Vicia faba explained

Vicia faba, commonly known as the broad bean, fava bean, or faba bean, is a species of vetch, a flowering plant in the pea and bean family Fabaceae. It is widely cultivated as a crop for human consumption, and also as a cover crop. Varieties with smaller, harder seeds that are fed to horses or other animals are called field bean, tic bean or tick bean. Horse bean, Vicia faba var. equina Pers., is a variety recognized as an accepted name.[1] This legume is very common in Southern European, Northern European, East Asian, Latin American and North African cuisines.

Some people suffer from favism, a hemolytic response to the consumption of broad beans, a condition linked to a metabolism disorder known as G6PDD. Otherwise the beans, with the outer seed coat removed, can be eaten raw or cooked. In young plants, the outer seed coat can be eaten, and in very young plants, the seed pod can be eaten.

Description

Vicia faba is a stiffly erect, annual plant 0.5to tall, with two to four stems that are square in cross-section. The leaves are 10to long, pinnate with 2–7 leaflets, and glaucous (grey-green). Unlike most other vetches, the leaves do not have tendrils for climbing over other vegetation.

The flowers are 1to long with five petals; the standard petals are white, the wing petals are white with a black spot (true black, not deep purple or blue as is the case in many "black" colorings)[2] and the keel petals are white. Crimson-flowered broad beans also exist, which were recently saved from extinction.[3] The flowers have a strong sweet scent which is attractive to bees and other pollinators.[4]

The fruit is a broad, leathery pod that is green, but matures to a dark blackish-brown, with a densely downy surface; the wild species has pods that are 5to long and 1 cm diameter, but many modern cultivars developed for food use have pods 15to long and 2–3 cm thick. Each bean pod contains 3–8 seeds. They are round to oval and have a 5–10 mm diameter in the wild plant, but are usually flattened and up to 20–25 mm long, 15 mm broad and 5–10 mm thick in food cultivars. V. faba has a diploid (2n) chromosome number of 12 (six homologous pairs). Five pairs are acrocentric chromosomes and one pair is metacentric.

Genome

The diploid genome of Vicia faba contains 13 GB of DNA, mostly obtained through amplification of retrotransposons and satellite repeats. The genome is one of the largest diploid field crops and contains a predicted 34,221 protein-coding genes.[5]

History and cultivation

Broad beans have a long tradition of cultivation in Old World agriculture, being among the most ancient plants in cultivation and also among the easiest to grow. While their wild ancestor has not been identified and their origin is unknown[6], charred legumes of a possible wild-type progenitor have been identified at the Natufian site of the el-Wad Terrace [7] . Carbonised domestic faba bean remains were discovered at three adjacent Neolithic sites in Israel's Lower Galilee (Yiftah'el, Ahi'hud and Nahal Zippori). Based on the radiocarbon dating of these remains, scientists now believe that the domestication of the crop may have begun as early as 8,250 BCE.[8]

Broad beans are still often grown as a cover crop to prevent erosion because they can overwinter and, as a legume, they fix nitrogen in the soil. The broad bean has high plant hardiness; it can withstand harsh and cold climates. Unlike most legumes, the broad bean can be grown in soils with high salinity, as well as in clay soil. However, it prefers rich loams.

In much of the English-speaking world, the name "broad bean" is used for the large-seeded cultivars grown for human food, while "horse bean" and "field bean" refer to cultivars with smaller, harder seeds that are more like the wild species and used for animal feed, though their stronger flavour is preferred in some human food recipes, such as falafel. The term "fava bean" (from for the bean) is used in some English-speaking countries such as Canada and the US, and "broad bean" is the most common name in Commonwealth countries like the UK, Australia and New Zealand.

Pests and diseases

Many diseases appear at a higher rate in higher humidity. Therefore, cultivars being bred for higher density should be evaluated for disease problems. This can be mitigated by west–east rows for more sun drying effect.[9]

Disease tolerance is an important part of breeding V. faba.[9]

If transplanted instead of direct seeded there is a lower risk of some diseases including Botrytis fabae.

