Ger toshav explained

Ger toshav (Hebrew: גר תושב, ger: "foreigner" or "alien" + toshav: "resident", lit. "resident alien") is a halakhic term used in Judaism to designate the legal status of a Gentile (non-Jew) living in the Land of Israel who does not want to convert to Judaism but agrees to observe the Seven Laws of Noah, a set of imperatives which, according to the Talmud, were given by God as a binding set of universal moral laws for the "sons of Noah"—that is, all of humanity. A ger toshav, especially one who decides to follow the Noahic covenant out of religious belief rather than ethical reasoning, is commonly deemed a "Righteous Gentile" (Hebrew: חסיד אומות העולם, Chassid Umot ha-Olam: "Pious People of the World"), and is assured of a place in the World to Come (Olam Ha-Ba).

Definition

A ger toshav ("resident alien") is a Gentile (non-Jew) living in the Land of Israel who agrees to follow the Seven Laws of Noah. The theological basis for the seven commandments of the Noahic Covenant is said to be derived interpretatively from demands addressed to Adam[1] and to Noah,[2] who are believed to be the progenitors of humankind in Judaism, and therefore to be regarded as universal moral laws. The seven commandments of the Noahic Covenant to which the ger toshav agrees to be bound are enumerated in the Babylonian Talmud (Avodah Zarah 8:4, Sanhedrin 56a-b):

  1. Do not worship idols.
  2. Do not curse God.
  3. Do not murder.
  4. Do not commit adultery or sexual immorality.
  5. Do not steal.
  6. Do not eat flesh torn from a living animal.
  7. Establish courts of justice.

The Encyclopedia Talmudit, edited by rabbi Shlomo Yosef Zevin, states that after the giving of the Torah, the Jewish people were no longer included in the category of the sons of Noah; however, Maimonides (Mishneh Torah, Hilkhot M'lakhim 9:1) indicates that the seven commandments are also part of the Torah, and the Babylonian Talmud (Sanhedrin 59a, see also Tosafot ad. loc.) states that Jews are obligated in all things that Gentiles are obligated in, albeit with some differences in the details. According to the Encyclopedia Talmudit, most medieval Jewish authorities considered that all the seven commandments were given to Adam, although Maimonides (Mishneh Torah, Hilkhot M'lakhim 9:1) considered the dietary law to have been given to Noah.

The term ger toshav may be used in a formal or informal sense. In the formal sense, a ger toshav is a Gentile who officially accepts the seven Noahide laws as binding upon themself in the presence of three haberim (men of authority), or, according to the rabbinic tradition, before a beth din (Jewish rabbinical court). In the Talmud there are two other, differing opinions (Avodah Zarah, 64b) that pertain to which commandments the ger toshav is required to follow:

  1. To abstain from idolatrous practices of any kind (detailed in Exodus 20:2–4 and Deuteronomy 5:6–8).
  2. To uphold all the 613 commandments in rabbinical enumeration, except for the prohibition against eating kosher animals that died by means other than ritual slaughter, or possibly (Meiri) any prohibition not involving kareth.

The accepted opinion is that the ger toshav must accept the Seven Laws of Noah before a rabbinical court of three. They will receive certain legal protection and privileges from the community, the rules regarding Jewish-Gentile relations are modified, and there is an obligation to render him aid when in need. The restrictions on having a Gentile do work for a Jew on the Shabbat are also greater when the Gentile is a ger toshav.

In the informal sense, a ger toshav is a Gentile who agrees to follow the seven Noahide laws on his own, or alternatively, simply rejects idolatry (the latter issue is in particular brought up regarding Muslims). According to the rabbinic tradition, a Gentile who agrees to follow the seven Noahide laws, although not before a beth din, is still regarded as Chassid Umot ha-Olam ("Pious People of the World"), and the observance of the Seven Laws of Noah grants them a place in the World to Come (Olam Ha-Ba). There is a debate among the halakhic authorities as to whether the rules regarding a ger toshav would apply to the informal case.

The procedure to officially recognize the legal status of ger toshav has been discontinued since the cessation of the year of Jubilee with the destruction of the Second Temple of Jerusalem; hence, there are no formal gerim toshavim extant today. However, it can be argued that a great deal are "informal" ones, especially since it is possible to be a Chassid Umot ha-Olam even when the Jubilee year is not observed.

