Yajurveda Explained

Religion:Historical Vedic religion
Hinduism
Language:Vedic Sanskrit
Period:Vedic period (BCE)
Chapters:40 adhyayas
Verses:1,975 mantras[1]

The Yajurveda (Sanskrit: [[wikt:यजुर्वेद|यजुर्वेद]],, from यजुस्, "worship",[2] and वेद, "knowledge") is the Veda primarily of prose mantras for worship rituals.[3] An ancient Vedic Sanskrit text, it is a compilation of ritual-offering formulas that were said by a priest while an individual performed ritual actions such as those before the yajna fire.[3] Yajurveda is one of the four Vedas, and one of the scriptures of Hinduism. The exact century of Yajurveda's composition is unknown, and estimated by Witzel to be between 1200 and 800 BCE, contemporaneous with Samaveda and Atharvaveda.

The Yajurveda is broadly grouped into two – the "black" or "dark" (Krishna) Yajurveda and the "white" or "bright" (Shukla) Yajurveda. The term "black" implies "the un-arranged, unclear, motley collection" of verses in Yajurveda, in contrast to the "white" which implies the "well arranged, clear" Yajurveda.[4] The black Yajurveda has survived in four recensions, while two recensions of white Yajurveda have survived into modern times.

The earliest and most ancient layer of Yajurveda samhita includes about 1,875 verses, that are distinct yet borrow and build upon the foundation of verses in Rigveda.[5] [6] The middle layer includes the Satapatha Brahmana, one of the largest Brahmana texts in the Vedic collection.[7] The youngest layer of Yajurveda text includes the largest collection of primary Upanishads, influential to various schools of Hindu philosophy. These include the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, the Isha Upanishad, the Taittiriya Upanishad, the Katha Upanishad, the Shvetashvatara Upanishad and the Maitri Upanishad.[8] [9]

Two of the oldest surviving manuscript copies of the Shukla Yajurveda sections have been discovered in Nepal and Western Tibet, and these are dated to the 12th-century CE.[10]

Etymology

Yajurveda is a compound Sanskrit word, composed of yajus (यजुस्) and Veda (वेद). Monier-Williams translates yajus as "religious reverence, veneration, worship, sacrifice, a sacrificial prayer, formula, particularly mantras uttered in a peculiar manner at a sacrifice".[11] Veda means "knowledge". Johnson states yajus means "(mostly) prose formulae or mantras, contained in the Yajur Veda, which are muttered".[12]

Michael Witzel interprets Yajurveda to mean a "knowledge text of prose mantras" used in Vedic rituals.[3] Ralph Griffith interprets the name to mean "knowledge of sacrifice or sacrificial texts and formulas".[13] Carl Olson states that Yajurveda is a text of "mantras (sacred formulas) that are repeated and used in rituals".[14]

Dating and historical context

The core text of the Yajurveda falls within the classical Mantra period of Vedic Sanskrit at the end of the 2nd millennium BCE – younger than the Rigveda, and roughly contemporary with the Atharvaveda, the Rigvedic Khilani, and the .[15] The scholarly consensus dates the bulk of the Yajurveda and Atharvaveda hymns to the early Indian Iron Age, after c. 1200 and before 800 BCE.

Text

Recensions

The Yajurveda text includes Shukla Yajurveda of which about 16 recensions are known, while the Krishna Yajurveda may have had as many as 86 recensions. Only two recensions of the Shukla Yajurveda have survived, Madhyandina and Kanva, and others are known by name only because they are mentioned in other texts. These two recensions are nearly the same, except for a few differences. In contrast to Shukla Yajurveda, the four surviving recensions of Krishna Yajurveda are very different versions.[16]

Shukla Yajurveda

The samhita in the Shukla Yajurveda is called the Vajasaneyi Samhita. The name Vajasaneyi is derived from Vajasaneya, the patronymic of Yajnavalkya, and the founder of the Vajasaneyi branch. There are two (nearly identical) surviving recensions of the Vajasaneyi Samhita (VS): Vajasaneyi Madhyandina and Vajasaneyi Kanva.[16] The lost recensions of the White Yajurveda, mentioned in other texts of ancient India, include Jabala, Baudhya, Sapeyi, Tapaniya, Kapola, Paundravatsa, Avati, Paramavatika, Parasara, Vaineya, Vaidheya, Katyayana and Vaijyavapa.[17]

