Urartu Explained

Conventional Long Name:Urartu
Common Name:Urartu
Era:Iron Age
Government Type:Monarchy
Year Start:860 BC 
Year End: 590 BC/547 BC[1]
Event End:Median conquest (or Achaemenid conquest in 547[2])
Image Map Caption:Urartu under Sarduri II, 743 BC
S1:Median Empire
S2:Achaemenid Empire
S3:Satrapy of Armenia
P1:Nairi
Capital:
Common Languages:
Religion:Urartian polytheism[5]
Leader1:Aramu
Leader2:Lutipri(?)
Leader3:Sarduri I
Leader4:Ishpuini
Leader5:Menua
Leader6:Argishti I
Leader7:Sarduri II
Leader8:Rusa I
Leader9:Argishti II
Leader10:Rusa II
Leader11:Sarduri III
Leader12:Rusa III
Leader13:Sarduri IV
Leader14:Rusa IV
Year Leader1:858–844
Year Leader2:844–834(?)
Year Leader3:834–828
Year Leader4:828–810
Year Leader5:810–785
Year Leader6:785–753
Year Leader7:753–735
Year Leader8:735–714
Year Leader9:714–680
Year Leader10:680–639
Year Leader11:639–635
Year Leader12:629–590 or 629–615
Year Leader13:615–595
Year Leader14:590–585

Urartu (; Armenian: Ուրարտու; Assyrian: ,[6] Babylonian: Urashtu, Hebrew: אֲרָרָט Ararat) was an Iron Age kingdom centered around Lake Van in the Armenian Highlands. It extended from the eastern bank of the upper Euphrates River to the western shores of Lake Urmia and from the mountains of northern Iraq to the Lesser Caucasus Mountains. Its kings left behind cuneiform inscriptions in the Urartian language, a member of the Hurro-Urartian language family. Since its re-discovery in the 19th century, Urartu, which is commonly believed to have been at least partially Armenian-speaking,[7] [8] [9] [10] [11] has played a significant role in Armenian nationalism.[12]

The kingdom emerged in the mid-9th century BC and dominated the Armenian Highlands in the 8th and 7th centuries BC.[13] Urartu frequently warred with Assyria and became, for a time, the most powerful state in the Near East.[14] Weakened by constant conflict, it was eventually conquered, either by the Iranian Medes in the early 6th century BC or by Cyrus the Great in the middle of the 6th century BC.[15] Archaeologically, it is noted for its large fortresses and sophisticated metalwork.[16]

Names and etymology

Various names were given to the geographic region and the polity that emerged in the region.

The name form of Armenia URARTU appears in 2 Assyrian inscriptions from the 9th century BC. Urartologists identify with this name form the land names mat U-RU-A Ţ -RI mentioned by Shalmaneser I (at the beginning of XIII century) and mat U-RA Ţ -RI mentioned by Adad-nirari II (at the end of X century).

The name forms URARTU and Ararat differ by one vowel (the vowel “a” is missing between the consonants r and t in the URARTU reading). And as the data in the table shows, it is the result of the misunderstanding that the cuneiform scholars who read the name of the country took the readings ar and ar2 of the AR and UB cuneiform signs, respectively, and ignored their readings ara8 and ara2․

On the famous Babylonian map representing the ancient world (in the 8th century BC) (see figure 1), in the inscription of the Assyrian king Nabopolassar (in 626-604 BC) and in the Behistun inscription of the Achaemenid Iranian king Darius I (in 522-486 BC), the name of Armenia is presented in the form UR-AŠ 2 -TU= URAŠTU. Some authors (S. Yeremyan, B.Piotrovsky, I. Dyakonoff, U. Horovits and others) distinguish URAŠTU from URARTU, but consider them equivalent names. In order for the writing form URAŠTU to be identical with URARTU=Ararat, it is necessary for the AŠ2 cuneiform sign to have the reading ru/ra.[44]

There is no direct evidence in existing cuneiform dictionaries that the AŠ 2 cuneiform sign has such readings. However, there are a number of side data that confirm the existence of these readings of the AŠ 2 cuneiform. The reading aš 2 of the cuneiform sign AŠ 2 was expressed by the cuneiform AŠ in the cuneiform dictionaries (AŠ 2 = AŠ). And the cuneiform AŠ has 3 ru readings.

History

Origins

Assyrian inscriptions of Shalmaneser I (c. 1274 BC) first mention Uruatri as one of the states of Nairi, a loose confederation of small kingdoms and tribal states in the Armenian Highlands in the thirteenth to eleventh centuries BC which he conquered. Uruartri itself was in the region around Lake Van. The Nairi states were repeatedly subjected to further attacks and invasions by the Middle and Neo-Assyrian Empires, which lay to the south in Upper Mesopotamia ("the Jazirah") and northern Syria, especially under Tukulti-Ninurta I (c. 1240 BC), Tiglath-Pileser I (c. 1100 BC), Ashur-bel-kala (c. 1070 BC), Adad-nirari II (c. 900 BC), Tukulti-Ninurta II (c. 890 BC), and Ashurnasirpal II (883–859 BC).

Urartu reemerged in Assyrian language inscriptions in the ninth century BC as a powerful northern rival to the Neo-Assyrian Empire. The Nairi states and tribes became unified kingdom under King Arame of Urartu (c. 860–843 BC), whose capitals, first at Sugunia and then at Arzashkun, were captured by the Assyrians under the Neo-Assyrian emperor Shalmaneser III.

