Honorificabilitudinitatibus Explained

Honorificabilitudinitatibus (honōrificābilitūdinitātibus, pronounced as /la/) is the dative and ablative plural of the medieval Latin word Latin: honōrificābilitūdinitās, which can be translated as "the state of being able to achieve honours". It is mentioned by the character Costard in Act V, Scene I of William Shakespeare's Love's Labour's Lost.

As it appears only once in Shakespeare's works, it is a hapax legomenon in the Shakespeare canon. At letters, it is the longest word in the English language which strictly alternates consonants and vowels.

Use in Love's Labour's Lost

The word is spoken by the comic rustic Costard in Act V, Scene 1 of the play. It is used after an absurdly pretentious dialogue between the pedantic schoolmaster Holofernes and his friend Sir Nathaniel. The two pedants converse in a mixture of Latin and florid English. When Moth, a witty young servant, enters, Costard says of the pedants:

Use in Baconianism

The word has been used by adherents of the Baconian theory who believe Shakespeare's plays were written in steganographic cypher by Francis Bacon. In 1905 Isaac Hull Platt argued that it was an anagram for hi ludi, F. Baconis nati, tuiti orbi, Latin for "these plays, F. Bacon's offspring, are preserved for the world". His argument was given wide circulation by Edwin Durning-Lawrence in 1910, complete with a cryptonumerical attempt to prove it justified.[1] The anagram assumes that Bacon would have Latinized his name as "Baco" or "Bacon" (the genitive case of which is "Baconis") rather than, as Samuel Schoenbaum argues, "Baconus", with genitive "Baconi".[2]

It is far from the only possible anagram. In 1898, Paget Toynbee noted that the word contains a glorification of Dante by himself as its letters could be rearranged to form the phrase Ubi Italicus ibi Danti honor fit (Where there is an Italian, there honour is paid to Dante).[3] [4] In the 1970s, John Sladek noted that the word could also be anagrammatized as I, B. Ionsonii, uurit [''writ''] a lift'd batch, thus "proving" that Shakespeare's works were written by Ben Jonson. In 2012, in a column for the Calcutta Telegraph, Stephen Hugh-Jones mocked it with the deliberately anachronistic "If I built it in, is author ID Bacon?", attributing this to a derisive William Shakespeare; and counter-"proved" that Shakespeare wrote Bacon by converting the latter's famous opening phrase "What is truth, said jesting Pilate..." into "Truth? A lasting jape. Hide it. WS".[5]

Other uses

Long before Love's Labour's Lost, the word and its variants had been used by medieval and then Renaissance authors.

Medieval

The unusually long word had apparently already been in circulation among scholars by the time of Petrus Grammaticus, 8th-century Italian poet, deacon, grammarian, and Charlemagne's primary Latin teacher. It can be found in Codex Bernensis 522 (Burgerbibliothek of Berne, Cod. 522), an early-9th-century manuscript copy of his work.[6] [7]

Italian lexicographer Papias used it circa 1055.[8]

Honorificabilitudo appears in a charter of 1187 by Ugone della Volta, second Archbishop of Genoa.[9] [10]

Various forms of the word were also discussed in Magnae Derivationes, an early etymological treatise of circa 1190[11] by Uguccione, Italian canon lawyer and Bishop of Ferrara:

It also appears in Ars poetica, treatise on rhetoric of circa 1208–1216 by English-born French scholar Gervase of Melkley:

Italian grammarian Johannes Balbus used the word in its complete form in his hugely popular 1286 Latin dictionary known as Catholicon (in 1460, it became one of the first books to be printed using Gutenberg's press).[8] [12] Quoting Uguccione, it says regarding honorifico:

A late-13th-century example can be found in an anonymous sermon in a manuscript in Bodleian Library (MS Bodl. 36, f. 131v).[13]

In his linguistic essay De vulgari eloquentia (On eloquence in the vernacular) of circa 1302–1305 Dante, drawing on Uguccione's Magnae Derivationes,[14] cites honorificabilitudinitate as an example of a word too long for the standard line in verse:

Honorificabilitudinitas occurs in De gestis Henrici septimi Cesaris (1313–1315), a book by the Italian poet Albertino Mussato which chronicled 1310–1313 Italian expedition of Henry VII, Holy Roman Emperor:It was for this work that in 1315 the commune of Padua crowned Mussato as poet laureate; he was the first man to receive the honour since antiquity.[15]

It is also found on an Exchequer record, in a hand of the reign of Henry VI (1422–1461).[16]