Recensions of the White Yajurveda
width=120px style="background: #ffad66;" Recension Name width=40px Adhyayas width=40px Anuvakas width= 40px No. of Verses width= 200px Regional presence width=60px Reference
width=120px Madhyandina width=40px 40 width=40px 303 width= 40px 1975 width= 200px Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, North India width=60px [18]
width=120px Kanva width=40px 40 width=40px 328 width= 40px 2086 width= 200px Maharashtra, Odisha, Telangana, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu width=60px [19]
Shukla Yajurveda Shaakhaas!Shakha!Samhita!Brahmana!Aranyaka!Upanishad
Madhyandina (VSM)Vajasneyi Samhita(Madhyandin)Madhyandina Shatapatha (SBM)survives as Shatapatha XIV.1–8, with accents.Brihadaranyaka Upanishad
Kanva (VSK)Vajasneyi Samhita(Kanva)Kanva Shatapatha (SBK)

(different from madhyandina)

survives as book XVII of SBKBrihadaranyaka Upanishad(different from above)

Krishna Yajurveda

There are four surviving recensions of the Krishna Yajurveda –,, and .[20] A total of eighty six recensions are mentioned to exist in Vayu Purana, however vast majority of them are believed to be lost.[21] The Katha school is referred to as a sub-school of Carakas (wanderers) in some ancient texts of India, because they did their scholarship as they wandered from place to place.[22] In contrast to the Shukla Yajurveda, the saṃhitās of the Krishna Yajurveda contained both mantras and explanatory prose (which would usually belong to the brāhmaṇas).

Recensions of the Black Yajurveda
width=120px style="background: #ffad66;" Recension Name width= 50px No. of Sub-recensions width=40px Kanda width=40px Prapathaka width= 40px No. of Mantras width= 200px Regional presence width=60px Reference
width=120px Taittiriya width= 50px 2 width=40px 7 width=40px 42 width= 40px width= 200px South India width=60px [23]
width=120px Maitrayani width= 50px 6 width=40px 4 width=40px 54 width= 40px width= 200px Western India width=60px [24]
width=120px Kāṭhaka (Caraka) width= 50px 12 width=40px 5 width=40px 40 width= 40px 3093 width= 200px Kashmir, North India, East India width=60px [25]
width=120px Kapiṣṭhala width= 50px 5 width=40px 6 width=40px 48 width= 40px width= 200px Extinct width=60px [26]
Krishna Yajurveda Shaakhaas!Shakha!Samhita!Brahmana!Aranyaka!Upanishad
TaittiriyaTaittiriya SamhitaTaittiriya Brahmana and Vadhula Brahmana

(part of Vadhula Srautrasutra)

Taittiriya AranyakaTaittiriya Upanishad
MaitrayaniMaitrayani SamhitaNot Availablevirtually same as the UpanishadMaitrayaniya Upanishad
Caraka-KathaKatha SamhitaŚatādhyāya Brāhmaṇa (only exists in fragments)[27] Katha Aranyaka (almost the entire text from a solitary manuscript)Kathaka Upanishad,

Katha-Shiksha Upanishad

The best known and best preserved of these recensions is the . Some attribute it to Tittiri, a pupil of Yaska and mentioned by Panini.[28] The text is associated with the Taittiriya school of the Yajurveda, and attributed to the pupils of sage Tittiri (literally, partridge birds).[29]

The is the oldest Yajurveda Samhita that has survived, and it differs largely in content from the Taittiriyas, as well as in some different arrangement of chapters, but is much more detailed.[30]

The or the , according to tradition was compiled by Katha, a disciple of Vaisampayana.[30] Like the Maitrayani Samhita, it offers much more detailed discussion of some rituals than the younger Taittiriya samhita that frequently summarizes such accounts.[30] The or the , named after the sage Kapisthala is extant only in some large fragments and edited without accent marks.[30] This text is practically a variant of the .

Organization

Each regional edition (recension) of Yajurveda had Samhita, Brahmana, Aranyakas, Upanishads as part of the text, with Shrautasutras, Grhyasutras and Pratishakhya attached to the text. In Shukla Yajurveda, the text organization is same for both Madhayndina and Kanva shakhas.[16] [17] The texts attached to Shukla Yajurveda include the Katyayana Shrautasutra, Paraskara Grhyasutra and Shukla Yajurveda Pratishakhya.