Modern times and views

See main article: Noahidism and Religious Zionism.

Menachem Mendel Schneerson, the Lubavitcher Rebbe, encouraged his followers on many occasions to preach the Seven Laws of Noah, devoting some of his addresses to the subtleties of this code.[3] Since the 1990s, Orthodox Jewish rabbis from Israel, most notably those affiliated to Chabad-Lubavitch and religious Zionist organizations,[4] [5] including The Temple Institute,[4] [5] have set up a modern Noahide movement.[4] [5] These Noahide organizations, led by religious Zionist and Orthodox Jewish rabbis, are aimed at non-Jews in order to proselytize among them and commit them to follow the Noahide laws.[4] [5] According to Rachel Z. Feldman,[4] American anthropologist and Assistant Professor of Religious Studies at Dartmouth College, many of the Orthodox Jewish rabbis involved in mentoring Noahides are supporters of the Third Temple movement who believe that the messianic era shall begin with the establishment of a Jewish theocratic state in Israel, supported by communities of Noahides worldwide:[4]

Feldman describes Noahidism as a "new world religion" that "carv[es] out a place for non-Jews in the messianic Zionist project" and "affirms the superiority of Judaism and Jewish biblical right to the Land of Israel, in line with the aims of the growing messianic Third Temple Movement in Jerusalem."[4] She characterizes Noahide ideology in the Philippines and elsewhere in the global south as having a "markedly racial dimension" constructed around "an essential categorical difference between Jews and Noahides".[4] David Novak, professor of Jewish theology and ethics at the University of Toronto, has denounced the modern Noahide movement by stating that "If Jews are telling Gentiles what to do, it’s a form of imperialism".[6]

According to the Jewish philosopher and professor Menachem Kellner's study on Maimonidean texts (1991), a ger toshav could be a transitional stage on the way to becoming a "righteous alien" (Hebrew: גר צדק, ger tzedek), i.e. a full convert to Judaism.[7] He conjectures that, according to Maimonides, only a full ger tzedek would be found during the Messianic era.[7] Furthermore, Kellner criticizes the assumption within Orthodox Judaism that there is an "ontological divide between Jews and Gentiles",[8] which he believes is contrary to what Maimonides thought and the Torah teaches,[8] stating that "Gentiles as well as Jews are fully created in the image of God".[8]

According to Menachem Mendel Schneerson, the status of ger toshav will continue to exist, even in the Messianic era. This is based on the statement in Hilkhot M'lakhim 12:5 that lit. “all the world (kol ha'olam) will be nothing but to know G‑d." In its plain meaning, he asserts, kol ha'olam also includes Gentiles. As proof, he cites 11:4, which deals with the Messianic era, and the similar term ha'olam kulo, "the world in its entirety", refers to Gentiles. Continuing the text in Hilkhot M'lakhim 12:5, Maimonides explicitly changes the topic to Jews by using the term Yisra'el, explaining that "Therefore, the Jews will be great sages and know the hidden matters, grasping the knowledge of their Creator according to the full extent of human potential", indicating that Jews and Gentiles will co-exist in the time of the Messiah.[9]

