Independent Online Explained

Independent Online
Type:News
Format:Online newspaper
Owner:Sekunjalo Investments
Public Investment Corporation
China International Television Corporation
China Africa Development Fund
Language:English
Headquarters:Cape Town, South Africa

Independent Online, popularly known as IOL, is a news website based in South Africa that has been involved in various controversies, including making up fake stories, fictitious journalists and doxing. IOL is controlled by majority shareholder, Sekunjalo Investments and its chairman Iqbal Survé.[1]

IOL serves the online versions of a number of South African newspapers, including The Star, Pretoria News, The Daily Voice, Cape Times, Cape Argus, Weekend Argus, The Mercury, Post, Diamond Fields Advertiser, Isolezwe, Daily Tribune, Sunday Tribune, The Independent on Saturday, and The Sunday Independent.[2] IOL regularly distributes Chinese state media content.[3] [4]

Corporate affairs

Ownership

Sekunjalo Investments initially owned 55% of the company via its subsidiary Sekunjalo Independent Media, the Public Investment Corporation (PIC) owned 25%, and two Chinese state-owned enterprises (China International Television Corporation and the China Africa Development Fund) owned the remaining 20% of the newspaper.[5] China International Television Corporation is a wholly-owned subsidiary of state broadcaster China Central Television (CCTV).[6] Before 2013, IOL was owned by Tony O'Reilly's Independent News & Media.

At some point, IOL was sold off from Sekunjalo Independent Media while the print publications entity Independent Newspapers remained under the ownership of Sekunjalo Independent Media.[7] [8]

The change in ownership structure came at a time when the South African Clothing and Textile Workers Union (SACTWU) had sued Sekunjalo Independent Media in the Western Cape High Court for failing to repay a loan of ZAR 150 million plus interest in aid of funding the purchase of the company from Tony O'Reilly.[9] The PIC had also filed an application asking the court to liquidate Sekunjalo Independent Media.[10] [11]

Management

Viasen Soobramoney took over as CEO of Independent Online from Vasantha Angamuthu in May 2023.[12] Angamuthu unexpectedly resigned from both her positions as CEO of Independent Online and as CEO African News Agency, sister companies within Survé's media empire.

In 2023, Independent Media issued retrenchment notices to its staff for the fifth time since Sekunjalo's purchase of the news organisation. IOL staff were initially not affected but later added to the list of business units facing job cuts.[13] [14] By October 2023, at least a third of staff were retrenched and the company failed to pay severance packages on time and instead issued grocery vouchers to the value of ZAR 2500 which initially were not loaded with any cash.[15] [16]

At the end of 2023, Group CEO of Independent Media unexpectedly resigned after 16 months in the job prompting Survé to again take up an executive role in the company.[17] [18]

Controversies

Chinese censorship

In 2018, Reporters Without Borders reported that an IOL columnist was forced out after publishing a column condemning the persecution of Uyghurs in China.[19] [20]

Information laundering

According to The Economist, IOL "often engages in 'information laundering' designed to make sentiment appear homegrown, says Herman Wasserman at the University of Cape Town. For instance, it will run a Chinese news-agency story on the biolab conspiracy, then get a left-wing student leader to write an article expressing concern about the supposed biolabs. Chinese news agencies will use that to write about how South Africans are worried, thus manufacturing a 'story' out of nothing at all."[21]

Bank account closures

IOL and Independent Media's banking facilities were threatened in 2022 when Standard Bank issued a notice to cut all ties with any company within the Sekunjalo Group.[22] This followed several other banks refusing to do business with the investment group, its subsidiaries and directors.[23]

Fake stories

In March 2020, IOL and the Durban-based Daily News published an article accusing a competitor news website, Daily Maverick, of "orchestrating and financially sponsoring a fake news smear campaign against prominent politicians, businessmen and executives, including Independent Media executive chairman Iqbal Survé." Daily Maverick took the matter to the High Court of South Africa, which found that the article was defamatory and unlawful, and ordered that IOL and Daily News retract the story and apologise, and that the writer of the article, Modibe Modiba, pay R100 000 in damages to Daily Maverick.[24] [25] [26]