Parasites

In mainland Europe and North Africa, the plant parasite Orobanche crenata (carnation-scented broomrape) can cause severe impacts on fields of broad beans, devastating their yields.

Fungal diseases

Botrytis fabae

See main article: Botrytis fabae.

Vicia faba is attacked by Botrytis fabae, the chocolate spot fungus, which can have a severe impact on yield. It is one of the worst diseases in fava beans, as it results in foliar damage, reduced photosynthesis, and reduced bean productivity. The fungus switches from non-aggressive growth to aggressive pathogenicity under the combination of increased temperature and humidity, which is worsened by low soil potassium and phosphorus content and by the higher humidity caused by higher seeding rates. The non-aggressive phase is marked by small red-brown leaf lesions, and sometimes the same on stems and pods. Treatment is less effective than prevention. Early planting avoids the problematic combination of high temperature and humidity in late spring into early summer. Decreasing seeding rate or thinning after emergence is also effective. Foliar fungicide is effective. If fava beans flower during the heights of summer temperatures there is an increased risk of this disease. If transplanted instead of direct seeded there is a lower risk of Botrytis fabae outbreaks.

Erysiphe cichoracearum

Erysiphe cichoracearum overwinters on residue and has alternate hosts. Resistant cultivars and overhead irrigation are preventative. Sulfur fungicides are recommended in severe outbreak.

Fusarium solani

This soil borne pathogen is mitigated by lower temperature, aeration, drainage, and sufficient nutrition. Symptoms include stunting, yellowing, necrotic basal leaves, and brown or red or black streak-shaped root lesions that grow together and may show above the soil as the disease progresses.

Uromyces viciae-fabae var. viciae-fabae

Faba bean rust is a fungal pathogen commonly affecting broad bean plants at maturity, causing small orange dots with yellow halos on the leaves, which may merge to form an orange lawn on both leaf surfaces.

Sclerotinia stem rot

Both Sclerotinia sclerotiorum and S. trifoliorum are pathogens of interest. Lithourgidis et al. have done extensive work over the years, including in 2007 for S. t., 2005 for S. s., and 1989 regarding procedures for field testing with S. s.[10]

Bacterial diseases

Xanthomonas campestris and X. axonopodis

Xanthomonas campestris and X. axonopodis can be inoculated by seed contamination and by overwintering in crop residue. Increased incidence with higher temperatures, rainfall, and humidity. Produces deliquescent, necrotic lesions, sometimes with a wider yellow lesion around them, and in advanced disease the plant will look burned. Can be prevented or treated by use of uninfected seed, resistant cultivars, seed treatments, and copper bactericides.

Pseudomonas syringae

Pseudomonas syringae overwinters on residue. Uninfected seed, rotation, and removal of residue are preventative.

Viral diseases

Faba bean necrotic yellows virus which it shares with other Vicia.[11] Timchenko et al. 2006 find Clink is not obviously necessary but highly conserved nonetheless, suggesting it is maintained by necessity for infection of other Vicia.

Insect pests

Aphis fabae

Broad bean plants are highly susceptible to early summer infestations of the black bean aphid, which can cover large sections of growing plants with infestations, typically starting at the tip of the plant. Severe infestations can significantly reduce yields, and can also cause discolouration of pods and reduction in their saleable values.

Aphis fabae is a major pest. May infest transplants. Reflective plastic mulch may be preventative. May be mechanically removed by high pressure water once plant is established. V. fabae is tolerant to low and medium degrees of infestation, so insecticide application is only required under high infestation.

