Colloid Explained

A colloid is a mixture in which one substance consisting of microscopically dispersed insoluble particles is suspended throughout another substance. Some definitions specify that the particles must be dispersed in a liquid,[1] while others extend the definition to include substances like aerosols and gels. The term colloidal suspension refers unambiguously to the overall mixture (although a narrower sense of the word suspension is distinguished from colloids by larger particle size). A colloid has a dispersed phase (the suspended particles) and a continuous phase (the medium of suspension). The dispersed phase particles have a diameter of approximately 1 nanometre to 1 micrometre.[2] [3]

Some colloids are translucent because of the Tyndall effect, which is the scattering of light by particles in the colloid. Other colloids may be opaque or have a slight color.

Colloidal suspensions are the subject of interface and colloid science. This field of study began in 1845 by Francesco Selmi,[4] [5] [6] [7] who called them pseudosolutions, and expanded by Michael Faraday[8] and Thomas Graham, who coined the term colloid in 1861.[9]

Classification

Colloids can be classified as follows:

Medium/phaseDispersed phase
style=width:30%; Gas style=width:30%; Liquid style=width:30%; Solid
Dispersion
medium
GasLiquid aerosol
Examples: fog, clouds, condensation, mist, steam, hair sprays
Solid aerosol
Examples: smoke, ice cloud, atmospheric particulate matter
LiquidFoam
Example: whipped cream, shaving cream
Emulsion or Liquid crystal
Examples: milk, mayonnaise, hand cream, latex,, liquid biomolecular condensate
Sol
Examples: pigmented ink, sediment, precipitates, solid biomolecular condensate
SolidSolid foam
Examples: aerogel, floating soap, styrofoam, pumice
Gel
Examples: agar, gelatin, jelly, gel-like biomolecular condensate
Solid sol
Example: cranberry glass

Homogeneous mixtures with a dispersed phase in this size range may be called colloidal aerosols, colloidal emulsions, colloidal suspensions, colloidal foams, colloidal dispersions, or hydrosols.

Hydrocolloids

Hydrocolloids describe certain chemicals (mostly polysaccharides and proteins) that are colloidally dispersible in water. Thus becoming effectively "soluble" they change the rheology of water by raising the viscosity and/or inducing gelation. They may provide other interactive effects with other chemicals, in some cases synergistic, in others antagonistic. Using these attributes hydrocolloids are very useful chemicals since in many areas of technology from foods through pharmaceuticals, personal care and industrial applications, they can provide stabilization, destabilization and separation, gelation, flow control, crystallization control and numerous other effects. Apart from uses of the soluble forms some of the hydrocolloids have additional useful functionality in a dry form if after solubilization they have the water removed - as in the formation of films for breath strips or sausage casings or indeed, wound dressing fibers, some being more compatible with skin than others. There are many different types of hydrocolloids each with differences in structure function and utility that generally are best suited to particular application areas in the control of rheology and the physical modification of form and texture. Some hydrocolloids like starch and casein are useful foods as well as rheology modifiers, others have limited nutritive value, usually providing a source of fiber.[10]

The term hydrocolloids also refers to a type of dressing designed to lock moisture in the skin and help the natural healing process of skin to reduce scarring, itching and soreness.

Components

Hydrocolloids contain some type of gel-forming agent, such as sodium carboxymethylcellulose (NaCMC) and gelatin. They are normally combined with some type of sealant, i.e. polyurethane to 'stick' to the skin.

Compared with solution

A colloid has a dispersed phase and a continuous phase, whereas in a solution, the solute and solvent constitute only one phase. A solute in a solution are individual molecules or ions, whereas colloidal particles are bigger. For example, in a solution of salt in water, the sodium chloride (NaCl) crystal dissolves, and the Na+ and Cl ions are surrounded by water molecules.  However, in a colloid such as milk, the colloidal particles are globules of fat, rather than individual fat molecules. Because colloid is multiple phases, it has very different properties compared to fully mixed, continuous solution.[11]

Interaction between particles

The following forces play an important role in the interaction of colloid particles:[12] [13]

This refers to the impossibility of any overlap between hard particles.

Colloidal particles often carry an electrical charge and therefore attract or repel each other. The charge of both the continuous and the dispersed phase, as well as the mobility of the phases are factors affecting this interaction.

A repulsive steric force typically occurring due to adsorbed polymers coating a colloid's surface.

An attractive entropic force arising from an osmotic pressure imbalance when colloids are suspended in a medium of much smaller particles or polymers called depletants.

