VTuber explained
A or is an online entertainer who uses a virtual avatar generated using computer graphics. Real-time motion capture software or technology are often—but not always—used to capture movement. The digital trend originated in Japan in the mid-2010s, and has become an international online phenomenon in the 2020s.[1] [2] A majority of VTubers are English- and Japanese-speaking YouTubers or live streamers who use avatar designs. By 2020, there were more than 10,000 active VTubers. Although the term is an allusion to the video platform YouTube, they also use websites such as Niconico, Twitch, Facebook, Twitter, and Bilibili.
The first entertainer to use the phrase "virtual YouTuber", Kizuna AI, began creating content on YouTube in late 2016. Her popularity sparked a VTuber trend in Japan, and it spurred the establishment of specialized agencies to promote them, including major ones such as Hololive Production, Nijisanji, and VShojo. Fan translations and foreign-language VTubers have marked a rise in the trend's international popularity.[3] Virtual YouTubers have appeared in domestic advertising campaigns and have broken livestream-related world records.
Overview
VTubers are online entertainers who are typically YouTubers or live streamers. They use avatars created with programs such as Live2D, portraying characters designed by online artists.[4] VTubers are not bound by physical limitations, and many of them engage in activities that are unconstrained by their real-world identity.[5] Some VTubers, particularly those from marginalized communities, choose to use avatars to reflect their online identity for personal comfort and safety reasons.[6] [7] Transgender VTubers may use their avatars as a means to better reflect their preferred presentation to their audience.[8]
VTubers often portray themselves as a kayfabe character, not unlike professional wrestling; Mace, a WWE wrestler who himself began streaming on Twitch as a VTuber in 2021, remarked that the two professions were "literally the same thing".[9]
VTubers are associated with Japanese popular culture and aesthetics, such as anime and manga,[10] and moe anthropomorphism with human or non-human traits. Some VTubers use anthropomorphic avatars, non-human characters such as animals.[11]
Technology
A VTuber's avatar is typically animated using a webcam and software, which captures the streamer's motions, expressions, and mouth movements, and maps them to a two- or three-dimensional model. Both free and paid programs have been developed for loading models and performing motion capture, with some capable of being used without a webcam (albeit with pre-determined animations), and some also supporting virtual reality hardware, or hand tracking devices such as the Leap Motion Controller.[12] Some programs use iPhone smartphones—particularly, those that include Face ID—as an external webcam, using their infrared-illuminated sensor for more precise motion capture.
The proprietary animation software Live2D is typically used to rig two-dimensional models constructed from drawn textures, while programs such as VRoid Studio can be used to create three-dimensional models.[13] [14] [15] Commissioned models can cost as high as US$2,000 depending on their level of detail.[16] By contrast, some VTubers, colloquially known as "PNGTubers" (in reference to the PNG image format), use static sprites as opposed to a rigged model.[17]
Alternative open-source software has been introduced, such as Inochi2D, which aims to serve the same purpose of Live2D in an open source manner. Such software is not backwards compatible with the Live2D standard, due to Live2D's anti-competitive license compatibility.[18] There is also open source 3D VTubing software such as the Virtual Puppet Project (vpuppr) that is compatible with former proprietary 3D Vtubing software due to the model format's open source nature.[19]
More recently, some Vtubers have introduced artificial intelligence into the design of their characters using AI-generated art and have even integrated AI into their core personality, gameplay, and chat interaction.[20]
Agencies and commercialization
Major VTubers are often employed by talent agencies, with business models influenced by those used by Japanese idol agencies. Streamers are employed by an agency to portray characters developed by the company, which are then commercialized via merchandising and other promotional appearances, as well as traditional revenue streams such as monetization of their videos, and viewer donations. The use of the term "graduation" to refer to a streamer retiring their character and/or leaving an agency, is also a holdover from the idol industry.[21] [22]
History
Predecessors
On February 12, 2010, visual novel maker Nitroplus began uploading videos to its YouTube channel featuring an animated 3D version of its mascot Super Sonico, who would usually talk to the audience about herself or about releases related to the company.[23] On June 13, 2011, UK-based Japanese vlogger Ami Yamato uploaded her first video, which featured an animated, virtual avatar speaking to the camera.[24] In 2012, Japanese company Weathernews Inc. debuted a Vocaloid-styled character called Weatheroid Type A Airi on SOLiVE24, a 24-hour weather live stream on Nico Nico Douga, on YouTube and their website.[25] [26] [27] In 2014, Airi got her own solo program every Thursday and began live broadcasting with motion capture.