In Krishna Yajurveda, each of the recensions has or had their Brahmana text mixed into the Samhita text, thus creating a motley of the prose and verses, and making it unclear, disorganized.[4] [30]

Contents

Samhitas

The Vajasaneyi Samhita has forty chapters or adhyayas, containing the formulas used with the following rituals:[31]

Chapters of the White Yajurveda
width=50pxChapter No. width=80px style="background: #ffad66;" Ritual Name width=40px Time width= 340px style="background: #ffad66;" Nature of Ritual width=60px Reference
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 1–2 width=80px Darṣapūrṇamāsa (Full and new moon rituals) width=40px style="text-align: center" 2 days width= 340px Offer cow milk to fire. Separate calves from the cows. width=60px [32] [33]
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 3 width=80px Agnihotraand Cāturmāsya width=40px style="text-align: center" 1 day, 4 months width= 340px The former is the daily oblation of milk into the fire, and the latter is the seasonal sacrifices at the beginning of the three seasons. width=60px [34]
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 4–8 width=80px width=40px style="text-align: center" width= 340px Bathe in river. Offer milk and soma to fire. Offerings to deities of thought, speech. Prayer to Indra to harm no crop, guard the cattle, expel demons. width=60px [35]
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 9–10 width=80px width=40px style="text-align: center" width= 340px The former is a variant of the soma sacrifice which involves a chariot race, and the latter is a variant of the soma sacrifice in which a king is consecrated. width=60px [36]
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 11–18 width=80px width=40px style="text-align: center" 360 width= 340px Formulas and rituals for building altars and hearths for Agni yajna, with largest in the shape of outspread eagle or falcon. width=60px [37]
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 19–21 width=80px Sautrāmaṇī width=40px style="text-align: center" width= 340px Ritual that deals with the overindulgence of soma, and to assure victory and success. width=60px [38]
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 22–25 width=80px width=40px style="text-align: center" 180 or 360 width= 340px Horse sacrifice ritual conducted by kings. width=60px [39]
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 26–29 width=80px width=40px style="text-align: center" width= 340px Supplementary formulas for above sacrifices width=60px [40]
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 30–31 width=80px Puruṣamedha width=40px style="text-align: center" width= 340px Symbolic sacrifice of Purusha (Cosmic Man). Nominal victim played the part, but released uninjured after the ceremony, according to Max Muller[41] and others.[42] A substitute for Ashvamedha (horse sacrifice). The ritual plays out the cosmic creation. width=60px [43]
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 32–34 width=80px Sarvamedha width=40px style="text-align: center" 10 width= 340px Stated to be more important than Purushamedha above. This ritual is a sacrifice for Universal Success and Prosperity. Ritual for one to be wished well, or someone leaving the home, particularly for solitude and moksha, who is offered "curd and ghee (clarified butter)". width=60px [44]
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 35 width=80px Pitriyajna width=40px style="text-align: center" width= 340px Ritual funeral-related formulas for cremation. Sacrifice to the Fathers and Ancestors. width=60px [45]
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 36–39 width=80px width=40px style="text-align: center" width= 340px According to Griffith, the ritual is for long life, unimpaired faculties, health, strength, prosperity, security, tranquility and contentment. Offerings of cow milk and grains to yajna fire. width=60px [46]
height=50px width=120px style="text-align: center" 40 width=80px width=40px style="text-align: center" width= 340px This chapter is not an external sacrifice ritual-related. It is Isha Upanishad, a philosophical treatise about inner Self (Atman, Soul). The verse 40.6 states, "The man who in his Self beholds all creatures and all things that be, And in all beings sees his Self, then he doubts no longer, ponders not. width=60px [47]
Structure of the mantrasThe various ritual mantras in the Yajurveda Samhitas are typically set in a meter, and call on Vedic deities such as the Savita (Sun), Indra, Agni, Prajapati, Rudra and others. The Taittiriya Samhita in Book 4, for example, includes the following verses for the Agnicayana ritual recitation (abridged),

Satapatha Brahmana

See main article: article and Satapatha Brahmana. The title Satapatha Brahmana means "Brahmana of the Hundred Paths".[48] It is one of the largest Brahmana text that has survived.[48] It includes, states Staal, a "veritable encyclopedia of meandering opinions on ritual and other matters".[48]