Sedimentation velocity

The Earth’s gravitational field acts upon colloidal particles. Therefore, if the colloidal particles are denser than the medium of suspension, they will sediment (fall to the bottom), or if they are less dense, they will cream (float to the top). Larger particles also have a greater tendency to sediment because they have smaller Brownian motion to counteract this movement.

The sedimentation or creaming velocity is found by equating the Stokes drag force with the gravitational force:

mAg=6\piηrv

where

mAg

is the Archimedean weight of the colloidal particles,

η

is the viscosity of the suspension medium,

r

is the radius of the colloidal particle,

and

v

is the sedimentation or creaming velocity.

The mass of the colloidal particle is found using:

mA=V(\rho1-\rho2)

where

V

is the volume of the colloidal particle, calculated using the volume of a sphere

V=

4
3

\pir3

,

and

\rho1-\rho2

is the difference in mass density between the colloidal particle and the suspension medium.

By rearranging, the sedimentation or creaming velocity is:

v=

mAg
6\piηr

There is an upper size-limit for the diameter of colloidal particles because particles larger than 1 μm tend to sediment, and thus the substance would no longer be considered a colloidal suspension.[14]

The colloidal particles are said to be in sedimentation equilibrium if the rate of sedimentation is equal to the rate of movement from Brownian motion.

Preparation

There are two principal ways to prepare colloids:[15]

Stabilization

The stability of a colloidal system is defined by particles remaining suspended in solution and depends on the interaction forces between the particles. These include electrostatic interactions and van der Waals forces, because they both contribute to the overall free energy of the system.[16]

A colloid is stable if the interaction energy due to attractive forces between the colloidal particles is less than kT, where k is the Boltzmann constant and T is the absolute temperature. If this is the case, then the colloidal particles will repel or only weakly attract each other, and the substance will remain a suspension.

If the interaction energy is greater than kT, the attractive forces will prevail, and the colloidal particles will begin to clump together. This process is referred to generally as aggregation, but is also referred to as flocculation, coagulation or precipitation.[17] While these terms are often used interchangeably, for some definitions they have slightly different meanings. For example, coagulation can be used to describe irreversible, permanent aggregation where the forces holding the particles together are stronger than any external forces caused by stirring or mixing. Flocculation can be used to describe reversible aggregation involving weaker attractive forces, and the aggregate is usually called a floc. The term precipitation is normally reserved for describing a phase change from a colloid dispersion to a solid (precipitate) when it is subjected to a perturbation. Aggregation causes sedimentation or creaming, therefore the colloid is unstable: if either of these processes occur the colloid will no longer be a suspension.

Electrostatic stabilization and steric stabilization are the two main mechanisms for stabilization against aggregation.

A combination of the two mechanisms is also possible (electrosteric stabilization).

A method called gel network stabilization represents the principal way to produce colloids stable to both aggregation and sedimentation. The method consists in adding to the colloidal suspension a polymer able to form a gel network. Particle settling is hindered by the stiffness of the polymeric matrix where particles are trapped,[21] and the long polymeric chains can provide a steric or electrosteric stabilization to dispersed particles. Examples of such substances are xanthan and guar gum.

Destabilization

Destabilization can be accomplished by different methods:

Unstable colloidal suspensions of low-volume fraction form clustered liquid suspensions, wherein individual clusters of particles sediment if they are more dense than the suspension medium, or cream if they are less dense. However, colloidal suspensions of higher-volume fraction form colloidal gels with viscoelastic properties. Viscoelastic colloidal gels, such as bentonite and toothpaste, flow like liquids under shear, but maintain their shape when shear is removed. It is for this reason that toothpaste can be squeezed from a toothpaste tube, but stays on the toothbrush after it is applied.

Monitoring stability

The most widely used technique to monitor the dispersion state of a product, and to identify and quantify destabilization phenomena, is multiple light scattering coupled with vertical scanning.[23] [24] [25] [26] This method, known as turbidimetry, is based on measuring the fraction of light that, after being sent through the sample, it backscattered by the colloidal particles. The backscattering intensity is directly proportional to the average particle size and volume fraction of the dispersed phase. Therefore, local changes in concentration caused by sedimentation or creaming, and clumping together of particles caused by aggregation, are detected and monitored.[27] These phenomena are associated with unstable colloids.

