Maurism Explained
Maurism (Maurismo in Spanish) was a conservative political movement that bloomed in Spain from 1913 around the political figure of Antonio Maura after a schism in the Conservative Party between idóneos ('apt ones') and mauristas ('maurists'). Its development took place in a period of crisis for the dynastic parties of the Spanish Restoration regime. The movement, which fragmented in several factions in the 1920s, has been portrayed as a precursor of the Spanish radical right.
History
The 1913 refusal by Antonio Maura to accept the terms of the turno pacífico (the alternation in government between the two major parties in the Restoration two-party system) and assume the presidency of the Council of Ministers led to a schism in the Conservative Party between idóneos (supporters of Eduardo Dato and dynastic normality) and the followers of Maura, leading to the establishment of a new movement, maurismo. In October 1913 a seminal speech by Ángel Ossorio y Gallardo delivered in Zaragoza gave birth to the so-called maurismo callejero ('street Maurism'). This side of Maurism became active in street politics using popular agitation, even physical violence.Maurism, aside from the figure of Antonio Maura, was partially inspired by historian Gabriel Maura (son of Antonio Maura), and received some influences from the ideas of French monarchist Charles Maurras—Maura and Maurras wrote to each other—and Action Française. However, Antonio Maura never got to lend support to the radical side of the movement created around him. Other notable Mauristas were José Calvo Sotelo, José Félix de Lequerica, Fernando Suárez de Tangil and César Silió. Miguel Ángel Perfecto identified three inner factions within the movement: the social Catholic one of Ossorio, the liberal-conservative strand of Gabriel Maura and the neoconservatives of Goicoechea. Additionally, the followers of Juan de la Cierva within the Conservative Party, as they drifted away from the orthodoxy of Eduardo Dato, ended up orbiting around authoritarian stances close to Maurism, but they did not merge into the organizational structure.The social strata prevalent among mauristas, whose first National Assembly was held in January 1913, were young people from the aristocracy and the wealthy middle classes. The movement built up its own organic structure and related media, created Maurist circles and even worker associations and presented candidates for local and general elections. Maurists were noted for the wide dissemination of their propaganda, embracing the catch-phrase "¡Maura Sí!" ('Yes to Maura!'). Attempts were made to reach capture working class support but these did not succeed as it was perceived as too middle class and establishment-minded, with republican groups managing to mobilise the workers much more successfully.
Presenting itself as an antithetical to the Restoration regime instituted by Antonio Cánovas del Castillo (canovismo), Maurism tried to lead a conservative modernization, endorsing an interventionist, nationalist and corporative ideological project. It has been characterised as a regenerationist movement. It shared with that movement the belief that defeat in the Spanish–American War had been the fault of a political system that was rife with incompetence and corruption, with Maurism prescribing the imposition of a new patriotic system from above by elites. Another feature of Maurism was confessional Catholicism. The movement's social action could be described as paternalist, with a tutelary function of the upper classes over the lower ones. During World War I, Maurists largely supported Germanophile stances, although Maura himself defended neutrality and Ossorio endorsed Germanophobia.In the 1917 Madrid local elections nine Maurist councillors were elected. At this election non-dynastic unconventional candidates (Maurists and the republican-socialist coalition) took marginally more seats than the candidates elected by the traditional Restoration parties.The 1919 Maura cabinet, that included three Maurists, Goicoechea, Silió and Ossorio, was a window of opportunity for Maurism but it ended up in failure. Maura had become aware of the difficulties in fulfilling the Maurist agenda without the support of the dynastic forces. Since then the movement shifted towards fragmentation.
In the 1920 election to the Cortes the Maurist fraction only got 22 members of the parliament. Two "antagonistic" factions split from Maurism. In one side the scion led by Ángel Ossorio y Gallardo, supportive of social Catholicism and Christian democracy, founded the Partido Social Popular in 1922. On the other side Antonio Goicoechea led an anti-liberal and authoritarian scion, vouching for an "organic democracy", concept later advanced by Francoism. In 1922 the Maurists around Manuel Delgado Barreto and the journal La Acción looked to Italian Fascism. Goicoechea insisted on a proclaimed popular support in Spain for the rise of "a Mussolini" in the country. The very vagueness that underpinned Maurism, which insisted on a "revolution from above" but left the interpretation of this vague concept up to individual adherents, has been characterised as encouraging this factionalism and preventing it from fully emerging as a coherent ideology. For his part Maura never addressed these issues, preferring to remain an aloof figurehead rather than seeking to lead an organised political movement.
