Allotropes of boron explained

Boron can be prepared in several crystalline and amorphous forms. Well known crystalline forms are α-rhombohedral (α-R), β-rhombohedral (β-R), and β-tetragonal (β-T). In special circumstances, boron can also be synthesized in the form of its α-tetragonal (α-T) and γ-orthorhombic (γ) allotropes. Two amorphous forms, one a finely divided powder and the other a glassy solid, are also known. Although at least 14 more allotropes have been reported, these other forms are based on tenuous evidence or have not been experimentally confirmed, or are thought to represent mixed allotropes, or boron frameworks stabilized by impurities.^[1] Whereas the β-rhombohedral phase is the most stable and the others are metastable, the transformation rate is negligible at room temperature, and thus all five phases can exist at ambient conditions. Amorphous powder boron and polycrystalline β-rhombohedral boron are the most common forms. The latter allotrope is a very hard^[2] grey material, about ten percent lighter than aluminium and with a melting point (2080 °C) several hundred degrees higher than that of steel.^[3]

Elemental boron has been found in star dust and meteorites, but does not exist in the high oxygen environment of Earth. It is difficult to extract from its compounds. The earliest methods involved reduction of boric oxide with metals such as magnesium or aluminium. However, the product is almost always contaminated with metal borides. Pure boron can be prepared by reducing volatile boron halides with hydrogen at high temperatures.^{[4] [5]} Very pure boron, for use in the semiconductor industry, is produced by the decomposition of diborane at high temperatures, followed by purification via zone melting or the Czochralski process.^[6] Even more difficult to prepare are single crystals of pure boron phases, due to polymorphism and the tendency of boron to react with impurities; typical crystal size is ~0.1 mm.

Summary of properties

Boron phase	α-R	α-T	β-R	β-T	γ	Amorphous
Symmetry	Rhombohedral	Tetragonal	Rhombohedral	Tetragonal	Orthorhombic	Semi-random	Semi-random
Occurrence	common	special	common	common	special
Atoms/unit cell	12	50	105‒108	192	28
Density (g/cm^3)	2.46	2.29‒2.39	2.35	2.36	2.52	1.73	2.34–35
Vickers hardness (GPa)^[7]	42		45		50–58
Bulk modulus (GPa)	224		184		227
Band gap (eV)	2	1.55^[8]	1.6	1.16^[9]	2.1	0.56–0.71
Color	Crystals are clear red	Black and opaque, with metallic lustre^[10]	Dark to shiny silver-grey	Black/red^[11]	Dark grey	Black to brown^[12]	Opaque black
Year first reported	1958	1943/1973^[13]	1957	1960	2009^[14]	1808	1911^[15] ^[16]

α-rhombohedral boron

α-rhombohedral boron has a unit cell of twelve boron atoms. The structure consists of icosahedra in which each boron atom has five nearest neighbors within the icosahedron. If the bonding were the conventional covalent type then each boron would have donated five electrons. However, boron has only three valence electrons, and it is thought that the bonding in the icosahedra is achieved by the so-called 3-center electron-deficient bonds where the electron charge is accumulated at the center of a triangle formed by three adjacent atoms.

The isolated icosahedra are not stable, due to the nonuniformity of the honeycomb; thus boron is not a molecular solid, but the icosahedra in it are connected by strong covalent bonds.

α-tetragonal boron

Pure α-tetragonal can only be synthesized as thin layers deposited on an underlying substrate of isotropic boron carbide (B₅₀C₂) or nitride (B₅₀N₂). Most examples of α-tetragonal boron^[17] are in fact boron-rich carbide or nitrides.

β-rhombohedral boron

β-rhombohedral boron has a unit cell containing 105–108 (ideally exactly 105) atoms. Most atoms form B₁₂ discrete icosahedra; a few form partially interpenetrating icosahedra, and there are two deltahedral B₁₀ units, and a single central B atom. For a long time, it was unclear whether the α or β phase is most stable at ambient conditions; however, gradually a consensus was reached that the β phase is the most thermodynamically stable allotrope. It exhibits a Mohs hardness of 9.5, and is one of the hardest pure elements, only surpassed by carbon (as diamond).^{[18] [19] [20] [21] [22]}

β-tetragonal boron

The β phase was produced in 1960 by hydrogen reduction of BBr₃ on hot tungsten, rhenium or tantalum filaments at temperatures 1270–1550 °C (i.e. chemical vapor deposition). Further studies have reproduced the synthesis and confirmed the absence of impurities in this phase.^{[23] [24] [25]}

γ-boron

The γ-phase can be described as a NaCl-type arrangement of two types of clusters, B₁₂ icosahedra and B₂ pairs. It can be produced by compressing other boron phases to 12–20 GPa and heating to 1500–1800 °C, and remains stable at ambient conditions. There is evidence of significant charge transfer from B₂ pairs to the B₁₂ icosahedra in this structure; in particular, lattice dynamics suggests the presence of significant long-range electrostatic interactions.