Dynamic light scattering can be used to detect the size of a colloidal particle by measuring how fast they diffuse. This method involves directing laser light towards a colloid. The scattered light will form an interference pattern, and the fluctuation in light intensity in this pattern is caused by the Brownian motion of the particles. If the apparent size of the particles increases due to them clumping together via aggregation, it will result in slower Brownian motion. This technique can confirm that aggregation has occurred if the apparent particle size is determined to be beyond the typical size range for colloidal particles.

Accelerating methods for shelf life prediction

The kinetic process of destabilisation can be rather long (up to several months or years for some products). Thus, it is often required for the formulator to use further accelerating methods to reach reasonable development time for new product design. Thermal methods are the most commonly used and consist of increasing temperature to accelerate destabilisation (below critical temperatures of phase inversion or chemical degradation). Temperature affects not only viscosity, but also interfacial tension in the case of non-ionic surfactants or more generally interactions forces inside the system. Storing a dispersion at high temperatures enables to simulate real life conditions for a product (e.g. tube of sunscreen cream in a car in the summer), but also to accelerate destabilisation processes up to 200 times.Mechanical acceleration including vibration, centrifugation and agitation are sometimes used. They subject the product to different forces that pushes the particles / droplets against one another, hence helping in the film drainage. Some emulsions would never coalesce in normal gravity, while they do under artificial gravity.[28] Segregation of different populations of particles have been highlighted when using centrifugation and vibration.[29]

As a model system for atoms

In physics, colloids are an interesting model system for atoms.[30] Micrometre-scale colloidal particles are large enough to be observed by optical techniques such as confocal microscopy. Many of the forces that govern the structure and behavior of matter, such as excluded volume interactions or electrostatic forces, govern the structure and behavior of colloidal suspensions. For example, the same techniques used to model ideal gases can be applied to model the behavior of a hard sphere colloidal suspension. Phase transitions in colloidal suspensions can be studied in real time using optical techniques,[31] and are analogous to phase transitions in liquids. In many interesting cases optical fluidity is used to control colloid suspensions.[32]

Crystals

See main article: Colloidal crystal.

A colloidal crystal is a highly ordered array of particles that can be formed over a very long range (typically on the order of a few millimeters to one centimeter) and that appear analogous to their atomic or molecular counterparts.[33] One of the finest natural examples of this ordering phenomenon can be found in precious opal, in which brilliant regions of pure spectral color result from close-packed domains of amorphous colloidal spheres of silicon dioxide (or silica, SiO2).[34] [35] These spherical particles precipitate in highly siliceous pools in Australia and elsewhere, and form these highly ordered arrays after years of sedimentation and compression under hydrostatic and gravitational forces. The periodic arrays of submicrometre spherical particles provide similar arrays of interstitial voids, which act as a natural diffraction grating for visible light waves, particularly when the interstitial spacing is of the same order of magnitude as the incident lightwave.[36] [37]

Thus, it has been known for many years that, due to repulsive Coulombic interactions, electrically charged macromolecules in an aqueous environment can exhibit long-range crystal-like correlations with interparticle separation distances, often being considerably greater than the individual particle diameter. In all of these cases in nature, the same brilliant iridescence (or play of colors) can be attributed to the diffraction and constructive interference of visible lightwaves that satisfy Bragg’s law, in a matter analogous to the scattering of X-rays in crystalline solids.

The large number of experiments exploring the physics and chemistry of these so-called "colloidal crystals" has emerged as a result of the relatively simple methods that have evolved in the last 20 years for preparing synthetic monodisperse colloids (both polymer and mineral) and, through various mechanisms, implementing and preserving their long-range order formation.[38]

In biology

Colloidal phase separation is an important organising principle for compartmentalisation of both the cytoplasm and nucleus of cells into biomolecular condensates—similar in importance to compartmentalisation via lipid bilayer membranes, a type of liquid crystal. The term biomolecular condensate has been used to refer to clusters of macromolecules that arise via liquid-liquid or liquid-solid phase separation within cells. Macromolecular crowding strongly enhances colloidal phase separation and formation of biomolecular condensates.

