The verse (ayah) 256 of Al-Baqara is a very famous verse in the Islamic scripture, the Quran.[1] The verse includes the phrase that "there is no compulsion in religion". Immediately after making this statement, the Quran offers a rationale for it: Since the revelation has, through explanation, clarification, and repetition, clearly distinguished the path of guidance from the path of misguidance, it is now up to people to choose the one or the other path. This verse comes right after the Throne Verse.[2]
The overwhelming majority of Muslim scholars consider that verse to be a Medinan one,[3] [4] [5] when Muslims lived in their period of political ascendance,[6] [7] and to be non abrogated,[8] including Ibn Taymiyya,[9] Ibn Qayyim,[10] Al-Tabari,[11] Abi ʿUbayd,[12] Al-Jaṣṣās,[13] Makki bin Abi Talib,[14] Al-Nahhas,[15] Ibn Jizziy,[16] Al-Suyuti,[17] Ibn Ashur,[18] Mustafa Zayd,[19] and many others.[20] According to all the theories of language elaborated by Muslim legal scholars, the Quranic proclamation that 'There is no compulsion in religion. The right path has been distinguished from error' is as absolute and universal a statement as one finds,[21] and so under no condition should an individual be forced to accept a religion or belief against his or her will according to the Quran.[22] [23] [24] [25]
The meaning of the principle that there is no compulsion in religion was not limited to freedom of individuals to choose their own religion. Islam also provided non-Muslims with considerable economic, cultural, and administrative rights.[26]
According to some commentators, this verse (Quran 2:256) was directed towards a small group of residents of Medina and is related to an incident during the time of the Prophet. The incident involved a Muslim boy who had been educated in a Jewish school in Medina and decided to depart with a Jewish tribe that was being expelled from the city. When the boy's distraught parents asked the Prophet if they could compel their son to stay, he told them that there is no compulsion in religion, as stated in the verse.[27] [28] It is reported that Mujahid said that "This verse was revealed about a man of the Helpers who had a black boy called Subayh whom he used to coerce to become Muslim".[29]
In all cases, following the famous maxim (Consideration is granted to the Generality of the Language, not to the Specificity of the Reason [for Revelation])[30] [31] [32] it is concluded that the verse is general in meaning,[27] [28] and thus the verse has been understood over the centuries as a general command that people cannot be forced to convert to Islam.[27] [33]
According to Khaled Abou El Fadl, and other scholars such as S. A. Rahman,[34] the phrase "there is no compulsion in religion" from verse Q.2:256[35]
Other Islamic scholars disagree.[37] First, the "no compulsion" phrase should not be used out of context and all exegesis of Quran that is "linear-atomistic" analysis of one small phrase in one verse is flawed.[38] The complete verse and nearby verses should be read to understand the "complex hermeneutic totality" of context for anything in Quran.
It is reported that Mujahid said that "This verse was revealed about a man of the Helpers [Ansar of Medina] who had a black boy called Subayh whom he used to coerce to become Muslim".[29] In addition scholar argue, no single phrase or verse in Quran is less or more relevant in Islam than other phrases or verses in Quran; and other verses in Quran such as verse 66 of At-Tawba state "Make no excuses! You have lost faith after your belief. If We pardon a group of you, We will punish others for their wickedness.", As well as "And say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “˹This is˺ the truth from your Lord. Whoever wills let them believe, and whoever wills let them disbelieve.” ...",[39] "Had your Lord so willed ˹O Prophet˺, all ˹people˺ on earth would have certainly believed, every single one of them! Would you then force people to become believers?",[40] "So, ˹continue to˺ remind ˹all, O Prophet˺, for your duty is only to remind. You are not ˹there˺ to compel them ˹to believe˺",[41] "He said, “O my people! Consider if I stand on a clear proof from my Lord and He has blessed me with a mercy from Himself,1 which you fail to see. Should we ˹then˺ force it on you against your will?". According to some western scholars, in the history of Islamic exegesis scholarship, that verse is considered as an early revelation, and abrogated by verses that were revealed to Muhammad at a later stage in his life.[42] However, as stated by the famous British orientalist Sir Thomas Walker Arnold the verse in question is a Medinan verse, when Muslims lived in their period of political ascendance. Moreover, Muslim scholars have established the abrogated verses and Q.2:256 isn't among them.[17] Finally, to understand the Quran, the sayings and actions of Muhammad as recorded in Hadith collections are considered by Islamic scholars. Taken together, the vast majority of Islamic scholars of every fiqh have traditionally held with the position that there should be punishment for apostasy in Islam.[43]
The Quran commentator (Muffasir) Ibn Kathir, a Sunni, suggests that the verse implies that Muslims should not force anyone to convert to Islam since the truth of Islam is so self-evident that no one is in need of being coerced into it,[28]
Kashani, a Sufi,[44] interprets Q.2:256 as follows
A number of verses relate to Quran 2:256 and this includes,
These verses indicate that compulsion is strictly prohibited.[21] [26] [28] [35] [45] [46]
. A.C. Brown. Jonathan. Jonathan A.C. Brown. Misquoting Muhammad: The Challenge and Choices of Interpreting the Prophet's Legacy. 2014. Oneworld Publications. 978-1780744209. 186. registration.
. A.C. Brown. Jonathan. Jonathan A.C. Brown. Misquoting Muhammad: The Challenge and Choices of Interpreting the Prophet's Legacy. 2014. Oneworld Publications. 978-1780744209. 92. 3. The Fragile Truth Of Scripture. registration.
. S. A. Rahman. S. A. Rahman. Punishment of Apostasy in Islam. https://books.google.com/books?id=L4fsYtFf5AoC. 2007. The Other Press. 978-983-9541-49-6. 132–142. Summary and Conclusions.
. S. A. Rahman. S. A. Rahman. Punishment of Apostasy in Islam. 2007. The Other Press. 978-983-9541-49-6. 7–15, 110–123.
. Hashim Kamali. Mohammad. Mohammad Hashim Kamali. Shari'ah Law: An Introduction. registration. 2008. Oneworld Publications. 978-1851685653. 202–3.