Education in Taiwan explained

Country Name:Taiwan
Agency:Ministry of Education
Leader Titles:Minister
Leader Names:Pan Wen-chung
Budget:NT$ 608.6 billion (US$ 20 billion)
Budget Year:2003
Primary Languages:Mandarin, some courses and programs are in Taiwanese, Hakka, Formosan languages or English
System Type:National
Established Events:12-year National Education
Established Dates:September 2019
Literacy Year:2017
Literacy Total:98.87%[1]
Literacy Men:99.73%
Literacy Women:97.69%
Enrollment Year:5,384,9261
Enroll Total:2,153,7172
Enroll Primary:1,676,970
Enroll Secondary:1,270,1943
Enroll Post-Secondary: -
Footnotes:1Ministry of Education website
2Includes Kindergarten
3Includes junior colleges

The educational system in Taiwan is the responsibility of the Ministry of Education. The system produces pupils with some of the highest test scores in the world, especially in mathematics and science.[2] [3] Former president Ma Ying-jeou announced in January 2011 that the government would begin the phased implementation of a twelve-year compulsory education program by 2014.[4]

In 2015, Taiwanese students achieved one of the world's best results in mathematics, science and literacy, as tested by the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), a worldwide evaluation of 15-year-old school pupils' scholastic performance. Taiwan is one of the top-performing OECD countries in reading literacy, mathematics and sciences with the average student scoring 523.7, compared with the OECD average of 493, placing it seventh in the world and has one of the world's most highly educated labor forces among OECD countries.[5] [6] [7] Although current law mandates only nine years of schooling, 95 percent junior high school students go on to a senior vocational high school, trade school, junior college, or university.[8] [9]

In Taiwan, adhering to the Confucian paradigm for education where parents believe that receiving a good education is a very high priority for Taiwanese families and an important goal in their children's life.[10] Many parents in Taiwan believe that effort and persistence matters more than innate ability if their children want to receive better grades in school.[11] [12] These beliefs are shared by the teachers and guidance counselors and the schools as they regularly keep the parents abreast on their child's overall academic performance in the school. Many parents have high expectations for their children, emphasize academic achievement and actively intervene in their children's academic progress by making sure that their children receive top grades and would go on to great sacrifices including borrowing money to put their child through university.

Due to its role in promoting Taiwan's economic development, high test results, and high university entrance rate, Taiwan's education system has been praised. 45 percent of Taiwanese aged 25 to 64 hold a bachelor's degree or higher.[13] [14] Furthermore, the education system has been criticized for its overemphasis on rote memorization and excessive academic pressure it places on students. Students in Taiwan are faced with immense pressure to succeed academically from their parents, teachers, peers, and society in order to secure prestigious white collar job positions while eschewing vocational education, critical thinking, and creativity. With a narrow bandwidth of prestigious job positions and a far greater number of university graduates seeking them, many have been employed in lesser positions with salaries far below their expectations.[15] Taiwan's universities have also been criticized for not keeping up with the technological trends and employment demands in its fast moving job market referring to a skills mismatch cited by a number of self assessed and overeducated university graduates.[16] In addition, the Taiwanese government has been criticized for undermining the economy as it has been unable to create enough jobs to support the demands of the numerous unemployed university graduates.[17] [18]

History

See main article: History of education in Taiwan.

The Dutch East India Company, the Ming Chinese loyalists under Koxinga, Qing China, and the Japanese all implemented education systems on Taiwan.[19] Christianity was taught under Dutch rule.[20] Taiwan also had many academies, such as Daodong Academy, Fongyi Academy, Huangxi Academy, Jhen Wen Academy, Mingxin Academy and Pingtung Academy.

