Hidden track explained

In the field of recorded music, a hidden track (sometimes called a ghost track, secret track or unlisted track) is a song or a piece of audio that has been placed on a CD, audio cassette, LP record, or other recorded medium, in such a way as to avoid detection by the casual listener. In some cases, the piece of music may simply have been left off the track listing, while in other cases, more elaborate methods are used. In rare cases, a 'hidden track' is actually the result of an error that occurred during the mastering stage production of the recorded media.^[1] However, since the rise of digital and streaming services such as iTunes and Spotify in the late 2000s and early 2010s, the inclusion of hidden tracks has declined on studio albums.

It is occasionally unclear whether a piece of music is 'hidden.' For example, "Her Majesty," which is preceded by fourteen seconds of silence, was originally unlisted on The Beatles' Abbey Road but is listed on current versions of the album.^[2] That song and others push the definition of the term, causing a lack of consensus on what is considered a hidden track. Alternatively, such things are instead labeled as vague audio experiments, errors, or simply an integral part of an adjacent song on the record.^[3]

Techniques

A vinyl record may be double-grooved, with the second groove containing the hidden tracks. Examples of double-grooving include Monty Python's 'three-sided' Matching Tie and Handkerchief, Tool's Opiate EP,^[4] and Mr. Bungle's Disco Volante.

With the invention of digital media and compact discs, alternative methods for hiding unlisted tracks were conceived. With a similar aim of concealment, unlisted tracks are sometimes given their own separate index point on digital media. Songs can be placed in the pregap of the first track of certain CD formats, so that the CD must first be cued to the track, and then manually back-scanned. These are often referred to as Track 0^[5] or Hidden Track One Audio (HTOA).^[6] A CD player will not play these tracks without manual intervention, and some models (including many computer operating systems) are unable to read such content. On Super Furry Animals' Guerrilla, "The Citizens Band" is found in the pre-gap approximately five minutes before the beginning of track one. A glossary of terms used in the song's lyrics is printed on the interior of the cardboard outer sleeve of the CD. This essentially renders them inaccessible without taking the sleeve apart, hiding the glossary in a parallel way to the song itself.

A less concealed method is to place the song at the end of another track, typically the last track on the album, following a period of silence. For example, Nirvana's song "Endless, Nameless" was included as a hidden track in this way on their 1991 CD Nevermind, after 10 minutes of complete silence within the track listed as the final song.^{[7] [8]} Although it was not the first hidden song to use this technique, it gained significant attention.^[9] Similarly, short tracks of silence can be layered before the hidden track plays. On Lazlo Bane's debut album, 11 Transistor, the eleventh song is followed by 57 silent tracks, each four seconds in duration, with "Prada Wallet" (sometimes referred to as "The Birthday Song") being the 69th track on the album. The total length of silence between the two songs is 3:48.^[10]

It is possible for a track to be playable only through a computer, such as the '15th' track on Marilyn Manson's Mechanical Animals album, which can only be accessed through an Enhanced CD executable.

There are yet-deeper ways a track can be hidden. A "ghost" track can be subtly mixed to play concurrently with other, dominant audio, or heavily distorted in a way which must be undone to be played. For example, on a DVD included with the deluxe and 'ultra-deluxe' editions of Nine Inch Nails' Ghosts I–IV, two hidden bonus tracks ("37 Ghosts" and "38 Ghosts") are included as digital multitrack files, from which the songs may be reconstructed.

