| Criminal Penalty: | 30 years imprisonment |
| William Darrell Lindsey | |
| Birth Date: | May 18, 1935 |
| Apprehended: | December 1996 |
| Victims: | 7–25 (six convictions) |
| Criminal Status: | Deceased |
| Children: | 7 |
| Targets: | Prostitutes |
| Birth Place: | Palatka, Florida, U.S |
| Country: | United States |
| Death Place: | Marion Correctional Institute, Ocala, Florida, U.S |
| Conviction: | Second-degree murder (x6) |
| States: | Florida North Carolina |
| Spouse: | |
| Beginyear: | 1983 |
| Endyear: | 1996 |
| Other Names: | "Crazy Bill" |
William Darrell "Bill" Lindsey (born Armstrong; May 18, 1935 – April 17, 2001), also known as Crazy Bill, was an American serial killer who murdered six women in St. Augustine, Florida, and one in Asheville, North Carolina, between 1983 and 1996. As part of a plea deal, he pleaded guilty to six of the murders and received a 30-year sentence in Florida. On April 17, 2001, he died of cancer whilst imprisoned.
William Darrell Lindsey was born William Armstrong Jr. in Palatka on March 18, 1935, the only child of William, a roofer, and Mabel Armstrong, a homemaker. On August 18, 1935, when Lindsey was five months old, he was in the car with his parents when, for unknown reasons, the car swerved off the road and crashed. William and Mabel, in the front and passenger seats, died on impact. Lindsey, found wedged between the front and back seats, only sustained minor scratches and bruises.
A local couple from St. Augustine, Cecil and Olean Lindsey, who had recently experienced the loss of their infant son, adopted William. Besides William, the Lindseys had three other children, two older daughters and a son. Cecil, his adoptive father, was a well-liked man who worked multiple jobs, his favorite being an actor for a local town attraction. Olean, his adoptive mother, was a nurse. Olean, a religious woman, was physically and emotionally abusive to her children. She viewed what was typically considered regular mischievousness as sinful, and felt it was her duty to punish those who perpetrated these actions. She frequently beat her children with frying pans and leather straps, pulled their hair, pinched them, and berated them. Cecil was submissive to his wife, allowing her to discipline their children and control all other household matters while he focused on work and other community events.
During his childhood, William tortured multiple cats, killing one. He also set a hut on fire that other boys in his neighborhood had built. In school, he was described as a c-grade student with low intelligence. He had been held back several times, reaching grade 12 at age 21. A small, meek child, he was bullied by classmates and other children in his neighborhood.[1] Lindsey had no close friends and did not participate in any extracurricular activities. He did, however, have a job as a busboy at a local restaurant.
| Name | Age | Date of death | Place of death | Cause of death | Weapon used | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lisa Foley | 24 | October 9, 1983 | West Pope Road, St. Augustine Beach, Florida | Strangulation | Hands | |
| 1 | Anita McQuaig Stevens | 27 | November 29, 1988 | Fish Island Road, St. Augustine, Florida | Bludgeoning | Wood plank | |
| 2 | Constance Marie "Connie" Terrell | 26 | June 10, 1989 | Holmes Boulevard, St. Augustine, Florida | Gunshot wound to the head | .22 caliber semi-automatic rifle | |
| 3 | Lashawna Streeter | 27 | March 1, 1992 | Four Mile Road, St. Augustine, Florida | Beating | Hands | |
| 4 | Donetha Snead-Haile | 32 | April 1993[2] | King Street, St. Augustine, Florida | Unknown | Unknown | |
| 5 | Cheryl Denise "“Niecey" Lucas | 32 | Mid-June 1995 | Palmer Street, St. Augustine, Florida | Bludgeoning | Metal nail bar | |
| 6 | Diana Richardson | 48 | October 12, 1995 | Holmes Boulevard, St. Augustine, Florida | Beating | Hands | |
| 7 | Lucy Arnett Raymer | 32 | December 25, 1996 | Chunns Cove Rd, Asheville, North Carolina | Blows to the head | ||
| Source:[3] | |||||||
Lindsey was arrested for Lucy Raymer's murder after a taxi driver witnessed her going into Lindsey's trailer on the night of her murder. Detectives soon linked him to the Florida murders as well, and Lindsey made a full confession.[4]
Although he was originally believed to only be responsible for the murders of six women in St. Augustine between 1988 and 1996, it was found he was also responsible for the unsolved 1983 murder of Lisa Foley. Lindsey picked her photo out of a lineup and identified her as a woman he strangled during an argument after sex. Lisa was last seen with Lindsey at the Tradewinds Lounge in downtown St. Augustine on October 9, 1983. Her body was found in a marshy area on West Pope Road near St. Augustine Beach five days later. Lindsey wasn't linked to her murder until January 1997.
On May 21, 1999, he pleaded guilty to four counts of second-degree murder in the cases of Anita Stevens, Constance Terrell, Lashawna Street, and Cheryl Lucas. On July 8 of that year, he pleaded guilty to the two remaining murders – those of Donetha Snead-Haile and Diana Richardson. He was sentenced to 30 years' imprisonment.[5]
On April 17, 2001, Lindsey died from cancer whilst imprisoned at the Marion Correctional Institute in Ocala, Florida.[6]
Season five, episode eight of Investigation Discovery's ‘Evil Lives Here, titled, "I Hate Being Daddy's Girl," is about the childhood of Robin Lindsey, one of Lindsey's daughters.[7]
See also “Deadly Lust” by Marie and McCay Vernon. 2005.