Maurists such as José Calvo Sotelo and Goicoechea gave support after the to the latter's dictatorship — whose coming was cheered by the overwhelming majority of the Maurists — and they would finally participate in Renovación Española ('Spanish Renovation') during the Second Republic. José Luis Rodríguez Jiménez notes that Maurism added at some point the "Neither Right Nor Left" rhetoric, identified by the author as a feature of a drift from liberal conservatism towards authoritarian conservatism.
Bibliography
- Apuntes para una historia de la Restauración en la provincia de Cuenca: el maurismo (1913-1923), un movimiento sin masas. 2003. Irma Fuencisla. Álvarez Delgado. Añil. 77–80. 25. 1133-2263. Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha; Centro de Estudios de Castilla-La Mancha. Ciudad Real.
- Book: Historia política de España, 1875-1939. 1. Juan. Avilés Farré. María Dolores. Elizalde Pérez-Grueso. Susana. Sueiro Seoane. Tres Cantos. 2002. Ediciones Istmo. 84-7090-320-9.
- Hacia una comprensión de la dictadura de Primo de Rivera. Shlomo Ben-Ami. Shlomo. Ben-Ami. Revista de Derecho Político. 6. 1980. 107–132. 0210-7562.
- Book: Blinkhorn, Martin. Fascists and Conservatives: The Radical Right and the Establishment in Twentieth-Century Europe. London. Routledge. 1990. Martin Blinkhorn. 2003. 0-203-39323-6. Conservatism, traditionalism and fascism in Spain, 1898-1937. 118–137.
- Book: Bunk, Brian D.. Nation and conflict in modern Spain: essays in honor of Stanley G. Payne. 2008. Brian D. Bunk . Sasha D Pack . Carl-Gustaf Scott. 'A shape note of pugnacity': Conservative youth groups in Spain, 1914–1939. 15–29.
- El largo camino hacia el franquismo: Antonio Gallego Burín (1915-1939). Claudio. Hernández Burgos. Revista del Centro de Estudios Históricos de Granada y su Reino. 23. 2011. 193–206. 0213-7461. Universidad de Granada; Centro de Estudios Históricos de Granada y su Reino. Granada.
- Cabo. Miguel. Miguez. Antonio. Hispania. Revista Española de Historia. 2009. 69. 231. 87–116. 0018-2141. Madrid. Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas. El maurismo en Galicia. Un modelo de modernización conservadora en el marco de la Restauración. 10.3989/hispania.2009.v69.i231.100 . free. 10347/22715. free.
- Germanófilos y neutralistas: proyectos tradicionalistas y regeneracionistas para España (1914-1918). Maximiliano. Fuentes Codera. Ayer. 91. 3. Madrid. Asociación de Historia Contemporánea y Marcial Pons Ediciones de Historia. 2013. 63–92. 1134-2277.
- Gil Pecharromán . Julio Gil Pecharromán. Espacio, tiempo y forma. Serie V, Historia contemporánea . 6 . 1993 . 233–266 . Notables en busca de masas: El conservadurismo en la crisis de la Restauración . Julio . 1130-0124 . Madrid . . bot: unknown . https://web.archive.org/web/20150609192347/http://e-spacio.uned.es/fez/eserv/bibliuned%3AETFSerie5-6F6EEEB9-D760-4662-A52D-84780C3FBAF6/Documento.pdf . 2015-06-09 .
- Revista de Estudios Políticos. El gobierno de concentración en el pensamiento y al acción política de Antonio Maura (1918-1922). Fidel. Gómez Ochoa. 0048-7694. 69. 1990. 239–252. Madrid. Centro de Estudios Políticos y Constitucionales.