Reasoning

• Aaliyah's self-titled album Aaliyah features the hidden song "Messed Up" on track 15. During the stages of the album creation, Aaliyah had no desire to put this song on the album, but after numerous inquiries from different labels and colleagues, she settled on making it a hidden track.^[11]
• In some rare cases, it is used to avoid legal issues. An example is Ramones' Loco Live American version, which has the song "Carbona Not Glue" hidden after Pet Sematary on track 17. It was originally recorded on their album Leave Home, but the makers of the spot remover Carbona, a registered trademark, objected. Therefore, reference to the song was removed from the album and cover.^[12]
• "Freedom" by Paul McCartney was a hidden track on the original release of Driving Rain. It was later added as a track on the re-release. The track was not meant to be hidden; it was a tribute to 9/11 victims, and McCartney wanted it on the album. The artwork was already finalised, so there was no choice but to make it a hidden track.^[13]
• "Train in Vain" by The Clash, which appears at the end of London Calling, was left out of the vinyl's track listing simply because it was a last-minute addition to the album, when the sleeves were already printed. It is thus not a real hidden track. It was originally intended as a promotional giveaway for NME. The later CD versions list the track on the sleeve.^[14]
• Green Day's "All By Myself" (by drummer Tré Cool) was added as a secret song to Dookie due to the low sound quality of the original live recording.
• "Weird Al" Yankovic's "Bite Me" from the album Off the Deep End was put on after ten minutes of silence to scare listeners who had forgotten to turn off the CD player.^[15] It was also a loose parody of "Endless, Nameless" by Nirvana. The cover of Off the Deep End is also a parody of the album containing that track, Nevermind, and its first track is a parody of that album's first track, "Smells Like Teen Spirit".
• features a hidden track at 10 minutes and 13 seconds into the final track. The track consists of series creator Chris Carter explaining the series mythology and meaning behind the alien conspiracy. The hidden track even includes spoilers and minute details about the show's overall plot that had not yet been resolved on the show itself when the album was released. This track was included as both a surprise to devoted fans who would seek out answers in cross-promotional merchandise, and as a mystery to new fans who would need to watch the show more closely to better understand the track.^[16]
• Eugene Mirman's album The Absurd Night Club Comedy of Eugene Mirman includes a hidden track making fun of hidden tracks, and telling the listener that they have a very bizarre mission.^[17]
• The Jam's All Mod Cons does not list the song "English Rose" and its lyrics on original vinyl copies because Paul Weller believed the title and song would lose meaning without accompanying music. They have been added to re-releases of the album.
• Skip Spence's "Land of the Sun" was included as a hidden track by producer Bill Bentley to specifically close a tribute album to Spence, .^[18]
• Oasis' compilation album Time Flies features the single "Sunday Morning Call" as a hidden track. The album was an anthology of all of the band's singles, but principal songwriter Noel Gallagher openly detests the song,^[19] so chose to have it hidden.
• 311's Transistor album contains an instrumental intro track that was performed on their 1996 tour, often referred to as the “Transistor Intro.”

Notable hidden tracks

Some hidden tracks are historically significant, have become well known and even occasionally received radio airplay and climbed the charts.