Toxicity

Beans generally contain phytohaemagglutinin, a lectin that occurs naturally in plants, animals, and humans.[12] Most of the relatively low toxin concentrations found in V. faba can be destroyed by boiling the beans for 10 minutes.[12]

Broad beans are rich in levodopa, and should thus be avoided by those taking irreversible monoamine oxidase inhibitors to prevent a pressor response.[13] [14]

Genetic predisposition

Sufferers of favism must avoid broad beans, as they contain the alkaloid glycoside vicine which may initiate a hemolytic crisis.[15] A low-content vicine-convicine faba bean line was identified in the 1980s and the trait has been introduced into several modern cultivars. Low vicine-convicine faba beans are safe for consumption by G6PD-deficient individuals. As of 2019, a molecular marker may be used for marker-assisted breeding to reduce levels of vicine-convicine in fava beans.[16]

Uses

Culinary

Raw mature fava beans are 11% water, 58% carbohydrates, 26% protein, and 2% fat. A 100-gram reference amount supplies 1425kJ of food energy and numerous essential nutrients in high content (20% or more of the Daily Value, DV). Folate (26% DV), and dietary minerals, such as manganese, phosphorus, magnesium, and iron (range of 52 to 77% DV), have considerable content. B vitamins have moderate to rich content (19 to 48% DV). Fava beans present the highest protein-to-carbohydrate ratio among other popular pulse crops, such as chickpea, pea and lentil. Moreover, their consumption is recommended along with cereals as both foods are complementary in supplying all essential amino acids.[17]

Broad beans are generally eaten while still young and tender, enabling harvesting to begin as early as the middle of spring for plants started under glass or overwintered in a protected location, but even the main crop sown in early spring will be ready from mid to late summer. Horse beans, left to mature fully, are usually harvested in the late autumn, and are then eaten as a pulse. The immature pods are also cooked and eaten, and the young leaves of the plant can also be eaten, either raw or cooked as a pot herb (like spinach).

Preparing broad beans involves first removing the beans from their pods, then steaming or boiling the beans, either whole or after parboiling them to loosen their exterior coating, which is then removed. The beans can be fried, causing the skin to split open, and then salted and/or spiced to produce a savory, crunchy snack.

Algeria

In south Algerian cuisine, broad beans are used to make besarah and doubara. Doubara is popular in the city of Biskra.

China

In the Sichuan cuisine of China, broad beans are combined with soybeans and chili peppers to produce a spicy fermented bean paste called doubanjiang.

Colombia

Fava beans (Colombia: Haba(s)) are a common food in most regions of Colombia, mostly in Bogota and Boyacá.

Ecuador

Steamed fava beans (known as habitas) with cheese are common in the cold-weather regions of Ecuador, especially around the Andes mountains and surroundings of Ambato.

Egypt

Fava beans (Egyptian Masri: pronounced as /fuːl/) are a common staple food in the Egyptian diet, eaten by rich and poor alike. Egyptians eat fava beans in various ways: they may be shelled and then dried, or bought dried and then cooked in water on very low heat for several hours. They are the primary ingredient in Egyptian-style falafel (unlike the Levantine style, where the primary ingredient is chickpeas). The most popular way of preparing them in Egypt is by taking the cooked and partially mashed beans and adding oil, salt, and cumin to them. The dish, known as ful medames, is traditionally eaten with bread (generally at breakfast) and is considered one of Egypt's national dishes.

Ethiopia

Broad beans are one of the most popular legumes in Ethiopia. They are tightly coupled with every aspect of Ethiopian life. They are mainly used as an alternative to peas to prepare a flour called shiro, which is used to make shiro wot (a stew used widely in Ethiopian dishes). During the fasting period in the Ethiopian Orthodox Church tradition called Tsome Filliseta, Tsome arbeå, Tsome Tahsas, and Tsome Hawaria (which are in August, end of February, April, mid-November, beginning of January, and June–July), two uncooked spicy vegetable dishes are made using broad beans. The first is hilibet, a thin, white paste of broad bean flour mixed with pieces of onion, green pepper, garlic, and other spices. The second is siljo, a fermented, sour, spicy thin yellow paste of broad bean flour. Both are served with other stews and injera (a pancake-like bread) during lunch and dinner.

