spheroidal harmonics, which are convenient to use when boundary conditions are defined on a surface with a constant prolate spheroidal coordinate (See Smythe, 1968).

Bibliography

No angles convention

• Book: Morse PM, Feshbach H . 1953 . Methods of Theoretical Physics, Part I . McGraw-Hill . New York . 661. Uses ξ₁ = a cosh μ, ξ₂ = sin ν, and ξ₃ = cos φ.
• Book: Zwillinger D . 1992 . Handbook of Integration . Jones and Bartlett . Boston, MA . 0-86720-293-9 . 114. Same as Morse & Feshbach (1953), substituting u_k for ξ_k.
• Book: Smythe, WR. Static and Dynamic Electricity . 3rd . McGraw-Hill . New York . 1968.
• Book: Sauer R, Szabó I . 1967 . Mathematische Hilfsmittel des Ingenieurs . Springer Verlag . New York . 97 . 67025285. Uses coordinates ξ = cosh μ, η = sin ν, and φ.

Angle convention

• Book: . 1961 . Mathematical Handbook for Scientists and Engineers . registration . McGraw-Hill . New York . 177 . 59014456. Korn and Korn use the (μ, ν, φ) coordinates, but also introduce the degenerate (σ, τ, φ) coordinates.
• Book: Margenau H, Murphy GM . 1956 . The Mathematics of Physics and Chemistry . registration . D. van Nostrand . New York. 180 - 182 . 55010911 . Similar to Korn and Korn (1961), but uses colatitude θ = 90° - ν instead of latitude ν.
• Book: Moon PH, Spencer DE . 1988 . Prolate Spheroidal Coordinates (η, θ, ψ) . Field Theory Handbook, Including Coordinate Systems, Differential Equations, and Their Solutions . corrected 2nd ed., 3rd print . Springer Verlag . New York . 0-387-02732-7 . 28 - 30 (Table 1.06). Moon and Spencer use the colatitude convention θ = 90° − ν, and rename φ as ψ.

Unusual convention

• Book: Landau LD, Lifshitz EM, Pitaevskii LP . 1984 . Electrodynamics of Continuous Media (Volume 8 of the Course of Theoretical Physics) . 2nd . Pergamon Press . New York . 978-0-7506-2634-7 . 19 - 29 . Treats the prolate spheroidal coordinates as a limiting case of the general ellipsoidal coordinates. Uses (ξ, η, ζ) coordinates that have the units of distance squared.

External links

• MathWorld description of prolate spheroidal coordinates

Notes and References

1. Lehtola. Susi. 21 May 2019. A review on non-relativistic, fully numerical electronic structure calculations on atoms and diatomic molecules. Int. J. Quantum Chem.. 119. e25968. 10.1002/qua.25968. free. 1902.01431.