Menthone Explained

Menthone is a chemical compound of the monoterpene class of naturally ocurring organic compounds found in a number of essential oils, one that presents with minty flavor. It is a specific pair of stereoisomers of the four possible such isomers for the chemical structure, 2-isopropyl-5-methylcyclohexanone. Of those, the stereoisoomer l-menthone—formally, the (2S,5R)-trans isomer of that structure, as shown at right—is the most abundant in nature. Menthone is structurally related to menthol, which has a secondary alcohol (>C-OH) in place of the carbon-oxygen double bond (carbonyl group) projecting from the cyclohexane ring.

Menthone is obtained for commercial use after purifying essential oils pressed from Mentha species (peppermint and corn mint). It is used as a flavorant and in perfumes and cosmetics for its characteristic aromatic and minty aroma.

Occurrence

Menthone is a constituent of the essential oils of pennyroyal, peppermint, corn mint, pelargonium geraniums, and other plant species. In most essential oils, it is a minor component. Menthone was first synthesized by oxidation of menthol in 1881,[1] [2] before being found as a component in essential oils in 1891. Of the isomers possible for this chemical structure (see below), the one termed l-menthone—formally, the (2S,5R)-trans-2-isopropyl-5-methylcyclohexanone (see infobox and below)—is the most abundant in nature.[3]

Physical and sensory properties

Menthone is a liquid under standard conditions, and has a density of 0.895 g/cm3. Under the same conditions, the melting point is −6 °C, and its boiling point is 207 °C.

Menthone interacts cognitively with other components in food, drink, and other consummables, to present with what is termed a minty flavor.[4] Pure l-menthone has been desxribed as having an intensely minty clean aroma; in contrast, d-isomenthone has a "green" note,December 2024. increasing levels of which are perceived to detract from the aroma quality of l-menthone.

Structure and stereochemistry

The structure of 2-isopropyl-5-methylcyclohexanone (menthones and isomenthones, see following) were established historically by establishing identity of natural and synthetic products after chemical synthesis of this structure from other chemical compounds of established structure; these inferential understandings have, in modern organic chemistry, been augmented by supporting mass spectrometric and spectroscopic evidence (e.g., from NMR spectroscopy and circular dichroism) to make the conclusions secure.

The structure 2-isopropyl-5-methylcyclohexanone has two asymmetric carbon centers, one at each attachment point of the two alkyl group substituents, the isopropyl in the 2-position and the methyl in the 5-position of the cyclohexane framework.[5] The spatial arrangement of atoms—the absolute configuration—at these two points are designated by the descriptors R (Latin, rectus, right) or S (L., sinister, left) based on the Cahn–Ingold–Prelog priority rules. Hence, four unique stereoisomers are possible for this structure: (2S,5S), (2R,5S), (2S,5R) and (2R,5R).[6]

The (2S,5S) and (2R,5R) stereoisomers project the isopropyl and methyl groups from the same "side" of the cyclohexane ring, are the so-called cis isomers, and are termed isomenthone; the (2R,5S) and (2S,5R) stereoisomers project the two groups on the opposite side of the ring, are the so-called trans isomers, and are referred to as menthone.[5] Because the (2S,5R) isomer has an observed negative optical rotation, it is called l-menthone or (−)-menthone. It is the enantiomeric partner of the (2R,5S) isomer: (+)- or d-menthone.[5]

Interconversion

Menthone and isomenthone interconvert easily, the equilibrium favoring menthone;[7] if menthone and isomenthone are equilibrated at room temperature, the isomenthone content will reach 29%. Menthone can easily be converted to isomenthone and vice versa via a reversible epimerization reaction via an enol intermediate, which changes the direction of optical rotation, so that l-menthone becomes d-isomenthone, and d-menthone becomes l-isomenthone.[8]

Preparation and reactivity

Menthone is obtained commercially by fractional crystallization of the oils pressed from peppermint and cornmint, sp. Mentha.[7]

In the experimental laboratory, l-menthone may be prepared by oxidation of menthol with acidified dichromate. If the chromic acid oxidation is performed with stoichiometric oxidant in the presence of diethyl ether as co-solvent, a method introduced by H.C. Brown and colleagues in 1971, the epimerization of l-menthone to d-isomenthone is largely avoided.[9]

History

Menthone was first described by Moriya in 1881.[1] [2] It was later synthesized by heating menthol with chromic acid, and its structure was later confirmed by synthesizing it from 2-isopropyl-5-methylpimelic acid.

