Existential generalization explained

Existential generalization
Type:Rule of inference
Field:Predicate logic
Statement:There exists a member

x

in a universal set with a property of

Q

Symbolic Statement:

Q(a)\to\exists{x}Q(x),

In predicate logic, existential generalization[1] [2] (also known as existential introduction, ∃I) is a valid rule of inference that allows one to move from a specific statement, or one instance, to a quantified generalized statement, or existential proposition. In first-order logic, it is often used as a rule for the existential quantifier (

\exists

) in formal proofs.

Example: "Rover loves to wag his tail. Therefore, something loves to wag its tail."

Example: "Alice made herself a cup of tea. Therefore, Alice made someone a cup of tea."

Example: "Alice made herself a cup of tea. Therefore, someone made someone a cup of tea."

In the Fitch-style calculus:

Q(a)\to\exists{x}Q(x),

where

Q(a)

is obtained from

Q(x)

by replacing all its free occurrences of

x

(or some of them) by

a

.[3]

Quine

According to Willard Van Orman Quine, universal instantiation and existential generalization are two aspects of a single principle, for instead of saying that

\forallxx=x

implies

Socrates=Socrates

, we could as well say that the denial

Socrates\neSocrates

implies

\existsxx\nex

. The principle embodied in these two operations is the link between quantifications and the singular statements that are related to them as instances. Yet it is a principle only by courtesy. It holds only in the case where a term names and, furthermore, occurs referentially.[4]

See also

Notes and References

  1. Book: Copi . Irving M. . Cohen . Carl . Introduction to Logic . Prentice Hall . 2005.
  2. Book: Hurley, Patrick . A Concise Introduction to Logic 4th edition . registration . 1991 . Wadsworth Publishing . 9780534145156 .
  3. pg. 347. Jon Barwise and John Etchemendy, Language proof and logic Second Ed., CSLI Publications, 2008.
  4. Book: Willard Van Orman Quine . Willard Van Orman Quine. Roger F. Gibson . Quintessence . V.24. Reference and Modality . Cambridge, Massachusetts . Belknap Press of Harvard University Press . 2008 . 728954096. Here: p.366.