Denturist Explained

Denturist should not be confused with dentist.

Denturist
Employment Field:Dental
Formation:Diploma, Advanced diploma, bachelor's degree, or master's degree
Related Occupation:Dentist, dental hygienist, dental therapist, prosthetist

A denturist in the United States and Canada, clinical dental technologist in the United Kingdom and Ireland, dental prosthetist in Australia, or a clinical dental technician in New Zealand is a member of the oral health care team and role as primary oral health care provider who provides an oral health examination, planning treatment, takes impressions of the surrounding oral tissues, constructs and delivers removable oral prosthesis treatment (including dentures and partial dentures) directly to the patient.

Definitions

Denturism is defined as the practice by denturists of examining oral health, planning treatment, making artificial dentures including other removable oral appliances and fitting them to patients. It is a recognized profession throughout the world and currently utilized in many countries including Australia, New Zealand, United States, United Kingdom and Canada. In the United States, denturism is only legislated and practiced in 7 states (Maine, Arizona, Idaho, Montana, Washington, Oregon, and Colorado).[1] However, in Australia, the United Kingdom and Canada, all states, provinces and territories recognize the profession.[2] [3] [4]

The criteria and training to become a denturist vary by country and region, however after completion of required prerequisites which are completion of dental technology program or years experience in denturitry with completion of core required courses, generally the denturism programs take 3–5 years and the qualification ranges from a Diploma to a master's degree.[5] [6] Due to the diversity in training, the scope of practice for a denturist can alternate between countries, however the general principle remains the same.

Denturist curriculum contains courses such as, General biology, Micro biology, Human anatomy, Head and Neck anatomy, Dental anatomy, Physiolosy, Dental Materials, Dental technology theory, Infection prevention and control, Radiographic interpretation, Periodontology, Histology, Embryology, Nutrition, Psychology, Pathophysiology, Oral pathology, Pharmacology, Gerontology, Ethics, Removable and Fixed prosthetics, Implantology, Removable oral appliances, Clinical & Laboratory theory, Practice management, etc.[7]

The program is competitive and selective. Prospective students are encouraged to complete and earn Dental Technology Degree prior to applying Denture Specialist Program. By acquiring Dental Technology knowledge prior to entering Denture Specialist Program would help students to follow course works with better understanding. Work experience from denturist clinic, denture laboratory and other dental field is plus to be succeed before and after graduation.[8]

Role in the dental team

Denturists are an important part of the dental team. They often work alongside general dentists, dental specialists and other members of a dental team in both private and public sectors of the oral health workforce.[9] They can also work independently in their own clinic with patients providing appropriate management and treatment of dentures and other oral appliances. Denturists are well educated in clinical and technical knowledge of denture care, as well as completing many hours of practical skills in producing dentures. They ultimately receive more comprehensive study in oral prosthetics than any other health professional including the general dentist [10] since dental schools less emphasis in their curriculum about removable prosthetics and focus on implantology in contrast denturist schools teaches mainstream of removable prosthetics and dentures and spend several years for training. Therefore, the collaborative role of denturists provides an important model of re-allocating dental services to alleviate stresses from the general dentists, reserving time for restorative, cosmetic, hygiene, and emergency dental procedures.[11]

Denturists differ from both dental technicians and prosthodontists.[12] Dental technicians are registered members of the dental team who support dental practitioners in the delivery of dental services.[13] Prosthodontists are qualified dentists, who have specialized in making fixed or removable appliances for patients.[14]

History of denturism

Dentures throughout the ages

The use of "false teeth" has prevailed throughout the course of history. Archaeological evidence dating back to 1500 B.C. was found in Egypt.[15] The Egyptians would use real teeth threaded with a gold wire to create a false set of teeth. In northern Italy 700 B.C., the Etruscans made dentures out of animal teeth.[16] Hence the world of dental prosthodontics began to take shape. Despite being made of low quality material and having short life spans, dentures were relatively popular.

The first complete set of dentures is attributed to 16th century Japan.[17] They were known as the Japanese box and are quite similar in shape to modern day dentures.

In the 1700s, ivory dentures were developed from walrus, elephant or hippopotamus tusks.[18] Alexis Duchateu crafted the first porcelain dentures in 1770. These were prone to cracking and appeared too white to be natural teeth. Duchateus was a pharmacist, since Denturist, as an occupation was yet to be established.

In the 1800s, the incidence of dental decay and tooth loss began to increase rapidly.[19] The industrialisation period meant the consumption of sugar among British citizens increased by 500 percent.[19] A need for an alternative form of dentures was needed.

In 1815, the Battle of Waterloo gave rise to the highly demanded "Waterloo teeth".[20] These were dentures crafted primarily from the teeth of dead soldiers seated in a base of animal ivory. Waterloo dentures gave the appearance of natural teeth and were not as prone to breakage as porcelain dentures.