In the environment

Colloidal particles can also serve as transport vector[39] of diverse contaminants in the surface water (sea water, lakes, rivers, fresh water bodies) and in underground water circulating in fissured rocks[40] (e.g. limestone, sandstone, granite). Radionuclides and heavy metals easily sorb onto colloids suspended in water. Various types of colloids are recognised: inorganic colloids (e.g. clay particles, silicates, iron oxy-hydroxides), organic colloids (humic and fulvic substances). When heavy metals or radionuclides form their own pure colloids, the term "eigencolloid" is used to designate pure phases, i.e., pure Tc(OH)4, U(OH)4, or Am(OH)3. Colloids have been suspected for the long-range transport of plutonium on the Nevada Nuclear Test Site. They have been the subject of detailed studies for many years. However, the mobility of inorganic colloids is very low in compacted bentonites and in deep clay formations[41] because of the process of ultrafiltration occurring in dense clay membrane.[42] The question is less clear for small organic colloids often mixed in porewater with truly dissolved organic molecules.[43]

In soil science, the colloidal fraction in soils consists of tiny clay and humus particles that are less than 1μm in diameter and carry either positive and/or negative electrostatic charges that vary depending on the chemical conditions of the soil sample, i.e. soil pH.[44]

Intravenous therapy

Colloid solutions used in intravenous therapy belong to a major group of volume expanders, and can be used for intravenous fluid replacement. Colloids preserve a high colloid osmotic pressure in the blood,[45] and therefore, they should theoretically preferentially increase the intravascular volume, whereas other types of volume expanders called crystalloids also increase the interstitial volume and intracellular volume. However, there is still controversy to the actual difference in efficacy by this difference,[45] and much of the research related to this use of colloids is based on fraudulent research by Joachim Boldt.[46] Another difference is that crystalloids generally are much cheaper than colloids.[45]