In 1944–1945, the Republic of China under the Chinese Nationalist Party led by Chiang Kai-shek took control of the island; the existing private school infrastructure was curtailed over suspicions of its political loyalty. After the retreat of the ROC to Taiwan in 1949, they sought to use public schools to assimilate the Taiwanese population; private schools, seen as an obstacle to this process, were suppressed. By 1954, however, the party yielded to calls for education reform, and began to revitalize and expand private schooling. The Nationalists used a number of measures (such as filling school boards with loyalists and careful control of state funding) to ensure that private schooling remained under state influence.[21]

Public education

The public education system in Taiwan spans nursery schools through university. Public education has been compulsory from primary school through junior high school since 1968. In 2001 roughly 16% of the central budget was spent on education. In January 2011, President Ma announced plans to implement a full twelve-year compulsory education program by 2014. In addition, financial support for preschool education would begin, starting with fee waivers.

Access to high school and university is controlled by a series of national exams. Discipline in public schools of all levels is generally very tight with school uniforms and morning reveille being the norm. Students of all levels through high school are responsible for cleaning their own classrooms and areas around the school, cleanup time being a daily ritual. Corporal punishment is officially banned, but many reports suggest it is still practiced by many teachers, due in no small part to the fact that most parents support it.

The school year consists of two semesters. The fall semester begins in early September and runs till late January or early February. Winter vacation typically runs from three to four weeks around the Lunar New Year. Spring semester begins following the Lantern Festival in mid February and ends in late June. From middle school on, many schools hold "optional supplementary classes" during winter and summer vacation as well as after normal school hours. Despite the name, in many cases participation is compulsory. The language of instruction is Mandarin.

School grades

The school year is divided into two semesters. The first begins in the beginning of September and ends in January; the second begins in mid February and ends in late June.

LevelGradeAge by September 1Notes
Kindergartennone3–6Preschool education
Regulated by the Early Childhood Education and Care Act
Elementary school1st6National education, compulsory education
Regulated by the Primary and Junior High School Act
2nd7
3rd8
4th9
5th10
6th11
Junior high school7th12
8th13
9th14
Senior high schoolSenior High 1st (10th)15National education since 2019
Regulated by the Senior High School Education Act
Senior High 2nd (11th)16
Senior High 3rd (12th)17

The tertiary education and postgraduate education in Taiwan have different tracks and their years and grades varies.

LevelTypical lengthDegreeNotes
Junior college5 years after junior high school
2 years after senior high school
Associate degreeRegulated by the Junior College Act
University (Undergraduate)4–7 years after senior high school
2 years after junior college
Bachelor's degreeRegulated by the University Act
University (Postgraduate)1–4 years after bachelor's degreeMaster's degree
2–7 years after master's degreeDoctor's degree

In addition, special education, adult education, and continuing education also exist in Taiwan following similar systems mentioned above.

School grades

The school year is divided into two semesters. The first begins in the beginning of September and ends in January; the second begins in mid February and ends in late June.

LevelGradeAge by September 1Notes
Kindergartennone3–6Preschool education
Regulated by the Early Childhood Education and Care Act
Elementary school1st6–7National education, compulsory education
Regulated by the Primary and Junior High School Act
2nd7–8
3rd8–9
4th9–10
5th10–11
6th11–12
Junior high school7th12–13
8th13–14
9th14–15
Senior high schoolSenior High 1st (10th)15–16National education since 2019
Regulated by the Senior High School Education Act
Senior High 2nd (11th)16–17
Senior High 3rd (12th)17–18

The tertiary education and postgraduate education in Taiwan have different tracks and their years and grades varies.

LevelTypical lengthDegreeNotes
Junior college5 years after junior high school
2 years after senior high school
Associate degreeRegulated by the Junior College Act
University (Undergraduate)4–7 years after senior high school
2 years after junior college
Bachelor's degreeRegulated by the University Act
University (Postgraduate)1–4 years after bachelor's degreeMaster's degree
2–7 years after master's degreeDoctor's degree

National Education

The current national basic education in Taiwan is 12 years education. The implementation of this compulsory education replaces the old 9 years education.[22]

The 12 years education policy was originally proposed in 1983, but was delayed for financial reasons.