In 2021, IOL published a series of articles about a Tembisa woman having delivered decuplets (ten babies) which were penned by Pretoria News editor Piet Rampedi.[27] The story was debunked as fake news as no evidence of the births was available and multiple requests for donations were made both in print and online Independent Media platforms.[28] [29] Rampedi, Survé, IOL and Independent Media newspapers all went on to claim that the babies were trafficked but they provided no evidence to support their claims. Rampedi eventually resigned in January 2023 following a report by the Public Protector which found that the story was a lie.[30] Neither Rampedi nor the company or any of its publications apologised for the story, however, the 125-year-old Pretoria News ceased to be published a few months later.[31]

Press Ombudsman findings

In 2024 the South African Press Ombudsman found that IOL publications, notability the Sunday Independent, had transgressed three clauses of the Press Code by publishing and promoting unverified opinion pieces that caused "severe harm" to the personal and professional reputations of multiple journalists, namely Karyn Maughan, Nick Wilson, Jeff Wicks and Jan Cronjé.[32] The Ombudsman found that it should publish apologies and remove offending pieces.

Fictitious journalists

In 2022, IOL was accused of making up a fake journalist called Jamie Roz to spread fake news and disinformation in support of its chairman and controversial businessman Iqbal Survé.[33]

In 2023, veteran journalist Chris Roper found that a series of anonymous articles on IOL were likely written by Survé's spin doctor Feroza Petersen, who together with The Sunday Independent editor Sizwe Dlamini had penned many articles in support of Survé. News24 suggested that "Jamie Roz" could be Petersen, whose maiden name is (Fe)roz(a) Jamie, and also found that "Edmond Phiri", a byline used by IOL in articles supportive of Survé, is another undeclared fake persona.[34]

Doxing

On 15 July 2024, Independent Media and IOL held a press conference in Cape Town, titled "The Unmasking Project", where they claimed to reveal the identity of an anonymous X user known only as Goolam (@goolammv).[35] Independent Media's KwaZulu-Natal regional editor, Mazwi Xaba, claimed that the person linked to the account was Mohammed Vawda, a population statistics lecturer at the University of KwaZulu-Natal and part-time comedian. Other speakers at the press conference included Adri Senekal de Wet, Independent Media's editor-in-chief, Sifiso Mahlangu, editor of The Star, Siyavuya Mzantsi, editor of Cape Times, Melanie Peters, managing editor, Taariq Halim, Independent Media's Western Cape regional editor responsible for the Cape Argus and Daily Voice tabloid publications, and Lance Witten, editor-in-chief of IOL. Former cabinet minister, Lindiwe Sisulu, also shared her views on the anonymous X account, claiming that it was responsible for her failure to be elected ANC president at the party's conference in 2017.[36] [37]

Independent Media and IOL were accused of doxing, and Vawda denied being the person behind the anonymous account. Vawda said that he had received death threats as a result, and that he and his family had gone into hiding for their own safety. Vawda conceded that his job at the university was also put in jeopardy due to the university being questioned about its association to a 'racist' account.

The press conference was steamed live on YouTube but IOL has since restricted the video to being private, however, excerpts of the video and images of Vawda remain widely available on social media. IOL has deleted some of the posts related to Vawda on X.[38] [39]

Vawda has sought legal assistance from Advocate Ben Winks and Rupert Candy Attorneys, and he is seeking an immediate retraction of the story and allegations against him, with further litigation against IOL, Independent Media and Sisulu to follow.

Witten promised "legal actions" against Vawda to follow the press conference, but no further details were provided. The anonymous user @goolammv has used the platform X to call out corrupt politicians and their associates in business, including Independent Media boss, Iqbal Survé, for failing to repay a R150 million loan taken from clothing workers union, SACTWU. Following the doxing press conference, the anonymous user @goolammv took to X to lash out at Survé for falsely revealing the identity of the account for the fourth time.

Sisulu claimed that the anonymous user was also linked to the Office of the Presidency and State Security Agency, saying that during her tenure as Minister of Intelligence between 2001 and 2004, overseeing the State Security Agency, her ministry had "bugged everyone" but that she hadn't shared the details of the information she had gathered during that time, yet she believed that Cyril Ramaphosa's Office of the Presidency, in which the State Security Agency is now held, had been doing so via the anonymous user, Goolam. The Presidency denied Sisulu's allegations and asked her to provide evidence to support her claims.[40] [41]

On 17 July 2024, Vawda's attorneys issued a letter of demand to Survé, Soobramoney, Witten, Senekal de Wet, Peters, Mahlangu, Halim, Mzantsi and Sisulu. Vawda demanded a second press conference to be held the next day, with each of the speakers present at the initial press conference to apologise publicly and via live streaming platforms. Only Senekal de Wet and Soobramoney subsequently apologised to Vawda via a pre-recorded video, published on X.[42]

