End of the British Mandate for Palestine explained

Short Title:Palestine Act 1948
Type:Act
Parliament:Parliament of the United Kingdom
Long Title:An Act to make provision with respect to the termination of His Majesty's jurisdiction in Palestine, and for purposes connected therewith.
Year:1948
Citation:11 & 12 Geo. 6. c. 27
Royal Assent:29 April 1948
Collapsed:yes

The end of the British Mandate for Palestine was formally made by way of the (11 & 12 Geo. 6. c. 27) of 29 April.[1] A public statement prepared by the Colonial and Foreign Office confirmed termination of British responsibility for the administration of Palestine from midnight on 14 May 1948.[2] [3]

Background

Mandatory Palestine was created at the end of the First World War out of the dissolution of the Ottoman Empire. In 1920 Britain was awarded the mandate for Palestine by the League of Nations, to administer until such time as the territory was "able to stand alone".[4] The White Paper of 1939 provided for the establishment of an independent Palestinian state within 10 years.[5] As explained by Malcolm MacDonald to the 1939 meeting of the Permanent Mandates Commission it was not clear at that stage what form such a state would take.[6]

The February 1945 Yalta Conference agreed that arrangements would be made to provide for United Nations trusteeships for existing League Mandates.[7]

In July 1945, the Harrison Report was published,[8] describing the conditions of the displaced persons camps in post-World War II Europe.

In October 1945, then Foreign Secretary Bevin told the cabinet that Britain intended to turn over the Palestine problem to the UN except that Britain would be accused of evading its responsibilities if it did not first make some efforts of its own in resolving the situation.[9]

The League of Nations at its last meeting on 18 April 1946 agreed to liquidate and transfer all of its assets to the UN.[10] The assembly also passed a resolution approving and welcoming the intention of the British government to grant independence to Transjordan.[11] [12]

The report of the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry was published 20 April 1946.[13]

That part of the mandate in respect of Transjordan legally ended on 17 June 1946 with the ratification of the Treaty of London.[14]

In July 1946, a committee created to establish how the Anglo-American proposals would be implemented proposed the Morrison–Grady Plan.

Following the failure of the 1946–1947 London Conference on Palestine, at which the United States refused to support the British leading to both the Morrison–Grady Plan and the Bevin Plan being rejected by all parties, the British decided to refer the question to the UN on 14 February 1947.[15]

The United Nations Special Committee on Palestine (UNSCOP) was created on 15 May 1947, reported on 3 September 1947 and on 29 November 1947, the United Nations Partition Plan for Palestine was passed. It recommended that the Mandate terminate as soon as possible and not later than 1 August 1948.

Two weeks later, on 11 December, Colonial Secretary Arthur Creech Jones announced that the British Mandate would terminate on 15 May 1948.[16]

UN

The British requested that the Palestine question be placed on the agenda of the Second Regular Session of the General Assembly and that a Special Session be convened to constitute a Special Committee to prepare for Assembly consideration of the subject. The First Special Session of the General Assembly met between 28 April and 15 May 1947 to consider the British request. An attempt by the five Arab members of the UN (Egypt, Iraq, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia and Syria) to add an item to the agenda addressing the "termination of the Mandate over Palestine and the declaration of its independence" was unsuccessful.[17]

Following the publication of the UNSCOP report, the Ad Hoc Committee on the Palestinian Question was formed by a vote of the Second Regular Session of the General Assembly on 23 September 1947.

Palestine

See also: 1948 Palestine war. Regulations governing land transfers and clauses relating to immigration were implemented although by 1944, 24,000 of 75,000 immigration certificates still remained for use. The immigration limits were relaxed to allow immigration at the rate of 18,000 a year as a reaction to the situation of Jewish refugees in Europe.[18]

With the end of the war, the new Labour Government, led by Clement Attlee, with Ernest Bevin as Foreign Secretary, decided to maintain the White Paper policy.