Elementary school

Elementary schools span grades 1 through 6, classes are held from Monday through Friday, typically from 7:30 AM through 4 PM (or noon on Wednesdays). Subjects include:

Like junior high schools, students are typically assigned to the elementary school closest to their registered place of residence. This leads some parents to file their children's household registration with other relatives or friends for the purpose of sending their children to what are perceived as better schools.

Junior high school

See main article: Secondary education in Taiwan. Junior high school spans grades 7 through 9 and is the last half of compulsory education. Junior high students typically focus on preparing for the national senior high school entrance exams at the end of 9th grade. School ends around 5PM, but students often stay in school later for quizzes and additional exam preparations.

Subject matter covered includes:

At the end of their third year, students participate in the national senior high school entrance exams and are assigned to senior high schools based upon their scores. Students may also participate in a separate national vocational school entrance exam if they wish to attend vocational school. In both cases, public schools are usually the most popular while private schools have traditionally been viewed as a backup for those unable to score high enough for public schools.

Roughly 94.7% of junior high school students continue on to senior high or vocational school.

Regular senior high school

Senior high school spans grades 10 through 12, again the main goal of students is to score highly on the national university entrance exams at the end of their third year. The pace is just as, if not more intense than junior high school.

Discipline in educational institutions from high school and up (including vocational schools) is the responsibility of military officers stationed at the individual schools (as opposed to elementary and junior high school where teachers and school administrators were responsible for discipline). In addition to the normal subjects, students are also required to attend a military education class covering issues such as civil defense, military drills, national defense, and basic firearms. In the past, high (and vocational) school students were expected to take on civil defense duties in the event of national emergency. Boys and girls were trained to use firearms and hurl grenades.

In many high schools incoming students may select science or liberal arts tracks depending on where their interests lie. The different learning tracks are commonly referred to as groups. Group I consists of liberal arts students, Group II and Group III of science based students (the latter studies biology as an additional subject). Science based curriculum consists of more rigorous science and mathematics classes intended to prepare the student for a career in the sciences and engineering; the liberal arts track places a heavier emphasis on literature and social studies to prepare students for a future in those fields. Often, students in Group I are exempted to study science even if they wish to, and students in Group II are not required to take geography, civics and history.

Entrance to university is administered via two methods: by recommendations or by taking the national university entrance examination. For those that participate in recommendations, they have to take a national academic exam and select a list of majors that they are applying to. The first stage is a screening of exam results for eligibility and the second stage would be dependent on the conditions of individual departments selected. For those that did not choose to take the recommendations process, or have failed their applications, they have the choice to participate in the national university entrance exams after graduation in hopes of university admission. Students who graduate from a senior high school usually end up taking up the national university entrance examination to enter a general four year university. They can also apply to junior colleges, an institute of technology, or a university of science and technology as an alternative choice.[23]

Skill-based senior high school

In June 2016, "vocational high schools" were renamed as skill-based senior high schools. Vocational training and related career choices are introduced through course electives in lower secondary school.[24] Skill-based senior high schools are three-year institutions that are similar to regular senior high schools. Unlike regular senior high schools, they place a heavier emphasis on practical and vocational skills.[25] These schools offer a variety of programs that cater to the needs of students with different abilities and skills. Skill-based senior high schools offer programs that are organized into six different categories: agriculture, industry, business, marine products, everyday life sphere, and art.[26] Graduates of senior skill-based senior high schools can choose to enter the workforce, start their own business, or go on to higher education. Senior skill-based senior high school graduates can apply to junior colleges, institutes of technology, and universities of science and technology. They can also take the national university entrance exams to enter general four-year universities.[27]