Urartologist Paul Zimansky speculated that the Urartians, or at least their ruling family after Arame, may have emigrated northwest into the Lake Van region from their religious capital of Musasir.[45] According to Zimansky, the Urartian ruling class were few in number and governed over an ethnically, culturally, and linguistically diverse population. Zimansky went so far as to suggest that the kings of Urartu might have come from various ethnic backgrounds themselves.[46]

Growth

Assyria fell into a period of temporary stagnation for decades during the first half of the 9th century BC, which had aided Urartu's growth. Within a short time it became one of the largest and most powerful states in the Near East.[46]

Sarduri I (c. 832–820 BC), the son of Lutipri, established a new dynasty and successfully resisted Assyrian attacks from the south led by Shalmaneser III, consolidated the military power of the state, and moved the capital to Tushpa (modern Van, Turkey, on the shore of Lake Van). His son, Ispuini (c. 820–800 BC) annexed the neighbouring state of Musasir, which became an important religious centre of the Urartian Kingdom, and introduced the cult of Ḫaldi.[46]

Ispuini was also the first Urartian king to write in the Urartian language (previous kings left records written in Akkadian).[46] He made his son Sarduri II viceroy. After conquering Musasir, Ispuini was in turn attacked by Shamshi-Adad V. His co-regent and subsequent successor, Menua (c. 800–785 BC) also enlarged the kingdom greatly and left inscriptions over a wide area. During Ispuini's and Menua's joint rule, they shifted from referring to their territory as Nairi, instead opting for Bianili.[46]

Urartu reached the highest point of its military might under Menua's son Argishti I (c. 785–760 BC), becoming one of the most powerful kingdoms of ancient Near East. Argishti I added more territories along the Aras and Lake Sevan, and frustrated Shalmaneser IV's campaigns against him. Argishti also founded several new cities, most notably Erebuni Fortress in 782 BC. 6600 prisoners of war from Hatti and Supani were settled in the new city.[47] [48]

At its height, the Urartu kingdom stretched north beyond the Aras and Lake Sevan, encompassing present-day Armenia and even the southern part of present-day Georgia almost to the shores of the Black Sea; west to the sources of the Euphrates; east to present-day Tabriz, Lake Urmia, and beyond; and south to the sources of the Tigris.

Tiglath-Pileser III of Assyria defeated Sarduri II of Urartu in the first year of his reign (745 BC). There the Assyrians found horsemen and horses, tamed as colts for riding, that were unequalled in the south, where they were harnessed to Assyrian war-chariots.[49]

Checkpoints

Kayalıdere Castle is one of the important centers that enabled the Urartian kingdom to control the surrounding regions from Lake Van to the west.[50]

Decline and recuperation

In 714 BC, the Urartian kingdom suffered heavily from Cimmerian raids and the campaigns of Sargon II. The main temple at Musasir was sacked, and the Urartian king Rusa I was crushingly defeated by Sargon II at Lake Urmia. He subsequently committed suicide in shame.[51]

Rusa's son Argishti II (714–685 BC) restored Urartu's position against the Cimmerians, however it was no longer a threat to Assyria and peace was made with the new king of Assyria Sennacherib in 705 BC. This, in turn, helped Urartu enter a long period of development and prosperity, which continued through the reign of Argishti's son Rusa II (685–645 BC).

After Rusa II, however, Urartu grew weaker under constant attacks from Cimmerian and Scythian invaders. As a result, it became dependent on Assyria, as evidenced by Rusa II's son Sarduri III (645–635 BC) referring to the Assyrian king Ashurbanipal as his "father".[52] [53]

Fall

According to Urartian epigraphy, Sarduri III was followed by two kings—Rusa III (also known as Rusa Erimenahi) (620–609 BC) and his son, Rusa IV (609–590 or 585 BC). There is speculation that Rusa III's father, Erimena, may have been a king as well, possibly ruling from 635 to 620 BC, but little is known about him. It is possible that Rusa III established a new dynasty and that his father, Erimena, had not been king.[54] [55]

Late during the 7th century BC (during or after Sarduri III's reign), Urartu was invaded by Scythians and their allies—the Medes. In 612 BC, the Median king Cyaxares the Great together with Nabopolassar of Babylon and the Scythians conquered Assyria after it had been irreversibly weakened by civil war. The Medes then took over the Urartian capital of Van in 590 BC, effectively ending the sovereignty of Urartu.[56] [57] However, some historians believe that Urartu survived until the middle of the 6th century BC and was eventually destroyed by Cyrus the Great.[58] Many Urartian ruins of the period show evidence of destruction by fire.

Appearance of Armenia

See main article: Satrapy of Armenia.

The Kingdom of Van was destroyed in 590 BC[59] and by the late 6th century, the Satrapy of Armenia had replaced it.[60] Little is known of what happened to the region between the fall of the Kingdom of Van and the appearance of the Satrapy of Armenia. According to historian Touraj Daryaee, during the Armenian rebellion against the Persian king Darius I in 521 BC, some of the personal and topographic names attested in connection with Armenia or Armenians were of Urartian origin, suggesting that Urartian elements persisted within Armenia after its fall.[61] In the Behistun Inscription (c. 522 BC) refer to Armenia and Armenians as synonyms of Urartu and Urartians.[62] The toponym Urartu did not disappear, however, as the name of the province of Ayrarat in the center of the Kingdom of Armenia is believed to be its continuum.[63] As the Armenian identity developed in the region, the memory of Urartu faded and disappeared.[64] Parts of its history passed down as popular stories and were preserved in Armenia, as written by Movses Khorenatsi in the form of garbled legends[65] [66] in his 5th century book History of Armenia, where he speaks of a first Armenian Kingdom in Van which fought wars against the Assyrians. Khorenatsi's stories of these wars with Assyria would help in the rediscovery of Urartu.[67]

According to Herodotus, the Alarodians (Alarodioi) were part of the 18th Satrapy of the Achaemenid Empire and formed a special contingent in the grand army of Xerxes I.[68] Some scholars have tried to link the Alarodians to Urartians, suggesting that Alarodian was a variation of the name Urartian/Araratian. According to this theory, the Urartians of the 18th Satrapy were subsequently absorbed into the Armenian nation.[69] Modern historians, however, have cast doubt on the Alarodian connection to the Urartians.[70]

In a study published in 2017,[71] the complete mitochondrial genomes of 4 ancient skeletons from Urartu were analyzed alongside other ancient populations found in modern-day Armenia and Artsakh spanning 7,800 years. The study shows that modern-day Armenians are the people who have the least genetic distance from those ancient skeletons. As well, some scholars asserted that the Urartians are the most easily identifiable ancestors of the Armenians.[72] [73] [74] [75]

Geography

Urartu comprised an area of approximately 200000sqmi, extending from the Euphrates in the West to Lake Urmia in the East and from the Caucasus Mountains south towards the Zagros Mountains in northern Iraq.[76] More specifically, Urartu was an area directly surrounded by the mountain chains of the eastern Pontus at the north, the Lesser Caucasus at to the northeast, and the Taurus mountains at the south.[77] It was centred around Lake Van, which is located in present-day eastern Anatolia.[78]

At its apogee, Urartu stretched from the borders of northern Mesopotamia to the southern Caucasus, including present-day Turkey, Nakhchivan,[79] Armenia and southern Georgia (up to the river Kura). The Taurus mountains also served as a natural barrier against southern threats, particularly from the Assyrians. Archaeological sites within its boundaries include Altintepe, Toprakkale, Patnos and Haykaberd. Urartu fortresses included Erebuni Fortress (present-day Yerevan), Van Fortress, Argishtihinili, Anzaf, Haykaberd, and Başkale, as well as Teishebaini (Karmir Blur, Red Mound) and others.

