Centimetre–gram–second system of units explained

The centimetre–gram–second system of units (CGS or cgs) is a variant of the metric system based on the centimetre as the unit of length, the gram as the unit of mass, and the second as the unit of time. All CGS mechanical units are unambiguously derived from these three base units, but there are several different ways in which the CGS system was extended to cover electromagnetism.[1] [2] [3]

The CGS system has been largely supplanted by the MKS system based on the metre, kilogram, and second, which was in turn extended and replaced by the International System of Units (SI). In many fields of science and engineering, SI is the only system of units in use, but CGS is still prevalent in certain subfields.

In measurements of purely mechanical systems (involving units of length, mass, force, energy, pressure, and so on), the differences between CGS and SI are straightforward: the unit-conversion factors are all powers of 10 as and . For example, the CGS unit of force is the dyne, which is defined as, so the SI unit of force, the newton, is equal to .

On the other hand, in measurements of electromagnetic phenomena (involving units of charge, electric and magnetic fields, voltage, and so on), converting between CGS and SI is less straightforward. Formulas for physical laws of electromagnetism (such as Maxwell's equations) take a form that depends on which system of units is being used, because the electromagnetic quantities are defined differently in SI and in CGS. Furthermore, within CGS, there are several plausible ways to define electromagnetic quantities, leading to different "sub-systems", including Gaussian units, "ESU", "EMU", and Heaviside–Lorentz units. Among these choices, Gaussian units are the most common today, and "CGS units" is often intended to refer to CGS-Gaussian units.

History

The CGS system goes back to a proposal in 1832 by the German mathematician Carl Friedrich Gauss to base a system of absolute units on the three fundamental units of length, mass and time.[4] Gauss chose the units of millimetre, milligram and second.[5] In 1873, a committee of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, including physicists James Clerk Maxwell and William Thomson recommended the general adoption of centimetre, gram and second as fundamental units, and to express all derived electromagnetic units in these fundamental units, using the prefix "C.G.S. unit of ...".[6]

The sizes of many CGS units turned out to be inconvenient for practical purposes. For example, many everyday objects are hundreds or thousands of centimetres long, such as humans, rooms and buildings. Thus the CGS system never gained wide use outside the field of science. Starting in the 1880s, and more significantly by the mid-20th century, CGS was gradually superseded internationally for scientific purposes by the MKS (metre–kilogram–second) system, which in turn developed into the modern SI standard.

Since the international adoption of the MKS standard in the 1940s and the SI standard in the 1960s, the technical use of CGS units has gradually declined worldwide. CGS units have been deprecated in favor of SI units by NIST,[7] as well as organizations such as the American Physical Society and the International Astronomical Union. SI units are predominantly used in engineering applications and physics education, while Gaussian CGS units are still commonly used in theoretical physics, describing microscopic systems, relativistic electrodynamics, and astrophysics.[8] [9]

The units gram and centimetre remain useful as noncoherent units within the SI system, as with any other prefixed SI units.

Definition of CGS units in mechanics

In mechanics, the quantities in the CGS and SI systems are defined identically. The two systems differ only in the scale of the three base units (centimetre versus metre and gram versus kilogram, respectively), with the third unit (second) being the same in both systems.

There is a direct correspondence between the base units of mechanics in CGS and SI. Since the formulae expressing the laws of mechanics are the same in both systems and since both systems are coherent, the definitions of all coherent derived units in terms of the base units are the same in both systems, and there is an unambiguous relationship between derived units:

v=

dx
dt
  (definition of velocity)

F=m

d2x
dt2
  (Newton's second law of motion)

E=\int\vec{F}d\vec{x}

  (energy defined in terms of work)

p=

F
L2

  (pressure defined as force per unit area)

η=\tau/

dv
dx
  (dynamic viscosity defined as shear stress per unit velocity gradient).

Thus, for example, the CGS unit of pressure, barye, is related to the CGS base units of length, mass, and time in the same way as the SI unit of pressure, pascal, is related to the SI base units of length, mass, and time:

1 unit of pressure = 1 unit of force / (1 unit of length)2 = 1 unit of mass / (1 unit of length × (1 unit of time)2)

1 Ba = 1 g/(cm⋅s2)

1 Pa = 1 kg/(m⋅s2).

Expressing a CGS derived unit in terms of the SI base units, or vice versa, requires combining the scale factors that relate the two systems:

1 Ba = 1 g/(cm⋅s2) = 10−3 kg / (10−2 m⋅s2) = 10−1 kg/(m⋅s2) = 10−1 Pa.

Definitions and conversion factors of CGS units in mechanics

Quantity Quantity symbol CGS unit name Unit symbol Unit definition In SI units
length, positionL, xcm 10−2 m
mg 10−3 kg
timetseconds1 second 1 s
vcentimetre per second cm/s cm/s 10−2 m/s
aGal cm/s2 10−2 m/s2
Fdyn g⋅cm/s2 10−5 N
Eerg g⋅cm2/s2 10−7 J
Perg per seconderg/s g⋅cm2/s3 10−7 W
pBag/(cm⋅s2) 10−1 Pa
μPg/(cm⋅s) 10−1 Pa⋅s
kinematic viscosityνStcm2/s 10−4 m2/s
wavenumberk cm−1[10] or Kcm−1 100 m−1

Derivation of CGS units in electromagnetism

CGS approach to electromagnetic units

The conversion factors relating electromagnetic units in the CGS and SI systems are made more complex by the differences in the formulas expressing physical laws of electromagnetism as assumed by each system of units, specifically in the nature of the constants that appear in these formulas. This illustrates the fundamental difference in the ways the two systems are built:

In each of these systems the quantities called "charge" etc. may be a different quantity; they are distinguished here by a superscript. The corresponding quantities of each system are related through a proportionality constant.

Maxwell's equations can be written in each of these systems as:[8] [11]

System ! width=175 Gauss's law ! width=175 Ampère–Maxwell law ! width=175 Gauss's law for magnetism ! width=175 Faraday's law
CGS-ESU

\nablaEESU=4\pi\rhoESU

\nabla x BESU-c-2

E

ESU=4\pic-2JESU

\nablaBESU=0

\nabla x EESU+

B

ESU=0

CGS-EMU

\nablaEEMU=4\pic2\rhoEMU

\nabla x BEMU-c-2

E

EMU=4\piJEMU

\nablaBEMU=0

\nabla x EEMU+

B

EMU=0

\nablaEG=4\pi\rhoG

\nabla x BG-c-1

E

G=4\pic-1JG

\nablaBG=0

\nabla x EG+c-1

B

G=0

\nablaELH=\rhoLH

\nabla x BLH-c-1

E

LH=c-1JLH

\nablaBLH=0

\nabla x ELH+c-1

B

LH=0

\nablaESI=\rhoSI/\epsilon0

\nabla x BSI-\mu0\epsilon

SI
0E

=\mu0JSI

\nablaBSI=0

\nabla x ESI+

B

SI=0

Electrostatic units (ESU)

In the electrostatic units variant of the CGS system, (CGS-ESU), charge is defined as the quantity that obeys a form of Coulomb's law without a multiplying constant (and current is then defined as charge per unit time):

ESU
F={q
1
ESU
q
2

\overr2}.

The ESU unit of charge, franklin (Fr), also known as statcoulomb or esu charge, is therefore defined as follows:[12] Therefore, in CGS-ESU, a franklin is equal to a centimetre times square root of dyne:

1/2
1Fr=1statcoulomb=1esu charge=1dyne1/2{ ⋅ cm=1g

{}cm3/2{}s-1

} .The unit of current is defined as:
-1
1Fr/s=1statampere=1esu current=1dyne1/2{ ⋅ cm{}s

=1g1/2{}cm3/2{}s-2

} .

In the CGS-ESU system, charge q is therefore has the dimension to M1/2L3/2T−1.

Other units in the CGS-ESU system include the statampere (1 statC/s) and statvolt (1 erg/statC).

In CGS-ESU, all electric and magnetic quantities are dimensionally expressible in terms of length, mass, and time, and none has an independent dimension. Such a system of units of electromagnetism, in which the dimensions of all electric and magnetic quantities are expressible in terms of the mechanical dimensions of mass, length, and time, is traditionally called an 'absolute system'.[13] :3

Unit symbols

All electromagnetic units in the CGS-ESU system that have not been given names of their own are named as the corresponding SI name with an attached prefix "stat" or with a separate abbreviation "esu", and similarly with the corresponding symbols.[12]

Electromagnetic units (EMU)

In another variant of the CGS system, electromagnetic units (EMU), current is defined via the force existing between two thin, parallel, infinitely long wires carrying it, and charge is then defined as current multiplied by time. (This approach was eventually used to define the SI unit of ampere as well).

The EMU unit of current, biot (Bi), also known as abampere or emu current, is therefore defined as follows:[12] Therefore, in electromagnetic CGS units, a biot is equal to a square root of dyne:

1/2
1Bi=1abampere=1emu current=1dyne1/2=1g1/2{ ⋅ cm

{}s-1

}.The unit of charge in CGS EMU is:

1Bi{ ⋅ s=1abcoulomb=1emucharge=1dyne1/2{}s=1g1/2{}cm1/2

}.

Dimensionally in the CGS-EMU system, charge q is therefore equivalent to M1/2L1/2. Hence, neither charge nor current is an independent physical quantity in the CGS-EMU system.