The word appears in Adagia, an annotated collection of Greek and Latin proverbs, compiled by Dutch humanist Erasmus; he recalls a humorous couplet about a man called Hermes who was fond of using foot-and-a-half words:[17] First published in 1500, by Shakespeare's time it was a very popular book, widely used as a text-book in English schools.[18] [19] The couplet itself was a popular schoolboy joke, current both in Erasmus's and Shakespeare's times, and beyond.[20]

In the foreword to his 1529 translation of Lucan, French humanist and engraver Geoffroy Tory used the word as an example of bad writing, citing the Hermes couplet.[21] [22]

It also occurs in the works of Rabelais[8] and in The Complaynt of Scotland (1549).[23]

The word in its various forms was frequently used as test of the pen by scribes. One example is found in a fourteenth-century Pavian codex.[24] It may also be seen, with some additional syllables, scribbled on a page of a late-16th-century heraldic manuscript (British Library, MS Harley 6113).[16] [25] Alternative form in honorificabilitudinacionibus is attested from manuscripts in Bamberg (Bamberg State Library, Q.V.41) and Munich (Bavarian State Library, Cgm 541).[26] [27] Other examples include Erfurt O.23, Prague 211 (f. 255v), Bratislava II Q.64 (f. 27r),[27] Pembroke 260 (flyleaf),[28] and a manuscript of Hoccleve.[29]

The word is also known from at least two inscriptions on medieval tableware. A small goblet inscribed with honorificabilitudinitatibus around it was found at Kirby Muxloe Castle in Leicestershire, England.[30] [31] A pewter cruet engraved with an abbreviated version of the word (honorificabiliut) next to the owner's name (Thomas Hunte) was unearthed in a well filled in 1476 during 1937 conservation works at Ashby de la Zouch Castle, also in Leicestershire. The cruet was cast around 1400 and is currently in Victoria and Albert Museum, London.[32] [33] [34] [35]

Modern

Shakespeare's times

The year after the publication of Love's Labours Lost it is used by English satirist Thomas Nashe in his 1599 pamphlet Nashe's Lenten Stuff:Nashe is referring to the exotic medicinal plant Guaiacum, the name of which was also exotic to the English at that time, being the first Native American word imported into the English language.[36]

The word also appears in John Marston's 1605 play The Dutch Courtesan, Act V, Scene II:

In John Fletcher's tragicomedy The Mad Lover of 1617 the word is used by the palace fool:

John Taylor ("The Water Poet") uses an even longer version of the word, honorificicabilitudinitatibus in the very first sentence of his 1622[37] pamphlet Sir Gregory Nonsence:

After Shakespeare

Following the tradition of medieval scholars, Charles du Cange included both honorificabilitudo and honorificabilitudinitatibus in his 1678 Latin lexicon Glossarium mediae et infimae Latinitatis, quoting Ugone della Volta and Albertino Mussato.[9]

Thomas Blount listed the anglicized form of the word, honorificabilitudinity (defined as "honorableness"), among the 11,000 hard or unusual words in his 1656 Glossographia, the largest English dictionary at the time.[38] [39] [40] The entry was quoted by Elisha Coles in An English Dictionary, published in 1676.[41] [42] It was also repeated by Nathan Bailey in his influential 1721 An Universal Etymological English Dictionary.[43] [44]

While honorificabilitudinitatibus was not included in Samuel Johnson's famous dictionary,[45] Dr Johnson did comment on its length in his 1765 edition of The Plays of William Shakespeare:

Commenting on this, antiquarian Joseph Hunter wrote in 1845:

In 1858, Charles Dickens wrote an essay Calling Bad Names for the weekly magazine Household Words he edited at the time; it starts with the Love's Labour's Lost quote and uses it to satirize the scientific publications that use too many Latin words:

James Joyce also used this word in his mammoth 1922 novel Ulysses, during the Scylla and Charybdis episode; when Stephen Dedalus articulates his interpretation of Hamlet:

In 1993 U.S. News & World Report used the word in its original meaning with reference to a debate about new words' being used in the game of Scrabble:

In the American animated television series Pinky and the Brains 1995 episode "Napoleon Brainaparte", the word is defined as "with honorablenesses".[46]

Jeff Noon 2001 book of experimental poetry, Cobralingus, used the fictional Cobralingus Engine to remix this word in the style of electronic music to create a prose poem entitled "Pornostatic Processor".[47]

In the 2005 episode "Sick Days & Spelling" of the Nickelodeon TV show Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide, Ned Bigby enters the spelling bee, having easy words until he comes across the word "honorificabilitudinitatibus" and gives up.