Discovery

Urartian inscriptions were found in Kepenek Castle, located on a hill near the center of Muş, and in the Alazlı.[80] Inspired by the writings of the medieval Armenian historian Movses Khorenatsi (who had described Urartian works in Van and attributed them to the legendary Ara the Beautiful and Queen Semiramis), the French scholar Antoine-Jean Saint-Martin suggested that his government send Friedrich Eduard Schulz, a German professor, to the Van area in 1827 on behalf of the French Oriental Society.[81] Schulz discovered and copied numerous cuneiform inscriptions, partly in Assyrian and partly in a hitherto unknown language. Schulz also discovered the Kelishin stele, bearing an Assyrian-Urartian bilingual inscription, located on the Kelishin pass on the current Iraqi-Iranian border. A summary account of his initial discoveries was published in 1828. Schulz and four of his servants were murdered by Kurds in 1829 near Başkale. His notes were later recovered and published in Paris in 1840. In 1828, the British Assyriologist Henry Creswicke Rawlinson had attempted to copy the inscription on the Kelishin stele, but failed because of the ice on the stele's front side. The German scholar R. Rosch made a similar attempt a few years later, but he and his party were attacked and killed.

In the late 1840s Sir Austen Henry Layard examined and described the Urartian rock-cut tombs of Van Castle, including the Argishti chamber. From the 1870s, local residents began to plunder the Toprakkale ruins, selling its artefacts to European collections. In the 1880s this site underwent a poorly executed excavation organised by Hormuzd Rassam on behalf of the British Museum. Almost nothing was properly documented.

The first systematic collection of Urartian inscriptions, and thus the beginning of Urartology as a specialized field dates to the 1870s, with the campaign of Sir Archibald Henry Sayce. The German engineer Karl Sester, discoverer of Mount Nemrut, collected more inscriptions in 1890/1.Waldemar Belck visited the area in 1891, discovering the Rusa stele. A further expedition planned for 1893 was prevented by Turkish-Armenian hostilities. Belck together with Lehmann-Haupt visited the area again in 1898/9, excavating Toprakkale. On this expedition, Belck reached the Kelishin stele, but he was attacked by Kurds and barely escaped with his life. Belck and Lehmann-Haupt reached the stele again in a second attempt, but were again prevented from copying the inscription by weather conditions. After another assault on Belck provoked the diplomatic intervention of Wilhelm II, Sultan Abdul Hamid II agreed to pay Belck a sum of 80,000 gold marks in reparation. During World War I, the Lake Van region briefly fell under Russian control. In 1916, the Russian scholars Nikolay Yakovlevich Marr and Iosif Abgarovich Orbeli, excavating at the Van fortress, uncovered a four-faced stele carrying the annals of Sarduri II. In 1939 Boris Piotrovsky excavated Karmir Blur, discovering Teišebai, the city of the god of war, Teišeba. Excavations by the American scholars Kirsopp and Silva Lake in 1938-40 were cut short by World War II, and most of their finds and field records were lost when a German submarine torpedoed their ship, the . Their surviving documents were published by Manfred Korfmann in 1977.

A new phase of excavations began after the war. Excavations were at first restricted to Soviet Armenia. The fortress of Karmir Blur, dating from the reign of Rusa II, was excavated by a team headed by Boris Piotrovsky, and for the first time the excavators of a Urartian site published their findings systematically. Beginning in 1956 Charles A. Burney identified and sketch-surveyed many Urartian sites in the Lake Van area and, from 1959, a Turkish expedition under Tahsin Özgüç excavated Altintepe and Arif Erzen.

In the late 1960s, Urartian sites in northwest Iran were excavated. In 1976, an Italian team led by Mirjo Salvini finally reached the Kelishin stele, accompanied by a heavy military escort. The Gulf War then closed these sites to archaeological research. Oktay Belli resumed excavation of Urartian sites on Turkish territory: in 1989 Ayanis, a 7th-century BC fortress built by Rusas II of Urartu, was discovered 35 km north of Van. In spite of excavations, only a third to a half of the 300 known Urartian sites in Turkey, Iran, Iraq, and Armenia have been examined by archaeologists (Wartke 1993). Without protection, many sites have been plundered by local residents searching for treasure and other saleable antiquities.

On 12 November 2017, it was announced that archaeologists in Turkey had discovered the ruins of a Urartian castle during underwater excavations around Lake Van. The castle dated to the 8th or 7th centuries BC.[82]

Economy and politics

See main article: Economy of Urartu.

The economic structure of Urartu was similar to other states of the ancient world, especially Assyria. The state was heavily dependent on agriculture, which required centralized irrigation. These works were managed by kings, but implemented by free inhabitants and possibly slave labour provided by prisoners. Royal governors, influential people and, perhaps, free peoples had their own allotments. Individual territories within the state had to pay taxes the central government: grain, horses, bulls, etc. In peacetime, Urartu probably led an active trade with Assyria, providing cattle, horses, iron and wine.

align="center" width="20%"
    - Part of iron pitchfork, found near Lake Van and Iron plowshare, found during excavations in Rusahinili (Toprakkale).Urartian saddle quern

According to archaeological data, farming on the territory of Urartu developed from the Neolithic, even in the 3rd millennium BC. In the Urartian age, agriculture was well developed and closely related to Assyrian methods on the selection of cultures and methods of processing.[83] From cuneiform sources, it is known that in Urartu grew wheat, barley, sesame, millet, and emmer, and cultivated gardens and vineyards. Many regions of the Urartu state required artificial irrigation, which has successfully been organized by the rulers of Urartu in the heyday of the state. In several regions remain ancient irrigation canals, constructed by Urartu, mainly during the Argishti I and Menua period, some of which are still used for irrigation.