In 2014 the FaceRig indie software launched on Indiegogo as an EU crowdfunding project, and later that year it was released on Steam, becoming the first software suite that enabled live avatars at home via face motion capture that started being actively used on streaming websites and YouTube. The Live2D software module enabling 2D avatars and was added one year later in 2015 in collaboration with Live2D, Inc.
Breakout
In late 2016, Kizuna AI, the first VTuber to achieve breakout popularity,[28] [29] made her debut on YouTube. She was the first to coin and use the term "virtual YouTuber". Created by digital production company Activ8 and voice-acted by Nozomi Kasuga,[30] Kizuna AI created a sense of "real intimacy" with fans, as she was responsive to their questions. Within ten months, she had over two million subscribers and later became a culture ambassador of the Japan National Tourism Organization.[31] Kizuna Ai's popularity can be attributed to the oversaturation of traditional webcam YouTubers and for aspects of characters that the audience would not expect. For example, despite having a friendly appearance, Kizuna Ai often swears in her videos when she gets frustrated while playing a game.[32]
The VTuber trend
Kizuna AI's sudden popularity sparked a VTuber trend. Between May and mid-July 2018, the number of active VTubers increased from 2,000 to 4,000.[33] and followed Kizuna as the second and third most popular VTubers, with 750,000 and 625,000 subscribers respectively. and, two other early VTubers, each gained followings of 500,000 in six months.
In the beginning of 2018, Anycolor Inc. (then known as Ichikara) founded the VTuber agency Nijisanji. Nijisanji helped popularise the use of Live2D models instead of the prior focus on 3D models as well as the shift towards livestreaming instead of edited video and clips that was the standard for VTubers like Kizuna Ai.[34] Cover Corporation, a company that was originally developing augmented and virtual reality software, shifted its focus to VTubers by establishing Hololive.
After their initial success in Japan, the trend began to expand internationally via their appeal to the anime and manga fandom. Agencies like Hololive and Nijisanji created branches in China, South Korea, Indonesia, and India, as well as English-language branches targeting a global audience. Meanwhile, independent VTubers began to appear in many countries, from Japan to the United States. In July 2018, VTubers had a collective subscriber count of 12.7 million, and more than 720 million total views.[35] By January 2020, there were over 10,000 VTubers.[36]
The COVID-19 pandemic led to an overall increase in viewership of video game live streaming in general in 2020, which helped contribute to the growth of VTubers into a mainstream phenomenon. Searches on Google for VTuber related content increased over 2020, leading towards the September 2020 launch of Hololive's English branch.[37] In August 2020, seven of the ten largest Super Chat earners of all time on YouTube were VTubers, including Hololive member at number one, who by that time had earned approximately (approximately US$ in 2020).[38] VTubers accounted for 38% of YouTube's 300 most profitable channels, with a total revenue of US$26,229,911 (roughly half of which being viewer donations).
At the same time, the popularity of VTubers continued to rise on Twitch, with a host of several notable English-speaking VTubers such as VShojo members Projekt Melody and Ironmouse.[39] [40] Pokimane also experimented with avatar-based streams using a model commissioned from a VTuber artist.