The Satapatha Brahmana was translated by Eggeling in late 19th-century, reprinted often and has been well read because of the translation. However, it has been misinterpreted and misused, states Staal, because "it contains enough material to support any theory".[48] Eggeling, the first translator of Satapatha Brahmana called it "flimsy symbolism rather than serious reasoning", similar to "speculative vaporings" found in the Christian and non-Christian variety of Gnosticism.[48] [49]

Upanishads

The Yajurveda has six primary Upanishads embedded within it.[9]

Brihadaranyaka Upanishad

The Brihadaranyaka Upanishad is found in the White Yajurveda.[4] It is one of the Mukhya Upanishads, and among the largest and oldest as well (~700 BCE).[8] It is a key scripture of Hinduism that has influenced all schools of Hindu philosophy. The text is a treatise on Ātman (Soul, Self), with passages on metaphysics, ethics and a yearning for knowledge that influenced various Indian religions, ancient and medieval scholars.[50] [51] [52]

The Brihadaranyaka Upanishad is among the earliest extensive discussions of the Hindu concept of dharma, karma and moksha (liberation from sorrow, freedom, emancipation, self-realization). Paul Deussen calls it, "unique in its richness and warmth of presentation", with profoundness that retains its full worth in modern times.[53] Max Muller illustrated its style as follows,

Isha Upanishad

The Isha Upanishad is found in the White Yajurveda.[4] It is one of the shortest Upanishads, embedded as the final chapter of the Shukla Yajurveda. A key scripture of the Vedanta sub-schools of Hinduism, its name is derived from "hidden in the Lord (Self)".[54]

The Isha Upanishad discusses the Atman (Soul, Self) theory of Hinduism, and is referenced by both Dvaita (dualism) and Advaita (non-dualism) sub-schools of Vedanta.[55] [56] It is classified as a "poetic Upanishad" along with Kena, Katha, Svetasvatara and Mandukya Upanishads.[57]

Taittiriya Upanishad

The Taittiriya Upanishad is found in the black Yajurveda.[4] It is the seventh, eighth and ninth chapters of Taittiriya Aranyaka, which are also called, respectively, the Siksha Valli, the Ananda Valli and the Bhrigu Valli.[4] [58]

The Taittiriya Upanishad includes verses that are partly prayers and benedictions, partly instruction on phonetics and praxis, partly advice on ethics and morals given to graduating students from ancient Vedic gurukul (schools), partly a treatise on allegory, and partly philosophical instruction.[4]

The text offers a view of education system in ancient India. It also includes sections on ethics and invocation for one's personal development. Max Muller translates the text's tenth anuvaka, for example, as an affirmation of one's Self as a capable, empowered blissful being. The tenth anuvaka asserts, "I am he who shakes the tree. I am glorious like the top of a mountain. I, whose pure light (of knowledge) has risen, am that which is truly immortal, as it resides in the sun. I (Soul, Self) am the treasure, wise, immortal, imperishable. This is the teaching of the Veda, by sage Trisanku."[59]

Katha Upanishad

The Katha Upanishad is found in the black Yajurveda.[4] The Upanishad is the legendary story of a little boy, Nachiketa – the son of sage Vajasravasa, who meets Yama – the Indian deity of death. Their conversation evolves to a discussion of the nature of man, knowledge, Ātman (Soul, Self) and moksha (liberation).[60]

The Kathaka Upanishad is an important ancient Sanskrit corpus of the Vedanta sub-schools. It asserts that "Atman (Soul, Self) exists", teaches the precept "seek Self-knowledge which is Highest Bliss", and expounds on this premise like the other primary Upanishads of Hinduism. The detailed teachings of Katha Upanishad have been variously interpreted, as Dvaita (dualistic)[61] and as Advaita (non-dualistic).[62] [63] [64]

The Katha Upanishad found in the Yajurveda is among the most widely studied Upanishads. Philosophers such as Arthur Schopenhauer praised it, Edwin Arnold rendered it in verse as "The Secret of Death", and Ralph Waldo Emerson credited Katha Upanishad for the central story at the end of his essay Immortality, as well as his poem "Brahma".[62] [65]

Shvetashvatara Upanishad

The Shvetashvatara Upanishad is found in the black Yajurveda.[4] The text opens with metaphysical questions about the primal cause of all existence, its origin, its end, and what role if any did time, nature, necessity, chance, the spirit had as primal cause?[66] It then develops its answer, concluding that "the Universal Soul exists in every individual, it expresses itself in every creature, everything in the world is a projection of it, and that there is Oneness, a unity of souls in one and only Self".