• The Beatles' track "Her Majesty" from their 1969 album Abbey Road is considered a hidden track. It was originally a part of the medley on side two of the album, before Paul McCartney requested that it be removed; the engineer who edited it out of the rough mix placed it after the medley to preserve it, and when the Beatles heard it there, they decided to place it there on the album.^[20] The original pressings of Abbey Road did not list "Her Majesty" on the back cover song title listing, nor the record label; subsequent LP pressings and then CD issues were issued revealing the track. However, two years prior, in 1967, on the UK version of the Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band album, there was the "inner groove" that appeared after "A Day in the Life" at the end of side two. It was an unexpected, untitled, and un-credited Beatles recording; so this might be deemed a precursor to the hidden track. A potential hidden track on yet another Beatles album is on The Beatles (also known popularly as The White Album) 1968 double album. The hidden track is a snippet of a song called "Can You Take Me Back", serving as an "outro" to "Cry Baby Cry".
• Nirvana put the hidden song "Endless, Nameless" 10 minutes after the last listed track on their 1991 album Nevermind. It was the first prominent hidden track in the CD era and inspired a slew of hidden tracks on albums in the following years. Lead singer Kurt Cobain said he got the idea from when he would make mix tapes for his friends and then add a secret song after a long silent gap at the end, to startle them. Interestingly, some of the initial pressings of the album accidentally omitted the secret track because the person pressing the album thought it was not meant to be there. This was quickly corrected in subsequent pressings after the band let the label know.
• Janet Jackson's track "Whoops Now", a hidden track from her album janet.,^[21] was released as a single, and reached number nine in UK Singles Charts, and number one in New Zealand Singles Chart.
• The Rembrandts had a sudden radio hit in 1995 with "I'll Be There for You", the theme song to Friends, so it was added at the last minute to their third album LP. As a result, the song was a hidden track on the early printing, since the CD packaging had already been completed by the time the song was added. However, a sticker was added to the outer shrink wrap advising the song's inclusion.
• Eels' album Daisies of the Galaxy contains a hidden track, "Mr. E's Beautiful Blues", which was released as a single, and received radio airplay, although it was not featured on the sleeve notes.^[22] The song was, in fact, released as the first single from the album, and peaked at number 11 on the UK Singles Chart.
• Cracker's "Euro-Trash Girl", an original, was one of their biggest radio hits, despite being a hidden track on Kerosene Hat.^[23]
• "Skin (Sarabeth)" by Rascal Flatts, a hidden track from their 2004 album Feels Like Today, received enough airplay to chart in the Top 40 on the country charts, peaking at number 2 in late 2005. In mid-2005, the album was re-issued, with the song officially listed as a track, coinciding with the song's release as a single.^[24]
• Of the two hidden tracks on Lauryn Hill's The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill, one of them, the cover of "Can't Take My Eyes Off You" was nominated for a Grammy in 1999 in the category of 'Best Female Pop Vocal Performance'. It was the first time a hidden track was nominated for a Grammy.^[25]
• One of the hidden tracks on P!nk's fourth album, "I Have Seen the Rain", gained significant attention by P!nk fans, as her father, James T. Moore, was featured on the song.^[26]
• Peter, Paul and Mary's 2003 album, In These Times, revealed that after 25 seconds of silence from "Oh, Had I a Golden Thread", there was a hidden live track of a Spanish folk song "Mi Caballo Blanco",^[27] although it was listed in the box set Carry It On.^[28] The track was later officially listed on their 2014 album Discovered: Live in Concert^[29]
• Tally Hall's 2005 album Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum had a hidden track, aptly titled "Hidden in the Sand", that would prove to be the band's most successful song, gaining over 35 million plays on YouTube^[30] and over 216 million on Spotify.^[31]
• My Chemical Romance put the hidden track "Blood" after the final song on their 2006 rock opera The Black Parade, though it would be omitted on Japanese editions of the album.
• Coldplay's song "O", from their 2014 album Ghost Stories, is composed mainly of a hidden track, called "Fly On". This track made it into charts in the UK, France, and the US, peaking at #9 on the US Rock Digital Song Sales. "Fly On" appeared on their 2014 live album, with "O" being replaced by its reprise.
• Fall Out Boy placed a hidden track titled "Lullabye" right before the start of their 2008 album Folie à Deux. It is an acoustic ballad influenced by Bob Dylan, written with the intention of helping Pete Wentz' son, Bronx Mowgli, fall asleep. The track is only accessible by placing a CD version of the album into a media player and pressing the previous track button before "Disloyal Order of Water Buffaloes" begins.
• Deftones's 1997 album, Around the Fur, has two hidden tracks. "Bong Hit" starts after 19:31 minutes of the last track "MX". After 12:41 minutes of silence (after "Bong Hit"), "Damone" starts.
• Incubus's second album, S.C.I.E.N.C.E., has a mix of sounds and music called "Segue 1", which starts after 30 seconds of the track "Calgone".
• On early copies of Better than Ezra's 1996 album Friction, Baby, the track "Mejor de Ezra" is contained in the pregap, meaning listeners must start the first track, "King of New Orleans", then rewind the CD to hear the hidden song. Later copies of the album tack this secret track onto the end of the album.
• Robbie Williams has had a hidden track on many of his albums. On his first studio album, Life thru a Lens, the standard edition included one hidden track.^[32] His second album, I've Been Expecting You, includes two.^[33] By doing this, Williams' regular listeners would have likely expected a hidden track of sorts on the third album, Sing When You're Winning. To play on this, instead of a hidden track appearing on the album, a recording of Williams' saying "No, I'm not doing one on this album" plays after 24 minutes of silence.^[34]

See also

• Easter egg (media)
• B-side
• List of albums containing a hidden track
• List of albums with tracks hidden in the pregap
• Backmasking
• Bonus track
• Sampling (music)
• Surprise album