In September 2020, Anycolor created an "Aggressive Acts and Slander Countermeasure Team" to offer counselling to victims of harassment and take legal measures against perpetrators of harassment, specifically the online harassment plaguing the Japanese entertainment industry. This announcement came in the wake of Hololive's VTuber Mano Aloe's retirement after only two weeks of activity due to online harassment.[41]
YouTube's 2020 Culture and Trends report highlights VTubers as one of the notable trends of that year, with 1.5 billion views per month by October.[42]
On March 30, 2021, Kizuna AI was chosen as one of Asia's top 60 influencers.[43]
In May 2021, Twitch added a VTuber tag for streams as part of a wider expansion of its tag system.[44] In July 2021, Gawr Gura—a member of Hololive's first English branch—overtook Kizuna Ai as the most-subscribed VTuber on YouTube.[45] [46]
Cover's CEO Motoaki "Yagoo" Tanigo was selected as one of the Japan's Top 20 Entrepreneurs by Forbes Japan in its January 2022 issue.[47] The following month, in the midst of a subathon event, Ironmouse accumulated the largest number of active paid subscriptions of all streamers on the platform at that point in time, although still behind an overall record previously set by Ludwig.[48] According to data provided by parent company Amazon, VTubing content on Twitch grew by 467% in 2021 compared with a year earlier.[49]
Use in marketing
Due to their popularity, companies and organizations have used virtual YouTubers as a method of advertising or bringing attention to a product or service. When SoftBank announced the release of the iPhone XS and XS Max in 2018, Kizuna AI appeared at the event and promoted the products on her channel.[50]
Some organizations and companies have employed their own VTuber characters as mascots within marketing.[51] [52] These include the government of Japan's Ibaraki Prefecture (which developed the character of Ibaraki Hiyori), the streaming service Netflix (which developed the character N-ko to appear in videos promoting its anime content),[53] Sega (who planned to have in-character streams with Sonic the Hedgehog and his Japanese voice actor Jun'ichi Kanemaru),[54] and anime streaming service Crunchyroll (which launched a YouTube channel for its mascot Crunchyroll-Hime in October 2021).[55] The Fukuoka SoftBank Hawks baseball team has two VTuber mascots, named Takamine Umi (also known as Hawk Kannon Sea) and Aritaka Hina, both unveiled in 2020. They have their own YouTube channel and their own Twitter accounts. Occasionally, they make appearances on the Fukuoka PayPay Dome's videoboard.[56]
In August 2018, Wright Flyer Live Entertainment released a mobile application allowing VTubers to live stream videos while monetizing them and connecting with their viewers. In a news conference in Tokyo, the head of Wright Flyer Live Entertainment stated, "just increasing the number [of VTubers] is not that effective. We want them to keep on doing their activities. [To do that], gaining fans and monetization are essential. So, we are providing a platform to support that".[57] This followed Wright Flyer Live Entertainment's parent company Gree, Inc.'s ¥10 billion ($89.35 million) investment in VTubers, as well as a ¥10 billion sales target by 2020.[33]
On June 24, 2019, VTuber Kaguya Luna, in collaboration with Nissin Foods to advertise its Yakisoba UFO noodles, held a live stream with a smartphone attached to a helium balloon. By the end of the stream, the smartphone reached an altitude of 30km (20miles) above sea level and was noted by Guinness World Records as being the live stream recorded at the highest altitude, breaking the previous record of 18.42km (11.45miles).[58]
Good Smile Company has begun producing nendoroids of Kizuna Ai in 2018, with a full push for various Japanese and international VTuber PVC-made statues since the 2020s.[59] [60] [61]
In 2020, Japanese VTubers Ayapan and Jajami were invited by the Brazilian embassy in Tokyo, Japan, in November to present their content made for the Brazilian public and how VTuber works, where they had a meeting with Ambassador Eduardo Paes Saboia, being the first contact of VTubers with a Brazilian authority.[62]
In 2021, Hololive English member Gawr Gura made a cameo appearance in an anime-themed ad by American fast food chain Taco Bell (which premiered to coincide with the 2020 Summer Olympics in Tokyo).[63]
In June 2022, Hololive member Inugami Korone became the official brand ambassador for the Sonic the Hedgehog franchise in Japan. She would later appear in the Sonic the Hedgehog 2 film as the voice actress for one of the characters in the Japanese dub, and Korone-themed downloadable content would be released for the game Sonic Frontiers.[64] [65] She also made a cameo appearance in an episode of Yo-kai Watch ♪ that aired in March 2023.[66]
In November 2023, Arashi member Kazunari Ninomiya, who's been working with Puzzle & Dragons since 2014 (with Arashi, and from 2021 as himself), became a VTuber for the latest CM campaign.[67] [68] [69]
Further reading
Notes and References
- News: Japan's virtual YouTubers have millions of real subscribers — and make millions of real dollars. Rest of World. July 26, 2021. March 28, 2023. February 6, 2022. https://web.archive.org/web/20220206081758/https://restofworld.org/2021/vtubers/. live.