Notes and References

  1. 2:16 HE
  2. See Genesis Rabbah 34; Sanhedrin 59b
  3. Book: Schneerson, Menachem Mendel . Menachem Mendel Schneerson . 1979 . . 4 . 1094 . Collected Talks . yi . . . 978-0-8266-5722-0.
    Book: Schneerson, Menachem Mendel . Menachem Mendel Schneerson . 1985 . . 26 . 132–144 . Collected Talks . yi . . . 978-0-8266-5749-7.
    Book: Schneerson, Menachem Mendel . Menachem Mendel Schneerson . 1987 . . 35 . 97 . Collected Talks . yi. . . 978-0-8266-5781-7.
  4. Feldman. Rachel Z.. August 2018. The Children of Noah: Has Messianic Zionism Created a New World Religion?. PDF. Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religions. Berkeley. University of California Press. 22. 1. 115–128. 10.1525/nr.2018.22.1.115. 149940089. 1092-6690. 1541-8480. 98656716. 36349271. 31 May 2020. Project MUSE.
  5. News: Ilany . Ofri . The Messianic Zionist Religion Whose Believers Worship Judaism (But Can't Practice It) . . . 12 September 2018 . https://archive.today/20200209223631/https://www.haaretz.com/jewish/.premium-the-messianic-zionist-religion-that-wants-to-recruit-7-billion-members-1.6455144 . 9 February 2020 . live . 31 May 2020.
  6. Web site: The Modern Noahide Movement . Kress . Michael . 2018 . My Jewish Learning . 10 November 2020.
  7. Book: Kellner, Menachem . Menachem Kellner . 1991 . Maimonides on Judaism and the Jewish people . . . SUNY Series in Jewish Philosophy . 44 . 0-7914-0691-1 . against my reading of Maimonides is strengthened by the fact that Maimonides himself says that the ger toshav is accepted only during the time that the Jubilee is practiced. The Jubilee year is no longer practiced in this dispensation [...]. Second, it is entirely reasonable to assume that Maimonides thought that the messianic conversion of the Gentiles would be a process that occurred in stages and that some or all Gentiles would go through the status of ger toshav on their way to the status of full convert, ger tzedek. But this question aside, there are substantial reasons why it is very unlikely that Maimonides foresaw a messianic era in which the Gentiles would become only semi-converts (ger toshav) and not full converts (ger tzedek). Put simply, semi-converts are not separate from the Jews but equal to them; their status is in every way inferior and subordinate to that of the Jews. They are separate and unequal..
  8. Web site: Orthodoxy and "The Gentile Problem" . Kellner . Menachem . Menachem Kellner . Spring 2016 . . . https://web.archive.org/web/20200801013545/https://www.jewishideas.org/article/orthodoxy-and-gentile-problem . 1 August 2020 . live . 10 November 2020.
  9. Book: Moses Maimonides . Maimonides . 2012 . https://www.sefaria.org/Mishneh_Torah%2C_Kings_and_Wars.8?lang=bi . Hilkhot M'lakhim (Laws of Kings and Wars) . . 8:10 . Brauner . Reuven . . 10 November 2020.
  10. News: HaLevi . Ezra . 28 September 2005 . Sanhedrin Moves to Establish Council For Noahides . . . 1 November 2020.
  11. News: HaLevi . Ezra . 10 January 2006 . A group of non-Jewish delegates have come to Jerusalem to pledge their loyalty to the Laws of Noah . . . 1 November 2020.
  12. Book: Hayes . Christine . Christine Hayes . https://books.google.com/books?id=WGZ0_PUBLVcC&pg=PA19 . Part I: Gentile Impurities in Biblical and Second Temple Sources — Chapter 2: Gentile Impurity in the Bible . Gentile Impurities and Jewish Identities: Intermarriage and Conversion from the Bible to the Talmud . 2002 . . . 19-44 . 10.1093/0195151208.003.0002 . 9780199834273 . 2001051154.
  13. Schneerson, Menachem Mendel. Sha'arei Ge'ulah. pp. 267–8 (translated from Hebrew; emphasis and round brackets, but not the square brackets, in original text): There is a further detail in the wording of the Rambam in the completion and conclusion of his book [Mishneh Torah, Hilkhot M'lakhim 12:5]: "And the occupation of the entire world will not be anything other than to know G‑d." Because in its plain meaning, it thereby includes the nations of the world as well (similar to what the Rambam wrote in the previous chapter, that the Messianic king will "improve the world in its entirety to serve G‑d ... I will transform the nations etc."), especially since immediately afterwards the Rambam changes [terminology] and writes "And therefore Israel will be great sages etc." In any case, even when there is a Jewish king and a Sanhedrin, and all the twelve tribes live in the Land of Israel, Jewish law does not permit forcing someone to convert and become a ger tzedek against his will.[9]

    High Council of

    See main article: 2004 attempt to revive the Sanhedrin.

    A "High Council of ", set up to represent Noahide communities around the world, was endorsed by a group that claimed to be the new Sanhedrin.[10] The High Council of consists of a group of Noahides who, at the request of the nascent Sanhedrin, gathered in Jerusalem on 10 January 2006 to be recognized as an international Noahide organization for the purpose of serving as a bridge between the nascent Sanhedrin and Noahides worldwide.[11] There were ten initial members who flew to Israel and pledged to uphold the Seven Laws of Noah and to conduct themselves under the authority of the Noahide (religious court) of the nascent Sanhedrin.

