Modal collapse explained

In modal logic, modal collapse is the condition in which every true statement is necessarily true, and vice versa; that is to say, there are no contingent truths, or to put it another way, that "everything exists necessarily"^{[1] [2]} (and likewise if something does not exist, it cannot exist). In the notation of modal logic, this can be written as

\phi \leftrightarrow \Box \phi .

In the context of philosophy, the term is commonly used in critiques of ontological arguments for the existence of God and the principle of divine simplicity.^[3] For example, Gödel's ontological proof contains

\phi → \Box \phi as a theorem, which combined with the axioms of system S5 leads to modal collapse. Since some regard divine freedom as essential to the nature of God, and modal collapse as negating the concept of free will, this then leads to the breakdown of Gödel's argument.^[4]

Notes and References

1. Tomaszewski . Christopher . 2019 . Collapsing the modal collapse argument: On an invalid argument against divine simplicity . Analysis . en . 79 . 2 . 275–284 . 10.1093/analys/any052 . 0003-2638. subscription .
2. Schmid . Joseph C. . 2022 . The fruitful death of modal collapse arguments . International Journal for Philosophy of Religion . en . 91 . 1 . 3–22 . 10.1007/s11153-021-09804-z . 236427989 . 0020-7047.
3. Book: Benzmüller . Christoph . Paleo . B. W. . The Square of Opposition: A Cornerstone of Thought . 2016 . The Ontological Modal Collapse as a Collapse of the Square of Opposition . Studies in Universal Logic . 307–313 . 10.1007/978-3-319-45062-9_18. 978-3-319-45061-2 . 42006078 .
4. Pedersen . Daniel J. . Lilley . Christopher . 2022 . Divine Simplicity, God's Freedom, and the Supposed Problem of Modal Collapse . Journal of Reformed Theology . 16 . 1–2 . 127–147 . 10.1163/15697312-bja10028 . 248106829 . 1569-7312. free . 2164/18891 . free .