- Web site: Virtual YouTubers behind famous avatars in Japan make millions from superfans. 9 May 2022. South China Morning Post.
- Web site: Chen. James. November 30, 2020. The Vtuber takeover of 2020. December 14, 2020. Polygon. en. December 8, 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20201208180104/https://www.polygon.com/2020/11/30/21726800/hololive-vtuber-projekt-melody-kizuna-ai-calliope-mori-vshojo-youtube-earnings. live.
- Web site: Nagata. Kazuaki. July 17, 2018. Japan's latest big thing: 'virtual YouTubers'. December 14, 2020. The Japan Times. en-US. February 14, 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20190214122631/https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2018/07/17/national/japans-latest-big-thing-virtual-youtubers/. live.
- Web site: Dazon. Laura. March 16, 2020. Virtual Youtubers – What's the appeal?. live. December 14, 2020. Quench. en-US. January 21, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210121134912/https://cardiffstudentmedia.co.uk/quench/culture/virtual-youtubers-whats-the-appeal/.
- News: Faber . Tom . April 20, 2021 . VTubers and the Women Behind the Masks . Financial Times . December 22, 2022 . November 28, 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20221128053810/https://www.ft.com/content/9d8ec8be-1329-4840-8428-e787058169ff . live .
- Web site: Mancuso . Devin . December 15, 2020 . The Rise of VTubers as Social Media Influencers, Explained . December 22, 2022 . www.virtualhumans.org . en . November 28, 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20221128144409/https://www.virtualhumans.org/article/the-rise-of-vtubers-as-social-media-influencers-explained . live .
- Book: Turner, Anna Birna . Streaming as a Virtual Being: The Complex Relationship Between VTubers and Identity . June 24, 2022 . 35 . en . December 22, 2022 . March 28, 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230328233130/http://mau.diva-portal.org/smash/record.jsf?pid=diva2%3A1676326&dswid=449 . live .
- D'Anastasio. Cecilia. He's a WWE Star and a Vtuber. Those Worlds Aren't So Different. en-US. Wired. September 27, 2021. 1059-1028. August 25, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210825221046/https://www.wired.com/story/brennan-williams-mace-jibo-wwe-vtubing/. live.
- Bredikhina . Liudmila . March 1, 2021 . Virtual Theatrics and the Ideal VTuber Bishōjo . Replaying Japan . en . 3 . 21 . December 22, 2022 . December 22, 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20221222214922/https://shs.hal.science/halshs-03781959 . live .
- News: Hernandez . Patricia . The otter who became an accidental VTuber star . March 19, 2021 . Polygon . February 18, 2021 . en . The internet has seen a torrent of different types of 'VTubers' over the last year, and while some models are fusions of humans and creatures, few have broken through as straight-up animals. . March 16, 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210316211837/https://www.polygon.com/2021/2/18/22289309/twitch-vtuber-chester-otter-vr-kris-yim-animation . live .
- Web site: Weatherbed . Jess . December 24, 2021 . How to be a Vtuber . April 20, 2022 . TechRadar . en . December 28, 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20211228054947/https://www.techradar.com/how-to/how-to-be-a-vtuber . live .
- Web site: Martinello. Eva. January 29, 2021. The best VTuber software. September 1, 2021. Dot Esports. en-US. September 1, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210901020943/https://dotesports.com/streaming/news/the-best-vtuber-software. live.
- Web site: Çakır. Gökhan. January 29, 2021. How to become a VTuber. September 1, 2021. Dot Esports. en-US. September 1, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210901020942/https://dotesports.com/streaming/news/how-to-become-a-vtuber. live.