External links

• Hidden Songs — a user-submitted database of hidden song listings

Notes and References

1. Web site: Rogers . Jude . Manna for fans: the history of the hidden track in music . The Guardian . 25 January 2015 . 25 January 2015.
2. Web site: Hidden Songs: The Beatles, "Her Majesty". live. https://web.archive.org/web/20070422235856/http://hiddensongs.com/songs/abbeyroad.html. 2007-04-22. 2007-03-07.
3. Web site: Hidden Songs: The Beatles, "Untitled". live. https://web.archive.org/web/20070427055038/http://hiddensongs.com/songs/sgtpepper.html. 2007-04-27. 2007-03-07.
4. Web site: The Tool FAQ. 2007-03-07. live. https://web.archive.org/web/20070304132245/http://toolshed.down.net/faq/faq.html. 2007-03-04.
5. Book: Katz, Bob. Mastering Audio: The Art and the Science. Robert A.. Katz. Focal Press. 2002. 0-240-80545-3. 93.
6. Web site: HTOA - Hidden Track One Audio. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20090905083000/http://www.daefeatures.co.uk/htoa.php. 2009-09-05.
7. Book: Cross, Charles R.. Nevermind. Jim. Berkenstadt. Music Sales Group. 2004. 0-8256-7286-4. 103.
8. Web site: Endless, Nameless. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20060720155708/http://livenirvana.com/songguide/body0ff0.html?songid=31. 2006-07-20. 2007-03-08.
9. Book: Thompson, Dave. The Music Lover's Guide to Record Collecting. Backbeat Books. 2002. 0-87930-713-7. 50–51.
10. Web site: 11 Transistor - Lazlo Bane. live. https://web.archive.org/web/20150926185341/http://www.allmusic.com/album/11-transistor-mw0000615852. 2015-09-26. AllMusic.
11. Web site: Rare Gem: Aaliyah 'Messed Up' (early version). YouKnowIGotSoul.com. 19 December 2018. 16 October 2012.
12. Web site: LOCO LIVE (American version). live. https://web.archive.org/web/20081222014827/http://kauhajokinyt.fi/~jplaitio/offilive.html#amer. 2008-12-22.
13. Web site: Wawzenek. Bryan. How Paul McCartney began building his next era on 'Driving Rain'. UltimateClassicRock.com. 19 December 2018.
14. Web site: The Greatest Songs Ever! 'Train in Vain (Stand by Me)'. 2007-03-07. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20090221070346/http://www.blender.com/guide/articles.aspx?id=299. 2009-02-21.
15. Web site: Midnight Star "Ask Al" Q&As for January/February 1998. 2001-06-26. 2021-08-28.
16. Web site: X-Files knowledge. staff. live. https://web.archive.org/web/20121005162143/http://www.aintitcool.com/node/1060. 2012-10-05.
17. Web site: Mirman. Eugene. Absurd Nightclub Comedy of Eugene Mirman: Eugene Mirman: Music. Amazon. 2011-07-27.
18. News: Margaret . Moser. Back Door Man: The Man Behind More Oar, Bill Bentley. Austin Chronicle. December 17, 1999. https://web.archive.org/web/20070412081144/http://www.austinchronicle.com/gyrobase/Issue/story?oid=oid%3A75120. April 12, 2007.
19. Web site: Noel Gallagher's Oasis DVD commentary highlights. ac2006. 30 January 2014. 4 May 2018. YouTube. live. https://web.archive.org/web/20170223100253/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=caB5RoaBvsI. 23 February 2017.
20. Book: Lewisohn, Mark. Mark Lewisohn. 2004. The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions. London. EMI/Hamlyn. 183. 0-681-03189-1. 2004.
21. Web site: Hampp. Andrew. Janet Jackson, 'janet.': classic track-by-track review. Billboard.com. 18 May 2013. 19 December 2018.
22. Web site: The Most Beautiful of Freaks. 8 January 2009. Peter. Naldrett. MusicCritic.com. March 2000. live. https://web.archive.org/web/20080820085323/http://www.music-critic.com/rock/eels_daisiesofgalaxy.htm. 20 August 2008.
23. Web site: 'Kerosene Hat' is hot. 2007-03-07. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20071017000850/http://www.epinions.com/content_32102190724. 2007-10-17.
24. Web site: Piano Sheet Music - Rascal Flatts - Skin. 2007-03-07. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20070928110014/http://www.encoremusic.com/piano/1704836.html. 2007-09-28.
25. Web site: Kot. Greg. 10 nominations put Lauryn Hill atop Grammy heap. ChicagoTribune.com. 19 December 2018.
26. Web site: I Have Seen The Rain (feat. James T. Moore) by P!nk on Apple Music. Apple Music. April 2006. 30 December 2019.
27. Web site: Mi Caballo Blanco.
28. Web site: Carry It on [Bonus DVD] - Peter, Paul and Mary | Songs, Reviews, Credits | AllMusic. AllMusic.
29. Web site: Now Available: Peter, Paul & Mary, Discovered: Live in Concert Rhino.
30. Web site: Tally Hall - Hidden in the Sand (Music Video) . youtube.com . December 10, 2022.
31. Web site: Becker. Sarah. Revisiting Tally Hall's surprise hit "Hidden in the Sand". AudioPhix. en. April 13, 2024. April 16, 2024.
32. Bresnark, Robin. "Review: Robbie Williams – Life Thru A Lens, Chrysalis". Melody Maker (4 October 1997): 51.
33. Web site: I've Been Expecting You . 2024-02-28 . Robbie Williams . en.
34. Web site: BBC Staffordshire - Robbie Williams - Sing When You're Winning . 2024-02-28 . www.bbc.co.uk.