In Suzanne Selfors' 2011 children's novel Smells Like Treasure, her spelling champion character, Hercules Simple, uses the word.[48]

See also

General and cited references

Notes and References

  1. K. K. Ruthven, Faking Literature, Cambridge University Press, 2001, p.102
  2. Samuel Schoenbaum, Shakespeare's Lives, Oxford University Press, 2nd ed.1991 p.421
  3. Toynbee, 1902, p. 113, fn. 1
  4. Book: The Shakespearean Ciphers Examined. 2011. Cambridge University Press. 9780521141390. 106. W. F. Friedman. E. S. Friedman.
  5. Stephen Hugh-Jones, "Fantasy as Fact", The Telegraph, 6 June 2012
  6. Simms, p.179
  7. http://katalog.burgerbib.ch/detail.aspx?ID=129544 Burgerbibliothek Bern Cod. 522 Sammelbd.: Petrus grammaticus: Ars; Aelius Donatus: Ars grammatica; Kommentare zu Donat
  8. Hamer, 1971, p. 484
  9. du Cange, Honorificabilitudo: "Honorificabilitudo, pro Dignitas, in Charta Hugonis Archiep. Genuensis ann. 1187. apud Ughellum".
  10. Book: Secoli cristiani della Liguria, ossia, Storia della metropolitana di Genova. 1843. 61–66. Giovanni Battista Semeria.
  11. Sharpe, 1996, p. 103
  12. Venzke, 2000
  13. Madan and Craster, 1922, pp. 99–100
  14. Toynbee, 1902, p.113
  15. Book: In the Footsteps of the Ancients: The Origins of Humanism from Lovato to Bruni. limited. 2003. Brill. Leiden. 9780391042025. 130. Ronald G. Witt.
  16. Hunter, 1845, p. 264
  17. Mynors 1982, p.251
  18. Hutton, p. 393
  19. Book: Watson, Foster. The English grammar schools to 1660: their curriculum and practice. 1908. Cambridge University Press. 28, 425. 15 January 2014.
  20. Mynors 1982, p. 401, fn. 4
  21. Tory, 1529
  22. Ivans, 1920, pp. 85–86
  23. Hutton, 1931, pp. 393–395
  24. Nencioni 1967, p. 93
  25. Bobinski, 1897, p.
  26. Traube, 1909, pp. 95–96, fn. 7
  27. Bertalot, 1917, p. 55, fn. 47–8
  28. James, 1905, pp. 237–238
  29. Küsswetter, 1906, p. 23 cites a facsimile by the Early English Text Society.
  30. Web site: Butt. Stephen. Honorificabilitudinitatibus - John Woodford (1358-1401). The Woodforde Family: A History of the Woodforde Family from 1300. 19 January 2014. https://web.archive.org/web/20140202190815/http://www.woodforde.co.uk/page07.htm. 2 February 2014.
  31. Book: The Truth Will Out: Unmasking the Real Shakespeare. 2006. Pearson Education. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey. 9781405840866. 240. B. James. W. D. Rubinstein.
  32. Web site: Cruet, cast pewter, England, about 1400, museum number: M.26–1939. Victoria and Albert Museum. 15 January 2014.
  33. Web site: Cruet. Victoria and Albert Museum. 19 January 2014.
  34. Weinstein 2011, p. 130
  35. Simms, 1938, pp. 178-179 text + pl. L
  36. Book: Bailey, Richard W . Edward Finegan . John R. Rickford . Language in the USA: Themes for the Twenty-first Century . . 2004 . 978-0-521-77747-6 . 3 . Part I - American English: Its Origins and History . http://www.cambridge.org/catalogue/catalogue.asp?isbn=9780511206948&ss=exc.
  37. Di Biase 2006, p. 277
  38. Ballentine, 2010, p. 77
  39. Blount, 1656
  40. Notes and Queries, 1881, p. 418, reply by Xit
  41. Notes and Queries, 1881, p. 418, reply by F. C. Birkbeck Terry
  42. Coles, 1676
  43. Notes and Queries, 1881, p. 29, query by James Hooper
  44. Bailey, 1721
  45. Johnson, 1755, p. 970: honorary is followed by honour.
  46. Web site: Pinky and The Brain Episode Guide. 20 January 2014. pattycakes.
  47. Jeff Noon; Cobralingus. 2001. Hove UK. Codex Books.
  48. Suzanne Selfors, "Smells Like Treasure," ch. 35, New York: Little, Brown Books for Young Readers, 2011.