- Web site: Hernandez. Patricia. February 18, 2021. The otter who became an accidental VTuber star. September 1, 2021. Polygon. en. October 11, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20211011075647/https://www.polygon.com/2021/2/18/22289309/twitch-vtuber-chester-otter-vr-kris-yim-animation. live.
- Web site: Hernandez. Patricia. September 14, 2020. Why Pokimane's Vtubing Twitch stream has everyone talking. September 1, 2021. Polygon. en. July 3, 2022. https://web.archive.org/web/20220703144545/https://www.polygon.com/2020/9/14/21436437/pokimane-imane-anys-twitch-vtubing-vtuber-anime-livestream-mainstream-popularity. live.
- Web site: February 12, 2022 . The Growing VTuber Community - The Gate's Wide Open . May 14, 2022 . Anime Corner . en-us . May 26, 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220526005729/https://animecorner.me/the-growing-vtuber-community/ . live .
- Web site: Live2D Open Software License Agreemeent . live . February 16, 2023 . March 15, 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230315094524/https://www.live2d.com/eula/live2d-open-software-license-agreement_en.html .
- Web site: VRM Consortium . February 16, 2023 . vrm-consortium.org . February 16, 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230216171516/https://vrm-consortium.org/en/#:~:text=VRM%20is%20a%20file%20format,writing%20VRM%20files%20for%20Unity. . live .
- Web site: D'Anastasio . Cecilia . Cecilia D'Anastasio . June 17, 2023 . Meet Neuro-sama, the AI Twitch Streamer Who Plays Minecraft, Sings Karaoke, Loves Art . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20230620223130/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2023-06-16/neuro-sama-an-ai-twitch-influencer-plays-minecraft-sings-karaoke-loves-art . June 20, 2023 . August 4, 2024 . Bloomberg.
- Web site: Marinescu. Jake Dean, Delia. June 10, 2021. The Virtual YouTube World Is in Uproar. What's the Virtual YouTube World?. November 8, 2021. Slate Magazine. en. November 8, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20211108010227/https://slate.com/technology/2021/06/kiryu-coco-graduating-vtube-hololive.html. live.
- Web site: The Vtuber Industry: Corporatization, Labor, and Kawaii. live. November 8, 2021. Vice. December 22, 2020 . en. May 31, 2022. https://web.archive.org/web/20220531221328/https://www.vice.com/en/article/akdj3z/the-vtuber-industry-corporatization-labor-and-kawaii.
- Web site: すーぱーそに子 ワンダーフェスティバル2010[冬]]. February 12, 2010 . Nitroplus. October 13, 2020. January 5, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210105153339/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXzdjNeFGdE&feature=applinks. live.
- Trying this out.... Ami Yamato. June 13, 2011. YouTube. en. February 14, 2019. March 11, 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20200311154801/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pciLZ8ffPY. live.
- "ウェザーロイド Airi". Comptique Extra issue of December: Vtique Vol.02 (コンプティーク 12月号増刊 Vティーク Vol.2). Kadokawa. 2018. pp.76–79.
- Web site: SOLiVE24 (SOLiVE ムーン) 2012-04-13 21:31:23〜 . . April 13, 2012 . November 1, 2020 . March 18, 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220318151149/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FzJ0w5mmGKo&t=2325 . live .
- Web site: SOLiVE24 (SOLiVEナイト) 2014-04-10 23:32:32〜 . . April 10, 2014 . November 1, 2020 . November 7, 2020 . https://web.archive.org/web/20201107134852/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nt4yQtLS-cs&t=1970 . live .
- News: Faber . Tom . VTubers and the women behind the masks . May 24, 2021 . . April 20, 2021 . May 15, 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210515184549/https://www.ft.com/content/9d8ec8be-1329-4840-8428-e787058169ff . live .
- News: Lufkin. Bryan. October 2, 2018. The virtual vloggers taking over YouTube. en. BBC. February 14, 2018. August 13, 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20190813130007/https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20181002-the-virtual-vloggers-taking-over-youtube. live.
- News: Loveridge. Lynzee. Nozomi Kasuga Confirms She is Kizuna AI Voice Actress. Anime News Network. April 25, 2020. May 25, 2020. May 14, 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20200514023257/https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/interest/2020-04-25/nozomi-kasuga-confirms-she-is-kizuna-ai-voice-actress/.158960. live.
