Transitive verb explained

A transitive verb is a verb that entails one or more transitive objects, for example, 'enjoys' in Amadeus enjoys music. This contrasts with intransitive verbs, which do not entail transitive objects, for example, 'arose' in Beatrice arose.

Transitivity is traditionally thought of as a global property of a clause, by which activity is transferred from an agent to a patient.[1]

Transitive verbs can be classified by the number of objects they require. Verbs that entail only two arguments, a subject and a single direct object, are monotransitive. Verbs that entail two objects, a direct object and an indirect object, are ditransitive,[2] or less commonly bitransitive.[3] An example of a ditransitive verb in English is the verb to give, which may feature a subject, an indirect object, and a direct object: John gave Mary the book.

Verbs that take three objects are tritransitive.[4] In English a tritransitive verb features an indirect object, a direct object, and a prepositional phrase – as in I'll trade you this bicycle for your binoculars – or else a clause that behaves like an argument – as in I bet you a pound that he has forgotten.[5] Not all descriptive grammars recognize tritransitive verbs.[6]

A clause with a prepositional phrase that expresses a meaning similar to that usually expressed by an object may be called pseudo-transitive. For example, the Indonesian sentences Dia masuk sekolah ("He attended school") and Dia masuk ke sekolah ("He went into the school") have the same verb (masuk "enter"), but the first sentence has a direct object while the second has a prepositional phrase in its place.[7] A clause with a direct object plus a prepositional phrase may be called pseudo-ditransitive, as in the Lakhota sentence Haŋpíkčeka kiŋ lená wé-čage ("I made those moccasins for him").[8] Such constructions are sometimes called complex transitive. The category of complex transitives includes not only prepositional phrases but also dependent clauses, appositives, and other structures.[9] There is some controversy regarding complex transitives and tritransitives; linguists disagree on the nature of the structures.

In contrast to transitive verbs, some verbs take zero objects. Verbs that do not require an object are called intransitive verbs. An example in modern English is the verb to arrive.

Verbs that can be used in an intransitive or transitive way are called ambitransitive verbs. In English, an example is the verb to eat; the sentences You eat (with an intransitive form) and You eat apples (a transitive form that has apples as the object) are both grammatical.

The concept of valency is related to transitivity. The valency of a verb considers all the arguments the verb takes, including both the subject and all of the objects. In contrast to valency, the transitivity of a verb only considers the objects. Subcategorization is roughly synonymous with valency, though they come from different theoretical traditions.

History

Transitive phrases, i.e. phrases containing transitive verbs, were first recognized by the stoics and from the Peripatetic school, but they probably referred to the whole phrase containing the transitive verb, not just to the verb.[10] [11] The advancements of the stoics were later developed by the philologists of the Alexandrian school.[10]

Lexical vis-à-vis grammatical information

Traditionally, transitivity patterns are thought of as lexical information of the verb, but recent research in construction grammar and related theories has argued that transitivity is a grammatical rather than a lexical property, since the same verb very often appears with different transitivity in different contexts. Consider:

In grammatical construction theories, transitivity is considered as an element of grammatical construction, rather than an inherent part of verbs.[12] [13]

In English

The following sentences exemplify transitive verbs in English.

Other languages

In some languages, morphological features separate verbs based on their transitivity, which suggests this is a salient linguistic feature. For example, in Japanese:

However, the definition of transitive verbs as those with one object is not universal, and is not used in grammars of many languages.

In Hungarian

Hungarian is sometimes misunderstood to have transitive and intransitive conjugation for all verbs, but there is really only one general conjugation.In present and future, there is a lesser used variant – a definite, or say emphatic conjugation form. It is used only when referring to a previous sentence, or topic, where the object was already mentioned. Logically the definite article a(z) as reference is used here—and due to verb emphasis (definite), word order changes to VO.

házat látok — I see (a) house – (general)

látom a házat — I see the house – (The house we were looking for)

almát eszem — I eat (an) apple – (general)

eszem az almát — I eat the apple – (The one mom told me to)

bort iszom — I drink wine – (general)

iszom a bort — I drink the wine – (That you offered me before)

In English one would say 'I do see the house', etc., stressing the verb – in Hungarian, the object is emphasized – but both mean exactly the same thing.

In Pingelapese

In the Pingelapese language, transitive verbs are used in one of four of their most common sentence structures. Transitive verbs according to this language have two main characteristics. These characteristics are action verbs and the sentence must contain a direct object. To elaborate, an action verb is a verb that has a physical action associated to its meaning. The sentence must contain a direct object meaning there must be a recipient of said verb. Two entities must be involved when using a transitive sentence. There is also a fixed word order associated with transitive sentences: subject-transitive verb-object.[14] For example:

Linda (Subject) e aesae (transitive verb) Adino (object) This sentence translates to, Linda knows Adino.