Notes and References

  1. Book: Israelachvili, Jacob N. . Intermolecular and surface forces . 2011 . Academic Press . 978-0-08-092363-5. 4rd . Burlington, MA . 706803091.
  2. Book: International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry. Subcommittee on Polymer Terminology. Compendium of polymer terminology and nomenclature : IUPAC recommendations, 2008. 2009. Royal Society of Chemistry. Jones, Richard G. . 978-1-84755-942-5. Cambridge. 406528399.
  3. Stepto. Robert F. T.. 2009-01-01. Dispersity in polymer science (IUPAC Recommendations 2009). Pure and Applied Chemistry. 81. 2. 351–353. 10.1351/PAC-REC-08-05-02. 95122531. free.
  4. Selmi, Francesco "Studi sulla dimulsione di cloruro d'argento". Nuovi Annali delle Scienze Naturali di Bologna, 1845.
  5. Selmi, Francesco, Studio intorno alle pseudo-soluzioni degli azzurri di Prussia ed alla influenza dei sali nel guastarle, Bologna: Tipi Sassi, 1847
  6. Hatschek, Emil, The Foundations of Colloid Chemistry, A selection of early papers bearing on the subject, The British Association Committee on Colloid Chemistry, London, 1925
  7. Selmi, Francesco - Sur le soufre pseudosoluble, sa pseudosolution e le soufre mou, Journal de Pharmacie et de Chimie, tome 21, 1852, Paris
  8. 10.1162/posc.2006.14.1.97. Discovering Discovery: How Faraday Found the First Metallic Colloid . 2006 . Tweney . Ryan D. . Perspectives on Science . 14 . 97–121 . 55882753 .
  9. 10.1098/rstl.1861.0011. X. Liquid diffusion applied to analysis . Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London . 1861 . 151 . 183–224 . 186208563 . . Page 183: "As gelatine appears to be its type, it is proposed to designate substances of the class as colloids, and to speak of their peculiar form of aggregation as the colloidal condition of matter."
  10. Saha . Dipjyoti . Bhattacharya . Suvendu . 6 November 2010 . Hydrocolloids as thickening and gelling agents in food: a critical review . . 47 . 6 . 587–597 . 10.1007/s13197-010-0162-6 . 3551143 . 23572691 .
  11. 10.1021/acs.langmuir.0c01139 . Differences between Colloidal and Crystalline Evaporative Deposits . 2020 . McBride . Samantha A. . Skye . Rachael . Varanasi . Kripa K. . Langmuir . 36 . 40 . 11732–11741 . 32937070 . 221770585 .
  12. Book: Lekkerkerker. Henk N.W.. Tuinier. Remco. Colloids and the Depletion Interaction. Springer. Heidelberg. 2011. 10.1007/978-94-007-1223-2. 9789400712225. 5 September 2018. https://web.archive.org/web/20190414163235/https://cds.cern.ch/record/1399210. 14 April 2019. dead.
  13. van Anders. Greg. Klotsa. Daphne. Ahmed. N. Khalid. Engel. Michael. Glotzer. Sharon C.. 2014. Understanding shape entropy through local dense packing. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 111. 45. E4812–E4821. 10.1073/pnas.1418159111. 1309.1187. 25344532. 4234574. 2014PNAS..111E4812V. free.
  14. Book: Cosgrove, Terence. Colloid Science: Principles, Methods and Applications. John Wiley & Sons. 2010. 9781444320183.
  15. Kopeliovich, Dmitri. Preparation of colloids. substech.com
  16. Book: Everett, D. H.. Basic principles of colloid science. 1988. Royal Society of Chemistry. 978-1-84755-020-0. London. 232632488.
  17. Slomkowski. Stanislaw. Alemán. José V.. Gilbert. Robert G.. Hess. Michael. Horie. Kazuyuki. Jones. Richard G.. Kubisa. Przemyslaw. Meisel. Ingrid. Mormann. Werner. Penczek. Stanisław. Stepto. Robert F. T.. 2011-09-10. Terminology of polymers and polymerization processes in dispersed systems (IUPAC Recommendations 2011). Pure and Applied Chemistry. de. 83. 12. 2229–2259. 10.1351/PAC-REC-10-06-03. 96812603. free.
  18. 2011-01-01. Intermolecular Force. Interface Science and Technology. 18. 1–57. 10.1016/B978-0-12-375049-5.00001-3. Park. Soo-Jin. Seo. Min-Kang. 9780123750495.
  19. Book: Colloid stability : the role of surface forces. Part I. 2007. Wiley-VCH. Tadros, Tharwat F. . 978-3-527-63107-0. Weinheim. 701308697.
  20. Genz. Ulrike. D'Aguanno. Bruno. Mewis. Jan. Klein. Rudolf. 1994-07-01. Structure of Sterically Stabilized Colloids. Langmuir. 10. 7. 2206–2212. 10.1021/la00019a029.
  21. Comba. Silvia. Sethi. Stabilization of highly concentrated suspensions of iron nanoparticles using shear-thinning gels of xanthan gum. Water Research. August 2009. 43. 15. 3717–3726. 10.1016/j.watres.2009.05.046. 19577785. 2009WatRe..43.3717C .
  22. Bean. Elwood L.. Campbell. Sylvester J.. Anspach. Frederick R.. Ockershausen. Richard W.. Peterman. Charles J.. 1964. Zeta Potential Measurements in the Control of Coagulation Chemical Doses [with Discussion]]. Journal (American Water Works Association). 56. 2. 214–227. 10.1002/j.1551-8833.1964.tb01202.x. 41264141.
  23. 10.1016/S0378-5173(03)00364-8. Systematic characterisation of oil-in-water emulsions for formulation design. 2003. Roland. I. International Journal of Pharmaceutics. 263. 85–94. 12954183. Piel. G. Delattre. L. Evrard. B. 1–2.