- Web site: Come to Japan with Kizuna AI . . February 14, 2019 . https://web.archive.org/web/20190214131723/https://us.jnto.go.jp/cometojapan/ . February 14, 2019.
- Web site: How Fan Translators Made Virtual YouTubers a Global Phenomenon. December 14, 2020. Anime News Network. en. January 20, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210120144212/https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/feature/2020-08-31/how-fan-translators-made-virtual-youtubers-a-global-phenomenon/.162925. live.
- News: Nagata. Kazuaki. July 17, 2018. Japan's latest big thing: 'virtual YouTubers'. The Japan Times. February 14, 2019. February 14, 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20190214122631/https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2018/07/17/national/japans-latest-big-thing-virtual-youtubers/. live.
- Web site: 公開 . 日時 . 尖ったメンバーばかりのVTuberグループ"にじさんじ"の魅力を紹介 . Dengeki Online . June 5, 2020 . January 28, 2021 . February 1, 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210201172001/https://dengekionline.com/articles/37642/ . live .
- Web site: バーチャルYouTuber、4,000人を突破 動画再生回数は合計7億2千万回に. July 10, 2018. Mogura VR. July 3, 2020. September 17, 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20200917034507/https://www.moguravr.com/vtuber-4000/. live.
- Web site: ユーザーローカル、バーチャルYouTuberの1万人突破を発表 9000人から4ヵ月で1000人増. January 15, 2020. PANORA. July 3, 2020. January 31, 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20200131233315/https://panora.tokyo/archives/4247. live.
- Regis . Rafael . August 25, 2021 . Análise do impacto econômico, da expansão de popularidade e das novas tecnologias do fenômeno VTuber . Analysis of the economic impact, expansion of popularity and new technologies of the VTuber phenomenon . VIII Encontro de Engenharia No Entretenimento . Portuguese . Rio de Janeiro . Universidade Federal do Estado do Rio de Janeiro (UNIRIO) . 8.
- Web site: Morissy . Kim . August 23, 2020 . Playboard: World's Biggest Superchat Earner is Virtual YouTuber Kiryu Coco . September 1, 2020 . Anime News Network . en . August 24, 2020 . https://web.archive.org/web/20200824031955/https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/interest/2020-08-22/playboard-world-biggest-superchat-earner-is-virtual-youtuber-kiryu-coco/.163103 . live .
- Web site: Desatoff. Sam. September 23, 2020. Report: Twitch viewership reached 1.47 billion hours in August (StreamElements, Arsenal.gg). GameDaily.biz. October 26, 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20200928131845/https://gamedaily.biz/article/1884/report-twitch-viewership-reached-147-billion-hours-in-august-streamelements-arsenalgg. September 28, 2020. live.
- White. DeForest. October 29, 2020. Column: Bonus Stage: The Sudden Rise of Vtubers. The Eastern Progress. November 1, 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20201101134922/https://www.easternprogress.com/opinion/column-bonus-stage-the-sudden-rise-of-vtubers/article_ff508dd8-1a38-11eb-8f26-6f366eb5f250.html. November 1, 2020. live.
- Web site: Morrissy. Kim. September 4, 2020. Bushiroad and NIJISANJI Are Taking Online Harassment Seriously. September 8, 2020. Anime News Network. en. September 4, 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20200904120714/https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/interest/2020-09-03/bushiroad-and-nijisanji-are-taking-online-harassment-seriously/.163560. live.
- Web site: December 15, 2020. YouTube Culture & Trends – Data and Cultural Analysis for You. live. https://web.archive.org/web/20201218081931/https://www.youtube.com/trends/articles/report-sources/. December 18, 2020. December 16, 2020. YouTube Culture & Trends. en.
- Web site: SIXTY60 〜BEST OF ASIA 2021〜 - 60MAG(SIXTYMAGAZINE) . March 30, 2021 . May 12, 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210512150603/https://mag.sixty-percent.com/sixty60_2021 . dead .