Baqella nifro (boiled broad beans) are eaten as a snack during some holidays and during a time of mourning. This tradition goes well into religious holidays, too. On the Thursday before Good Friday (in the Ethiopian Orthodox Church tradition, tselote hamus (the Prayer of Thursday)), people eat a different kind of nifro called gulban. Gulban is made of peeled half-beans collected and well-cooked with other grains such as wheat, peas, and chickpeas.

England

In England, broad beans are usually boiled.[18]

There is a project aimed at increasing broad bean consumption, particularly by use of broad bean flour in bread.[19]

Finland

In Finnish, the word for "fava bean" is (literally "ox bean"). Fava beans are used to make a meat substitute called Härkis.

Greece

The Greek word fáva (φάβα) does not refer to broad beans, but to the yellow split pea and also to another legume, Lathyrus clymenum. Broad beans are known instead as koukiá (Greek, Modern (1453-);: κουκιά), and are eaten in a stew combined with artichokes, while they are still fresh in their pods. Dried broad beans are eaten boiled, sometimes combined with garlic sauce (skordalia).

In Crete, fresh broad beans are shelled and eaten as a companion to tsikoudia, the local alcoholic drink.

Favism is quite common in Greece because of malaria endemicity in previous centuries, and people afflicted by it do not eat broad beans.

India

In India, fava beans are eaten in the Northeastern state of Manipur. They are locally known as hawai-amubi and are ingredients in the dish eromba.

Iran

Broad beans, or "Baghalee" are primarily cultivated in the central and north parts of Iran. The city of Kashan has the highest production of broad beans with high quality in terms of the taste, cooking periods and color. However, broad beans have a very short season (roughly two weeks). The season is usually in the middle of spring. When people have access to fresh beans in season, they cook them in brine and then add vinegar and Heracleum persicum depending on taste. They also make an extra amount to dry to be used year-round. The dried beans can be cooked with rice, which forms one of the most famous dishes in north of Iran (Gilan) called baghalee polo which means "rice with broad beans". In Iran, broad beans are cooked, served with Golpar-origan and salt and sold on streets in the winter. This food is also available preserved in metal cans.

Iraq

Broad beans which are called Bagilla (باگله/باقله) in the Iraqi dialect of Arabic are a common ingredient in many Iraqi foods. One of the most popular Iraqi dishes that uses the broad bean is Bagilla Bil-Dihin also called Tishreeb Bagilla . This dish is a common breakfast dish in Iraq and consists of bread soaked in boiled broad beans’ water then topped with broad beans, melted Ghee, and often also a boiled or fried egg. Fool is another common breakfast dish in Iraq as well as many other Arab countries and consists of mashed fava beans. Another famous Iraqi dish is Timmen Bagilla, which is Arabic for 'broad bean rice'. This classic Iraqi dish consists of rice cooked with broad bean and dill.

Italy

In Sardinia, broad beans are traditionally cooked with lard, often substituted or paired with bacon or minced pork.

In Rome, fava beans are popular either cooked with guanciale or with globe artichokes, as side dish together with lamb or kid, or raw with pecorino romano. Fave e pecorino is the traditional dish for 1 May picnic in Liguria, Tuscany, Marche, Umbria and Latium.

In Sicily, maccu is a Sicilian soup prepared with fava beans as a primary ingredient.[20]

In Apulia, broad bean purée with wild chicory is a typical dish.