This phase was reported by Wentorf in 1965;^[26] however, neither structure nor chemical composition were established. The structure was solved using ab initio crystal structure prediction calculations and confirmed using single crystal X-ray diffraction.

Cubic boron

Sullenger et al. (1969) and McConville et al. (1976)^[27] reported a cubic allotrope of boron, obtained in argon plasma experiments, with a unit cell of 1705±3 atoms and a density of 2.367 g/cm³. While this allotrope is occasionally mentioned in the literature, no subsequent work appears to have been published either confirming or discrediting its existence. Donohue (1982) commented that the number of atoms in the unit cell did not appear to be icosahedrally related (the icosahedron being a motif common to boron structures).

High-pressure superconducting phase

Compressing boron above 160 GPa produces a boron phase with an as yet unknown structure. Contrary to other phases, which are semiconductors, this phase is a metal and becomes a superconductor with a critical temperature increasing from 6 K at 160 GPa to 11 K at 250 GPa.^[28] This structural transformation occurs at pressures at which theory predicts the icosahedra will dissociate.^[29] Speculation as to the structure of this phase has included face-centred cubic (analogous to Al); α-Ga, and body-centred tetragonal (analogous to In).^[30] It has also been suggested that the nonmetal-metal transition is simply the result of a band gap closure, as occurs with iodine, rather than a structural transition.^[31]

Borophene

See main article: Borophene. There exist several two-dimensional forms of boron (together called borophenes), and even more are predicted theoretically.^[32]

Borospherene

See main article: article and Borospherene. The discovery of the quasispherical allotropic molecule borospherene (B₄₀) was announced in July 2014.^[33]

Amorphous boron

Amorphous boron contains B₁₂ regular icosahedra that are randomly bonded to each other without long range order.^[34] Pure amorphous boron can be produced by thermal decomposition of diborane at temperatures below 1000 °C. Annealing at 1000 °C converts amorphous boron to β-rhombohedral boron.^[35] Amorphous boron nanowires (30–60 nm thick) or fibers^[36] can be produced by magnetron sputtering and laser-assisted chemical vapor deposition, respectively; and they also convert to β-rhombohedral boron nanowires upon annealing at 1000 °C.

