Overspecialization Explained

Overspecialization is when a person works in an excessively narrow occupation or scientific field.[1]

Effects

In work

In the workplace, specialization of labor is used to divide up the workload in a manner that improves efficiency. However, holders of overspecialized positions tend to perform repetitive jobs, leading to boredom, dissatisfaction, and lower-quality output.[2]

In medicine

The breadth of medical knowledge has expanded vastly since the 1980s.[3] It has been argued that specialization is necessary in medicine to divide up the vast knowledge needed to tackle certain classes of diseases, such as cancer.[4] However, specializing too narrowly leads to poor training; unnecessary health care; low-quality care, especially in regions with poor medical infrastructure;[5] and knowledge that can rapidly become outdated. Overspecialization detracts from physicians' ability to identify and treat problems in patients.[3] One proposed solution is to use databases that streamline the obtaining of necessary information and knowledge, while teaching medicine to a depth that the human mind can handle.[3]

In academia

Modern universities offer a large number of academic majors where students can pursue research. However, overspecialization is considered to be a serious problem in research because it prevents academics from assessing the relationship between different fields in order to solve certain problems.[6]

The Ph.D system has been criticized for encouraging overspecialization, which can leave students ill-prepared for corporate jobs.[7]

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Definition of OVERSPECIALIZE . . 28 May 2020 . en.
  2. Adeyoyin . Samuel Olu . Agbeze-Unazi . Florence . Oyewunmi . Olatundun . Adegun . Adewale . Ayodele . Rafiu . Effects of Job Specialization and Departmentalization on Job Satisfaction among the Staff of a Nigerian University Library . Library Philosophy and Practice (E-journal) . 1 January 2015 . 2 June 2020.
  3. Papaioakeim . Miltiadis . Kaldoudi . Eleni . Vargemezis . Vasilios . Simopolous . K . Confronting the Problem of Ever Expanding Core Knowledge and the Necessity of Handling Over-Specialized Disciplines in Medical Education . November 2006 . Proceedings of ITAB . 25–27 . 2 June 2020.
  4. Book: Donald W. Seldin . Biomedical Scientists and Public Policy . 1978 . Springer US . 978-1-4613-2886-5 . Specialization as Scientific Advancement and Overspecialization as Social Distortion.
  5. Villet . R. . Overspecialization in surgery . French: Mémoires de l'Académie de Chirurgie . 1991 . 117 . 3 . 212–3 . 1797472 . 2 June 2020 . fr.
  6. Web site: The dangers of overspecialization in academia . . 28 May 2020 . en . 19 September 2018.
  7. Web site: Rethinking the Ph.D. . 1 June 2020 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20080421004607/http://units.aps.org/units/fiap/newsletters/nov95/03.cfm . 21 April 2008 . John A. Armstrong, "Rethinking the PhD", originally appeared in Issues in Science and Technology.