Decisions in combat sports explained

In combat sports, a decision is a result of the fight or bout that does not end in a knockout, submission or other finish, in which the (usually) three judges' scorecards are consulted to determine the winner; a majority of judges must agree on a result. The judges' result can either award a win, loss, or draw.

If no judges are in attendance for scoring and the fight reaches the time limit with no finish, the fight goes to no decision.

Scoring

If a fight reaches the time limit with no finish, the outcome of fight is decided based on the judges' scorecards. In most professional boxing and mixed martial arts fights, there are three judges.

In a "ten-point system", a judge must award the fighter whom they judged as having "won the round" ten points, while the other fighter receives nine points or fewer. If a judge feels that there was no clear winner in a round, they must award both fighters ten points. This does not include point deductions from referees; rounds where neither fighter scores ten points can occur.

At the end of the bout, each judge will tally the scores to determine which fighter had won, if any, according to the judge's tally; a fighter that "won" a majority of rounds usually emerges with more points. If a fighter ends up with a higher number of points, that fighter "won" on that judge's scorecard. A fighter has to "win" on at least two scorecards to win the fight. If neither fighter "won" on at least two scorecards, the match is a draw; in championship fights, the champion usually retains the title in a draw, if not, it is "vacated" - the title belongs to no fighter and is vacant. The scores do not necessarily have to be identical in unanimous decisions.

Summary

Judges' scorecards winner Scorecards tallyDecision Fight result Example
bgcolor=redRed bgcolor=blueBlue bgcolor=yellowDraw
bgcolor=redRed bgcolor=redRed bgcolor=redRed 3 0 0 bgcolor=redRed corner wins Mike Tyson vs. Tony Tucker
bgcolor=yellowdraw bgcolor=blueBlue bgcolor=blueBlue 0 2 1 bgcolor=blueBlue corner wins Manny Pacquiao vs. Juan Manuel Márquez III
bgcolor=blueBlue bgcolor=redRed bgcolor=redRed 2 1 0 bgcolor=redRed corner wins Oscar De La Hoya vs. Floyd Mayweather
bgcolor=blueBlue bgcolor=redRed bgcolor=yellowdraw 1 1 1 bgcolor=yellowEvander Holyfield vs. Lennox Lewis
bgcolor=yellowdraw bgcolor=yellowdraw bgcolor=redRed 1 0 2 bgcolor=yellowBernard Hopkins vs. Jean Pascal
bgcolor=yellowdraw bgcolor=yellowdraw bgcolor=yellowdraw 0 0 3 bgcolor=yellowChris John vs. Rocky Juarez I

Other decisions

It happens when a fight has to be stopped because of a headbutt. If the fight has exceeded a certain number of rounds, the judges' scorecards can be used to determine a winner, as above.

It occurs when the judges' can not determine a winner when the fight goes to the scorecards due to a headbutt.

It is used to describe a fight that ends for external reasons, which does not result in a win, a loss or a draw.

It happens when, during any rest period between rounds, a boxer refuses to continue or their corner pulls them out, thereby forcing the referee to call an end to the fight.

It happens when a bout is stopped short of knockout or judges' decision because, intentionally, one or both contestants have repeatedly flagrantly fouled an opponent or violated other rules. The disqualified boxer automatically loses the bout to the opponent.

It happens when a fighter gives in to the opponent. The fighter who gives in loses the fight.