Vawda rejected IOL's apology saying that it was "not good enough" while his attorneys issued a second letter of demand, saying that the apology was "not prominent enough to have captured the attention of Internet users".[43] [44]

On 19 July 2024, Vawda's lawyers filed summons in the High Court, seeking R1.2 million in damages as a result of the harm caused to Vawda. According to court papers, a contract killing was arranged on 15 July 2024 offering a reward of R250 000 for Vawda's life.[45]

A criminal complaint was laid by Vawda on 26 July 2024 at the Sandton SAPS station.[46] The victim asked police to investigate one charge of crimen injuria and one charge in terms of the Cybercrimes Act, while requesting that police investigate any further charges that may be added on. Survé, Senekal de Wet, Mahlangu, Xaba, Peters, Mzantsi, Halim and Witten are suspects in this criminal investigation.

Further reading

See also

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Hogg . Alec . 2019-04-15 . Iqbal Survé, specialist in media capture AND state capture . 2024-07-17 . BizNews.com . en-GB.
  2. Web site: South of the Sahara . 23 February 2009 . . 12 February 2009 . https://web.archive.org/web/20090212085831/http://www-sul.stanford.edu/depts/ssrg/africa/southafrica/rsanews.html . live .
  3. News: Pike . Lili . May 18, 2022 . How China uses global media to spread its views — and misinformation . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20220623014538/https://www.grid.news/story/global/2022/05/18/how-china-uses-global-media-to-spread-its-views-and-misinformation/ . 23 June 2022 . May 29, 2022 . Grid News.
  4. Web site: September 28, 2022 . Coercion, Capture, and Censorship: Case Studies on the CCP's Quest for Global Influence . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20220929013634/https://www.iri.org/resources/coercion-capture-and-censorship-case-studies-on-the-ccps-quest-for-global-influence/ . 29 September 2022 . 2022-09-29 . . en-US.
  5. Web site: Sam Sole and Craig McKune. 28 August 2014. What's black and white and in the red all over?. 8 September 2014. Mail & Guardian. 4 October 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20191004025908/https://mg.co.za/article/2014-08-28-whats-black-and-white-and-in-the-red-all-over. live.
  6. Web site: CITVC Signs Partnership Deal With NATPE . 2022-07-09 . . 6 May 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220506230146/https://www.natpe.com/citvc-signs-partnership-deal-with-natpe/ . live .
  7. Web site: Rensburg . Dewald van . 2021-01-28 . PIC looks on while 'Survé Inc' burns through state pensioners' billions . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20230326123758/https://amabhungane.org/stories/210128-pic-looks-on-while-surve-inc-burns-through-state-pensioners-billions/ . 26 March 2023 . 2024-01-10 . . en-ZA.
  8. Web site: Rensburg . Dewald van . 2019-11-14 . PIC wants to "investigate" Sekunjalo directors after liquidation . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20231006071445/https://amabhungane.org/stories/pic-wants-to-investigate-sekunjalo-directors-after-liquidation/ . 6 October 2023 . 2024-01-10 . . en-ZA.
  9. Web site: Cronje . Jan . Union in court to get R300m back from Iqbal Survé-linked Sekunjalo Independent Media . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20240108201218/https://www.news24.com/fin24/companies/union-in-court-to-get-r300m-back-from-iqbal-surve-linked-sekunjalo-independent-media-20230828 . 8 January 2024 . 2024-01-08 . . en-US.
  10. Web site: Mahlaka . Ray . 2021-05-12 . PIC pushes Iqbal Survé into a corner as more of his entities, including Independent Media, are dragged to court . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20240108204539/https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-05-12-pic-pushes-iqbal-surve-into-a-corner-as-more-of-his-entities-including-independent-media-are-dragged-to-court/ . 8 January 2024 . 2024-01-08 . . en.
  11. Web site: Cronje . Jan . State asset manager applies to liquidate Sekunjalo Independent Media . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20240108201119/https://www.news24.com/Fin24/just-in-state-asset-manager-applies-to-liquidate-sekunjalo-independent-media-20191112 . 8 January 2024 . 2024-01-08 . . en-US.