In 1889, Ernst Beckmann discovered that dissolving menthone in concentrated sulfuric acid gave a new ketonic material which gave an equal but opposite optical rotation to the starting material.[10] Beckmann's inferences from his results situated menthone as a crucial player in a great mechanistic discovery in organic chemistry. Beckmann concluded that the change in structure underlying the observed opposite optical rotation was the result of an inversion of configuration at the asymmetric carbon atom next to the carbonyl group (which, at that time was believed to be the carbon atom attached to the methyl rather than the isopropyl group). He postulated that this occurred through an intermediate enol—a tautomer of the ketone—such that the original absolute configuration of that carbon atom changed as its geometry went from terahedral to trigonal planar. This report is an early example of an inference that an otherwise undetectable intermediate was involved in a reaction mechanism, one that could account for the observed structural outcome of the reaction.

Related compounds

References

  1. Read, John . 1930 . Recent Progress in the Menthone Chemistry . . 7 . 1 . 1–50 . 10.1021/cr60025a001 . 3 December 2024 . subscription.
  2. Moriya, M. . 1881 . XV.—Contributions From the Laboratory of the University of Tôkiô, Japan. No. IV. On Menthol or Peppermint Camphor . . 39 . 77–83 . 10.1039/CT8813900077 . 3 December 2024 . Zenodo.org.
  3. Book: Ager, David . 2005 . Handbook of Chiral Chemicals . 2nd . 64 . Boca Raton, FL . CRC Press . 9781420027303 . en . 3 December 2024.
  4. Book: Hirsch, Alan R.. 2015-03-18. Nutrition and Sensation. 276ff. Boca Raton, FL . CRC Press. 9781466569089. en . 3 December 2015.
  5. Book: Singh, G.. 2007. Chemistry of Terpenoids and Carotenoids. New Delhi, India . Discovery Publishing House . 9788183562799 . 41 . en . 3 December 2024.
  6. Book: Singh, G.. 2007. Chemistry of Terpenoids and Carotenoids. New Delhi, India . Discovery Publishing House . 9788183562799 . 41 . en . 3 December 2024.
  7. Book: Sell . Charles S. . 2006 . Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology . Terpenoids . 10.1002/0471238961.2005181602120504.a01.pub2 . 0471238961 . subscription.
  8. Book: Seidel, Arza; Bickford, Michalina & Chu, Kelsee . 2012 . Kirk-Othmer Chemical Technology of Cosmetics . New York, NY . John Wiley & Sons . 9781118518908 . en . 3 December 2024. Note, an earlier citation suggested appearance of this content on page 339, which cannot be confirmed with digital information accessible. Note, a further version of the book appears here, with some accessible content, but not the content on the epimerisation of menthone-isomenthone, see this link.
  9. Brown . H.C. . Garg. C.P.. Liu . K.-T. . H.C. Brown . 1971 . The Oxidation of Secondary Alcohols in Diethyl Ether With Aqueous Chromic Acid. A Convenient Procedure for the Preparation of Ketones in High Epimeric Purity . J. Org. Chem. . 36 . 3 . 387–390 . 10.1021/jo00802a005 . 3 December 2024 . subscription.
  10. Untersuchungen in der Campherreihe . Investigations in the Camphor-series . Beckmann, Ernst . Liebigs Annalen. 1889 . 250. 3 . 322–375 . 10.1002/jlac.18892500306 . Ernst Beckmann . 3 December 2024 . Zenodo.org.