Coronation stone explained

A coronation stone is a stone which has taken part in the ceremony of a monarch’s coronation. These stones were primarily used in medieval Europe, but historical examples exist throughout the world. Stones believed to have been used as coronation stones still exist, but public figures and historians argue about their authenticity and use today. Some are considered by historians to have been invented in the early modern period.

List

Stone Kings Location Period Notes Refs
Coronation Stone[1] Kings of Wessex and Kings of the EnglishLate 9th century
Lia FáilKing of Tara and High King of IrelandGaelic Ireland[2]
Stone of Scone[3] or Stone of DestinyKing of Scotland, King of Great Britain, King of the United KingdomNow EdinburghMid 9th century
Stones of MoraKing of SwedenKnivsta13th to 15th century
Duke's Chair or Duke's Seatprinces of Carantania, dukes of CarinthiaZollfeld plain between Maria Saal (Klagenfurt-Land) and Klagenfurt, in Carinthia (Austria)Herman, Duke of Carinthia (1161) - Ferdinand IV, King of the Romans (1651)
Prince's Stone[4] princes of Carantania, dukes of Carinthiaoriginally it stood northwest of the Kaiserpfalz of Karnburg in the Zollfeld plain;
nowadays in the Landhaus of Klagenfurt
Medieval Europe
Kök Tash[5] Kings of the Timurid EmpireSamarkand13th century

History

While there does not appear to be a single common source, the origins of most coronation stones are associated with legends with connections to historical events. It has been proposed that stones, being a common and long lasting natural material, were naturally used as seats and were associated with monarchs. Over time, that association evolved to make these stones equal to the sacredness of a monarch. Many of the coronation stones in the British Isles claim to share a common origin, specifically the Lia Fail and Stone of Scone, though this is disputed among sources.[6] [7]

In Europe, there are many recorded instances of coronation ceremonies being conducted with these stones.

Outside of Europe, there are mentions of special stones being used by rulers for their coronation ceremonies, such as the Kök Tash, Etai Odidem/Ntui,[8] and Vatubulia.[9]

Modern use and controversy

While most of these coronation stones are no longer in use, the Stone of Scone still holds a symbolic place in the United Kingdom and Scotland. As a result of nationalist contentions, this coronation stone has been the center of controversies, even resulting in its theft in 1950,[10] though it was returned.

The Stone of Scone has been slated for use again in the coronation ceremony of Charles III.[11] This has resulted in further controversy about its veracity and the place that a coronation stone has in a modern monarchy.[12] [13]

Notes and References

  1. Encyclopedia: Keynes. Simon . 2001. Kingston-upon-Thames. Michael Lapidge . John Blair . Simon Keynes . Donald Scragg . The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Anglo-Saxon England. Blackwell Publishing. 978-0-6312-2492-1.
  2. Conwell . Eugene A. . On the Lia Fail on Tara Hill . Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy . 1864 . 9 . 539–540 . 20488943 .
  3. Book: Breeze . David John . Munro . Graeme . The Stone of Destiny: Symbol of Nationhood . 1997 . Historic Scotland . 978-1-900168-44-1 .
  4. Nitze . William A. . The Siege Perilleux and the Lia Fáil or "Stone of Destiny" . Speculum . 31 . 2 . 1956 . 258–262 . 0038-7134 . 10.2307/2849412 . 2849412. 162472740 .
  5. Sela . Ron . The 'Heavenly Stone' (Kök Tash) of Samarqand: A Rebels' Narrative Transformed . Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain & Ireland . January 2007 . 17 . 1 . 21–32 . . 10.1017/S1356186306006535 . 163004650 .
  6. MacLean . Hector . The Ancient Peoples of Ireland and Scotland Considered . The Journal of the Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland . 1891 . 20 . 154–179 . 10.2307/2842234 . 2842234 .
  7. Hartland . E. Sidney . The Voice of the Stone of Destiny: An Enquiry into the Choice of Kings by Augury . Folklore . 1903 . 14 . 1 . 28–60 . 10.1080/0015587X.1903.9719334 . 1254267 .
  8. Jeffreys . M. D. W. . Some Notes on the Ekoi . The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland . 1939 . 69 . 1 . 95–108 . 10.2307/2844232 . 2844232 .
  9. Book: Geraghty . Paul . The Prehistory of Suva . 25–54 . j.ctv2xc67p4.11 . Suva Stories . 2022 . ANU Press . 978-1-76046-533-9 .
  10. Book: Jones . Mark . Restitution . 149–168 . j.ctt1287k16.16 . Cultural Heritage Ethics . 2014 . Open Book Publishers . 978-1-78374-068-0 .
  11. Web site: 2022-09-11 . Historic Stone of Destiny to be moved to London for new King's coronation . 2022-12-13 . The Independent . en.
  12. Web site: Drysdale . Neil . Why will the Stone of Destiny be used in King Charles III coronation . 2022-12-13 . The Courier . 22 September 2022 . en-GB.
  13. Web site: Gunn . Campbell . Campbell Gunn: Stone of Destiny's role in coronation is insulting tokenism . 2022-12-13 . Press and Journal . 26 September 2022 . en-GB.