Art and architecture

See main article: Art of Urartu.

There is a number of remains of sturdy stone architecture, as well as some mud brick, especially when it has been burnt, which helps survival. Stone remains are mainly fortresses and walls, with temples and mausolea, and many rock-cut tombs. The style, which developed regional variations, shows a distinct character, partly because of the greater use of stone compared to neighbouring cultures. The typical temple was square, with stone walls as thick as the open internal area but using mud brick for the higher part. These were placed at the highest point of a citadel and from surviving depictions were high, perhaps with gabled roofs; their emphasis on verticality has been claimed as an influence of later Christian Armenian architecture.[84]

The art of Urartu is especially notable for fine lost-wax bronze objects: weapons, figurines, vessels including grand cauldrons that were used for sacrifices, fittings for furniture, and helmets. There are also remains of ivory and bone carvings, frescos, cylinder seals and of course pottery. In general their style is a somewhat less sophisticated blend of influences from neighbouring cultures. Archaeology has produced relatively few examples of the jewellery in precious metals that the Assyrians boasted of carrying off in great quantities from Musasir in 714 BC.[84]

Religion

See also: Urartu religion. The Urartian pantheon seems to have comprised a diverse mix of Hurrian, Akkadian, Armenian, and Hittite deities.[85]

Starting with the reign of Ishpuini, the Urartian pantheon was headed by a triad made up of Ḫaldi (the supreme god), Theispas (Teisheba, god of thunder and storms, as well as sometimes war), and Shivini (a solar god). Their king was also the chief-priest or envoy of Ḫaldi. Some temples to Ḫaldi were part of the royal palace complex, while others were independent structures.

With the expansion of Urartian territory, many of the gods worshipped by conquered peoples were incorporated into the Urartian pantheon as a means of confirming the annexation of territories and promoting political stability. Some main gods and goddesses of the Urartian pantheon include:[86]

Ḫaldi was not a native Urartian god but apparently an obscure Akkadian deity (which explains the location of the main temple of worship for Ḫaldi in Musasir, believed to be near modern Rawandiz, Iraq).[87] Ḫaldi was not initially worshiped by the Urartians as their chief god. His cult does not appear to have been introduced until the reign of Ishpuini.[87]

Theispas was a version of the Hurrian god, Teshub.[88]

According to Diakonoff and Vyacheslav Ivanov, Shivini (likely pronounced Shiwini or Siwini) was likely borrowed from the Hittites.[89]

On the Gate of Mehr (Mehri-Dur), overlooking modern Van, an inscription lists a total of 79 deities, and what type of sacrificial offerings should be made to each; goats, sheep, cattle, and other animals served as the sacrificial offerings. Urartians did not practice human sacrifice.[90]

A number of the gods mentioned in the Gate of Mehr may be of Armenian origins,[85] including Ara (or Arwaa),[91] and possibly the goddess Selardi (although there is confusion about this deity's gender and name, some believe it is to be read Melardi).[91] [92] [93]

It has been suggested that the Urartian pantheon could correspond to mountain peaks located within the Armenian Highlands.[94]

Language

The modern name of the written language used by the kingdom's political elite is Urartian; the language is attested in numerous cuneiform inscriptions throughout Armenia and eastern Turkey. It is unknown what other languages were spoken by the peoples of Urartu under the Kingdom of Van, but there is evidence of linguistic contact between the proto-Armenian language and the Urartian language at an early date (sometime between the 3rd—2nd millennium BC), before the formation of the kingdom.[95] [96] [97]

Urartians used Assyrian language, script, and form in building inscriptions.[98] This language and script was used until the late ninth century BC when the Urartian language was used.[99]

Urartian language

See main article: Urartian language. "Urartian" is the modern name for the extinct language used in the cuneiform inscriptions of the Kingdom of Urartu. Its only known relative is Hurrian; together they form the small Hurro-Urartian language family. Other names used to refer to the language are "Khaldian" ("Ḫaldian"), or "neo-Hurrian". The latter term is considered problematic, however, as it is now thought that Urartian and Hurrian share a common ancestor; formerly, it was thought that Urartian was descended from, or a dialect of, Hurrian.[70] In fact, according to Paul Zimansky:

The Urartian language is an ergative-absolutive, agglutinative language, which belongs to neither the Semitic nor the Indo-European language families, but to the Hurro-Urartian language family, which is not known to be related to any other language or language family, despite repeated attempts to find genetic links.

Examples of the Urartian language have survived in many inscriptions, written in the Assyrian cuneiform script, found throughout the area of the Kingdom of Urartu. Although, the bulk of the cuneiform inscriptions within Urartu were written in the Urartian language, a minority of them were also written in Akkadian (the official language of Assyria).

There are also claims of autochthonous Urartian hieroglyphs, but this remains uncertain.[100] Unlike the cuneiform inscriptions, Urartian hieroglyphs have not been successfully deciphered. As a result, scholars disagree as to what language is used, or whether they even constitute writing at all. The Urartians originally would have used these locally developed hieroglyphs, but later adapted the Assyrian cuneiform script for most purposes. After the 8th century BC, the hieroglyphic script would have been restricted to religious and accounting purposes.

The Kingdom of Urartu, during its dominance, had united disparate tribes, each of which had its own culture and traditions. Thus, when the political structure was destroyed, little remained that could be identified as one unified Urartian culture.[101] According to Zimansky:[102]

Ultimately, little is known of what was truly spoken in the geopolitical region until the creation of the Armenian alphabet in the 4th century AD. Some scholars believe that the ethnonym "Armina" itself and all other names attested with reference to the rebellions against Darius in the Satrapy of Armenia (the proper names Araxa, Haldita, and Dādṛšiš, the toponyms Zūzahya, Tigra, and Uyamā, and the district name Autiyāra) are not connected with Armenian linguistic and onomastic material attested later in native Armenian sources, nor are they Iranian, but seem related to Urartian.[103] However, others suggest that some of these names have Armenian or Iranian etymologies.[104] [105]

Proto-Armenian language

See main article: Proto-Armenian language. The presence of a population who spoke Proto-Armenian in Urartu prior to its demise is subject to speculation, but the existence of Urartian words in the Armenian language and Armenian loanwords into Urartian[106] suggests early contact between the two languages and long periods of bilingualism.[8] The presence of toponyms, tribal names, and deities of probable Proto-Armenian etymologies which are attested in records left by Urartian kings, such as Uelikuni, Uduri-Etiuni, Abiliani, and Arzashkun, the personal names Arame and Diaṣuni, and the deities Arṣibedini and Aniqu, further supports the presence of an Armenian speaking population in at least the northern regions of Urartu.[107] [108] [8] [109] [85] The Urartian confederation united the disparate peoples of the highlands, which began a process of intermingling of the peoples and cultures (probably including Armenian tribes) and languages (probably including Proto-Armenian) within the highlands. This intermixing would ultimately culminate in the emergence of the Armenian language as the dominant language within the region.