Higher education

University

University entrance is the traditional route taken by Taiwanese students to enter the gateway of higher education as it is by far the most prestigious form of higher education in Taiwan. Since 2008, the percentage of high school graduates entering university has exceeded 95 percent.[28] [29] [30] [31] The Taiwanese higher education system is similar to the American higher education system. Since the 1990s many trade schools and junior colleges have been "promoted" to university status as results of a series of educational reform, which can account for the Taiwan's high university entrance rate.[28] Even though a high score is desired as an admission criterion to the nations most esteemed and prestigious institutions, as consequences of such reforms, the job market is flooded with unemployed university graduates.[32] [33] [18]

Overview

Scholars distributions in the north by 2015.[34] [35]
University Number of scholars
National Taiwan University 2066
National Taiwan Normal University 894
National Chengchi University 744
Fu Jen Catholic University728
National Central University 663
National Chiao Tung University 735
National Tsing Hua University 838
National Yang-Ming University 402
Sum 6342

Taiwan has many universities, both public and private. Tuition is less expensive in public universities than in private universities, like in most western countries. Many public universities receive financial support from the government. There are currently five University alliances in Taiwan, intentionally modeled after other educational systems such as the University of California system. NTNU is the internationally top-ranked university for linguistics especially for foreigners interested in learning (advanced) Mandarin,[36] as well as other institutes for serious Mandarin learning opportunities for foreigners.[37]

Nowadays some private schools are supported by commercial groups or religious bodies (such as Fu Jen Catholic University, Tzu Chi University).

Engineering is popular, and engineering degrees account for over a quarter of the bachelor's degrees awarded in Taiwan. It is also related to future employment opportunities because of the government policy focusing on high-tech manufacturing industries. See also: Engineering education in Taiwan

Public

Some of the highly regarded public universities in Taiwan include: (Research = Designated National Research University[38])

Research, formerly Taihoku Imperial University, Taiwan's representative public university, founded in Japanese era. Distinguished programs in all fields. AACSB accredited.

Well known for programs in agriculture and biology.

Research, Best known for engineering, medicine, science programs. One of only two higher ranking universities in Taiwan that offer aerospace engineering program. There is a possible bright future with private spaceflight working for privately owned non-governmental spaceflight companies or later on at NSPO.

Research, Distinguished programs in oceanography, computer science, optoelectronics, nanotechnology, political science, sociology and business management programs. AACSB accredited.

Best known for engineering, physical science, social science, education, sustainability management, indigenous studies, business management, creative writing, and TCSL program.

Private

There are also a few representative private universities:

In contrast with junior high and high school, where students are pressured by the highly selective entrance exams, college life in Taiwan is generally seen as being rather relaxed. Graduate degrees from the U.S. and Europe are also highly prized with many students applying to foreign graduate schools after completing university (though the number has declined somewhat in recent years). An average of 13,000 university graduates per year choose to pursue graduate studies in the U.S.

Founded by Japanese government (1895–1945)

YearSchool nameOriginal name
1911National Chung Hsing UniversityAdvanced Academy of Agronomy and Forestry
1922National Taiwan Normal UniversityTaihoku College
1928National Taiwan UniversityTaihoku Imperial University
1931National Cheng Kung UniversityTainan Technical College

Similarities with universities in China

Many universities in Taiwan were originally established in Republic of China before the retreat of the ROC government from Mainland to Taiwan after the Chinese Civil War. Some of the universities who were originally established in the Mainland were reestablished in Taiwan. To avoid ambiguity, the ROC government generally added the National word in front of those universities in Taiwan to differentiate them with the ones in China.

YearUniversities in TaiwanYearUniversities in China
1951Soochow University1900Soochow University
1956National Tsing Hua University1911Tsinghua University
1958National Chiao Tung University1896Shanghai Jiao Tong University
1961Fu Jen Catholic University1925Catholic University of Peking
1980National Sun Yat-sen University1924Sun Yat-sen University
1995National Chi Nan University1906Jinan University

Teaching Excellence Universities Award

The Ministry of Education in Taiwan started the Teaching Excellence Universities Award in 2006. Since the beginning of this award, only six universities have earned this honor every year.