The Shvetashvatara Upanishad is notable for its discussion of the concept of personal god – Ishvara, and suggesting it to be a path to one's own Highest Self.[67] [68] The text is also notable for its multiple mentions of both Rudra and Shiva, along with other Vedic deities, and of crystallization of Shiva as a central theme.[68]

Maitrayaniya Upanishad

The Maitrayaniya Upanishad, also known as the Maitri Upanishad, is found in the black Yajurveda. It consists of seven Prapathakas (lessons). The first Prapathaka is introductory, the next three are structured in a question-answer style and discuss metaphysical questions relating to Atman (Self, Soul), while the fifth to seventh Prapathaka are supplements.[69] However, several manuscripts discovered in different parts of India contain lesser number of Prapathakas, with a Telugu-language version showing just four.

The common kernel of the Maitri Upanishad across different recensions, states Max Muller, is a reverence for soul, that can be summarized in a few words as, "(Man) is the Self – the immortal, the fearless, the Brahman".[70] The Maitrayaniya Upanishad is notable for its references to theories also found in Buddhism, elements of the Samkhya and Yoga schools of Hinduism, as well as the Ashrama system.[71]

Srautasutras

The Yajurveda had Shrautasutras and Grhyasutras attached to it, from fifteen schools: Apastamba, Agastya, Agniveshyaka, Baudhayana, Bharadvaja, Hiranyakeshi, Kaundinya, Kusidaka, Katyayana, Lokaksita, Madhyamdina, Panca-Kathaka, Satyasadha, Sakala, Sandilya, Vaikhanasa, and Vadula.[72] Of these nine have survived, along with portions of Kaundinya.[72]

Manuscripts and translations

Most surviving manuscripts and recensions of Yajurveda's Samhitas, Aranyakas and Brahmanas remain untranslated into Western languages. The two reliable translations are from British India colonial era, and have been widely studied.[73] These are AB Keith's translation of Taittiriya Samhita of the Black Yajurveda,[74] and Juliu Eggeling's translation of Satapatha Brahmana of the White Yajurveda.[49]

Ralph Griffith published an early translation of White Yajurveda Samhita.[75] However, Frits Staal has questioned his translations and considers them "fantasies and best discarded".[76]

Devi Chand published a re-interpreted translation of Yajurveda in 1965, reprinted as 3rd edition in 1980, wherein the translation incorporated Dayananda Saraswati's monotheistic interpretations of the Vedic text, and the translation liberally adds "O Lord" and "the Creator" to various verses, unlike other translators.[77]

Ezourvedam forgery

In 18th century, French Jesuits published Ezourvedam, claiming it to be a translation of a recension of the Yajurveda.[78] [79] The Ezourveda was studied by Voltaire,[80] and later declared a forgery, representing Jesuit ideas to Indians as a Vedic school.[79]

Significance

The text is a useful source of information about the agriculture, economic and social life during the Vedic era. The verses, for example, list the types of crops considered important in ancient India,