  12. Web site: 2023-05-10 . Viasen Soobramoney appointed as CEO at IOL . 2024-01-10 . IOL . 24 May 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230524154441/https://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/viasen-soobramoney-appointed-as-ceo-at-iol-99243a1c-4db2-4217-aa4c-80c9e603256d . live .
  13. Web site: Nevill . Glenda . 2019-09-18 . Jobs on the line at ANA and Independent Media . 2024-01-22 . The Media Online . en-US . 2 July 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220702014616/https://themediaonline.co.za/2019/09/jobs-on-the-line-at-ana-and-independent-media/ . live .
  14. Web site: Cronje . Jan . Independent Newspapers set to cut at least 40% of its staff . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20240108213825/https://www.news24.com/fin24/companies/independent-newspapers-set-to-cut-at-least-40-of-its-staff-20230719 . 8 January 2024 . 2024-01-08 . . en-US.
  15. Web site: Cronje . Jan . Independent Newspapers retrenches 128, delays payment of severance packages . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20240108213906/https://www.news24.com/fin24/companies/independent-newspapers-retrenches-128-delays-payment-of-severance-packages-20231108 . 8 January 2024 . 2024-01-08 . . en-US.
  16. Web site: Cohen . Tim . 2023-11-09 . In blow to PIC, Iqbal Survé's Independent Media retrenches a third of its staff . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20240108213823/https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2023-11-09-in-blow-to-pic-iqbal-surves-independent-retrenches-a-third-of-its-staff/ . 8 January 2024 . 2024-01-08 . . en.
  17. News: 2024-01-10 . Independent Media appoints new executives . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20240110103754/https://www.pressreader.com/south-africa/the-mercury-south-africa/20240110/281582360470652 . 10 January 2024 . 2024-01-10 . The Mercury.
  18. Web site: Wilson . Nick . Independent Media CEO steps down as Iqbal Survé returns as executive chair . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20240110122128/https://www.news24.com//fin24/companies/independent-media-ceo-steps-down-as-iqbal-surve-returns-as-executive-chair-20240110 . 10 January 2024 . 2024-01-10 . . en-US.
  19. News: 18 September 2018 . South Africa: Journalist loses column after publishing an article critical of China . . 8 July 2022 . 8 July 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220708175341/https://rsf.org/en/south-africa-journalist-loses-column-after-publishing-article-critical-china . live .
  20. Joseph . Natasha . April 2021 . A new world order . . en . 50 . 1 . 70–71 . 10.1177/03064220211012307 . 0306-4220 . 233449064 .
  21. News: September 22, 2022 . How Russia is trying to win over the global south . . live . subscription . 2022-09-25 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220924214041/https://www.economist.com/international/2022/09/22/how-russia-is-trying-to-win-over-the-global-south . 24 September 2022 . 0013-0613.
  22. Web site: Gous . Nico . July 19, 2022 . Standard Bank latest to cut ties with Sekunjalo Group . subscription . 2024-01-10 . BusinessLIVE . en-ZA . 25 January 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230125180119/https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/companies/financial-services/2022-07-19-standard-bank-latest-to-cut-ties-with-sekunjalo-group/ . live .
  23. Web site: Cronje . Jan . 19 Jul 2022 . Standard Bank also dropping Iqbal Survé's Sekunjalo group as a client . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20230802215726/https://www.news24.com/fin24/companies/standard-bank-is-now-also-dropping-iqbal-surves-sekunjalo-group-as-a-client-20220719 . 2 August 2023 . 2024-01-10 . . en-US.
  24. News: . Independent Online . 26 February 2023 . Apology to Daily Maverick and Branko Brkic .
  25. Web site: IOL apology to Daily Maverick and its editor . 2024-07-19 . Bizcommunity . en.
  26. Web site: Davis . Rebecca . 2023-02-23 . Independent Online publicly apologises to Daily Maverick for false reporting . 2024-07-19 . Daily Maverick . en.
  27. News: 2021-06-23 . South African 10 babies story not true, inquiry finds . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20210625123752/https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-57581054 . 25 June 2021 . 2024-01-10 . . en-GB.