Medical school

Medical school in Taiwan begins as an undergraduate major and lasts six years (six years for dentistry), with the final two years being hands on training at a teaching hospital. Graduates of medical school may elect to continue on to graduate school to pursue a doctoral degree.

Law school (College of Law)

There are no law schools in the sense of US law schools. Many universities have college of law or department of law, provide legal education as an undergraduate major and lasts for four years.

Teacher training

Most higher educational institutions offering programs in education. Such programs run four years, in addition to a half-year internship, with students receiving teaching credentials at the end of the program. They also have to take extra test for being a teacher in public school. While currently education programs are available in most institutes of tertiary education, prospective teachers typically go to a "university of education" if they want to teach primary school, and a "normal university" for secondary school. One exception is National Changhua University of Education, which, like normal universities, is renowned for its dedication to cultivating secondary school teachers.

Teachers' In-service Advancement Education Information & Resources

With the implementation of reformation of education policy in Taiwan, in order to integrate the resources of teachers' in-service advancement education and to encourage teachers to participate in the in-service advancement education activities positively, the Ministry of Education established 12 regional teacher's in-service advancement education centers in 2003. The National Kaohsiung Normal University (NKNU) was chosen as the general coordinator and was responsible for setting up, managing the Nationwide Teacher In-Service Education Information Web.

The Nationwide Teacher In-Service Education Information Web provides teachers with a communication platform for in-service teacher advancement education in Taiwan. That is to encourage teachers to have a continuous growth in teaching. The information of advancement activities and teachers’ participation records are shown by digital platform.

This network provides activities and individual's learning records for K–12 teachers. This database-technology platform is in an electronic format to record teacher's training progress and learning time. It establishes a regulating mechanism to integrate educational and administrative resources from education institutions and local authorized educational authorities respectively. That is for fulfilling the ideals of educational reform in an effective way.

The purposes of Nationwide Teacher In-service Advancement Education Information Web are as follows:

Graduate school

Each college in each university usually has their own graduate schools. In addition, the Taiwan International Graduate Program affiliated to Academia Sinica, the national academy of Taiwan, offers an English-language program in life sciences and physical sciences for both Taiwanese and international students.

Doctoral programs in Taiwan last two to seven years; most are four years.

International programs

International programs in Taiwan include bachelor's, master's and PhD degree programs targeted at students from abroad.

Vocational

Vocational education in Taiwan is offered at junior colleges, institutes of technology, and at universities of science and technology where they can earn associate degrees to doctoral degrees. There are currently 87 institutions in Taiwan that offer vocational training.[39] The Ministry of Education has been promoting vocational education and trying to persuade young Taiwanese to consider vocational schools as an alternative route to attending university.[24]

Junior colleges

Junior colleges can be classified into five-year junior colleges and two-year junior colleges according to entry requirement. Since 2004, they offer associate degrees under Article 29 of the Junior College Law.[40] Various subjects that are covered by junior colleges include marine resources, medicine, languages, home economics, and tourism and hospitality.

Five-year junior colleges

Students enter five-year junior colleges after graduating junior high school and passing a national exam. The curriculum is similar to that of vocational schools with the exception that five-year junior colleges run for two additional years. Students are required to complete 220 credit hours in these programs. Upon graduation, students are awarded an associate degree.

Two-year junior colleges

Two-year junior colleges offer advanced vocational training for graduates of vocational or senior high schools. Two-year junior college programs are attended by vocational senior high school graduates or graduates of a university of science and technology. They also accept students who have completed a vocational program during high school. Upon graduation, students are awarded an associate degree.[41] Graduates of two-year junior colleges can choose to enter the workforce, start their own business, pursue additional studies at a two-year institute of technology program in a department of their choice or choose to pursue additional education at a four-year university.[42]

Institutes of Technology and Universities of Science and Technology

Under the University Act, institutes of technology and universities of science and technology offer associate's, bachelor's, master's, and doctoral degree programs. Both institutes of technology and universities of science and technology admit students who have graduated from a junior college or those holding a similar academic qualification and have undertaken an entrance exam. Two-year and four-year bachelor programs at institutes of technology and universities of science and technology. A bachelor's degree is awarded to a student who has completed 128 credit hours after graduating from a four bachelor's degree program. Two-year bachelor's degree programs are for students who already hold an associate degree and have completed 80 credit hours. Master's degrees require an additional 24 credits while PhD students have to complete an additional 18 credits along with a dissertation.