Bibliography

• Book: Amberger, E. . 1981 . Elemental boron . Gmelin handbook of inorganic and organometallic chemistry: B Boron, Supplement 2 . Buschbeck . K. C. . 1–112 . Berlin . Springer-Verlag . 8th . 3-540-93448-0.
• Book: Donohue, J. . 1982 . The structures of the elements . Malabar, Florida . Robert E. Krieger . 0-89874-230-7.
• Hoard . J. L. . Sullenger . D. B. . Kennard . C. H. L. . Hughes . R. E. . January 1970 . The structure analysis of β-rhombohedral boron . Journal of Solid State Chemistry . 1 . 2 . 268–277 . 10.1016/0022-4596(70)90022-8. 1970JSSCh...1..268H .
• Book: Housecroft . C. E. . Sharpe . A. G. . 2008 . Inorganic chemistry . Harlow . Pearson Education . 3rd . 978-0-13-175553-6.
• Book: Madelung, O. . 1983 . Landolt-Bornstein numerical data and functional relationships in science and technology. New series. Group III. Volume 17: Semiconductors. Subvolume e: Physics of non-tetrahedrally bonded elements and binary compounds I . Springer-Verlag: New York . 0-387-11780-6.
• Nelmes . R. J. . Loveday . J. S. . Allan . D. R. . Besson . J. M. . Hamel . G. . Grima . P. . Hull . S. . 1993 . Neutron- and x-ray-diffraction measurements of the bulk modulus of boron . Physical Review B . 47 . 13 . 7668–7673 . 1993PhRvB..47.7668N . 10.1103/PhysRevB.47.7668 . 10004773.
• Oganov . A. R. . Chen . J. . Ma . Y. . Glass . C. W. . Yu . Z. . Kurakevych . O. O. . Solozhenko . V. L. . 12 Feb 2009 . Ionic high-pressure form of elemental boron . Nature . 457 . 7027 . 863–868 . 0911.3192 . 2009Natur.457..863O . 10.1038/nature07736 . 19182772. 4412568 .
• Sullenger . D. B. . Phipps . K. D. . Seabaugh . P. W. . Hudgens . C. R. . Sands . D. E. . Cantrell . J. S. . 1969 . Boron modifications produced in an induction-coupled argon plasma . Science . 163 . 3870 . 935‒937 . 1969Sci...163..935S . 10.1126/science.163.3870.935 . 17737317. 25956278 .
• Talley . C. P. . La Placa . S. . Post . B. . 1960 . A new polymorph of boron . Acta Crystallographica . 13 . 3 . 271‒2 . 10.1107/S0365110X60000613 .
• Wang . Y. Q. . Duan . X. F. . 2003 . Crystalline boron nanowires . Applied Physics Letters . 82 . 2 . 272 . 2003ApPhL..82..272W . 10.1063/1.1536269 . 122278136.
• Wentorf . R. H. . 1965 . Boron: Another form . Science . 147 . 3653 . 49–50 . 1965Sci...147...49W . 10.1126/science.147.3653.49 . 17799779. 20539654 .
• Book: Wiberg, N. . 2001 . Inorganic chemistry . San Diego . Academic Press . 0-12-352651-5.
• Will . G. . Kiefer . B. . 2001 . Electron deformation density in rhombohedral α-boron . Zeitschrift für anorganische und allgemeine Chemie . 627 . 9 . 2100‒104 . 10.1002/1521-3749(200109)627:9<2100::AID-ZAAC2100>3.0.CO;2-G.
• Zarechnaya . E. Y. . Dubrovinsky . L. . Dubrovinskaia . N. . Filinchuk . Y. . Chernyshov . D. . Dmitriev . V. . Miyajima . N. . El Goresy . A. . Braun . H. . 2009 . Superhard semiconducting optically transparent high pressure phase of boron . Physical Review Letters . 102 . 18 . 185501‒4 . 2009PhRvL.102r5501Z . 10.1103/PhysRevLett.102.185501 . 19518885 . 14942345 . 8.