In Polish

The definition of transitive verbs as those with one object is not used in grammars of many languages. For example, it is generally accepted in Polish grammar[15] [16] [17] [18] that transitive verbs are those that:

Both conditions are fulfilled in many instances of transitive verbs:

Maria widzi Jana (Mary sees John; Jana is the accusative form of Jan)
Jan jest widziany przez Marię (John is seen by Mary)

See also

Notes and References

  1. Hopper. Paul J. Thompson. Sandra A. Transitivity in grammar and discourse. Language. June 1980. 56. 2. 251–299. https://web.archive.org/web/20070627234224/http://latina.phil2.uni-freiburg.de/raible/Lehre/2006/Materialien/Hopper_Thompson.pdf . 2007-06-27 . live. 24 January 2016. 10.1353/lan.1980.0017. 144215256.
  2. Book: Kempen. Gerard. Harbusch. Karin. Thomas Pechmann . Christopher Habel. Multidisciplinary Approaches to Language Production. 2004. Walter de Gruyter. 978-3-11-017840-1. 173–181. A corpus study into word order variation in German subordinate clauses: Animacy affects linearization independently of grammatical function assignment. We distinguish two types of transitive clauses: those including only [a subject–direct object] pair are monotransitive; clauses containing [subject, direct object, and indirect object] are ditransitive..
  3. Book: Maslova, Elena. Vladimir P. Nedjilkov. Reciprocal Constructions, Volume 1. 2007. John Benjamins Publishing. 978-90-272-2983-0. 1835–1863. Reciprocals in Yukaghir languages.
  4. Kittila, Seppo . A typology of tritransitives: alignment types and motivations . Linguistics . 45 . 3 . 2007 . Walter de Gruyter. Germany . 453–508 . 10.1515/LING.2007.015. 10138/136282 . 53133279 . free .
  5. Book: Mita, Ryohei. J. Askedal . I. Roberts . T. Matsuchita . H. Hasegawa. Germanic Languages and Linguistic Universals. 2009. John Benjamins Publishing Company. 978-90-272-8768-7. 121–142. On tritransitive verbs.
  6. Narasimhan . Bhuvana . Eisenbeiß . Sonja . Brown . Penelope . 'Two's company, more is a crowd': the linguistic encoding of multiple-participant events . Linguistics . 2007 . 45 . 3 . 10.1515/LING.2007.013. 55658350 . https://web.archive.org/web/20180720014711/http://repository.essex.ac.uk/11509/1/0c9605229ce53af0ac000000.pdf . 2018-07-20 . live .
  7. Stevens . Alan . 1970 . Pseudo-transitive verbs in Indonesian . Indonesia . 9 . 9 . 67–72 . 10.2307/3350622. 3350622 . 1813/53485 . free .
  8. Esteban . Avelino Corral . 2012 . A comparative analysis of three-place predicates in Lakhota within the RRG framework . Spanish Journal of Applied Linguistics . 25 . 9–26.
  9. Hampe . Beate . 2011 . Discovering constructions by means of collostruction analysis: The English denominative construction . Cognitive Linguistics . 22 . 2 . 211–245 . 10.1515/cogl.2011.009. 147402733 .
  10. Web site: linguaggio nell'Enciclopedia Treccani. 2020-09-29. www.treccani.it. it-IT.
  11. Book: English Grammatical Categories: And the Tradition to 1800. 9780521143264. Michael. Ian. 2010-06-10.
  12. Web site: Transitive and intransitive verb . 2023-11-09 . grammarerror.com.
  13. Web site: TRANSITIVE meaning in the Cambridge English Dictionary. dictionary.cambridge.org. en. 2019-02-24.
  14. Web site: Preverbal particles in Pingelapese: A language of Micronesia - ProQuest. .
  15. Book: Polański. Kazimierz. Jurkowski. Marian. 1999. Zakład Narodowy im. Ossolińskich. Wrocław. 83-04-04445-5. Encyklopedia językoznawstwa ogólnego.
  16. Book: Nagórko, Alicja. Zarys gramatyki polskiej. Państwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe. Warszawa. 2007. 978-83-01-15390-8.
  17. Book: Bąk, Piotr. Gramatyka języka polskiego - zarys popularny. Wydawnictwo “Wiedza Powszechna”. Warszawa. 1977. 83-214-0923-7.
  18. Book: Milewski, Tadeusz. Językoznawstwo. Państwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe. Warszawa. 1967.