Private education

Private educational institutions are pervasive in Taiwan ranging from private schools at all levels to supplementary cram schools or buxiban.

Cram schools

See main article: Cram school. With the intense pressure placed on students to achieve by parents, many students enroll in private after-school classes intended to supplement their regular education. These cram schools are an extremely large (and profitable) business in Taiwan and have been criticized by some as being the result of cultural overemphasis on academic achievement.[43] Popular subjects in cram schools include English, mathematics, and physics. Cram schools are mostly popular amongst junior and senior high school students.

Classes are generally very orderly and controlled, with class sizes as high as 200 or so students in some well-known institutions. The quality of cram schools varies considerably. Some of the larger schools and chains write their own programs and produce their own textbooks.[44]

Kindergartens and preschool

While many public kindergartens and preschools exist in Taiwan, private kindergartens and preschools are also quite popular. Many private preschools offer accelerated courses in various subjects. Curriculum at such preschools often encompasses subject material such as science, art, physical education and even mathematics classes. The majority of these schools are part of large school chains, which operate under franchise arrangements. In return for annual fees, the chain enterprises may supply advertising, curriculum, books, materials, training, and even staff for each individual school.

There has been a huge growth in the number of privately owned and operated English immersion preschools in Taiwan since 1999. These English immersion preschools generally employ native English speaking teachers to teach the whole preschool curriculum in an ‘English only’ environment. The legality of these types of schools has been called into question on many occasions, yet they continue to prosper. Some members of Taiwanese society have raised concerns as to whether local children should be placed in English immersion environments at such a young age, and have raised fears that the students abilities in their mother language may suffer as a result. The debate continues, but at the present time, the market for English Immersion Preschools continues to grow.

In October 2016, Education Minister Pan Wen-chung said that the Executive Yuan will allocated a budget of NT$6.2 billion to establish 1,000 kindergartens over the next four years so that it can raise the percentage of children enrollment by 30–40% by 2020.[45]

3+3 High School system

Following the new policy of the test to enter senior high school (the CAP test), it is now wildly believed by the parents that it is better and more convenient for their children to not need to worry about continuing education from junior to senior high school by continuing education at the same private school. This system allows for students to skip the CAP test, otherwise known as "Comprehensive Assessment Program for Junior High School Students" and take only the university entrance exam after completion of senior high. Therefore, many senior high schools in Taiwan such as Private Nan Shan Senior High School started their own Junior departures.

Other

Special Education Services in Taiwan

As Special Education Act was announced in 1984, students with special needs started to receive special education services in Taiwan. Two subgroups were further classified by professionals in special education, including students with difficulties and students with giftedness. In order to provide support that meet students needs, three main ways of special education services are provided: centralized special education class, decentralized resource room, and itinerant resource program. Students from age 2 to 22 can receive special education services in the process of assessment, placement and educational provision.[46] [47]

Nursing education

See main article: Nursing in Taiwan.

Chinese as a second language

Taiwan has long been and with the growing popularity of learning Chinese internationally, an ideal destination for learning the language.