- Web site: Marshall. Cass. May 27, 2021. Twitch introduces more than 350 new streamer tags, including Vtuber, transgender, queer. September 1, 2021. Polygon. en. September 1, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210901012115/https://www.polygon.com/22456783/twitch-new-streamer-tags-vtuber-transgender-queer-trans-community. live.
- Web site: Harding. Daryl. Gawr Gura Swims Past Kizuna AI to Be the Most Subscribed VTuber Ever. September 1, 2021. Crunchyroll. en-us. July 1, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210701092112/https://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2021/07/01-1/gawr-gura-swims-past-kizuna-ai-to-be-the-most-subscribed-vtuber-ever. live.
- Web site: Gawr Gura breaks YouTube milestone to become most popular VTuber ever. Dexerto. July 4, 2021. March 28, 2023. December 3, 2022. https://web.archive.org/web/20221203164258/https://www.dexerto.com/entertainment/gawr-gura-breaks-youtube-milestone-most-popular-vtuber-1605637/?amp. live.
- Web site: 中沢弘子. November 25, 2021. 世界中にファン5000万人。VTuber「ホロライブ」が急成長する理由. live. November 26, 2021. Forbes JAPAN(フォーブス ジャパン). ja. November 26, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20211126053917/https://forbesjapan.com/articles/detail/44507.
- Web site: Miceli. Max. February 21, 2022. VTuber Ironmouse surpasses 95,000 Twitch subscribers, takes the throne for active subs on platform. February 22, 2022. Dot Esports. en-US. February 21, 2022. https://web.archive.org/web/20220221180127/https://dotesports.com/streaming/news/vtuber-ironmouse-surpasses-95k-twitch-subscribers-most-active-subs-on-platform. live.
- Web site: Twitch's New Star of Streaming Charts Is Anime Avatar Ironmouse. Bloomberg. April 6, 2022. April 8, 2022. May 16, 2022. https://web.archive.org/web/20220516012834/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-04-06/twitch-s-new-star-of-streaming-charts-is-anime-avatar-ironmouse. live.
- Web site: 【SoftBank】新型iPhone発売セレモニーにお邪魔しました!!【XS / MAX】 . YouTube . September 29, 2018 . A.I. Channel . February 14, 2019 . September 29, 2018 . https://web.archive.org/web/20180929142735/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=blDfqqCDQfU&gl=US&hl=en . live .
- Web site: Nagumo . Jada . January 19, 2020 . Japan's virtual celebrities rise to threaten the real ones . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20210629013545/https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Media-Entertainment/Japan-s-virtual-celebrities-rise-to-threaten-the-real-ones . June 29, 2021 . June 23, 2021 . Nikkei Asia . Nikkei.
- News: October 13, 2018 . Ibaraki's virtual YouTuber first in Japan used to promote a prefecture . The Japan Times . February 14, 2019 . https://web.archive.org/web/20190214132653/https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2018/08/23/national/ibarakis-virtual-youtuber-first-japan-used-promote-prefecture/ . February 14, 2019.
- Web site: Kastrenakes . Jacob . April 28, 2021 . Netflix's official Vtuber is part sheep and promotes anime . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20211008205343/https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/28/22408078/netflix-vtuber-anime-n-ko-youtube . October 8, 2021 . September 10, 2021 . The Verge . en.
- Web site: Diaz . Ana . June 24, 2021 . Sonic the Hedgehog is a Vtuber now . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20211104042404/https://www.polygon.com/22548770/sega-sonic-the-hedgehog-vtuber-30th-anniversary . November 4, 2021 . November 4, 2021 . Polygon . en-US.
- Web site: October 25, 2021 . Crunchyroll-Hime launches YouTube channel . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20211104042408/https://advanced-television.com/2021/10/25/crunchyroll-hime-launches-youtube-channel/ . November 4, 2021 . November 4, 2021 . advanced-television.com . en-GB.
- Web site: HAWKS . Fukuoka SoftBank . 福岡ソフトバンクホークスVTuber 鷹観音海、有鷹ひな紹介サイト . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20220223125719/https://www.softbankhawks.co.jp/ex/vtuber/ . February 23, 2022 . February 25, 2022 . ソフトバンクホークス オフィシャルサイト . ja.