EMU notation

All electromagnetic units in the CGS-EMU system that do not have proper names are denoted by a corresponding SI name with an attached prefix "ab" or with a separate abbreviation "emu".[12]

Practical CGS units

The practical CGS system is a hybrid system that uses the volt and the ampere as the units of voltage and current respectively. Doing this avoids the inconveniently large and small electrical units that arise in the esu and emu systems. This system was at one time widely used by electrical engineers because the volt and ampere had been adopted as international standard units by the International Electrical Congress of 1881.[14] As well as the volt and ampere, the farad (capacitance), ohm (resistance), coulomb (electric charge), and henry (inductance) are consequently also used in the practical system and are the same as the SI units. The magnetic units are those of the emu system.[15]

The electrical units, other than the volt and ampere, are determined by the requirement that any equation involving only electrical and kinematical quantities that is valid in SI should also be valid in the system. For example, since electric field strength is voltage per unit length, its unit is the volt per centimetre, which is one hundred times the SI unit.

The system is electrically rationalized and magnetically unrationalized; i.e., and, but the above formula for is invalid. A closely related system is the International System of Electric and Magnetic Units,[16] which has a different unit of mass so that the formula for ′ is invalid. The unit of mass was chosen to remove powers of ten from contexts in which they were considered to be objectionable (e.g., and). Inevitably, the powers of ten reappeared in other contexts, but the effect was to make the familiar joule and watt the units of work and power respectively.

The ampere-turn system is constructed in a similar way by considering magnetomotive force and magnetic field strength to be electrical quantities and rationalizing the system by dividing the units of magnetic pole strength and magnetization by 4. The units of the first two quantities are the ampere and the ampere per centimetre respectively. The unit of magnetic permeability is that of the emu system, and the magnetic constitutive equations are and . Magnetic reluctance is given a hybrid unit to ensure the validity of Ohm's law for magnetic circuits.

In all the practical systems ε0 = 8.8542 × 10−14 A⋅s/(V⋅cm), μ0 = 1 V⋅s/(A⋅cm), and c2 = 1/(4π × 10−9 ε0μ0).

Other variants

There were at various points in time about half a dozen systems of electromagnetic units in use, most based on the CGS system.[17] These include the Gaussian units and the Heaviside–Lorentz units.

Electromagnetic units in various CGS systems

Conversion of SI units in electromagnetism to ESU, EMU, and Gaussian subsystems of CGS[18] ! Quantity! Symbol !! SI unit !! ESU unit !! Gaussian unit !! EMU unit
electric chargeq ≘ (10−1 c) statC (Fr) ≘ (10−1) abC
I ≘ (10−1 c) statA (Fr/s) ≘ (10−1) abA (Bi)
φ / V, E1 V≘ (108 c−1) statV (erg/Fr) ≘ (108) abV
E≘ (106 c−1) statV/cm (dyn/Fr) ≘ (106) abV/cm
D
p≘ (10) abCcm
Φe
≘ (4 × 10−11 c2) cm/cm ≘ (4 × 10−11) s2/cm2
B≘ (104 c−1) statT ≘ (104) G
H≘ (4 × 10−3) Oe
μ≘ (103) erg/G (Bi⋅cm2)
magnetic fluxΦm≘ (108 c−1) statWb ≘ (108) Mx
permeability≘ ((4)−1 × 107 c−2) s2/cm2 ≘ ((4)−1 × 107) cm/cm
resistanceR≘ (109 c−2) statΩ (s/cm) ≘ (109) abΩ
resistivityρ ≘ (1011 c−2) statΩcm (s) ≘ (1011) abΩcm
capacitanceC≘ (10−9 c2) statF (cm) ≘ (10−9) abF
inductanceL≘ (109 c−2) statH (s2/cm) ≘ (109) abH

In this table, c = is the numeric value of the speed of light in vacuum when expressed in units of centimetres per second. The symbol "≘" is used instead of "=" as a reminder that the units are corresponding but not equal. For example, according to the capacitance row of the table, if a capacitor has a capacitance of 1 F in SI, then it has a capacitance of (10−9 c2) cm in ESU; but it is incorrect to replace "1 F" with "(10−9 c2) cm" within an equation or formula. (This warning is a special aspect of electromagnetism units. By contrast it is always correct to replace, e.g., "1 m" with "100 cm" within an equation or formula.)

Physical constants in CGS units

Commonly used physical constants in CGS units[19] ! Constant ! Symbol ! Value
m
μB (EMU, Gaussian)
(ESU)
a0
k
me
e (ESU, Gaussian)
(EMU)
α
G
h
reduced Planck constant ħ
c

Advantages and disadvantages

Lack of unique unit names leads to potential confusion: "15 emu" may mean either 15 abvolts, or 15 emu units of electric dipole moment, or 15 emu units of magnetic susceptibility, sometimes (but not always) per gram, or per mole. With its system of uniquely named units, the SI removes any confusion in usage: 1 ampere is a fixed value of a specified quantity, and so are 1 henry, 1 ohm, and 1 volt.