See: List of Chinese language schools in Taiwan

Students

In 2015, there were 40,000 students from mainland China studying in Taiwan, in which 34,114 of them were short-term exchange students.[49]

See also

References

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: zh:國人教育水準 . https://www.gender.ey.gov.tw/gecdb/Stat_Statistics_DetailData.aspx?sn=cC3K6vUAfeUlTCcfbr03CQ%3d%3d&d=m9ww9odNZAz2Rc5Ooj%2fwIQ%3d%3d . www.gender.ey.gov.tw . 24 May 2019 . zh.
  2. Web site: TIMSS Math 2003.
  3. Web site: TIMSS Science 2003.
  4. News: Talk of the day -- Taiwan's education to enter new era. Focus Taiwan News Channel. 2011-01-02. 2011-01-02. 2011-01-07. https://web.archive.org/web/20110107142508/http://focustaiwan.tw/ShowNews/WebNews_Detail.aspx?ID=201101020011&Type=aTOD. dead.
  5. Web site: PISA - Results in Focus . OECD . 5.
  6. Web site: Chinese Taipei Student performance (PISA 2015) . OECD . 19 August 2019.
  7. Book: Kiersz, Andy . The latest ranking of top countries in math, reading, and science is out — and the US didn't crack the top 10 . 16 December 2016.
  8. Book: Patriarchy in East Asia: A Comparative Sociology of Gender . . Sechiyama, Kaku . 2013 . 254 . 978-9004230606.
  9. Book: Taiwan Country: Strategic Information and Developments . International Business Publications . 2012 . 25 . 978-1438775708.
  10. Dragon Gate: Competitive Examinations and Their Consequences . Prudence Chou, Chuing . . 2014.
  11. A matter of trust: shadow education in Taiwan . Prudence Chou, Chuing . . 2014.
  12. Book: Taiwan Country: Strategic Information and Developments . Kangmin Zeng . Cassell . 1999 . 328 . 978-0304700158.
  13. Web site: 5 mil. Taiwanese hold degrees from higher education institutions . China Post . 13 March 2016 . 19 August 2019.
  14. Web site: Higher Education Crisis in Taiwan . Inside Higher Ed . 5 August 2018 . 19 August 2019 . Hsueh, Chia-Ming.
  15. Book: Lee, Pearl . University degrees: Mindset shift needed . The Straits Times . 13 April 2015 . 25 August 2019 . 18 January 2017 . https://web.archive.org/web/20170118203426/http://news.asiaone.com/news/education/university-degrees-mindset-shift-needed . dead .
  16. Web site: Taiwan's higher education enrollment starts a downward slide . 16 August 2016 . ICEF Monitor.
  17. News: The draw of blue collar jobs in Taiwan . Sui . Cindy . BBC News . 23 September 2013 . 19 August 2019 . 19 August 2019 . https://web.archive.org/web/20190819222900/https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-24156168 . dead .
  18. Web site: Education in Taiwan: Taiwan's Colleges and Universities . Chou . Chuing . 12 November 2014.
  19. Book: United States. Office of Education. Bulletin. 1908. U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Office of Education. 4–64.
  20. Book: Ferdinand Verbiest Foundation. Missionary Approaches and Linguistics in Mainland China and Taiwan. January 2001. Leuven University Press. 978-90-5867-161-5. 233–.
  21. Wong . Ting-Hong . Education and National Colonialism in Postwar Taiwan: The Paradoxical Use of Private Schools to Extend State Power, 1944–1966 . History of Education Quarterly . May 2020 . 60 . 2 . 156–184 . 10.1017/heq.2020.25. 225917190 .
  22. Web site: 12 years education website. 12 years education website. 2015-12-16. 2015-12-22. https://web.archive.org/web/20151222123841/http://12basic.edu.tw/. dead.
  23. Web site: Technological and Vocational Education in Taiwan, Republic of China . Ministry of Education . 1 August 2011 . 23 August 2019 . 14 . 13 September 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220913092945/https://english.moe.gov.tw/public/Data/New182910424171.pdf . dead .