A theory, supported by the official historiography of Armenia and experts in Assyrian and Urartian studies such as Igor M. Diakonoff, Giorgi Melikishvili, Mikhail Nikolsky, and Ivan Mestchaninov, suggests that Urartian was solely the formal written language of the state, while its inhabitants, including the royal family, spoke Proto-Armenian. This theory primarily hinges on the fact that the Urartian language used in the cuneiform inscriptions were very repetitive and scant in vocabulary (having as little as 350–400 roots). Furthermore, over 250 years of usage, it shows no development, which is taken to indicate that the language had ceased to be spoken before the time of the inscriptions or was used only for official purposes.

A complementary theory, suggested by Tamaz V. Gamkrelidze and Ivanov in 1984, places the Proto-Indo-European homeland (the location where Indo-European would have emerged from) in the Armenian Highlands, which would entail the presence of proto-Armenians in the area during the entire lifetime of the Urartian state.[110] Although this theory has less support than the more popular Kurgan hypothesis, the Armenian hypothesis would support the theory that the Urartian language was not spoken, but simply written, and postulates that the Armenian language was an in situ development of a 3rd millennium BC Proto-Indo-European language.

See also

References

Literature

External links

Notes and References

  1. Nunn . Astrid . 2011-05-15 . « The Median 'Empire', the End of Urartu and Cyrus the Great's Campaign in 547 BC (Nabonidus Chronicle II 16) ». Ancient West & East 7, 2008, p. 51-66. . Abstracta Iranica. Revue bibliographique pour le domaine irano-aryen . fr . 31 . 10.4000/abstractairanica.39422 . 0240-8910. Après citation des passages pertinents, analyse des toponymes et une nouvelle lecture de la Chronique de Nabonide II 16, dont le nom géographique clef doit être lu « Urartu », il reste : Cyrus le Grand a « marché vers Urartu et vaincu son roi ». Urartu n’a donc pas été détruit par les Mèdes à la fin du VIIe s. mais a continué à exister comme entité politique jusqu’au milieu du VIe s. La Chronique de Nabonide (II 16) montre bien que la conquête de Cyrus le Grand mit fin à ce royaume.. free .
  2. Nunn . Astrid . 2011-05-15 . « The Median 'Empire', the End of Urartu and Cyrus the Great's Campaign in 547 BC (Nabonidus Chronicle II 16) ». Ancient West & East 7, 2008, p. 51-66. . Abstracta Iranica. Revue bibliographique pour le domaine irano-aryen . fr . 31 . 10.4000/abstractairanica.39422 . 0240-8910. Après citation des passages pertinents, analyse des toponymes et une nouvelle lecture de la Chronique de Nabonide II 16, dont le nom géographique clef doit être lu « Urartu », il reste : Cyrus le Grand a « marché vers Urartu et vaincu son roi ». Urartu n’a donc pas été détruit par les Mèdes à la fin du VIIe s. mais a continué à exister comme entité politique jusqu’au milieu du VIe s. La Chronique de Nabonide (II 16) montre bien que la conquête de Cyrus le Grand mit fin à ce royaume.. free .
  3. Book: Van de Mieroop, Marc . A History of the Ancient Near East, ca. 3000-323 BC . Blackwell Publishing . 2007 . 215.
  4. Diakonoff. Igor M. First Evidence of the Proto-Armenian Language in Eastern Anatolia. Annual of Armenian Linguistics. 1992. 13. 51–54. 0271-9800.
  5. Book: Essays on Ancient Anatolia in the Second Millennium B.C.. Takahito, Prince Mikasa. Avia Taffet . Jak Yakar. 1998. Politics and religion in Urartu. Chūkintō-Bunka-Sentā Tōkyō. Bulletin of the Middle Eastern Culture Center in Japan. Harrassowitz Verlag. 10. 133–140. https://books.google.com/books?id=O60Ho5bIErcC&pg=PA133. 9783447039673. 0177-1647.
  6. Eberhard Schrader, The Cuneiform inscriptions and the Old Testament (1885), p. 65.
  7. Diakonoff. Igor M. First Evidence of the Proto-Armenian Language in Eastern Anatolia. Annual of Armenian Linguistics. 1992. 13. 51–54. 0271-9800.
  8. Book: . 1997. Fitzroy Dearborn . Mallory, J. P. . Adams, Douglas Q.. 978-1884964985. London. 30. 37931209. Armenian presence in their historical seats should then be sought at some time before c 600 BC; ... Armenian phonology, for instance, appears to have been greatly affected by Urartian, which may suggest a long period of bilingualism..
  9. Robert Drews. Militarism and the Indo-Europeanizing of Europe. Routledge. 2017. p. 228. "The vernacular of the Great Kingdom of Biainili was quite certainly Armenian. The Armenian language was obviously the region's vernacular in the fifth century BC, when Persian commanders and Greek writers paired it with Phrygian. That it was brought into the region between the early sixth and the early fifth century BC, and that it immediately obliterated whatever else had been spoken there, can hardly be supposed; ... Because Proto-Armenian speakers seem to have lived not far from Hurrian speakers our conclusion must be that the Armenian language of Mesrop Mashtots was descended from an Indo--European language that had been spoken in southern Caucasia in the Bronze Age."
  10. Hrach Martirosyan (2013). "The place of Armenian in the Indo-European language family: the relationship with Greek and Indo-Iranian*" Leiden University. p. 85-86.
  11. Petrosyan, Armen. "The Armenian Elements in the Language and Onomastics of Urartu." Aramazd: Armenian Journal of Near Eastern Studies. 2010. https://www.academia.edu/2939663/The_Armenian_Elements_in_the_Language_and_Onomastics_of_Urartu
