Warren Spring Laboratory Explained

Warren Spring Laboratory
Lab Type:Environmental research laboratory
Research Field:Pollution, waste management, alternative fuel
Director:
    • S.H. Clarke[1]
    • Charles C. Hall[2]
    • Alan Robinson[3]
    City:Stevenage
    Country:England
    Alumni:Martin Williams
    Location Map:Hertfordshire
    Coordinates:51.885°N -0.2004°W
    Operating Agency:Department of Trade and Industry

    Warren Spring Laboratory was a UK government environmental science research centre that operated in Stevenage, Hertfordshire from 1958 until its closure in 1994.[4] Described by New Scientist as "Britain's leading laboratory for environmental research",[5] and by The Times as "one of Europe's most important environmental research centres",[6] it had an international reputation[7] in areas such as air and water pollution, waste management and recycling, land remediation, alternative fuel research, and chemical engineering.[8] In 1994, after some political controversy, the laboratory was closed and merged with AEA Technology to form the National Environmental Technology Centre (NETCEN).[4]

    Key research

    Broadly, Warren Spring's mission was to monitor and reduce environmental pollution and land contamination, to optimize the use of materials, and to recover useful materials, such as precious metals, from waste.[9] It was organized in separate divisions, which changed over the years. In the early 1960s, the divisions were Atmospheric Pollution; Chemical Engineering and Process Development; Engineering Services and Human Sciences; Extraction of Metals; Mineral Processing; and Physical and Chemical Services.[10] In the early 1990s, the six divisions were: Air Pollution; Pollution Abatement; Materials Recovery; Biological Treatment; Marine Pollution and Bulk Materials; and Chemical Analysis.[9]

    The air pollution division was headed by Sean Craxford and, later, Martin Williams.[3] [11] Initially, its work included tackling the problem of smog, which had contributed to around 12,000 deaths during the 1952 Great Smog of London.[12] [13]

    According to a 1958 article in Nature, the Department of Scientific and Industrial Research (DSIR) wanted Warren Spring "to be a versatile station, free to do work on any subject which becomes important for the nation and which cannot be fitted into the programme of another research body".[14] For example, in 1960, Warren Spring Laboratory was tasked with "deciding the best ways to deal with oil pollution of the foreshores of coastal resorts" (a mission later extended to include "the treatment and disposal of floating oil at sea").[15]

    History

    The laboratory was originally conceived as a replacement for the DSIR Fuel Research Station in Greenwich.[4] However, it was deliberately given a much less specific name, based on the area in Stevenage where it was built, to reflect a wider brief than simply researching fuel.[4]

    Warren Spring was planned by the Fuel Research Station's chief development officer, David Penny, who became the project's consulting engineer. According to The Herald, "despite a rather vague and constantly changing specification, the Warren Spring laboratory at Stevenage was completed on schedule and met all the complex technical requirements".[16] Its first director was S.H. Clarke, previously director of fire research at the Department of Scientific and Industrial Research.[14]

    The laboratory initially consisted of six main buildings (the principal, 113-meter-long three-storey laboratory, a three-story administration block built at right angles to it; and three smaller laboratories), plus assorted workshops and engineering stores.[1] The main buildings were constructed from lightweight, easily movable partition walls that were designed to be "as flexible as possible in interior layout".[1]

    After transferring from DSIR to the Ministry of Technology in 1965, it was run by the Department of Trade and Industry (and its various successors) until 1994.[4]

    Closure

    In the early 1990s, Michael Heseltine, the UK government's President of the Board of Trade, announced that Warren Spring Laboratory would move to new premises in nearby Welwyn Garden City.[5] [6] Later, however, following a report from the PA Consulting Group, Heseltine scrapped the plan and announced that the laboratory would merge with the Atomic Energy Authority (AEA) and transfer to Harwell, Oxfordshire instead.[6] This prompted considerable public opposition – and many of the Warren Spring staff simply refused to move, including most of its air pollution scientists.[17] [18]

    There was political opposition too. In May 1993, an Early Day Motion supported by 89 mostly opposition (Labour) MPs noted "with concern reports that the President of the Board of Trade now intends to go back on the agreement reached in 1992 to relocate Warren Spring Laboratory and instead to close it with the loss of 150 jobs and scientific expertise built up over many years; and calls on the President of the Board of Trade to save Warren Spring Laboratory from closure".[19] Later, opposition MP Michael Meacher highlighted what he saw as conflicts of interest and a lack of competitive tendering, arguing that the plan was essentially motivated by the government's wider privatisation agenda,[20] while Chris Smith MP called the plan "merely a fattening-up exercise for privatising AEA, which was not a particularly sellable proposition on its own".[6] In response, for the government, David Davis MP countered that the merger would "over the next five years, save the taxpayer perhaps £32 million",[21] though the eventual saving was just £8 million.[22]

