X International Chopin Piano Competition Explained

The Tenth International Fryderyk Chopin Piano Competition
Venue:National Philharmonic, Warsaw
Holder Label:Winner
Holder: Đặng Thái Sơn
Previous:9th
Main:Chopin Competition
Next:11th

The X International Chopin Piano Competition (Polish: X Międzynarodowy Konkurs Pianistyczny im. Fryderyka Chopina) was held from 1 to 20 October 1980 in Warsaw. Đặng Thái Sơn, who in the final played with an orchestra for the first time in his life, won first prize, becoming the first pianist from Asia to do so. The elimination of Ivo Pogorelić after the third stage was a great source of controversy.

Awards

The competition consisted of three elimination stages and a final with seven pianists.

The following prizes were awarded:[1]

PrizeWinner
Đặng Thái Sơn
Tatiana Shebanova
Arutyun Papazyan
4thnot awarded
5thAkiko Ebi Japan
Poland
6thErik Berchot France
Dan Atanasiu Romania
Bernard d'Ascoli France
Angela Hewitt Canada
Kevin Kenner United States
Alexander Lonquich
Ivo Pogorelić
United States

Three special prizes were awarded:

Special prizeWinner
Best Performance of a ConcertoĐặng Thái Sơn
Tatiana Shebanova
Best Performance of MazurkasĐặng Thái Sơn
Poland
Best Performance of a PolonaiseĐặng Thái Sơn
Tatiana Shebanova

Jury

The jury consisted of:[1]

Pogorelić Scandal

There was a sensation at the 1980 Chopin Competition in Warsaw when, in a decision going against audience opinion, Ivo Pogorelić was not admitted to the final round because of his unconventional interpretations. This came about because of a wide discrepancy in the jury’s marking; half the panel of judges gave him the highest number of points and half the lowest. He was awarded only a special prize for his “exceptionally original pianistic talent”. Others were less fond of his less traditional style of play.

Jury member Eugene List explained: "I'm the first to say that the boy is very talented [...] but I voted very low for him. This is a special kind of competition. It's only Chopin. He doesn't respect the music. He uses extremes to the point of distortion. And he puts on too much of an act." Louis Kentner resigned after the first stage after all of his students had been eliminated from the competition,[1] saying that "if people like Pogorelić make it to the second stage, I cannot participate in the work of the jury. We have different aesthetic criteria."[2]

In the third stage, Pogorelić once again caused controversy, performing his program in the wrong order, leaving the stage part way through, and wearing an extravagant concert attire that made him look like "a prince dropped in the middle of the desert". In the end, Pogorelić was not admitted into the final. Martha Argerich resigned in protest, proclaiming him a "genius" who "her colleagues could not appreciate because of an entrenched conservatism", which is "why she was ashamed to be associated with them". Nikita Magaloff and Paul Badura-Skoda announced their solidarity with Argerich, though coming short of resigning themselves, declaring that it was "unthinkable that such an artist should not make it to the finals".[2] According to Đặng Thái Sơn, the eventual winner, Argerich still sent a public telegram to Warsaw to congratulate him, after learning the final results.[3]

Pogorelić later accused in a one-sided interview in 1993, claiming that "The Soviet Bloc authorities had decided months before the competition that it was politically necessary to have a North Vietnamese winner. My decision to participate was not at all welcome. I was told I should wait a year, for the Tchaikovsky competition, when I would have the first prize guaranteed."[4] In 2008, he demanded an official inquiry into the jury decisions of the 1980 competition, however, the Chopin Institute refused to reopen the case.[2]

Further reading

Notes and References

  1. Web site: The 10th International Fryderyk Chopin Piano Competition. 2021-07-29. Fryderyk Chopin Institute.
  2. McCormick. Lisa. 2018. Pogorelich at the Chopin: Towards a sociology of competition scandals. The Chopin Review. Fryderyk Chopin Institute. 1. 2544-9249. 29 July 2021. 27 January 2022. https://web.archive.org/web/20220127080742/http://chopinreview.com/pages/issue/7/1. dead.
  3. News: Ho. Elijah. 2011-09-22. Interview with Dang Thai Son. The Counterpoints.
  4. News: Henken. John. 1993-01-13. Pogorelich Founds Piano Competition. Los Angeles Times.