  12. Book: Redgate, Anne Elizabeth. The Armenians. Wiley. 2000. 978-0-631-22037-4. Elizabeth Redgate., p. 276.
  13. Book: Zimansky, Paul E. . The Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East . 2011-01-01 . Oxford University Press . 978-0-19-506512-1 . Urartu . 10.1093/acref/9780195065121.001.0001 . 2018-11-22 . http://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/acref/9780195065121.001.0001/acref-9780195065121-e-1097.
  14. Book: Zimansky, Paul E. . The Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East . 2011-01-01 . Oxford University Press . 978-0-19-506512-1 . Urartu . 10.1093/acref/9780195065121.001.0001 . 2018-11-22 . http://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/acref/9780195065121.001.0001/acref-9780195065121-e-1097.
  15. Book: Jacobson, Esther . The Art of the Scythians: The Interpenetration of Cultures at the Edge of the Hellenic World . 1995 . BRILL . 9789004098565 . 33 . en.
  16. Book: Zimansky, Paul E. . The Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East . 2011-01-01 . Oxford University Press . 978-0-19-506512-1 . Urartu . 10.1093/acref/9780195065121.001.0001 . 2018-11-22 . http://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/acref/9780195065121.001.0001/acref-9780195065121-e-1097.
  17. Abram Rigg Jr., Horace. "A Note on the Names Armânum and Urartu". Journal of the American Oriental Society, 57/4 (December 1937), pp. 416–418.
  18. Zimansky, Paul E. Ancient Ararat: A Handbook of Urartian Studies. Delmar, New York: Caravan Books, 1998, p. 28. .
  19. Trevor Bryce. The Routledge Handbook of the Peoples and Places of Ancient Western Asia. Taylor & Francis. p. 310. 2009.
  20. Aram Kosyan. "Towards the Hittite Eastern Periphery". Armenian Journal of Near Eastern Studies. Vol. VI. Issue 2. 2011. pp. 91–92.
  21. [David Marshall Lang|Lang, David Marshall]
  22. Redgate, Anna Elizabeth. The Armenians. Cornwall: Blackwell, 1998, pp. 16–19, 23, 25, 26 (map), 30–32, 38, 43. .
  23. Book: Freedman. David Noel. Eerdmans Dictionary of the Bible. Myers. Allen C.. 2000-12-31. Amsterdam University Press. 978-90-5356-503-2.
  24. Paul Zimansky. "Urartian and Urartians". In Sharon R. Steadman, Gregory McMahon (eds.). The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Anatolia (10,000–323 BCE). Oxford University Press. 2001. p. 549.
  25. Birgit Christiansen. "Granaries in Urartu and Neighboring States and the Monumentalization of Administrative Records". In Pavel S. Avestisyan, Roberto Dan, Yervand H. Grekyan (eds.). Over the Mountains and Far Away. Archaeopress Archaeology. 2019. pp. 137, 140.
  26. A. Y. Movsisyan, "The hieroglyphic script of van kingdom (Biainili, Urartu, Ararat)", Publishing House Gitutyun of NAS RA, Yerevan 1998.
  27. I. M. Diakonoff, "The Pre-history of the Armenian People". Delmar, New York (1968), p. 72.
  28. Piotrovsky, Boris B. The Ancient Civilization of Urartu. New York: Cowles Book Co., Inc., 1969, 51.
  29. Bryce, Trevor (2009). The Routledge Handbook of the Peoples and Places of Ancient Western Asia. Taylor & Francis.
  30. Kosyan, Aram (2011). "Towards the Hittite Eastern Periphery". Armenian Journal of Near Eastern Studies. VI (2): 91–92.
  31. Paul Zimansky. Ecology and Empire: The Structure of the Urartian State. pp. 49–50.
  32. Lehmann-Haupt, C. F. Armenien. Berlin: B. Behr, 1910–1931.
  33. Zimansky, Paul. "Xenophon and the Urartian legacy". Dans les pas des Dix-Mille (1995): 261–262.
  34. Greppin . John A. C. . Diakonoff . I. M. . October–December 1991 . Some Effects of the Hurro-Urartian People and Their Languages upon the Earliest Armenians . Journal of the American Oriental Society . 111 . 4 . 727. 10.2307/603403 . 603403 .
  35. Zimansky, Paul. Ecology and Empire: The Structure of the Urartian State. 1985. p. 67.
  36. Simon . Zsolt . 2012 . Where is the Land of Sura of the Hieroglyphic Luwian Inscription KARKAMIŠ A4b and Why Were Cappadocians Called Syrians by Greeks? . Altorientalische Forschungen . 39 . 1 . 167–180 . 10.1524/aofo.2012.0011 . 163257058 . 0232-8461.
  37. Payne . M. R. . Ceylan . A. . 2003 . A new Urartian inscription from Ağri-Pirabat . Studi Micenei ed Egeo-Anatolici . XLV . 2 . 191–201.
  38. Web site: The Book of Genesis: Chapter 8. LatinVulgate.com. Mental Systems. 8 June 2018. latinvulgategen84.
  39. 19:37 NRSV
  40. 19:37 KJV
  41. Book: Brand. Chad. Holman Illustrated Bible Dictionary. Mitchell. Eric. etal. November 2015. B&H Publishing Group. 978-0-8054-9935-3.
  42. Armen Petrosyan. "The Indo-European and Ancient Near Eastern Sources of the Armenian Epic". Journal of Indo-European Studies. Institute for the Study of Man. 2002. p. 184.
  43. Armen Petrosyan. https://www.academia.edu/3656244/The_Indo_European_and_Ancient_Near_Eastern_Sources_of_the_Armenian_Epic_Washington_D_C_2002?auto=download "The Indo-European and Ancient Near Eastern Sources of the Armenian Epic"
  44. Book: Martirosyan, Hamlet . URARTU, ARATTA, ŠUBUR, ARMANNU, URI - ՀԱՅՔԻ ՍԵՊԱԳԻՐ ԱՆՎԱՆՈՒՄՆԵՐԸ.
  45. https://www.academia.edu/10023756/Urartian_and_the_Urartians Zimansky, Paul Urartu and the Urartians, pp. 557
  46. Urartian Material Culture As State Assemblage: An Anomaly in the Archaeology of Empire, Paul Zimansky, Page 103 of 103-115
  47. Adam T. Smith. The Political Landscape: Constellations of Authority in Early Complex Polities. University of California Press. 2003. https://books.google.com/books?id=5KhXE6mqSx8C&dq=6600+argishti+erebuni&pg=PA168