Japan

Broad beans, called Soramame (Japanese:) lit: "Sky Bean", are consumed in a variety of ways in Japan. Most commonly, the beans are boiled and are eaten straight or added to rice. It is also consumed as a popular snack called "ikarimame" (Japanese:) lit: "Anchor Bean", where the beans are roasted or fried.[21]

Luxembourg

Judd mat Gaardebounen, or smoked collar of pork with broad beans, is the national dish of Luxembourg.[22]

Malta

They are a primary ingredient of the Maltese kusksu, a vegetable soup primarily containing fava beans and pasta beads. They are also used in an appetizer called bigilla where they are served as a pureé mixed with olive oil, lemon juice, garlic, parsley and mint. It is served with bread or crackers.

Mexico

In Mexico, fava beans are often eaten in a soup called, meaning "fava soup". They are also eaten fried, salted, and dried, as a snack, either by themselves or in combination with other salted, dried beans and nuts.

Morocco

In Morocco, fava beans are cooked, steamed or made into tabiṣart, a dip sold as a street food and commonly eaten in winter.[23]

Nepal

In Nepal, fava beans are called bakulla. They are eaten as a green vegetable when the pods are young, generally stir-fried with garlic. When dried, fava beans are eaten roasted, or mixed with other legumes, such as moong beans, chick peas, and peas, and called qwati. The mixture, soaked and germinated, is cooked as soup and consumed with rice or beaten rice on the occasion of Janai Purnima also known as Rakshya Bandhan, a festival celebrated by the Hindus. The dry and stir-fried version of qwati is called biraula. The qwati soup is believed to reinvigorate the body affected by monsoon paddy season.

Netherlands

In the Netherlands, they are traditionally eaten with fresh savory and some melted butter. The combination of the beans tossed with crispy fried bacon is also common. When rubbed, the velvet insides of the pods are a folk remedy against warts.

Peru

Fava beans (Peruvian Spanish: haba(s)) are eaten fresh or dried toasted, boiled, roasted, stewed or in soup. Habas are one of the essential ingredients of "Pachamanca" in the Andes of Peru, and are also an additive for "Panetela", which is a homemade remedy to keep your child fed and hydrated in cases of diarrhea or stomach infection and even for cholera treatment.

Peruvian dishes with fava beans include:

Portugal

Fava beans are widely cultivated in Portugal and are very popular throughout the country. The most popular dish cooked with favas is "favada", a stew with onion and pork—depending on the region of the country the pork may be chorizo, bacon, pork shoulder, ribs or the mixture of many of these. In Alentejo a lot of coriander will be added in the end. Besides favada, fava beans may be served dry and fried as an appetiser.

Serbia

Broad bean aspic (Serbian:) is a Serbian winter dish in which the pureed cooked beans are combined with crushed garlic and set in a mould, topped with ground paprika in hot oil.

Spain

Broad beans are widely cultivated in Spain. Culinary uses vary among regions, but they can be used as the main pulse in a stew (Habas estofadas, michirones) or as an addition to other dishes (menestra, paella). In certain regions they can be eaten while unripe or fried and packaged as a snack.

Sudan

Fava beans are one of the most widely consumed foods in Sudan. For most Sudanese they form the main dish during breakfast time (fatoor), especially more so for city and urban dwellers. The beans are cooked by steadily boiling over a sustained period of time. Similar to Egypt, the cooked beans are mashed, and prepared by adding salt and pepper. For additional flavour, sesame oil is added along with a sprinkling of jibna ("feta" cheese) on top. The dish is then eaten with bread, sometimes mix all in one dish this called (fatta or boash).

Sweden

Broad beans (Swedish: bondbönor|lit=peasant beans), which in Sweden were traditionally eaten as soaked brown, and boiled, dried broad beans fried in lard, were for a very long time popular to add to other foods as a filling side, specially with fried pork. The green, raw, and lightly boiled broad beans were used seasonally as a side green.