    The site of Warren Spring Laboratory, at Gunnels Wood Road, Stevenage, was sold to Glaxo, the pharmaceuticals company, for £25 million, and subsequently became a research and development laboratory.[22]

    Notes and References

    1. Focus for Research at Warren Spring: Laboratory Where Many Programmes Intersect . Engineering . 21 August 1959. 67.
    2. News and Views: Warren Spring Laboratory: Dr C.C. Hall . Nature . 20 July 1963 . 199 . 230 . 28 November 2023.
    3. Book: Air pollution research in Britain c.1955-c.2000 : the transcript of a Witness Seminar held by the History of Modern Biomedicine Research Group . Queen Mary University of London . London . 54 . 24 November 2023.
    4. Web site: Records of the Warren Spring Laboratory . The National Archives . UK Government . 6 February 2022.
    5. News: Bown . William . Forum: Fetid air over Warren Spring - William Bown peers under the public fig leaves of government double-dealing . 6 February 2022 . New Scientist . 20 August 1993.
    6. News: Nuttall . Nick . Heseltine to close top pollution lab - Warren Spring Laboratory, Stevenage, Hertfordshire . The Times . 11 June 1993 . 8.
    7. News: Is this gadget a driver's dream? . Leicester Mercury . 2 September 1999 . 12 . Tests were commissioned at the Department of Trade and Industry's internationally-known Warren Spring Laboratory..
    8. Web site: Warren Spring Laboratory: Volume 199: debated on Friday 22 November 1991 . Hansard . UK Parliament . 6 February 2022 . 22 November 1991.
    9. Web site: Warren Spring Laboratory: Annual Review 1992: Technology and the Environment . 12 December 2022 . Stevenage, Hertfordshire . 1992.
    10. Web site: Records of the Warren Spring Laboratory: 1962-1993 . UK National Archives . 28 November 2023.
    11. Craxford . S.R. . Pollution from lead in petrol . Oil and Petrochemical Pollution . 1983 . 1 . 4 . 285-290.
    12. Web site: Smog : The Silent Killer . Wellcome Collection . 25 November 2023.
    13. Bell, M.L. . Davis, D.L. . Fletcher, T. . 2004 . A Retrospective Assessment of Mortality from the London Smog Episode of 1952: The Role of Influenza and Pollution . . 112 . 1; January . 6–8 . 10.1289/ehp.6539 . 14698923 . 1241789.
    14. The Warren Spring Laboratory . Nature . 26 July 1958 . 4630 . 225.
    15. Web site: Zuckerman . S . Torrey Canyon: Cabinet Office . HMSO . 2 December 2023 . 1967.
    16. News: Mann . Iain . David Penny Distinguished consultant engineer who worked for NEL and Yarrows . Herald, The/Sunday Herald . 19 October 2005.
    17. News: Key staff at Warren Spring refuse to move . 6 February 2022 . New Scientist . 1890 . 10 September 1993 . A survey of researchers at the Warren Spring Laboratory in Stevenage found that only half of those asked to move to AEA Technology's laboratories in Oxfordshire are prepared to go..
    18. News: Schoon . Nicholas . Car pollution unit scrapped while asthma cases soar: Six scientists quit over research merger . The Independent . 11 April 1994 . 2 . All six members of the vehicle emissions group at the Warren Spring Laboratory, the state's leading centre for research into pollution and environmental technology, are quitting. They are among nearly 100 scientists leaving the laboratory, run by the Department of Trade and Industry, because of its controversial merger with the state-owned UK Atomic Energy Authority..
    19. Web site: WARREN SPRING LABORATORY EDM (Early Day Motion) 2078: tabled on 25 May 1993 . Hansard . UK Parliament . 25 May 1993.
    20. News: Meacher . Michael . Letter: Cost of Government consultants . The Independent . 2 May 1994 . 13.
    21. News: Davis . David . Letter: Market testing: success stories . The Independent . 10 May 1994 . 17.
    22. Web site: Written Answers: Warren Spring Laboratory . Hansard . UK Parliament . 6 February 2022 . 22 June 1993.