  48. Hovhannisyan, Konstantine. «էրեբունի» (Erebuni). Armenian Soviet Encyclopedia. vol. iv. Yerevan: Armenian Academy of Sciences, 1979, pp. 90-91.
  49. D.D. Luckenbill, Ancient Records of Assyria and Babylonia, (1927, vol II:84), quoted in Robin Lane Fox, Travelling Heroes in the Epic Age of Homer (2008:17).
  50. Web site: Kayalıdere Kalesi Urartu Çanak Çömleği: 2018/2019 Yılı Kazıları. April 2023. Yuzuncu Yil University. Turkish . 3.
  51. Book: Roux, Georges. - Ancient Iraq page 314. Penguin. 1966. 314. 9780140208283.
  52. Journal of Ancient History 1951, No 3. Pages. 243–244
  53. Letter of Ashubanipal to Sarduri III. HABL, № 1242.
  54. [Michael Roaf]
  55. Michael Roaf. "Could Rusa son of Erimena have been king of Urartu during Sargon's Eighth Campaign?" BIAINILI-URARTUThe Proceedings of the Symposium held in Munich 12–14 October 2007. https://www.academia.edu/30995381/Could_Rusa_son_of_Erimena_have_been_king_of_Urartu_during_Sargon_s_Eighth_Campaign_
  56. Book: Chahin, M.. The Kingdom of Armenia: A History. 2001. Psychology Press. 978-0-7007-1452-0. en. 107.
  57. Book: Kurdoghlian, Mihran . Badmoutioun Hayots, Volume I . Hradaragoutioun Azkayin Oussoumnagan Khorhourti . 1994 . 46–48. hy.
  58. Nunn . Astrid . 2011-05-15 . « The Median 'Empire', the End of Urartu and Cyrus the Great's Campaign in 547 BC (Nabonidus Chronicle II 16) ». Ancient West & East 7, 2008, p. 51-66. . Abstracta Iranica. Revue bibliographique pour le domaine irano-aryen . fr . 31 . 10.4000/abstractairanica.39422 . 0240-8910. Après citation des passages pertinents, analyse des toponymes et une nouvelle lecture de la Chronique de Nabonide II 16, dont le nom géographique clef doit être lu « Urartu », il reste : Cyrus le Grand a « marché vers Urartu et vaincu son roi ». Urartu n’a donc pas été détruit par les Mèdes à la fin du VIIe s. mais a continué à exister comme entité politique jusqu’au milieu du VIe s. La Chronique de Nabonide (II 16) montre bien que la conquête de Cyrus le Grand mit fin à ce royaume.. free .
  59. Web site: Urartu – Lost Kingdom of Van. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20150702205257/http://www.starspring.com/ascender/urartu/urartu.html. 2015-07-02. 2015-06-18.
  60. Van de Mieroop, Marc. A History of the Ancient Near East c. 3000 – 323 BC. Cornwall: Blackwell, 2007, p. 217. .
  61. Daryaee, Touraj The Fall of Urartu and the Rise of Armenia, 2018, pp. 39.http://www.academia.edu/37612879/T._Daryaee_THE_FALL_OF_URARTU_AND_THE_RISE_OF_ARMENIA_Reflections_of_Armenian_Identity_in_History_eds._H._Berberian_and_T._Daryaee_UCI_Center_for_Persian_Studies_2018_pp._38-44
  62. Book: Oriental Studies in the USSR. Nauka Publishers, Central Department of Oriental Literature. 1988. Indiana University. 312. In his view, the first Armenian state was the kingdom of "The House of Togarmah" in the area of Melid (Melitene, modern Malatya) on ... Here, as we know from the abovementionaed inscriptions, “Armenia” and “Urartu” were synonyms ....
  63. Encyclopedia: Hewsen. R. H. AYRARAT. Encyclopædia Iranica. 2012-09-03.
  64. Armen Asher The Peoples of Ararat. 2009, p. 291. .
  65. Book: The Cambridge ancient history.. registration. 1970–2005. Cambridge University Press. Edwards, I. E. S. . 978-0521850735. 3rd. Cambridge [England]. 314. 121060. In 1828, a French scholar, J. St Martin, [...] began to grope towards an explanation by connecting [Urartian cuneiform inscriptions] with the garbled legends preserved by an Armenian chronicler, Moses of Khorene (Moses Khorenatsi), probably of the eighth century A.D., according to whom the region was invaded from Assyria by a great army under its queen Semiramis who built a wondrous fortified city, citadel, and palaces at Van itself beside the lake. [...] It is clear that by the time of Moses of Khorene all other memory of this kingdom [Kingdom of Urartu], once the deadly rival of Assyria itself, had been forgotten and remained so, except for these popular legends..
  66. Book: The heritage of Armenian literature. 2000–2005. Wayne State University Press. Hacikyan, A. J. . Basmajian, Gabriel . Franchuk, Edward S. . Ouzounian, Nourhan.. 978-0814328156. Detroit. 31. 42477084. The story [of the legend of Hayk] retains a few remote memories from tribal times, and reflects the struggles between Urartu-Ararat and Assyro-Babylonia from the ninth to the seventh centuries B.C. The tale had evolved through the ages, and by the time Movses Khorenatsi heard it and put it into writing, it had already acquired a coherent structure and literary style..
  67. Anatolian Iron Ages 5 . Fifth Anatolian Iron Ages Colloquium held at Van, 6-10 August 2001. 2005. British Institute at Ankara . Çilingiroğlu, Altan . Darbyshire, G. . 978-1912090570. London. 146. 607821861. What had for some time attracted the attention of scholars, and had led the Iranianist Saint-Martin of the Académie des Inscription in Paris to send the young Schulz to explore these sites [in Van], was to be found written in chapter 16 of Khorenatsi's work..
  68. Lang, pp. 112, 117
  69. Diakonov, I. The Pre-history of the Armenian People. Delmar, NY: Caravan Books, 1984.
  70. Zimansky, Paul "Urartian and Urartians." The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Anatolia (2011): 557.http://www.academia.edu/10023756/Urartian_and_the_Urartians