Syria

In Syria, broad beans are prepared in multiple ways for breakfast, lunch or dinner. Ful medames is the same as the Egyptian dish (it is not mashed though) but with the addition of tomato, parsley and onion and with olive oil. Another version of it includes the addition of tahini (sesame paste), olive oil, garlic and lemon. For lunch, broad beans are cooked with a mix of minced and big chunks of meat and is topped on white rice and eaten with cold yogurt and cucumber salad. Bulgur is sometimes used in preparing this recipe instead of rice. Broad beans are cooked with pieces of garlic, meat and meat stock with the addition of lemon juice and cilantro. This dish is called foulieh and is eaten on the side with rice. The same recipe is prepared without meat as a vegan dish eaten on Lent by Christians in Syria.

Turkey

In Turkey, broad beans are called Turkish: bakla. This is also the name of a zeytinyağlı dish made by simmering young and tender broad bean pods with chopped onions in olive oil. It is traditionally garnished with dill and served cool, together with yoghurt. Another dish is Turkish: [[fava (Turkish dish)|fava]], a meze prepared by pureeing beans with olive oil. Broad beans are also cooked with artichoke (Turkish: enginarlı iç bakla), which is another zeytinyağlı dish.

Vietnam

In Southern Vietnam, fava beans are usually stir fried with rice noodles, durians, shrimps, Thai basil, quail eggs and pig intestines in a dry stew called hủ tiếu lòng heo.

Other uses

Research

The first experimental demonstration that the pattern of replication of eukaryotic chromosomes follows the semiconservative DNA replication scheme proposed in 1953 by Watson and Crick[25] was reported in 1957 using V. faba root cells.[26]