See also

Sources

Further reading

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Construction of the Vedas . VedicGranth.Org . 3 July 2020 . 17 July 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210717035126/https://sites.google.com/a/vedicgranth.org/www/what_are_vedic_granth/the-four-veda/interpretation-and-more/construction-of-the-vedas?mobile=true . dead .
  2. Book: Jean Holm. John Bowker. Worship. 1994. A&C Black. 978-0-567-26232-5. 88.
  3. Michael Witzel (2003), "Vedas and Upaniṣads", in The Blackwell Companion to Hinduism (Editor: Gavin Flood), Blackwell,, pages 76–77
  4. [Paul Deussen]
  5. Antonio de Nicholas (2003), Meditations Through the Rig Veda: Four-Dimensional Man,, pages 273–274
  6. Edmund Gosse,, New York: Appleton, page 181
  7. Frits Staal (2009), Discovering the Vedas: Origins, Mantras, Rituals, Insights, Penguin,, pages 149–153, Quote: "The Satapatha is one of the largest Brahmanas..."
  8. [Paul Deussen]
  9. Patrick Olivelle (1998), Upaniṣhads, Oxford University Press,, pages 1–17
  10. Book: Michael Witzel. Qinyuan Wu. The Two Oldest Veda Manuscripts: Facsimile Edition of Vājasaneyi Saṃhitā 1–20 (Saṃhitā- and Padapāṭha) from Nepal and Western Tibet (c. 1150 CE). Harvard University Press (Harvard Oriental Series 92). 2019. 9780674988262. 1–8.
  11. Monier Monier Williams, Sanskrit English Dictionary, Oxford University Press, Entry for Yajus, page 839
  12. WJ Johnson (2009), Yajus, A Dictionary of Hinduism, Oxford University Press,
  13. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, page xvii
  14. Carl Olson (2007), The Many Colors of Hinduism, Rutgers University Press,, page 13
  15. http://www.people.fas.harvard.edu/~witzel/canon.pdf The Development of the Vedic Canon and its Schools
  16. CL Prabhakar (1972), The Recensions of the Sukla Yajurveda, Archiv Orientální, Volume 40, Issue 1, pages 347–353
  17. GS Rai, Sakhas of the Yajurveda in the Puranas, Purana, Vol 7, No. 1, pages 11–16
  18. GS Rai, Sakhas of the Yajurveda in the Puranas, Purana, Vol 7, No. 1, page 13
  19. GS Rai, Sakhas of the Yajurveda in the Puranas, Purana, Vol 7, No. 1, page 14
  20. Michael Witzel, Early Sanskritization, Origins and Development of the Kuru State, Harvard University (1996)
  21. GS Rai, Sakhas of the Krsna Yajurveda in the Puranas, Purana, Vol 7, No. 2, page 235
  22. GS Rai, Sakhas of the Krsna Yajurveda in the Puranas, Purana, Vol 7, No. 2, pages 236–238
  23. AB Keith, THE VEDA OF THE BLACK YAJUS SCHOOL: Taittiriya Sanhita, Oxford University, pages i–xii
  24. GS Rai, Sakhas of the Krsna Yajurveda in the Puranas, Purana, Vol 7, No. 2, pages 244
  25. GS Rai, Sakhas of the Krsna Yajurveda in the Puranas, Purana, Vol 7, No. 2, pages 238–241
  26. GS Rai, Sakhas of the Krsna Yajurveda in the Puranas, Purana, Vol 7, No. 2, pages 241–242
  27. Web site: Jamison. Stephanie W.. Witzel. Michael. 1992. Vedic Hinduism.
  28. Book: Dowson, John . A Classical Dictionary of Hindu Mythology, and Religion, Geography, History . Rupa & Co. . 319 . Calcutta . 1879 . 1984.
  29. A Weber,, Trubner & Co, pages 87–91
  30. GS Rai, Sakhas of the Krsna Yajurveda in the Puranas, Purana, Vol 7, No. 2, pages 235–253
  31. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, page i–xvi
  32. Frits Staal (2009), Discovering the Vedas: Origins, Mantras, Rituals, Insights, Penguin,, page 124
  33. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 1–16
  34. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 17–25
  35. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 26–70
  36. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 71–86
  37. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 87–171
  38. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 172–204
  39. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 205–234
  40. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 235–254
  41. Max Muller,, Volume 44, Part 5, Oxford University Press; Also see A Weber's agreement that this was symbolic on page 413
  42. Oliver Leaman (2006), Encyclopedia of Asian Philosophy, Routledge,, page 557, Quote: "It should be mentioned that although provision is made for human sacrifice (purusha-medha) this was purely symbolic and did not involve harm to anyone".
