| Litigants: | Whitmore v. Arkansas |
| Arguedate: | January 10 |
| Argueyear: | 1990 |
| Decidedate: | April 24 |
| Decideyear: | 1990 |
| Fullname: | Whitmore, Individually and as Next Friend of Simmons v. Arkansas et al. |
| Usvol: | 495 |
| Uspage: | 149 |
| Docket: | 88-7146 |
| Parallelcitations: | 110 S. Ct. 1717; 109 L. Ed. 2d 135; 1990 U.S. LEXIS 2182 |
| Holding: | The Eighth and the Fourteenth Amendments do not require mandatory appellate review of capital sentences. |
| Oralargument: | https://www.oyez.org/cases/1980-1989/1989/1989_88_7146/argument |
| Majority: | Rehnquist |
| Joinmajority: | White, Blackmun, Stevens, O'Connor, Scalia, Kennedy |
| Dissent: | Marshall |
| Joindissent: | Brennan |
| Lawsapplied: | U.S. Const. amend. VIII, XIV, |
Whitmore v. Arkansas, 495 U.S. 149 (1990), is a U.S. Supreme Court Case that held that the Eighth and the Fourteenth Amendments do not require mandatory appellate review of death penalty cases and that individuals cannot file cases as a next friend unless there is a prior relationship to the appellant and unless the appellant is "unable to litigate his own cause due to mental incapacity, lack of access to court, or other similar disability".
Ronald Gene Simmons was convicted of the mass murder of sixteen people and sentenced to death. Arkansas state law did not require appellate review of capital sentences, and Simmons chose to contest neither the conviction nor the sentence, in fact, requesting a speedy execution:
I, Ronald Gene Simmons, Sr., want it to be known that it is my wish and my desire that absolutely no action by anybody be taken to appeal or in any way change this sentence. It is further respectfully requested that this sentence be carried out expeditiously.Arkansas state law allowed the waiving of capital appeals so long as a separate hearing determined the competence of the condemned man. With Simmons' competence verified, his execution was to proceed when a fellow death row inmate, Jonas Whitmore, filed suit against the state of Arkansas both for himself and on behalf of Simmons.
Whitmore had been sent to Arkansas' death row in 1989 for stabbing to death a 62-year-old woman and robbing her of $250 after she had let him into her home and fed him milk and cookies. Whitmore had exhausted his direct line of appeals within the state and was about to pursue a habeas corpus claim in federal court. Whitmore wanted to see Simmons' case appealed within Arkansas because he believed that if his plea in the federal courts was successful and he was granted a new trial in which he was convicted anew, during sentencing, his single murder would look far less bad than Simmons' massacre of sixteen. Whitmore's attempt to force Simmons's case into appeal was three-pronged, arguing that:
Prior to Whitmore seeking appeal of Simmons' sentence, Louis J. Franz filed an appeal for Simmons as his next friend. Franz was a Catholic priest who ministered to prisoners in Arkansas and was also a member of Arkansas Churches for Life, an anti-death penalty organization. The Arkansas Supreme Court granted a stay of Simmons' execution while they considered Franz's petition.[1] [2] The Arkansas courts ultimately rejected Franz's petition due to the fact that Franz had not established that he had previously met Simmons, let alone had a close relationship to him. Franz also claimed standing as an aggrieved taxpayer and a concerned citizen. Both of those claims were also rejected.[3]
In 1989, the Arkansas Supreme Court, citing Franz's petition, rejected Whitmore's motion to intervene in Simmons' case.
On March 15, 1989, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a stay of execution for Whitmore to give time for it to consider his case.[4] [5]
On March 30, 1989, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit issued a stay of execution.[6]
The Court ruled against Whitmore on April 24, 1990, with Chief Justice Rehnquist writing for the majority of seven.[7] [8]
Justice Marshall wrote a dissent that was joined by Justice Brennan. Justice Marshall concluded that:
Ronald Gene Simmons was executed by lethal injection on June 25, 1990.[9] [10]
Jonas Whitmore was executed on May 11, 1994.[11]
Whitmore was cited in the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals' decision in Hamdi v. Rumsfeld to deny both Christian Peregrim, a private citizen, and Frank Dunham, a public defender for the Eastern District of Virginia, next of friend standing to request habeas relief for Yaser Hamdi, an American-born resident of Kuwait who was captured in Afghanistan.