In 1820, Claudius Ash was given the task of crafting a new and improved form of dentures.[21] Ash was a silversmith and goldsmith.[4] He constructed porcelain on 18-karat gold plates. The springs that held the dentures together were also made of gold. Dentures that were previously made from natural teeth or porcelain were both aesthetically and functionally inferior in comparison to Ash's design.

In the 1850s, Ash and his company developed Vulcanite (hardened rubber that seated porcelain teeth). His company was the leading supplier of this form of dentures in Europe. Charles Goodyear was awarded the patent for Vulcanite-based dentures in 1851.[22] Dentures, at the time, were primarily focused on aesthetics. Early in the 20th century, Dentistry shifted from treatment based therapy to prevention and as such, dentures that were in line with good health became more favourable.[23] Having a clear occupation for dentures alone became a requirement.

Legal recognition of denturists

The 1919 Tasmanian Dental Act made a clear distinction between the role of a Dentist and the practice of denture making. For a patient that required dentures, a consultation by referral from a Dentist became normal procedure.

Denturism – that is the field of dentures - was not recognised until more recent times.

The Health Amendment Act (1933) was the first legal document that gave rise to the practice of Denturism in Canada.[24] The Dental Mechanics Act of Alberta (1961) was the future update to this legislation allowing Denturists to begin work in the field.[25] They were also known as "Dental Mechanics" or "Denture Therapists."

This gave rise for the need for legal recognition of denturists in other countries. In the United States, the first legally recognised Denturists were found in Oregon, 1971.[26] In 1974, denturists were first legally recognised and in 1978, Denture Therapists began practicing.

The increasing rate of ill-fitting, misaligned, unstable and unsupportive dentures motivated three Denturists in 1956 to pursue international recognition.[27] Rolf Pfenniger, Hannes Stiebler and Stephan Grabert formed the Internationale Arbeitsgemeinschaft der Zahnprothetiker. In English, this is the International Federation of Denturists.

Denturists have campaigned for the right to practice independently in many states, with the argument that they can provide greater access and lower-cost prosthetic services.[28] This argument has been disproved by examining other jurisdictions in the world which have both dentists and denturists. In Canada, six years after regulating of denturists commenced, the fees quoted in their fee guide were similar to those of dentists. Consequently, most of these campaigns have so far failed.

In some jurisdictions, denturists must operate under the supervision or oral health certificate of a dentist. Many dentists argue that this does not happen. For example, in 1991, investigators hired by the Arizona Dental Association found that only three out of the state's 13 denturists advised callers to see a dentist before visiting them.[29] Many denturists argue that from a business point of view dentists are viewed as competition and in many locations dentists may "steal their business" after doing an exam.[30] With the work of the IFD and other denturist campaigns across the globe, there is hope for clearer recognition and scope in future.

Training in different countries

Australia

The following programs of study have currently been approved by the Dental Board of Australia for the profession of dental prosthetics. On successful completion of the selected courses, individuals are required to register with the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency to practice legally as a dental prosthetist.[31]

Australia
Education Provider QualificationCourse TypeCourse Length (Years)
align=left Griffith Universityalign=left Bachelor of Dental Prosthetics
(undergraduate entry)
align=left Bachelor's Degreealign=centre 3
align=left Griffith Universityalign=left Graduate Diploma of Dental Technology in Prosthetics
(post-graduate entry only)
align=left Graduate Diploma align=centre 1
align=left Griffith Universityalign=left Master of Dental Technology in Prosthetics
(post-graduate entry only)
align=left Master's Degreealign=centre 1.5
align=left Griffith Universityalign=left Master of Dental Technology in Prosthetics/Graduate Diploma of Dental Technology in Prosthetics (exit point only)
(post-graduate entry only)
align=left Master's Degreealign=centre 1/1.5
align=left RMIT Universityalign=left Advanced Diploma of Dental Prosthetics
(undergraduate entry)
align=left Advanced Diplomaalign=centre 2
align=left TAFE New South Wales Sydney Institutealign=left Advanced Diploma of Dental Prosthetics
(undergraduate entry)
align=left Advanced Diplomaalign=centre 2
align=left TAFE South Australiaalign=left Advanced Diploma of Dental Prosthetics
(undergraduate entry)
align=left Advanced Diplomaalign=centre 2
align=left TAFE Queenslandalign=left Bachelor of Dental Prosthetics
(undergraduate entry)
align=left Bachelor's Degreealign=centre 3

Canada

The following programs of study have currently been approved by the Denturist Association of Canada for the profession of denturism. On successful completion of the selected courses, individuals are then required to complete a Qualifying Examination administered by the College of Denturists, consisting of two components: a written examination and a structured clinical examination. Upon successful completion of the examination, individuals may then register with the College of Denturists of Ontario to practice legally as a denturist.[32]