- Book: Antonio Morales Moya. Las claves de la España del siglo XX. 4. 2001. Los conservadores españoles en el siglo XX. Pedro Carlos. González Cuevas. Feliciano. Montero. 39–62. 84-95486-25-3.
- Tradicionalismo, catolicismo y nacionalismo: la extrema derecha durante el régimen de la Restauración (1898-1930). Pedro Carlos. González Cuevas. Ayer. 71. Madrid. Asociación de Historia Contemporánea y Marcial Pons Ediciones de Historia. 2008. 25–52. 41325977. 1134-2277.
- Book: González Calleja, Eduardo. Eduardo González Calleja. La razón de la fuerza: orden público, subversión y violencia política en la España de la Restauración (1875-1917). 1998. 84-00-07778-4. Madrid. Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas.
- González Calleja. Eduardo González Calleja. Souto Kustrín. Sandra. 2007. Hispania. Revista Española de Historia. 67. 225. 73–102. De la dictadura a la república: orígenes y auge de los movimientos juveniles en España. Eduardo. Madrid. Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas. 10.3989/hispania.2007.v67.i225.36 . 0018-2141. 10261/162652. free.
- Espacio, tiempo y forma. Serie V, Historia contemporánea. 1. 1988. 145–162. Un aspecto de la "revolución desde arriba": maurismo y acción social. María Jesús. González. 1130-0124. Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia. 10.5944/etfv.1.1988.2654. Madrid. free.
- Perfecto. Miguel Ángel. La derecha radical española y el pensamiento antiliberal francés en el primer tercio del siglo XX: de Charles Maurras a Georges Valois. Studia historica. Historia contemporánea. Ediciones Universidad de Salamanca. Salamanca. 0213-2087. 30. 2012. 47–94.
- Book: Preston, Paul. Spain. S.J. Woolf. Fascism in Europe. London. Methuen. 1981. 0-416-30230-0. registration.
- Book: Preston, Paul. Paul Preston. The Politics of Revenge: Fascism and the Military in 20th-century Spain. Routledge. 1995. 1990. 0-203-40037-2.
- Book: Francisco J.. Romero Salvadó. A.. Smith. The Agony of Spanish Liberalism: From Revolution to Dictatorship 1913–23. Springer. 2010.
- Book: Alejandro. Quiroga. Miguel Ángel del. Arco. Right-Wing Spain in the Civil War Era: Soldiers of God and Apostles of the Fatherland, 1914-45. Bloomsbury Publishing. 2012. 9.
- Una unidad militar en los orígenes del fascismo en España: la Legión. José L.. Rodríguez Jiménez. José Luis Rodríguez Jiménez . Pasado y Memoria. Revista de Historia Contemporánea. 5. 2006. 5 . 219–240. 1579-3311. Universidad de Alicante. Alicante. 10.14198/PASADO2006.5.11 .
- Rodríguez Jiménez. José Luis Rodríguez Jiménez . ¿Qué fue ser de derechas en España? conservadurismo liberal, derecha autoritaria, derecha franquista (y un epílogo). José Luis. Bulletin d'histoire contemporaine de l'Espagne. 0987-4135. 44. 2009. 21–58.
- Book: Romero Salvadó, Francisco J.. Spain 1914-1918: Between War and Revolution. Routledge. 2002. 0-415-21293-6. London and Nueva York. 1999.
- Maura, el "maurismo" y sus élites . Manuel . Tuñón de Lara . Manuel Tuñón de Lara . Mayurqa: Revista del Departament de Ciències Històriques i Teoria de les Arts . Palma de Mallorca . 0301-8296 . 16 . 1976 . 71–85 . . bot: unknown . https://web.archive.org/web/20160227100849/http://www.raco.cat/index.php/mayurqa/article/viewFile/117699/149088 . 2016-02-27 .
- Book: La derecha española contemporánea. Sus orígenes: el maurismo. Espasa-Calpe. Javier. Tusell. Javier Tusell . Juan. Avilés. Juan Avilés Farré. 1986. Madrid. 84-239-6529-5.