    Non-necessity of conversion

    According to Christine Hayes, an American scholar of ancient Judaism and early Christianity serving as the Sterling Professor of Religious Studies in Classical Judaica at Yale University, the gerim were not necessarily Gentile converts in the Hebrew Bible, whether in the modern or rabbinic sense. Nonetheless, they were granted many rights and privileges when they lived in the Land of Israel. For example, they could offer sacrifices, actively participate in Israelite politics, keep their distinct ethnic identity for many generations, inherit tribal allotments, etc.[12]

    See also

    Bibliography

    • Encyclopedia: . Jewish Concepts: The Seven Noachide Laws . live . 2021 . 2017 . . American–Israeli Cooperative Enterprise (AICE) . https://web.archive.org/web/20170210052305/https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-seven-noachide-laws . 10 February 2017 . 17 October 2021.
    • Adler . Elchanan . Fall 2002 . The Sabbath Observing Gentile: Halakhic, Hashkafic, and Liturgical Perspectives . . . 36 . 3 . 14–45 . 23262836 . 7 November 2020.
    • Encyclopedia: Berlin . Meyer . Zevin . Shlomo Yosef . Shlomo Yosef Zevin . BEN NOAH . . IV . 1992 . 1969 . Yad Harav Herzog (Emet) . . 360–380 . 0873067142.
    • Book: Bleich, J. David . J. David Bleich . 1988 . Judaism and Natural Law . https://books.google.com/books?id=bJMnC8LQMu8C&pg=PA5 . Hecht . Neils S. . Jewish Law Annual . . . 7 . 5–42 . 9783718604807.
    • Book: Bleich, J. David . J. David Bleich . 1997 . Tikkun Olam: Jewish Obligations to Non-Jewish Society . https://books.google.com/books?id=6by4AQAAQBAJ&pg=PA61 . Shatz . David . Waxman . Chaim I. . Diament . Nathan J. . Tikkun Olam: Social Responsibility in Jewish Thought and Law . . . 61–102 . 978-0-765-75951-1.
    • Web site: The Bnei Noah (Children of Noah) . Feldman . Rachel Z. . 8 October 2017 . World Religions and Spirituality Project . 10 November 2020 . https://archive.today/20200121162034/https://wrldrels.org/2017/10/08/the-bnei-noah-children-of-noah/ . 21 January 2020 . live.
    • Book: van Houten, Christiana . 2009 . 1991 . The Alien in Israelite Law: A Study of the Changing Legal Status of Strangers in Ancient Israel . . . The Library of Hebrew Bible/Old Testament Studies . 107 . 978-1-85075-317-9.
    • Book: Kiel . Yishai . 2015 . Noahide Law and the Inclusiveness of Sexual Ethics: Between Roman Palestine and Sasanian Babylonia . https://books.google.com/books?id=9pc0CwAAQBAJ&pg=PA59 . Porat . Benjamin . Jewish Law Annual . . . 21 . 59–109 . 978-0-415-74269-6.
    • Book: Lichtenstein, Aaron . Aaron Lichtenstein . 1986 . 1981 . The Seven Laws of Noah . . . 2nd . 9781602803671.
    • Book: Novak . David . David Novak . 2011 . 1983 . The Image of the Non-Jew in Judaism: An Historical and Constructive Study of the Noahide Laws . . . Littman Library of Jewish Civilization . 10.2307/j.ctv1rmj9w . 9781786949820.
    • Wasserman . Mira Beth . 2019 . Noahide Law, Animal Ethics, and Talmudic Narrative . Crane . Jonathan K. . Filler . Emily . . . . 5 . 1 . 40–67 . 10.5325/jjewiethi.5.1.0040 . 201391432 . 2334-1785 . 2334-1777 . 2014201591 . 1082217204.
    • Encyclopedia: Zevin . Shlomo Yosef . Shlomo Yosef Zevin . "Ger Toshav", Section 1 . . 1979 . Yad Harav Herzog (Emet) . . 4th . he.
    • Encyclopedia: Zuesse . Evan M. . 2006 . Tolerance in Judaism: Medieval and Modern Sources . Neusner . Jacob . Jacob Neusner . Avery-Peck . Alan J. . Green . William Scott . Encyclopaedia of Judaism . IV . . . 10.1163/1872-9029_EJ_COM_0187 . 2688–2713 . 9789004141001.

    ]