Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind? Explained

Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind?
Cover:Tame Impala Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind? single art.jpg
Type:single
Artist:Tame Impala
Album:Innerspeaker
Released:30 January 2011
Recorded:June–August, 2009
Wave House, Injidup, Western Australia
Genre:Psychedelic rock
Length:3:19
Label:Modular Recordings
Producer:Kevin Parker
Prev Title:Expectation
Prev Year:2010
Next Title:Elephant
Next Year:2012

"Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind?" is a song by the Australian band Tame Impala, released as a single in 2011. It was recorded during the sessions for the Innerspeaker album in 2009, and released as the fourth single from that album. The single features artwork from Australian artist Leif Podhajsky, who also created the artwork for Innerspeaker and the follow-up Lonerism.[1]

Composition

"Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind?" was written by Kevin Parker in the key of F major in a 4/4 time signature.[2] It is based around four repeating barre chords of A minor, B-flat major, E minor and F major, played on electric guitar, to create a trance-like, hypnotic and spacious atmosphere, while the bass is played rhythmically to fill in the guitar spaces.

It starts with three hi-hat hits on the drums, which was included by Parker as a tribute to the Outkast song Hey Ya! which starts with an uncommon three upbeats, rather than the more common four upbeats.[3] Before the verse starts, a pitch-shifted, delayed, fuzz guitar kicks in, which many mistook for a synth,[4] to play a melody in the F major scale, featuring stereo panning effects to give it a sense of movement.[5]

The verse starts, featuring Parker's vocals, which are reverbed and delayed.[6] The lyrics are minimal and only featured in the verses, while a heavily chorused, distorted guitar plays a riff in the choruses.

Another verse comes in repeating the same lyrics, which gives way to a psychedelic outro, featuring many guitar overdubs with effects added to them coming to a crescendo. At only 3:19, "Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind?" is the shortest track on Innerspeaker.

Music video

While an official music video was never made, Pitchfork Media created an unofficial video. It features the band playing a rendition of "Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind?" in a woodland. It was shot in 3D and features strong 3D effects and warbly images that make use of the extra dimension.[7] [8]

Live performances

"Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind?" has featured in almost every single Tame Impala set since the release of Innerspeaker,[9] and was later added to the beginning of the set in 2011, transitioning into "Alter Ego".[10] Live, Parker occasionally incorporates a heavily reverbed, improvised guitar solo in the outro, using the F major scale.

It was performed on Late Night with Jimmy Fallon on the 12 August 2011 episode to an American audience of 3.6 million viewers, on Tame Impala's live television debut.[11] [12] Former bassist Nick Allbrook wasn't present for the performance when there was a delay in the delivery of his visa and was slow to get through customs. Tame Impala's guitar technician, Matt Handley, filled in for Allbrook on bass.[13]

Track listing

  1. "Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind?" – 3:19
  2. "Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind?" (Erol Alkan rework) – 8:14
  3. "Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind?" (Erol Alkan instrumental) – 8:14
  4. "Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind?" (Erol Alkan rework edit) – 4:15

Personnel

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Leif Podhajsky. Leif Podhajsky. 18 July 2012.
  2. Web site: Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind? tab. Ultimate Guitar. 17 July 2012.
  3. Web site: Tame Impala – Artist Advocacy interview. Artist Advocacy. 17 July 2012.
  4. Web site: Tame Impala WOW Magazine Interview. WOW Magazine. 14 July 2012. 6 August 2013. https://web.archive.org/web/20130806165632/http://www.wowmagazine.fr/2010/06/tame-impala-interview-3/. dead.
  5. Web site: Innerspeaker – Pitchfork review. Pitchfork. 17 July 2012.
  6. Web site: Innerspeaker – Amazon Review. Amazon. 17 July 2012.
  7. Web site: Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind? – 3D Video. Pitchfork. 17 July 2012.
  8. Web site: Why Won't You Make Up Your Mind? – Pitchfork. 11 July 2011 . Pitchfork. 17 July 2012.
  9. Web site: Tame Impala – May 14, 2010 setlist. setlist.fm. 17 July 2012.
  10. Web site: Tame Impala – April 15, 2011 setlist. setlist.fm. 17 July 2012.
  11. Web site: Tame Impala – Jimmy Fallon – Modular. Modular. 17 July 2012.
  12. Web site: Late Night with Jimmy Fallon ratings. https://web.archive.org/web/20110912063956/http://tvbythenumbers.zap2it.com/2011/08/18/jay-leno-and-jimmy-fallon-rank-1-vs-abcs-mostly-original-competition-and-cbss-encores-for-the-late-night-week-of-august-8-12/100757/. dead. 12 September 2011. tvbythenumber. 17 July 2012.
  13. Web site: Tame Impala – Jimmy Fallon – The Vine. The Vine. 17 July 2012.