  24. 10.1023/A:1025017502379. 2003. Lemarchand. Caroline. Couvreur. Patrick. Besnard. Madeleine. Costantini. Dominique. Gref. Ruxandra. 24157992. Pharmaceutical Research. 20. 1284–92. 12948027. Novel polyester-polysaccharide nanoparticles. 8.
  25. 10.1016/S0927-7757(98)00680-3. Characterisation of instability of concentrated dispersions by a new optical analyser: the TURBISCAN MA 1000. 1999. Mengual. O. Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects. 152. 1–2. 111–123 .
  26. Book: Bru, P. . Particle sizing and characterisation. T. Provder . J. Texter . 2004. etal.
  27. Matusiak. Jakub. Grządka. Elżbieta. 2017-12-08. Stability of colloidal systems - a review of the stability measurements methods. Annales Universitatis Mariae Curie-Sklodowska, sectio AA – Chemia. 72. 1. 33. 10.17951/aa.2017.72.1.33. free.
  28. Book: Pharmaceutical emulsions and suspensions. 89. Salager, J-L . Françoise Nielloud . Gilberte Marti-Mestres . 2000. 978-0-8247-0304-2. CRC press.
  29. 10.1021/la802459u. Size Segregation in a Fluid-like or Gel-like Suspension Settling under Gravity or in a Centrifuge. 2008. Snabre. Patrick. Pouligny. Bernard. Langmuir. 24. 13338–47. 18986182. 23.
  30. Manoharan. Vinothan N. . Colloidal matter: Packing, geometry, and entropy. Science. 349. 6251 . 1253751. 2015. 10.1126/science.1253751. 26315444. 5727282 . free.
  31. Greenfield. Elad . Nemirovsky, Jonathan . El-Ganainy, Ramy . Christodoulides, Demetri N . Segev, Mordechai . Shockwave based nonlinear optical manipulation in densely scattering opaque suspensions. Optics Express. 2013. 21. 20. 23785–23802. 10.1364/OE.21.023785 . 24104290 . 2013OExpr..2123785G . free .
  32. Greenfield. Elad . Rotschild, Carmel . Szameit, Alexander . Nemirovsky, Jonathan . El-Ganainy, Ramy . Christodoulides, Demetrios N . Saraf, Meirav . Lifshitz, Efrat . Segev, Mordechai . Light-induced self-synchronizing flow patterns. New Journal of Physics. 2011. 13. 5. 053021. 10.1088/1367-2630/13/5/053021. 2011NJPh...13e3021G . free .
  33. Pieranski, P.. 1983. Colloidal Crystals. Contemporary Physics. 24. 25–73. 10.1080/00107518308227471. 1983ConPh..24...25P .
  34. Sanders, J.V.. 1964. Structure of Opal. Nature . 204. 1151. 10.1038/204990a0. Sanders. J. V.. Segnit. E. R.. 4191566. 1964Natur.204..990J. 4962.
  35. Darragh, P.J.. 1976. Scientific American. 234. 4. 84–95. etal. 10.1038/scientificamerican0476-84. Opals. 1976SciAm.234d..84D.
  36. Luck . Werner . Klier . Manfred . Wesslau . Hermann . Über Bragg-Reflexe mit sichtbarem Licht an monodispersen Kunststofflatices. II . Berichte der Bunsengesellschaft für Physikalische Chemie . 1963 . 67 . 1 . 84–85 . 10.1002/bbpc.19630670114.
  37. Hiltner, P.A. . Krieger, I.M.. 1969. Diffraction of light by ordered suspensions. J. Phys. Chem.. 73. 2306. 10.1021/j100727a049. 7.
  38. Liu. Xuesong. Li. Zejing. Tang. Jianguo. Yu. Bing. Cong. Hailin. 2013-09-09. Current status and future developments in preparation and application of colloidal crystals. Chemical Society Reviews. 42. 19. 7774–7800. 10.1039/C3CS60078E. 23836297.
  39. Book: Frimmel, Fritz H. . Frank von der Kammer . Hans-Curt Flemming. 2007. Colloidal transport in porous media. 1. Springer. 292. 978-3-540-71338-8.
  40. Alonso. U.. T. Missana . A. Patelli . V. Rigato . 2007. Bentonite colloid diffusion through the host rock of a deep geological repository. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, Parts A/B/C. 32. 1–7. 469–476. 10.1016/j.pce.2006.04.021. 2007PCE....32..469A .
  41. Voegelin. A.. Kretzschmar. Stability and mobility of colloids in Opalinus Clay. Institute of Terrestrial Ecology, ETH Zürich. Nagra Technical Report 02-14.. December 2002. 1015-2636. 47. R.. Technischer Bericht / NTB. 22 February 2009. https://web.archive.org/web/20090309172632/http://www.nagra.ch/documents/database/dokumente/%24default/Default%20Folder/Publikationen/e%5Fntb02%2D14.pdf. 9 March 2009. dead.
  42. Web site: Diffusion of colloids in compacted bentonite . 12 February 2009 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20090304210603/http://www.kth.se/che/divisions/nuchem/research/1.19965?l=en_UK . 4 March 2009.
  43. Wold . Susanna. Trygve Eriksen. 2007. Diffusion of humic colloids in compacted bentonite. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, Parts A/B/C. 10.1016/j.pce.2006.05.002. 32. 1–7. 477–484. 2007PCE....32..477W .
  44. Book: Elements of the nature and properties of soils. Weil, Ray. Brady, Nyle C.. 9780133254594. Fourth. New York, NY. 1035317420. 11 October 2018.
  45. Web site: An Update on Intravenous Fluids. Martin. Gregory S.. 19 April 2005. Medscape. 6 July 2016.
  46. News: Millions of surgery patients at risk in drug research fraud scandal. Blake. Heidi. 3 March 2011. The Telegraph. UK. https://web.archive.org/web/20111104083124/http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/8360667/Millions-of-surgery-patients-at-risk-in-drug-research-fraud-scandal.html. 4 November 2011. dead. 4 November 2011.