Notes and References

1. Encyclopedia: Lundström . T. . J. J. . Zuckerman . A. P. . Hagen . Inorganic reactions and methods . Vol. 13: The formation of bonds to group-I, -II, and -IIIB elements . The solubility in the various modifications of boron . 2009 . John Wiley & Sons . New York . 978-0-470-14549-4 . 196–97.
2. [Vickers hardness]
3. Book: Lide, D. R. . CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 84th Edition. CRC Press. Boca Raton, Florida. 2003. Section 4, Properties of the Elements and Inorganic Compounds; Melting, boiling, and critical temperatures of the elements.
4. 10.1149/1.2428689. High-Purity Crystalline Boron. 1958. D. R. . Stern. Journal of the Electrochemical Society. 105. 676. Lynds. Lahmer. 11. free.
5. Boron. I. Preparation and properties of pure crystalline boron. 10.1021/ja01250a036. 1943. Journal of the American Chemical Society. 65. 1924. 10. Laubengayer. A. W.. Hurd. D. T.. Newkirk. A. E.. Hoard. J. L..
6. Book: Semiconductor materials. registration. Berger, L. I. . CRC Press. 1996. 0-8493-8912-7. 37–43.
7. On the hardness of a new boron phase, orthorhombic γ-B₂₈. Journal of Superhard Materials. 30. 2008. 428–429. 10.3103/S1063457608060117. 6. Solozhenko. V. L.. Kurakevych. O. O.. Oganov. A. R.. 1101.2959. 15066841.
8. Uemura . Naoki . Shirai . Koun . Hagen . Eckert . Jens . Kunstmann . 2016 . Structure, nonstoichiometry, and geometrical frustration of α-tetragonal boron . Physical Review B . 93 . 104101 . 10.1103/PhysRevB.93.104101 . 1602.01796 .
9. Hayami . Wataru . 2015 . Structural stability and electronic properties of β-tetragonal boron: A first-principles study . Journal of Solid State Chemistry . 221 . 378–383 . 10.1016/j.jssc.2014.10.012 .
10. Book: E. L.. Muetterties. The chemistry of boron and its compounds. John Wiley & Sons. New York. 25–154 (29, 82). J. L.. Hoard. R. E.. Hughes. Chapter 2: Elementary boron and compounds of high boron content: Structure, properties and polymorphism. 1967.
11. Black when viewed by reflected light; red by transmitted light
12. High purity amorphous boron powder is black whereas impure samples have a brown appearance: Lidin R. A. (1996). Inorganic substances handbook. New York: Begell House. p. 22; Zenkov . V. S. . 2006 . Adsorption-chemical activity of finely-dispersed amorphous powders of brown and black boron used in synthesizing metal borides . Powder Metallurgy and Metal Ceramics . 45 . 5–6. 279–282 (279) . 10.1007/s11106-006-0076-z . 97019942 . ; Loryan . V. E. . Borovinskaya . I. P. . Merzhanov . A. G. . 2011 . On combustion of boron in nitrogen gas . International Journal of Self-Propagating High-Temperature Synthesis . 20 . 3. 153–155 . 10.3103/S106138621103006X . 97864958 . ; Kanel . G. I. . Utkin . A. V. . Razorenov . S. V. . 2009 . Rate of the energy release in high explosives containing nano-size boron particles . Central European Journal of Energetic Materials . 6 . 1. 15–30 (18) .
13. 1943 was when the supposed structure was first reported; 1973 was when it was first reported that pure α-tetragonal boron can only be synthesized as thin layers deposited on an underlying substrate of isotropic boron carbide or nitride: Kunzmann, P. M. (1973). Structural studies on the crystal chemistry of icosahedral boron framework structure derivatives. PhD thesis. Cornell University; Amberger, E. (1981). "Elemental boron". In Buschbeck, K. C.. Gmelin handbook of inorganic and organometallic chemistry: B Boron, Supplement 2 (8th ed.). Berlin: Springer-Verlag. pp. 1–112 (60–61). .
14. γ-Boron was previously obtained in 1965, but its structure was not determined (see below).
15. E.. Weintraub . 1911. On the properties and preparation of the element boron . The Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry . 3. 299–301 (299). 10.1021/ie50029a007. 5 . Both in appearance and in its curved conchoidal fracture the lump and the broken-up pieces most nearly resemble black diamond ... with an amorphous structure..
16. A. W.. Laubengayer . A. E.. Brandaur . R. L.. 1942. Progress in the preparation and determination of the properties of boron. Journal of Chemical Education . 19. 382–85. 10.1021/ed019p382. 8. Boron ... shows a considerable tendency to assume the vitreous condition ... Volatile compounds of boron such as the halides and the hydrides have been decomposed by passing their vapors through an arc or by bringing them in contact with a hot surface or filament. Boron of high purity is reported procurable by this method, but it is either a very fine powder or of vitreous structure. . Brandaur. 1942JChEd..19..382L .
17. The Structure of Tetragonal Boron. 10.1021/ja01550a019. 1958 . Journal of the American Chemical Society. 80. 4507. 17. Hoard. J. L.. Hughes. R. E.. Sands. D. E..
