Breaking character explained

In theatre (especially in the illusionistic Western tradition), breaking character occurs when an actor fails to maintain the illusion that they are the character they are supposedly portraying. This is considered unprofessional while performing in front of an audience or camera (except when the act is a deliberate breaking of the fourth wall). One of the most common ways of breaking character is corpsing, in which an actor loses their composure and laughs or giggles in a comedy scene or scene requiring ludicrous actions. If the breaking of character is particularly serious, it would normally result in an abandonment of a take in recorded or filmed drama.

Famous breaks in film

The advent of DVD players, with the use of their precise pause and slow-motion functions, has made it far easier to spot breaks in character in motion pictures, and many internet sites collect such examples.^[1]

Example:

• Catherine Schell, who found it difficult to act with Peter Sellers in The Return of the Pink Panther and maintain her composure. Several scenes showing her laughing at his antics remain in the film.^{[2] [3]}

On television

Examples of actors breaking character on television include:

• Lucille Ball, in a rare example of breaking character for her, was forced to break character during filming of "Lucy and Viv Put in a Shower", a season 1 episode of The Lucy Show. In the climactic scene, the titular shower filled with water due to a drain malfunction, and Ball nearly drowned attempting to unplug it. Co-star Vivian Vance hastily reworked the script to allow Ball to recover her composure.^[4] Ball's near-drowning was included in the finished episode, which was one of several from the series to lapse into the public domain.
• Many instances of breaking character have occurred on Saturday Night Live, where showrunner Lorne Michaels is known to strongly discourage character breaks:^[5]
  • Christina Applegate and David Spade could not stop laughing at Chris Farley's motivational speaker character, Matt Foley. ^[6]
  • The band members in the "More Cowbell" sketch broke character reacting to Will Ferrell's antics. Jimmy Fallon often broke character, which became one of his trademarks.^{[7] [8] [9]}
  • Perhaps the most severe example of an entire cast breaking is the first appearance of the Debbie Downer character, where in a 2004 skit featuring Rachel Dratch, guest host Lindsay Lohan and others, Dratch eventually struggles to exclaim to exaggerated effect "By the way ... I can't have children!"^{[5] [10]}
  • While playing NewsNation host Bobbi Moore in an April 13, 2024 SNL skit, Heidi Gardner, who has built a reputation for maintaining composure during comedy scenes, drew considerable attention for corpsing in what Vulture magazine characterized "in spectacularly charming fashion".^{[11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17]}
• In the Doctor Who episode "The Feast of Steven", actor William Hartnell breaks character to wish the audience a merry Christmas, with actors Peter Purves and Jean Marsh also breaking character, erupting in laughter. The Christmas address was scripted, but the laughter was not.^[18] In episode 5 of the Doctor Who story Frontier in Space, there is a scene in which the Master (Roger Delgado) leads captive Jo Grant (Katy Manning) through a rocky terrain. Despite his typically soulless nature, the Master audibly tells Jo to "be careful down here" – an out-of-character statement from Delgado to aid Manning, who is very nearsighted.
• On The Daily Show, Jon Stewart or one of the correspondents occasionally broke character during a segment. One example was a piece on an allegation of a homosexual relationship involving the then Prince Charles and the British tabloids' shameless use of innuendo and euphemisms to spread the rumor while avoiding libelous statements. The segment had Stephen Colbert "reporting" from Britain and explaining, in terms laden with homoerotic imagery, that it would be journalistically irresponsible to go into detail about the story. He then peeled a banana and took a huge bite of it in imitation of fellatio, causing himself to smile and Stewart to begin giggling off screen. By the end of the segment, Colbert was laughing so hard he could barely speak.^[19]
• Tim Conway took almost sadistic pleasure in pushing his Carol Burnett Show co-stars to lose composure and break out in helpless laughter – in particular, Harvey Korman, in their Dentist Sketch as well as many others. ^[20] Vicki Lawrence, as Mama in one of their many "The Family" sketches, scored a rare turnabout on Conway (as Mickey, Ed's (Korman) hardware-store employee), who had reduced Korman to fits of laughter in the Siamese Elephant Sketch. After Conway's repeated interruptions during the sketch, making a bizarre story incrementally even more so, the cast attempted to resume the sketch – prompting Lawrence to break the fourth wall and ask Eunice (Carol Burnett) "You sure that little asshole's through?" which brought down the cast and studio audience as well. ^[21] Needless to say, the scene ended up on the cutting-room floor and is recognized as one of the best-known "blooper" outtakes in TV history. Asked about the scene, years later, Lawrence cryptically replied that the scene may have been an outtake, but wasn't a blooper. She never fully elaborated afterward.

Virtual and gaming environments

Breaking character or corpsing is also being used more frequently to describe a participant-player who, having assumed the role of a virtual character or avatar and is acting within a virtual or gaming environment, then breaks out of that character.^[22] For example, this could be a player-character behaving inappropriately within the social-cultural environment depicted by the virtual or gaming environment or the participant-player ceasing to interact-play (momentarily or entirely) leaving the character suspended and/or lifeless.