  28. Web site: Charles . Marvin . 31 Dec 2022 . Tembisa 10: Public Protector finds claims mom gave birth to decuplets 'unsubstantiated' . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20240110234405/https://www.news24.com/news24/southafrica/news/tembisa-10-public-protector-finds-claims-mom-gave-birth-to-decuplets-unsubstantiated-20221231 . 10 January 2024 . 2024-01-10 . . en-US.
  29. Web site: Monama . Tebogo . Charles . Marvin . 28 Oct 2021 . FACT CHECK What really happened to the Tembisa 10? Why Independent Media's claims just don't hold up . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20240110234403/https://www.news24.com/news24/southafrica/news/fact-check-what-really-happened-to-the-tembisa-10-why-independent-medias-claims-just-dont-hold-up-20211028 . 10 January 2024 . 2024-01-10 . . en-US.
  30. Web site: 31 Jan 2023 . Piet Rampedi, driving force behind 'Tembisa 10' decuplets story, resigns as Pretoria News editor . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20230730133830/https://www.news24.com/news24/southafrica/news/piet-rampedi-driving-force-behind-tembisa-decuplets-story-resigns-as-pretoria-news-editor-20230131 . 30 July 2023 . 2024-01-10 . . en-US.
  31. Web site: Cronje . Jan . 6 Jul 2023 . The Star publisher Independent Newspapers mulls job cuts as revenues keep falling . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20240110234404/https://www.news24.com/fin24/companies/the-star-publisher-independent-newspapers-mulls-job-cuts-as-revenues-keep-falling-20230706 . 10 January 2024 . 2024-01-10 . . en-US.
  32. Web site: Writer . Staff . Sunday Independent, IOL ordered to apologise for 'abuse' of News24 journalist, retract op-ed . 2024-08-09 . News24 . en-US.
  33. Web site: Haffajee . Ferial . 2022-09-06 . From making up decuplets to making up a writer, Independent Media's Iqbal Survé plumbs new depths . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20230131150820/https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2022-09-06-fake-news-fake-publication-next-level-iqbal-surves-iol-makes-up-a-journalist-to-further-attack-truth/ . 31 January 2023 . 2024-01-10 . . en.
  34. Web site: Wilson . Nick . Cronje . Jan . Wicks . Jeff . Inside Iqbal Survé's glitchy propaganda machine: Goebbels, AI and slippery writers . 21 May 2024 . . 21 May 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240521065558/https://specialprojects.news24.com/Inside-Iqbal-Surves-glitchy-propaganda-machine/index.html . live .
  35. Web site: Goba . Thabiso . Lecturer denies running @Goolammv X account, says he fears for his life . 2024-07-17 . EWN . en.
  36. Web site: Thamm . Marianne . 2024-07-16 . Survé and Sisulu's 'unmasking' event goes down like a lead balloon . 2024-07-17 . Daily Maverick . en.
  37. Web site: Heever . Megan van den . 2024-07-15 . Durban comedian claps back: 'I'm not Goolam' [video] ]. 2024-07-17 . The South African . en-ZA.
  38. News: Nkadimeng . Innocentia . 16 July 2024 . 'I'm fearful for my life': man accused of running pro-Ramaphosa viral X account dismisses claims . TimesLive.
  39. Web site: Nxumalo . Sakhiseni . UKZN lecturer demands retraction, apology from Independent Media for 'entirely false' X account claim . 2024-07-17 . News24 . en-US.
  40. Web site: Patel . Faizel . 2024-07-17 . Sisulu thinks Goolam is preoccupied with her and asks why there's no focus on Ramaphosa and Phala Phala . 2024-07-17 . The Citizen . en-US.
  41. Web site: Khoza . Amanda . Presidency pours cold water on Sisulu's claims, says 'bugging everybody' would have been illegal . 2024-07-17 . News24 . en-US.
  42. Web site: Patel . Faizel . 2024-07-17 . WATCH: Independent Media apologises for naming wrong man as Goolam after legal threat . 2024-07-17 . The Citizen . en.
  43. Web site: Thamm . Marianne . 2024-07-18 . Who's your Goolam? Independent Media's X account debacle continues . 2024-07-19 . Daily Maverick . en.
  44. Web site: Nxumalo . Sakhiseni . UPDATE 'A technical error': Independent Media apologises to UKZN lecturer over X account claim . 2024-07-19 . News24 . en-US.
  45. Web site: Sibiya . Noxolo . Independent Media sued for R1.2m by lecturer following X account slip-up . 2024-07-19 . News24 . en-US.
  46. News: Wicks . Jeff . 27 July 2024 . 'Suspect' Survé, top editors face criminal probe for Goolam gaffe . 27 July 2024 . News24.

This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Independent Online".

Except where otherwise indicated, Everything.Explained.Today is © Copyright 2009-2024, A B Cryer, All Rights Reserved. Cookie policy.