- News: Nagata . Kazuaki . Gree-owned firm launches app aimed at boosting Japan's booming world of 'virtual YouTubers' . February 14, 2019 . The Japan Times . https://web.archive.org/web/20190214134930/https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2018/08/07/business/gree-owned-firm-launches-app-aimed-boosting-japans-booming-world-virtual-youtubers/ . February 14, 2019 . en.
- News: Morrissy . Kim . Virtual YouTuber Kaguya Luna Breaks Guinness World Record By Holding Livestream at Highest Altitude . May 19, 2020 . Anime News Network . October 7, 2020 . https://web.archive.org/web/20201007035314/https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/interest/2019-06-29/virtual-youtuber-kaguya-luna-breaks-guinness-world-record-by-holding-livestream-at-highest-altitude/.148232 . live .
- Web site: December 12, 2021 . Nyatasha Nyanners is the First VShojo Nendoroid . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20221107173534/https://www.siliconera.com/nyatasha-nyanners-is-the-first-vshojo-nendoroid/ . November 7, 2022 . March 28, 2023 . Siliconera.
- Web site: July 3, 2021 . Gawr Gura and Mori Calliope Among Hololive Vtuber Figures Announced . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20220110104731/https://www.siliconera.com/gawr-gura-and-mori-calliope-among-hololive-vtuber-figures-announced/ . January 10, 2022 . March 28, 2023 . Siliconera.
- Web site: Nendoroid Kizuna AI . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20221111111638/https://www.goodsmile.info/en/product/7108/Nendoroid+Kizuna+AI.html . November 11, 2022 . November 11, 2022 . www.goodsmile.info . en.
- Web site: Eriki . November 11, 2020 . Embaixador do Brasil no Japão recebe as Vtubers Ayapan e Jajami . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20210917075605/https://sucodemanga.com.br/embaixador-do-brasil-no-japao-recebe-as-vtubers-ayapan-e-jajami/ . September 17, 2021 . June 4, 2022 . Suco de Mangá . pt-br.
- Web site: Cahn. Lauren. July 27, 2021. The Taco Bell Anime Commercial Cameo Only YouTubers Will Notice. September 27, 2021. Mashed.com. en-US. January 21, 2022. https://web.archive.org/web/20220121172457/https://www.mashed.com/472029/the-taco-bell-anime-commercial-cameo-only-youtubers-will-notice/. live.
- News: Harding . Daryl . VTuber Doggo Inugami Korone Goes Fast As Sonic the Hedgehog's Newest Ambassador . en-us . Crunchyroll . 2022-12-21.
- News: 25 August 2022 . Japanese Sonic Frontiers players receive special V-Tuber DLC costumes . Eurogamer.net . live . August 26, 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20221017121413/https://www.eurogamer.net/japanese-sonic-frontiers-players-receive-special-v-tuber-dlc-costumes . October 17, 2022.
- Web site: 2023-02-28 . Inugami Korone Will Voice a Character in Yo-Kai Watch Anime . 2023-11-28 . Siliconera . en-US.
- Web site: 21 November 2023 . 二宮和也、"VTuber"デビュー 本人1秒も登場せず「中の人」に専念 . https://web.archive.org/web/20231122010108/https://mdpr.jp/news/detail/4060391 . 22 November 2023 . 22 November 2023 . Model Press . Japanese.
- Web site: 21 November 2023 . 二宮和也、『パズドラ』新CMでVTuberデビュー 1秒も出演せず"中の人"に徹する . https://web.archive.org/web/20231122011955/https://news.livedoor.com/article/detail/25388481/ . 22 November 2023 . 22 November 2023 . Livedoor . Japanese.
- Web site: 9 June 2014 . 『パズドラ』新TV-CMに"嵐"の5名が出演! 6月10日からTV-CM全国放映&メイキング動画公開 . https://web.archive.org/web/20231122015310/https://dengekionline.com/elem/000/000/864/864330/ . 22 November 2023 . 22 November 2023 . Dengeki online . Japanese.