Professional wrestling

See main article: Kayfabe. Breaking character is not solely limited to performances in traditional theater, television, and film; the phenomenon is not unheard of in professional wrestling, which is normally highly scripted.

Fictional depictions of breaking character

In Ruggero Leoncavallo's opera Pagliacci, commedia dell'arte actor Canio kills his real-life wife and her lover onstage.

See also

• Fourth wall
• Out of character communication in the sociological theory of dramaturgy

Notes and References

1. Web site: Actors Breaking Character to Laugh With Each Other Between Takes . Abraham . June 6, 2013 . twentytwowords.com . September 7, 2015 . https://web.archive.org/web/20150906235757/http://twentytwowords.com/actors-breaking-character-to-laugh-with-each-other-between-takes-15-pictures/ . September 6, 2015 . dead .
2. Web site: Movie Reviews: The Return of the Pink Panther . Varley, John . John Varley (author) . 2013 . John Varley . September 7, 2015.
3. Web site: Ciaran Meets the Stars . Brown, Ciaran . Ciaran Brown . September 7, 2015.
4. Book: The Other Side of Ethel Mertz . Frank Castelluccio & Alvin Walker . Knowledge, Ideas & Trends . 270 . 1998 . 1-879198-26-6 . registration .
5. Web site: 2023-03-22 . The 'SNL' mistake that Will Ferrell loved most . 2024-04-30 . faroutmagazine.co.uk . en-US.
6. Web site: Matt Foley: Van Down by the River - SNL . .
7. Web site: Jimmy Fallon and James Franco laugh about 'more cowbell' sketch from 'SNL' on 'Tonight Show' . Reiher, Andrea . Mar 15, 2014 . Zap2it . 'You always cracked up!' says Franco. . September 7, 2015 . September 8, 2015 . https://web.archive.org/web/20150908105524/http://zap2it.com/2014/03/jimmy-fallon-and-james-franco-laugh-about-more-cowbell-sketch-from-snl-on-tonight-show/ . dead .
8. Web site: Jimmy Fallon Recalls Famous Blue Oyster Cult / 'More Cowbell' Saturday Night Live Skit . Lifton, Dave . June 27, 2012 . ultimateclassicrock.com . ...Fallon ... often had difficulty keeping a straight face. In a new interview, Fallon recalls why he broke up in the middle of the famous 'More Cowbell' sketch... . September 7, 2015.
9. When Is It OK to Crack Up? Some Ground Rules for the Cast of SNL . Winter, Jessica . July 25, 2013 . . September 7, 2015.
10. Web site: 2023-08-24 . Debbie Downer: A History of Rachel Dratch’s Iconic SNL Character . 2024-04-30 . NBC Insider Official Site . en-US.
11. Web site: Ivie . Devon . 2024-04-15 . Heidi Gardner Couldn’t Prepare for What She Saw . 2024-04-30 . Vulture . en.
12. Web site: Perez . Lexy . 2024-04-16 . Heidi Gardner Reacts to Breaking Character During ‘SNL’ ‘Beavis and Butt-Head’ Sketch: “I Lost It” . 2024-04-30 . The Hollywood Reporter . en-US.
13. Web site: Sharf . Zack . 2024-04-16 . ‘SNL’ Star Heidi Gardner Says ‘Anxiety Set in’ After Breaking So Hard During ‘Beavis and Butt-Head’ Sketch: ‘I’ll Never Be Able to Shake’ What I Saw . 2024-04-30 . Variety . en-US.
14. Web site: 2024-04-16 . ‘SNL’ Star Heidi Gardner Feels Terrible She Broke Character During ‘Beavis And Butt-Head’ Skit . 2024-04-30 . HuffPost . en.
15. Web site: Ortiz . Andi . 2024-04-16 . SNL: Heidi Gardner Explains Why She Lost It in 'Beavis and Butt-Head' Sketch . 2024-04-30 . TheWrap . en-US.
16. Web site: 2024-04-18 . 'SNL' shows behind-the-scenes footage of 'Beavis and Butt-Head' skit that broke Heidi Gardner . 2024-04-30 . TODAY.com . en.
17. Web site: Evans . Greg . 2024-04-16 . Heidi Gardner Explains Butt-Head Crack-Up On Last Saturday’s ‘SNL’ . 2024-04-30 . Deadline . en-US.
18. As The Feast of Steven was a one-off filler episode, and now only survives as a home-made audio recording, it's possible that the episode contains other instances of actors visually breaking character.
19. Prince Charles Scandal - The Daily Show with Jon Stewart . https://web.archive.org/web/20210130071449/https://www.cc.com/video/1gonk2/the-daily-show-with-jon-stewart-prince-charles-scandal . dead . January 30, 2021 . 2003-11-11 . en-us . 2024-04-30 . www.cc.com.
20. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9IUSM4EKcRI
21. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uasRKdYZ4xQ
22. Tim Marsh. 2006. Vicarious experience: staying there connected with and through our own and other characters. Chapter, In: Gaming As Culture: Essays on Reality, Identity And Experience in Fantasy Games. Jefferson, NC: McFarland, pp. 196-214.