Canada
Education Provider QualificationCourse TypeCourse Length (Years)
align=left CDI Collegealign=left Advanced Diploma of Dental Technologyalign=left Advanced Diplomaalign=centre 3
align=left College Edouard-Montpetitalign=left College Diploma of Techniques of Denturologyalign=left AdvancedDiplomaalign=centre 3
align=left George Brown Collegealign=left Ontario College Advanced Diploma (Denturism)align=left Advanced Diplomaalign=centre 3
align=left Georgian Collegealign=left Ontario College Advanced Diploma (Denturism)align=left Advanced Diplomaalign=centre 3
align=left Northern Alberta Institute of Technologyalign=left Diploma of Dental Technologyalign=left Advanced

Diploma

align=centre 3
align=left Oxford College of Arts, Business and Technologyalign=left Ontario College Advanced Diploma (Denturism)align=left Advanced Diplomaalign=centre 3

United States

In the United States, there are certain prerequisites that need to be completed before individuals can apply at either of the two programs of study approved by the National Denturist Association USA. The prequisites vary from prior work experience to related education in the dental field.
On successful completion of the selected courses, individuals are then required to complete a jurisdiction, written and clinical examination offered by each legislated state. Upon successful completion of the examination, individuals can register with each legislated state and the National Denturist Association USA to practice legally as a denturist.[33]

United Kingdom

The following programs of study have currently been approved by the General Dental Council for the profession of clinical dental technologist. Required prerequisites must be completed prior to enter Clinical Dental Technology Program. On successful completion of the selected courses, individuals are required to register with the General Dental Council to practice legally as a clinical dental technologist.[34]

United Kingdom
Education Provider QualificationCourse TypeCourse Length (Years)
align=left Edinburgh Postgraduate Dental Institutealign=left Clinical Dental Technologyalign=left BScalign=centre 3
align=left Kent, Surrey and Sussex Postgraduate Dentistryalign=left Clinical Dental Technologyalign=left BScalign=centre 3
align=left University of Central Lancashirealign=left Clinical Dental Technologyalign=left BScalign=centre 3

Scope of practice in different countries

The scope of practice differs in each country, based on the training undertaken.

Australia

The following scope of practice has been outlined by the Australian Dental Association for registered dental prosthetists.[35]
Dental prosthetists in Australia can:

United States

The following scope of practice has been outlined by the National Denturist Association for registered denturists.
Denturists in the United States can:

United Kingdom

The following scope of practice has been outlined by the General Dental council for registered clinical dental technologist.[36]
Clinical dental technologist in the United Kingdom can:

Additional skills which CDTs in the UK could develop include:

Canada

The following scope of practice has been outlined by the Denturist Association of Canada for registered denturists.
Denturists in Canada can:

See also

Notes and References

  1. Lombardi V. Legislation [Internet]. National Denturist Association. [cited 2018May14]. Available from: http://nationaldenturist.com/legislation
  2. Australian Dental Prosthetist Association. ADPA; [cited 2018May13]. Available from: https://www.adpa.com.au/about-us/about-the-adpa
  3. Denturism in Canada [Internet]. Denturist Association of Canada. [cited 2018May15]. Available from: http://www.denturist.org/about.html
  4. A Proud Heritage [Internet]. Dental Technologists Association. [cited 2018May14]. Available from: https://www.dta-uk.org/dta-heritage.php
  5. C6157 - Advanced Diploma of Dental Prosthetics [Internet]. RMIT University. [cited 2018May15]. Available from: http://www1.rmit.edu.au/programs/structure/c6157auscy
  6. Bachelor of Dental Prosthetics [Internet]. Griffith University. [cited 2018May15]. Available from: https://degrees.griffith.edu.au/Program/1581
  7. George Brown College School of Dental Health in Denturism, Griffith University Dental Prosthetic program
  8. George Brown College School of Dental Health in Denturism, Griffith University Dental Prosthetic program, Bates technical college Denturist program prerequisite
  9. Egan . J.G. . Payne . A.G.T. . Thomson . W.M. . 2008 . Removable prosthodontic services, including implant-supported overdentures, provided by dentists and denturists. . Journal of Oral Rehabilitation . 35 . 4 . 252–258 . 10.1111/j.1365-2842.2007.01797.x . 18321260 .
  10. Web site: Raymond Voller . D. . 2008 . Removable Prosthetics: Clinical Indications And Treatment Principles . Dentistrytoday.com . 2 April 2020.
  11. Web site: International Federation of Denturist . 2018 . Denturism: An Overview .
  12. Web site: What is a dental prosthetist? . Dentures Plus . 7 December 2013 . 15 May 2018 .
  13. Australian Dental Association. Dental Technician [Internet]. Sydney: ADA; 2018 [cited 2018 May 13]. Available from https://www.ada.org.au/Careers/Dental-Team/Technician
  14. Australian Dental Association. Dental Workforce, Education and Training [Internet]. Sydney: ADA; 2018 [cited 2018 May 13]. Available from https://www.ada.org.au/Dental-Professionals/Policies/Dental-Workforce,-Education-and-Training
  15. . Diaconu . D. . Vitalariu . A. . Cotaie . G. . Melinte . A. . Tatarciuc . M. . Religious and Spiritual Concepts in Dental Practices in Ancient Orient . International Journal of Medical Dentistry . October 2014 . 1 . 4 . 255.
  16. Gonzalez . Jorge . The evolution of dental materials for hybrid prosthesis . The Open Dentistry Journal . 2014 . 8 . 85–94 . 10.2174/1874210601408010085 . free. 24893781 . 4040944 . 2253221 .
  17. Moriyama . N. . Hasegawa . M. . 1987 . The history of the characteristic Japanese wooden denture . Bulletin of the History of Dentistry . 35 . 1 . 9–16 . 3552092 .
  18. Kelly . Jr . Benetti . P . Ceramic materials in dentistry: historical evolution and current practice: Ceramic materials in dentistry . Australian Dental Journal . June 2011 . 56 . 84–96 . 10.1111/j.1834-7819.2010.01299.x . 21564119 .
  19. Steckel . Richard H . Biological Measures of the Standard of Living . Journal of Economic Perspectives . 1 February 2008 . 22 . 1 . 129–152 . 10.1257/jep.22.1.129 . 19771661 .
  20. Pryor . Kevin . The mobilization of memory: The Battle of Waterloo in German and British memory, 1815-1915 . Theses . August 2010 .
  21. Ansari . Iman . Nature Versus Denture: An Ontology of Dental Prostheses . Architectural Theory Review . 3 May 2016 . 21 . 2 . 114–148 . 10.1080/13264826.2017.1283339 . 151365180 .
  22. Mittal . Sanjeev . Sukhija . Urvashi . Khindria . Sk . Evolution of denture base materials . The Journal of Indian Prosthodontic Society . 2009 . 9 . 2 . 64 . 10.4103/0972-4052.55246 . free .
  23. Prior, TG. The Dentists Act (1919). Acting Government Printer, Tasmania. Dental Board of Tasmania. http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/tas/num_act/tda191910gvn46225/tda191910gvn46225.pdf
  24. Cassettari LA. History of the Dental Laboratory and the Dental Laboratory Technician (Doctoral dissertation, Oklahoma State University).
  25. Fee . Alan D. . The dental mechanics of Canada . The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry . January 1974 . 31 . 1 . 10–21 . 10.1016/0022-3913(74)90215-7 . 4587621 .
  26. Rosenstein . D I . Joseph . L P . Mackenzie . L J . Wyden . R . Professional encroachment: a comparison of the emergence of denturists in Canada and Oregon. . American Journal of Public Health . June 1980 . 70 . 6 . 614–618 . 10.2105/AJPH.70.6.614 . 7377437 . 1619448 .
  27. Malherbe D. Provision of removable prosthetics by denturists-what is the controversy. Laboratory World: International Dentistry South Africa. 2006 Jan.
  28. Abrams . SH . Denturists: do they really provide more affordable care in Ontario? . Journal of the Canadian Dental Association . November 1997 . 63 . 10 . 771–4 . 9401299 .
  29. McCann D. Cameras capture unlicensed dentist. ADA News, July 15, 1991
  30. Williamson RT . College active in denturism fight . ACP Messinger . 2 . 25 . 4 . 1995 .
  31. Dental Board of Australia. Registration [Internet]. Canberra ACT: Australian Government; 2017 [cited 2018 May 11]. Available from http://www.dentalboard.gov.au/Registration.aspx
  32. College of Denturists of Ontario. Registering as a Denturist [Internet]. Toronto: College of Denturists of Ontario; 2018 [cited 2018 May 11]. Available from https://denturists-cdo.com/Applicants/Registering-as-a-Denturist.aspx
  33. National Denturist Association USA. Recognition and Regulation [Internet]. United States of America; 2018 [cited 2018 May 11]. Available from http://nationaldenturist.com/recognition-and-regulation
  34. General Dental Council. Registration [Internet]. London: General Dental Council; 2018 [cited 2018 May 11]. Available from https://www.gdc-uk.org/professionals/registration
  35. Dental Prosthetist [Internet]. Australian Dental Association. 2018 [cited 15 May 2018]. Available from: https://www.ada.org.au/Careers/Dental-Team/Dental-Prosthetist
  36. SCOPE OF PRACTICE [Internet]. Gdc-uk.org. 2018 [cited 17 May 2018]. Available from: https://www.gdc-uk.org/api/files/Scope%20of%20Practice%20September%202013.pdf