18. A Unifying Electron-Counting Rule for Macropolyhedral Boranes, Metallaboranes, and Metallocenes. Jemmis, E.D. . Balakrishnarajan, M.M. . Pancharatna, P.D.. J. Am. Chem. Soc.. 123. 2001. 4313–4323. 10.1021/ja003233z. 11457198. 18.
19. Electronic structure and bonding of β-rhombohedral boron using cluster fragment approach. Prasad, D.L.V.K. . Balakrishnarajan, M.M. . Jemmis, E.D.. Phys. Rev. B. 72. 19 . 2005. 195102. 10.1103/PhysRevB.72.195102 . 2005PhRvB..72s5102P.
20. Thermodynamic stability of boron: The role of defects and zero point motion . van Setten M.J. . Uijttewaal M.A. . de Wijs G.A. . de Groot R.A. . J. Am. Chem. Soc. . 129 . 2007 . 2458–2465 . 10.1021/ja0631246 . 17295480 . 9 . 2019-12-01 . 2021-04-15 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210415015024/https://pure.rug.nl/ws/files/2796591/2007JAmChemSocvSetten.pdf . dead .
21. Symmetry-broken crystal structure of elemental boron at low temperature. Widom M. . Mihalkovic M. . Phys. Rev. B. 77. 2008. 064113. 10.1103/PhysRevB.77.064113. 6. 2008PhRvB..77f4113W . 0712.0530 . 27321818 .
22. Book: Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology . 2001-01-26 . Wiley . 978-0-471-48494-3 . Kirk-Othmer . 1 . en . 10.1002/0471238961.0215181510011419.a01.pub2.
23. Bildung der gitter des reinen bors. Amberger, E. . Ploog, K. . J. Less-Common Met.. 23. 21. 1971. 10.1016/0022-5088(71)90004-X.
24. Kohlenstoff-induzierte gitter beim bor: I-tetragonales (B₁₂)₄B₂C und (B₁₂)₄B₂C₂. Ploog, K. . Amberger, E.. J. Less-Common Met.. 23. 33. 1971. 10.1016/0022-5088(71)90005-1.
25. Crystal structure of tetragonal boron related to α-AlB₁₂. Journal of Solid State Chemistry. 28. 1979. 289. 10.1016/0022-4596(79)90080-X. 1979JSSCh..28..289V. 3 . Vlasse. M.. Naslain. R.. Kasper. J. S.. Ploog. K..
26. E. Y.. Zarechnaya. L.. Dubrovinsky. N.. Dubrovinskaia. N.. Miyajima. Y.. Filinchuk. D.. Chernyshov. V.. Dmitriev. Synthesis of an orthorhombic high pressure boron phase. Science and Technology of Advanced Materials. 9. 2008. 10.1088/1468-6996/9/4/044209. 044209‒12 . 4. 2008STAdM...9d4209Z. 5099640. 27878026.
27. G. T.. McConville. D. B.. Sullenger. R. E.. Zielinski. D. U.. Gubser. D. E.. Sands . J. S.. Cantrell . 1976. Some physical properties of cubic boron. Physics Letters A . 58. 257‒259. 10.1016/0375-9601(76)90091-8 . 4 . 1976PhLA...58..257M .
28. Eremets, M. I. . Superconductivity in Boron. 10.1126/science.1062286 . Science . 293 . 2001 . 11452118. 5528. 2001Sci...293..272E. 272–4 . 23001035. etal. Mikhail Eremets.
29. High-pressure metallic phases of boron. Phys. Rev. B . 42. 1990. 10.1103/PhysRevB.42.9033. 9995117 . 1990PhRvB..42.9033M. 14 . Mailhiot . C. . Grant . J. B. . McMahan . A. K. . 9033–9039 .
30. Encyclopedia: Polian . A. . Ovsyannikov . S. V. . Gauthier . M. . Munsch . M. . Chervin . J-C . Lemarchand . G. . E . Boldyreva . Elena Boldyreva . P. . Dera . High-pressure crystallography: From fundamental phenomena to technological applications: Proceedings of the NATO Advanced Study Institute on High-Pressure Crystallography: Advanced Armor Materials and Protection from Explosives, Erice, Italy, 4‒14 June 2009 . Boron and boron-rich solids at high pressures. 2010 . Springer Science+Business Media. Dordrecht. 978-90-481-9257-1. 241‒250 (242).
31. J.. Zhao. J. P.. Lu. Pressure-induced metallization in solid boron. Physical Review B. 66. 092101 to 092105. 9. 10.1103/PhysRevB.66.092101. cond-mat/0109550 . 2002PhRvB..66i2101Z . 2002. 119426107.
32. Synthesis of borophenes: Anisotropic, two-dimensional boron polymorphs. Science. 2015. 1513–1516. 350. 6267. 10.1126/science.aad1080. 26680195. en. A. J.. Mannix. X.-F.. Zhou. B.. Kiraly. J. D.. Wood. D.. Alducin. B. D.. Myers. X.. Liu. B. L.. Fisher. U.. Santiago. 2015Sci...350.1513M. 4922135.
33. 10.1038/nchem.1999. 25054944. 1755-4349. advance online publication. 8. 727–731. Zhai. Hua-Jin. Ya-Fan . Zhao . Wei-Li . Li . Qiang . Chen . Hui . Bai . Han-Shi . Hu . Zachary A. . Piazza . Wen-Juan . Tian . Hai-Gang . Lu . Yan-Bo . Wu . Yue-Wen . Mu . Guang-Feng . Wei . Zhi-Pan . Liu . Jun . Li . Si-Dian . Li . Lai-Sheng . Wang. Observation of an all-boron fullerene. Nature Chemistry. 2014-07-13. 2014NatCh...6..727Z .
34. A neutron diffraction study of amorphous boron using a pulsed source. R. G. . Delaplane. U.. Dahlborg. W. S.. Howells. T.. Lundström. Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids. 106. 1–3. 1988. 66–69. 10.1016/0022-3093(88)90229-3. 1988JNCS..106...66D .
35. Crystallization of Massive Amorphous Boron. Gillespie, J. S. Jr.. J. Am. Chem. Soc.. 1966. 88. 2423. 10.1021/ja00963a011. 11.
36. Microfabrication of three-dimensional boron structures by laser chemical processing. J. Appl. Phys.. 72. 5956. 1992. 10.1063/1.351904. Johansson, S. . 1992JAP....72.5956J. 12 . etal.