  43. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 255–263
  44. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 264–287
  45. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 288–290
  46. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 291–303
  47. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus, pages 304–310
  48. Frits Staal (2009), Discovering the Vedas: Origins, Mantras, Rituals, Insights, Penguin,, pages 151–152
  49. Julius Eggeling, Satapatha Brahmana, Part 1, Book 1 and 2, Max Muller (Editor), Oxford University Press, page ix Introduction
  50. https://archive.org/stream/Brihadaranyaka.Upanishad.Shankara.Bhashya.by.Swami.Madhavananda#page/n0/mode/2up Brihadaranyaka Upanishad with Adi Shankara's commentary
  51. Brihadaranyaka Upanisad with the commentary of Madhvacharya, Translated by Rai Bahadur Sriśa Chandra Vasu (1933),
  52. Patrick Olivelle (1998), Upaniṣhads, Oxford University Press, 1998, pages 1–23
  53. Paul Deussen, Sixty Upanishads of the Veda, Volume 1, Motilal Banarsidass,, page 482
  54. [Max Muller]
  55. AK Bhattacharyya, Hindu Dharma: Introduction to Scriptures and Theology,, pages 25–46
  56. Madhava Acharya, The Commentary of Sri Madhva on Isha and Kena Upanishad, ; also Isavasyopanisad bhasya sangraha,,
  57. Deussen, Paul (1908), The philosophy of the Upanishads
  58. https://archive.org/stream/AitareyataittiriyaUpanishadsWithShankaraBhashya-English/05AitareyataittiriyaUpanishadsWithShankaraBhashya-English#page/n61/mode/2up Taittiriya Upanishad
  59. Max Muller, The Sacred Books of the East, Volume 15, Oxford University Press, Chapter 3: Taittiriya Upanishad, see Siksha Valli – Tenth Anuvaka
  60. Paul Deussen, Sixty Upanishads of the Veda, Volume 1, Motilal Banarsidass,, pages 269–273
  61. Ariel Glucklich (2008), The Strides of Vishnu: Hindu Culture in Historical Perspective, Oxford University Press,, page 70
  62. SH Nasr (1989), Knowledge and the Sacred: Revisioning Academic Accountability, State University of New York Press,, page 99, Quote: "Emerson was especially inebriated by the message of the Upanishads, whose nondualistic doctrine contained so lucidly in the Katha Upanishad, is reflected in his well known poem Brahma".
  63. https://archive.org/stream/upanishadsandsr00agoog#page/n12/mode/2up Kathopanishad
  64. Patrick Olivelle (1996), The Early Upanishads: Annotated Text & Translation, Oxford University Press,, Introduction Chapter
  65. R White (2010), Schopenhauer and Indian Philosophy, International Philosophical Quarterly, vol. 50, issue 1, pages 57–76
  66. Paul Deussen, Sixty Upanishads of the Veda, Volume 1, Motilal Banarsidass,, pages 305 with footnote 2
  67. Max Muller, The Shvetashvatara Upanishad, Oxford University Press, pages xxxii – xlii
  68. Paul Deussen, Sixty Upanishads of the Veda, Volume 1, Motilal Banarsidass,, pages 301–304
  69. Paul Deussen, Sixty Upanishads of the Veda, Volume 1, Motilal Banarsidass,, pages 327–386
  70. Max Muller, The Upanishads, Part 2, Maitrayana-Brahmana Upanishad Introduction, Oxford University Press, pages xliii–lii
  71. Paul Deussen, Sixty Upanishads of the Veda, Volume 1, Motilal Banarsidass,, pages 328–329
  72. Jan Gonda (1977), A History of Indian Literature: The Ritual Sutras, Vol 1, Fasc 2, Otto Harrassowitz,, page 489
  73. Frits Staal (2009), Discovering the Vedas: Origins, Mantras, Rituals, Insights, Penguin,, pages 353, 121–153
  74. AB Keith (1914), Taittiriya Sanhita, Harvard University Press
  75. Ralph Griffith, The texts of the white Yajurveda EJ Lazarus (1899)
  76. Frits Staal (2009), Discovering the Vedas: Origins, Mantras, Rituals, Insights, Penguin,, page 352
  77. Devi Chand (1980), The Yajurveda, 3rd Edition, Munshiram Manoharlal,
  78. Urs App (2011), The Birth of Orientalism. Chapter 1: Voltaire's Veda, University of Pennsylvania Press, pages 433–435
  79. Ludo Rocher (1984), Ezourvedam: A French Veda of the Eighteenth Century, University of Pennsylvania Studies on South Asia,, pages 61–66
  80. Moriz Winternitz and V. Srinivasa Sarma (2010), A History of Indian Literature, Volume 1, Motilal Banarsidass, ISBN, page 11 footnote 1