In the CGS-Gaussian system, electric and magnetic fields have the same units, 40 is replaced by 1, and the only dimensional constant appearing in the Maxwell equations is c, the speed of light. The Heaviside–Lorentz system has these properties as well (with ε0 equaling 1).

In SI, and other rationalized systems (for example, Heaviside–Lorentz), the unit of current was chosen such that electromagnetic equations concerning charged spheres contain 4, those concerning coils of current and straight wires contain 2 and those dealing with charged surfaces lack entirely, which was the most convenient choice for applications in electrical engineering and relates directly to the geometric symmetry of the system being described by the equation.

Specialized unit systems are used to simplify formulas further than either SI or CGS do, by eliminating constants through a convention of normalizing quantities with respect to some system of natural units. For example, in particle physics a system is in use where every quantity is expressed by only one unit of energy, the electronvolt, with lengths, times, and so on all converted into units of energy by inserting factors of speed of light c and the reduced Planck constant ħ. This unit system is convenient for calculations in particle physics, but is impractical in other contexts.

See also

References and notes

  1. Encyclopedia: Centimetre-gram-second system physics. Encyclopedia Britannica. 2018-03-27. en.
  2. Web site: The Centimeter-Gram-Second (CGS) System of Units – Maple Programming Help. www.maplesoft.com. 2018-03-27.
  3. Babel of units: The evolution of units systems in classical electromagnetism . Carron . Neal J. . 21 May 2015 . physics.hist-ph . 1506.01951 .
  4. . English translation
  5. Book: William . Hallock . Herbert Treadwell . Wade . 200 . 1906 . New York . Outlines of the evolution of weights and measures and the metric system . The Macmillan Co .
  6. First Report of the Committee for the Selection and Nomenclature of Dynamical and Electrical Units . September 1873 . Forty-third Meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science . Professor . Everett . Joseph David Everett . Sir W . Thomson . William Thomson, 1st Baron Kelvin . Professor GC . Foster . Carey Foster . Professor JC . Maxwell . James Clerk Maxwell . Mr GJ . Stoney . George Johnstone Stoney . Professor Fleeming . Jenkin . Fleeming Jenkin . Dr . Siemens . Carl Wilhelm Siemens . Mr FJ . Bramwell . Frederick Bramwell . John Murray . Bradford . 223 . 2012-04-08.
  7. Guide for the Use of the International System of Units (SI) . Thompson . Ambler . Taylor . Barry N. . March 2008 . 10 . March 3, 2024 .
  8. Book: Jackson, John David . Classical Electrodynamics . limited . 3rd . 775–784 . New York . Wiley . 1999 . 0-471-30932-X.
  9. Web site: Weisstein . Eric W. . cgs . Eric Weisstein's World of Physics . en.
  10. Web site: Atomic Spectroscopy. Atomic Spectroscopy. NIST. 25 October 2015.
  11. Leung . P. T. . 43177051 . A note on the 'system-free' expressions of Maxwell's equations . 2004 . European Journal of Physics . 25 . 2 . N1–N4 . 10.1088/0143-0807/25/2/N01 . 2004EJPh...25N...1L .
  12. Book: Cardarelli, F. . 2004 . Encyclopaedia of Scientific Units, Weights and Measures: Their SI Equivalences and Origins . Springer . 2nd . 20–25 . 1-85233-682-X . registration.
  13. Book: Fenna . Donald . A Dictionary of Weights, Measures, and Units . 2002 . Oxford University Press . 978-0-19-107898-9 . en.
  14. Book: Tunbridge, Paul . Lord Kelvin: His Influence on Electrical Measurements and Units . 34–40 . IET . 1992 . 0-86341-237-8 .
  15. Book: Knoepfel, Heinz E. . Magnetic Fields: A Comprehensive Theoretical Treatise for Practical Use . limited . 543 . Wiley . 2000 . 3-527-61742-6 .
  16. Book: International System of Electric and Magnetic Units . Dellinger . John Howard . 1916 . U.S. Government Printing Office . Washington, D.C..
  17. Bennett, L. H. . Page, C. H. . Swartzendruber, L. J. . Comments on units in magnetism . 1978 . Journal of Research of the National Bureau of Standards . 83 . 1 . 9–12 . 10.6028/jres.083.002. 34565970 . 6752159 . free.
  18. Book: Applied Electronics. pp. 830–831, Appendix B. Truman S.. Gray. 1954. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.. New York.
  19. Book: 1978 . A.P. French . Edwind F. Taylor . An Introduction to Quantum Physics . W.W. Norton & Company.

General literature