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: The Plant List: Vicia faba var. equina Pers. . 2013 . Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew and Missouri Botanic Garden . 24 April 2018.
  2. Web site: Core Historical Literature of Agriculture . Chla.library.cornell.edu . 30 April 2013.
  3. Web site: Daughter of the Soil . Daughter of the Soil . 30 April 2013 . 28 October 2011 . https://web.archive.org/web/20111028022154/http://www.daughterofthesoil.com/crimsonflowered.html . dead .
  4. Doug . Somerville . Honeybees in faba bean pollination . Agnote . DAI-128 . March 2002 . NSW Agriculture . 1034-6848 .
  5. Jayakodi . Murukarthick . Golicz . Agnieszka A. . Kreplak . Jonathan . Fechete . Lavinia I. . Angra . Deepti . Bednář . Petr . Bornhofen . Elesandro . Zhang . Hailin . Boussageon . Raphaël . Kaur . Sukhjiwan . Cheung . Kwok . Čížková . Jana . Gundlach . Heidrun . Hallab . Asis . Imbert . Baptiste . March 2023 . The giant diploid faba genome unlocks variation in a global protein crop . Nature . en . 615 . 7953 . 652–659 . 10.1038/s41586-023-05791-5 . 1476-4687 . 10033403 . 36890232. 2023Natur.615..652J .
  6. Oleg . Kosterin . The lost ancestor of the broad bean (Vicia faba L.) and the origin of plant cultivation in the Near East . Vavilov Journal of Genetics and Breeding . 18 . 4–1 . 831–840 . 2014 . 10.18699/VJ15.118 . free .
  7. Caracuta . Valentina . Weinstein-Evron . Mina . Kaufman . Daniel . Yeshurun . Reuven . Silvent . Jeremie . Boaretto . Elisabetta . 2016 . 14,000-year-old seeds indicate the Levantine origin of the lost progenitor of faba bean . Scientific Reports . 6 . 1 . 10.1038/srep37399 . 2045-2322 . 18 August 2024 . Nature.
  8. Caracuta . Valentina . Barzilai . Omry . Khalaily . Hamudi . Milevski . Ianir . Paz . Yitzhak . Vardi . Jacob . Regev . Lior . Boaretto . Elisabetta . 13 October 2015 . The onset of faba bean farming in the Southern Levant . Scientific Reports . en . 5 . 1 . 14370 . 10.1038/srep14370 . 26458981 . 4602238 . 2015NatSR...514370C . 2045-2322.
  9. Etemadi . Fatemeh . Hashemi . Masoud . Barker . Allen V. . Zandvakili . Omid Reza . Liu . Xiaobing . Agronomy, Nutritional Value, and Medicinal Application of Faba Bean (Vicia faba L.) . . 5 . 4 . 2019 . 2468-0141 . 10.1016/j.hpj.2019.04.004 . 170–182, See p. 172 . free . 2019HorPJ...5..170E .
  10. Book: Saharan . G. S. . Naresh . Mehta . Sclerotinia Diseases of Crop Plants: Biology, Ecology and Disease Management . Springer . . 2008 . 978-1-4020-8407-2 . 288440265 . . . .
  11. Dreher . Kate . Callis . Judy . Ubiquitin, Hormones and Biotic Stress in Plants . . Annals of Botany Company (OUP) . 99 . 5 . 1 May 2007 . 0305-7364 . 10.1093/aob/mcl255 . 787–822. 17220175 . 2802907 .
  12. Web site: . 254. 27 December 2013 . Bad Bug Book (2012). Foodborne Pathogenic Microorganisms and Natural Toxins Handbook: Phytohaemagglutinin.
  13. Web site: Daniel K. Hall-Flavin, M.D.. MAOIs and diet: Is it necessary to restrict tyramine?. Mayo Clinic.
  14. Angela . Felker . Monoamine Oxidase Inhibitors: A Modern Guide to an Unrequited Class of Antidepressants . CNS Spectrums . 13 . 10. 855–870 . 2008 . 18955941 . 10.1017/S1092852900016965 . 6118722 .
  15. Jennifer E. Frank . Diagnosis and management of G6PD deficiency . . 72 . 7 . 1277–82 . October 2005 . 16225031 .
  16. Khazaei. H. others. Eliminating vicine and convicine, the main anti-nutritional factors restricting faba bean usage. Trends in Food Science and Technology. 91. 549–556. 1 September 2019 . 0924-2244 . 10.1016/j.tifs.2019.07.051 . free.
  17. Sharan. S.. Zanghelini. G.. Zotzel. J.. Bonerz. D.. Aschoff. J.. Saint-Eve. A.. Maillard. M-N.. Fava bean (Vicia faba L.) for food applications: From seed to ingredient processing and its effect on functional properties, antinutritional factors, flavor, and color. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety. 2020 . 20. 1. 401–428. 10.1111/1541-4337.12687. 33331050. 229300206.
  18. Web site: Rose . Fooks . How to cook broad beans . 3 July 2020 . GoodtoKnow .
  19. Web site: Rachel . Hall . Beans in toast: UK should switch to broad bean bread, say researchers . 18 January 2023 . The Guardian.
  20. Book: Helstosky, Carol . Food Culture in the Mediterranean . Greenwood . 2009 . 7 . 978-0313346262.
  21. Itoh, Makiko, "Springtime beans aim for the sky", The Japan Times
  22. http://www.luxembourg.co.uk/recipes.html#Smoked Collar "Recipes from Luxembourg"
  23. Web site: Morocco's best street food. cnn.com. 10 May 2013 .
  24. Book: C. . Macris . G. . Cornelli . R. . McKirahan . On Pythagoreanism . De Gruyter . 2013 . 9783110318500 . 160 .
  25. WATSON JD, CRICK FH. The structure of DNA. Cold Spring Harb Symp Quant Biol. 1953;18:123-31. doi: 10.1101/sqb.1953.018.01.020. PMID 13168976
  26. Taylor JH, Woods PS, Hughes WL. THE ORGANIZATION AND DUPLICATION OF CHROMOSOMES AS REVEALED BY AUTORADIOGRAPHIC STUDIES USING TRITIUM-LABELED THYMIDINE. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1957 Jan 15;43(1):122-8. doi: 10.1073/pnas.43.1.122. PMID 16589984; PMCID: PMC528395