Immediately after the UN resolution, the 1947–1948 civil war in Mandatory Palestine broke out between the Arab and Jewish communities. On the last day of the Mandate, the creation of the State of Israel was proclaimed, and the 1948 Arab–Israeli War began. In March 1948, the British Cabinet had agreed that the civil and military authorities in Palestine should make no effort to oppose the setting up of a Jewish State or a move into Palestine from Transjordan.[19]

Sir Henry Gurney served as Chief Secretary in Palestine from October 1946 to termination and wrote a diary covering the period.[20] A review by historian Rory Miller speaks approvingly of editor Golani's decision to include detailed scholarly annotations and perspectives to the diary.[21]

Arab response

On 22 March 1945, the Arab League was founded. The Arab Higher Committee (AHC) was reconstituted in November 1945 to represent Palestinian Arabs [22] and met at the beginning of May 1946 to consider their response to the publication of the Anglo American report.[23] The Arab states reacted with summit meetings at Inshas at the end of May and Bloudan in June.[24] After the failure of the London Conference and UN referral the Arabs continued to press their demand for an immediate independent Arab Palestine.[25]

Jordan

Abdullah had connections with Zionists and Palestine over many years, according to an account given by historian Mary Wilson.[26] Historians have described a meeting between Abdullah and the Jewish Agency on 17 November 1947 during which Abdullah is alleged to have reached an understanding in regard to Abdullah's intent to occupy the Arab territories of the partition plan.[27] [28] [29] Following the end of the mandate, the Jordanian Arab Legion, under the leadership of Sir John Bagot Glubb, known as Glubb Pasha, was ordered to enter Palestine and secure the UN designated Arab area.[30]

Zionist response

In May 1942, the Biltmore Conference in New York City with 600 delegates and Zionist leaders from 18 countries attending, demands "that Palestine be established as a Jewish Commonwealth" (state), rather than a "homeland".[31]

American response

At the end of August 1945, U.S. President Harry Truman issued a statement requesting the British government to admit 100,000 Jewish refugees in Europe into Palestine.[32] On 14 May 1948, the United States de facto recognized the provisional Jewish government contemporaneously declared (de jure recognition on 31 January 1949).

Legal issues and reasons to terminate

Law professor Shabtai Rosenne says that there is no clear answer as to why the British took this step and lists miscalculation as well as political and military fatigue among others.[33] Ravndal cites works from the 1980s establishing that the British were motivated by "economic necessity and plain exhaustion" but then goes on to posit that the British were motivated by a Cold War desire to secure Britain's interests in the rest of the Middle East.A summary of different views is given by Benny Morris.

Mandates were intended to end with the independence of the Mandated territory. The British government had taken the position that there was nothing in law to prevent termination due to frustration of purpose.[34] In the event, the UNSCOP report recommended both that the Mandate be terminated and independence granted at the earliest practicable dates with a transition period between these events.