  24. Web site: Taiwan: Career and Technical Education . NCEE . 23 August 2019.
  25. Web site: Technological and Vocational Education in Taiwan . Ministry of Education of Taiwan . 2016 . 19 August 2019 . Pan, Wen-Chung . 16–17.
  26. Web site: Technological and Vocational Education in Taiwan . Ministry of Education of Taiwan . 2016 . 19 August 2019 . Pan, Wen-Chung . 14.
  27. Web site: Technological and Vocational Education in Taiwan, Republic of China . Ministry of Education . 1 August 2011 . 23 August 2019 . 14 . 13 September 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220913092945/https://english.moe.gov.tw/public/Data/New182910424171.pdf . dead .
  28. Web site: Taiwan: Higher Education under Pressure . IHE . 19 August 2019 . Hsueh, Chia Ming . 25.
  29. Web site: Taiwan's problem? Too many college graduates, too few machinists . USA Today . 7 May 2015 . 19 August 2019 . Wiese, Elizabeth.
  30. Web site: Higher Education Crisis in Taiwan . Inside Higher Ed . 5 August 2018 . 19 August 2019 . Hsueh, Chia-Ming.
  31. Choy . Wai Ching . Lau . Pui Yan Flora . Cross-border to Taiwan but not China: The decision-making mechanism of Hong Kong students pursuing higher education in Taiwan . Social Transformations in Chinese Societies . 1 January 2019 . 15 . 1 . 21–36 . 10.1108/STICS-06-2018-0012 . 150997454 .
  32. News: The draw of blue collar jobs in Taiwan . Sui . Cindy . BBC News . 23 September 2013 . 19 August 2019 . 19 August 2019 . https://web.archive.org/web/20190819222900/https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-24156168 . dead .
  33. Web site: Taiwan's higher education enrolment starts a downward slide . 16 August 2016 . ICEF Monitor.
  34. https://web.archive.org/web/20200305195547/http://web2.ym.edu.tw/files/11-1133-9-1.php NYMU
  35. Web site: 頂大專任教師人數 止跌回升 - 生活 . 自由電子報 . 2020-01-02 . zh . 2020-03-05.
  36. Web site: NTNU-Resources&Offices. en.ntnu.edu.tw.
  37. Web site: Learning Chinese in Taiwan - Your Gateway to Asia: Asian Consultants International. 2018-01-04. 2022-04-11. https://web.archive.org/web/20220411161326/http://www.asianconsultants.com/learn-chinese/. dead.
  38. Book: Huang . Muxuan (黃慕萱) . zh:書目計量與學術評鑑—國內七所研究型大學論文發表概況分析。引文分析與學術評鑑研討會論文集 . Taipei . 2004 . 135 - 152.
  39. Web site: Technological and Vocational Education in Taiwan . Ministry of Education of Taiwan . 2016 . 19 August 2019 . Pan, Wen-Chung. 28.
  40. Web site: Junior College Law . 10 July 2013 . 17 February 2014 . zh.
  41. Web site: Technological and Vocational Education in Taiwan . Ministry of Education of Taiwan . 2016 . 19 August 2019 . Pan, Wen-Chung. 27.
  42. Web site: Technological and Vocational Education in Taiwan . Ministry of Education of Taiwan . 2016 . 19 August 2019 . Pan, Wen-Chung. 26.
  43. Web site: Staff Writer . Survey shows Taiwan students overdependent on cram schools . www.taiwannews.com.tw . 24 October 2020 . Taiwan News . 21 November 2020.
  44. Web site: K. S. Yuan . James . Prudence Chou . Chuing . Buxiban in Taiwan . nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw . NCCU . 21 November 2020.
  45. Web site: Cabinet approves Taipower break up - Taipei Times. 21 October 2016.
  46. Web site: Ministry of Education, Republic of China (Taiwan). 2013-12-15. 2008-05-16. https://web.archive.org/web/20080516025340/http://english.moe.gov.tw/. dead.
  47. Web site: Special Education Information Network In Taiwan . 2017-08-19 . 2018-01-28 . https://web.archive.org/web/20180128122112/http://spec.moe.gov.tw/ensite/ . dead .
  48. Web site: notepad the association of Chinese school health nursing. notepad the association of Chinese school health nursing.
  49. Web site: 'NT$3.4 bil. loss' if mainland bars students.