Counter-rotating propellers explained

Counter-rotating propellers (CRP) are propellers which turn in opposite directions to each other.[1] They are used on some twin- and multi-engine propeller-driven aircraft.

The propellers on most conventional twin-engined aircraft turn clockwise (as viewed from behind the engine). Counter-rotating propellers generally turn clockwise on the left engine and counterclockwise on the right. The advantage of such designs is that counter-rotating propellers balance the effects of torque and P-factor, meaning that such aircraft do not have a critical engine in the case of engine failure.

Drawbacks of counter-rotating propellers come from the fact that, in order to reverse the rotation of one propeller, either one propeller must have an additional reversing gearbox, or the engines themselves must be adapted to turn in opposite directions. (Meaning that there are essentially two engine designs, one with left-turning and the other with right-turning parts, which complicates manufacture and maintenance.)

History

Counter-rotating propellers have been used since the earliest days of aviation, in order to avoid the aircraft tipping sideways from the torque reaction against propellers turning in a single direction. They were fitted to the very first controlled powered aeroplane, the Wright Flyer, and to other subsequent types such as the Dunne D.1 of 1907 and the more successful Dunne D.5 of 1910.

In designing the Lockheed P-38 Lightning, the decision was made to reverse the counter-rotation such that the tops of the propeller arcs move outwards (counterclockwise on the left and clockwise on the right), away from each other. Tests on the initial XP-38 prototype demonstrated greater accuracy in gunnery with the unusual configuration.

The counter-rotating powerplants of the German World War II Junkers Ju 288 prototype series (as the Bomber B contract winning design), the Gotha Go 244 light transport, Henschel Hs 129 ground attack aircraft, Heinkel He 177A heavy bomber and Messerschmitt Me 323 transport used the same rotational "sense" as the production P-38 did  - this has also been done for the modern American Bell Boeing V-22 Osprey tiltrotor VTOL military aircraft design. The following German World War II aviation engines were designed as opposing-rotation pairs for counter-rotation needs:

The aerodynamics of a propeller on one side of an aircraft change according to which way it turns, as it affects the P-factor. This can in turn affect performance under extreme conditions and therefore flight safety certification. Some modern types, such as the Airbus A400M, have counter-rotating propellers in order to meet air safety requirements under engine-out conditions.

List of aircraft with counter-rotating propellers

-- template:avilist default headings: ! Type Country Class Role Date Status Notes -->
Type Country Date Notes
EU 2009 Four engines
US 1974 Twin engines
British Aerospace Jetstream 41UK1992Twin engine
US 1978 Twin engines
UK 1944 Twin engines
UK 1907 Twin engines in fuselage on a common driveshaft
UK 1908 Single central engine
UK 1910 Single central engine
UK 1917 Twin engines
Germany 1942 Twin engines
Heinkel He 177A Greif (fourth prototype onwards) Germany 1940 Twin engines
Germany 1942 Twin engines
Germany 1940 Twin engines
Germany 1917 Four engines in fuselage
US 1939 Twin engines
Messerschmitt Me 323 Gigant Germany 1943 Six engines
US 1946 Twin engines
US 1969 Twin engines
Italy 1986 Twin engines
Piper PA-31 Navajo (some variants) US 1967 Twin engines
US 1971 Twin engines
US 1962 Twin engines
US 1973 Twin engines
US 1978 Twin engines
Vought V-173 Flying Pancake US 1942 Twin engines
Vought XF5U Flying Pancake US 1947 Twin engines
Wright Flyer and most other Wright models to 1916 US 1903 Single central engine.

References

Notes
  • Bibliography
  • Notes and References

    1. http://arc.aiaa.org/doi/abs/10.2514/3.25453 Counter-rotating propellant analysis using a frequency domain panel method