Notes and References

  1. Book: Bloomsbury Publishing. Whitaker's Britain. 26 September 2013. A&C Black. 978-1-4729-0380-8. 127–.
  2. Web site: British Government statement on the end of the Palestine Mandate. Fincham. David Gerald . 19 June 2015. 23 October 2018.
  3. Web site: Palestine Termination of the Mandate 15th May 1948. HMSO. 15 May 1948. 23 October 2018.
  4. http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/leagcov.asp#art22 Article 22, The Covenant of the League of Nations
  5. Cohen . Michael J. . Appeasement in the Middle East: the British White Paper on Palestine . The Historical Journal . 16 . 3 . 2009 . 571–596 . 0018-246X . 10.1017/S0018246X00002958. 159561563 .
  6. Web site: "Minutes of the Thirty-Sixth Session Held at Geneva from June 8th to 29th, 1939".
  7. Book: Bain, William . Between Anarchy and Society: Trusteeship and the Obligations of Power. 14 August 2003. OUP Oxford. 978-0-19-926026-3. 121–.
  8. Penkower, Monty Noam. "The Earl Harrison Report: Its Genesis and Its Significance". American Jewish Archives Journal, 68, no.1 (2016): 1–75
  9. Miriam Joyce. Haron. The British Decision to Give the Palestine Question to the United Nations. Middle Eastern Studies. 17. 2. 241–248. 1981. 4282830. 10.1080/00263208108700469.
  10. Web site: League of Nations Timeline. worldatwar.net.
  11. Web site: The British Embassy to the Department of State Aide-Mémoire dated 10th June, 1946 . 29 October 2018.
  12. https://books.google.com/books?id=FU2PAAAAMAAJ&q=termination+mandated+status+Transjordan Mandates, dependencies and trusteeship
  13. Book: Stone, Dan. The Liberation of the Camps: The End of the Holocaust and Its Aftermath. 5 May 2015. Yale University Press. 978-0-300-21603-5. In order to try and mitigate these fears and to alleviate some of the ill-will that was disrupting US– UK relations in the wake of the Harrison Report, in November 1945 the British government set up the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry on Palestine (AACI) to investigate Harrison's claims..
  14. Web site: Archived copy . 25 October 2018 . https://web.archive.org/web/20181004033332/http://treaties.fco.gov.uk/docs/pdf/1946/TS0032.pdf . 4 October 2018 . dead .
  15. Ravndal. Ellen Jenny. Exit Britain: British Withdrawal From the Palestine Mandate in the Early Cold War, 1947–1948. Diplomacy & Statecraft. 21. 3. 2010. 416–433. 0959-2296. 10.1080/09592296.2010.508409. 153662650.
  16. Book: Jones, Martin. Failure in Palestine: British and United States Policy After the Second World War. 6 October 2016. Bloomsbury Academic. 978-1-4742-9127-9.
  17. Book: Miguel Marín Bosch. Votes in the UN General Assembly. 2 March 1998. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers. 978-90-411-0564-6. 46–.
  18. Study (30 June 1978): The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem Part I: 1917-1947 - Study (30 June 1978), accessdate: 10 November 2018
  19. CAB/128/12 formerly C.M.(48) 24 conclusions 22 March 1948
  20. Book: Gurney, Sir Henry. Motti Golani . The End of the British Mandate for Palestine, 1948 The Diary of Sir Henry Gurney. Palgrave Macmillan. 2009. 9780230244733 .
  21. Miller. Rory. The End of the British Mandate for Palestine, 1948: The Diary of Sir Henry Gurney. Middle Eastern Studies. 47. 1. 2011. 211–213. 0026-3206. 10.1080/00263206.2011.540186. 147695956.
  22. Book: Morris, Benny. 1948: a history of the first Arab-Israeli war. Benny Morris. Yale University Press. 2008. 978-0-300-12696-9. 27 .
  23. H. Levenberg, "Bevin's Disillusionment: The London Conference, Autumn 1946", Middle Eastern Studies. p. 617 Vol. 27, No. 4 (October 1991)
  24. Book: Rubin, Barry. The Arab States and the Palestine Conflict. Syracuse University Press. 1981. 154. 978-0815622536.
  25. Arab Unity of Action and the Palestine Question, 1945-48. Middle Eastern Studies. 22. 3. 1986. 338–340. 4283126. Mayer. Thomas. 10.1080/00263208608700669.
  26. Book: Mary Christina Wilson. King Abdullah, Britain and the Making of Jordan. 28 June 1990. Cambridge University Press. 978-0-521-39987-6. 103–128.
  27. Book: Graham Jevon. Glubb Pasha and the Arab Legion: Britain, Jordan and the End of Empire in the Middle East. 27 April 2017. Cambridge University Press. 978-1-316-83396-4. 64–65.
  28. Karsh, Efraim The Arab-Israeli Conflict, London: Osprey, 2002 p. 51.
  29. Book: Avi., Shlaim. Collusion across the Jordan : King Abdullah, the Zionist movement, and the partition of Palestine. 1 January 1988. Columbia University Press. 9780231068383. 876002691.
  30. Sir John Bagot Glubb, A Soldier with the Arabs, London 1957, p. 200
  31. Book: Carole S. Kessner. Marie Syrkin: Values Beyond the Self. 2008. UPNE. 978-1-58465-451-3. 346–.
  32. Web site: STATEMENT ON PALESTINE BY PRESIDENT TRUMAN. New York Times. 13 November 1945.
  33. Book: Shabtai Rosenne. An International Law Miscellany. 1 January 1993. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers. 978-0-7923-1742-5. 636.
  34. Termination of the British Mandate for Palestine. The International Law Quarterly. 2. 1. 57–60. 1948. 763114.