  71. Eight Millennia of Matrilineal Genetic Continuity in the South Caucasus. June 29, 2017. Current Biology. 28669760 . To shed light on the maternal genetic history of the region, we analyzed the complete mitochondrial genomes of 52 ancient skeletons from present-day Armenia and Artsakh spanning 7,800 years and combined this dataset with 206 mitochondrial genomes of modern Armenians. We also included previously published data of seven neighboring populations (n = 482). Coalescence-based analyses suggest that the population size in this region rapidly increased after the Last Glacial Maximum ca. 18 kya. We find that the lowest genetic distance in this dataset is between modern Armenians and the ancient individuals, as also reflected in both network analyses and discriminant analysis of principal components.
    [...]
    A total of 19 archaeological sites are represented, covering large parts of Armenia as well as Artsakh (Figure 1), and estimated to be between 300–7800 years old based on contextual dating of artifacts. This time span is accompanied by at least seven well-defined cultural transitions: Neolithic, Chalcolithic, Kura-Araxes, Trialeti-Vanadzor 2, Lchashen-Metsamor, Urartian and Armenian Classical/Medieval (Figure 1).. Margaryan . A. . Derenko . M. . Hovhannisyan . H. . Malyarchuk . B. . Heller . R. . Khachatryan . Z. . Avetisyan . P. . Badalyan . R. . Bobokhyan . A. . Melikyan . V. . Sargsyan . G. . Piliposyan . A. . Simonyan . H. . Mkrtchyan . R. . Denisova . G. . Yepiskoposyan . L. . Willerslev . E. . Allentoft . M. E. . 27 . 13 . 2023–2028.e7 . 10.1016/j.cub.2017.05.087 . 23400138 . free . 2017CBio...27E2023M .
  72. Book: Chahin, M.. The kingdom of Armenia: a history. Curzon. 2001. 978-0700714520. 2nd revised. Richmond. 182.
  73. Book: Frye, Richard N.. The History of Ancient Iran. 1984. C.H. Beck. Munich. 978-3406093975. 73. registration. The real heirs of the Urartians, however, were neither the Scythians nor Medes but the Armenians..
  74. Book: Redgate, A. E.. The Armenians. 2000. Blackwell. Oxford. 978-0631220374. 5. registration. However, the most easily identifiable ancestors of the later Armenian nation are the Urartians..
  75. Book: Lang, David Marshall. Armenia: Cradle of Civilization. 1980. Allen & Unwin. London. 978-0049560093. 85–111. 3rd.
  76. Book: Zimansky, Paul E.. Oxford University Press. 978-0-19-506512-1. The Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East. Urartu. 2018-11-22. 2011-01-01. http://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/acref/9780195065121.001.0001/acref-9780195065121-e-1097. 10.1093/acref/9780195065121.001.0001.
  77. Book: Radner . Karen . The Oxford History of the Ancient Near East Volume IV: The Age of Assyria . Moeller . Nadine . Potts . D.T. . Oxford University Press . 2023 . 9780190687632 . 769.
  78. Book: Burney, Charles . Oxford University Press. 978-0-19-860568-3. The Oxford Companion to Architecture. Urartu. 2018-11-22. 2009-01-01. http://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/acref/9780198605683.001.0001/acref-9780198605683-e-1361. 10.1093/acref/9780198605683.001.0001.
  79. 1609-8498. 18. 4. 327–344. Dan. Roberto. Inside the Empire: Some Remarks on the Urartian and Achaemenid Presence in the Autonomous Republic of Nakhchivan. Iran & the Caucasus. 2014. 43899165. 10.1163/1573384X-20140402.
  80. Web site: Tarihi Eserler . 2024-04-25 . mus.bel.tr . tr.
  81. [H. F. B. Lynch|Lynch, H.F.B.]
  82. News: . Underwater ruins of 3,000-year-old castle discovered in Turkey . . . 12 November 2017. 21 November 2017.
  83. Piotrovskii, Boris, B. Ванское царство (Урарту), Moscow: Vostochnoy Literaturi Publishing, 1959.
  84. C. A. Burney, "Urartian". Grove Art Online, Oxford Art Online. Oxford University Press, accessed December 30, 2012, online, subscription required
  85. Yervand Grekyan. "Urartian State Mythology". Yerevan Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography Press. 2018. pp. 44-45. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/351107801_Biaynili-Owrartu_Astvacner_tacarner_pastamunk_BIAINILI-URARTU_GODS_TEMPLES_CULTS
  86. Book: Piotrovsky, Boris B.. The Ancient Civilization of Urartu: An Archaeological Adventure . 1969 . Cowles Book Co. . 978-0-214-66793-0.
  87. Zimansky, Paul . Imagining Haldi . Stories of Long Ago: Festschrift für Michael Roaf . 2012 . 714 .
  88. https://www.britannica.com/topic/Teshub
  89. Petrosyan, Armen. "The Eastern Hittites in the South and East of the Armenian Highland?" Aramazd: Armenian Journal of Near Eastern Studies. IV, 1 (2009). p. 63
  90. Book: Chahin, Mark. The Kingdom of Armenia. 1987 . Dorset Press. 978-0-88029-609-0.
  91. The Cambridge Ancient History: III Part 1: The Prehistory of the Balkans, the Middle East and the Aegean World, Tenth to Eighth Centuries BC. Cambridge University Press. 1971. p. 335.
  92. Adontz, Nicholas. The World-view of Ancient Armenians. Hayrmik Motuhty. 1926. No. 12, p. 75.
  93. Yervand Grekyan. "Urartian State Mythology". Yerevan Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography Press. 2018. p. 34 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/351107801_Biaynili-Owrartu_Astvacner_tacarner_pastamunk_BIAINILI-URARTU_GODS_TEMPLES_CULTS
  94. Book: Mirjo Salvini . Çilingiroğlu A., French D. H. . The historical background of the Urartian monument of Meher Kapisi . Anatolian Iron Ages 3; The proceedings of the Third Anatolian Iron Ages Colloquium held at Van, 6—12 1990 . Ankara . 1994 . 16 . British Institute of Archaeology in Ankara . 16 . 205–210 . 10.18866/j.ctt1pc5gxc.31 . 1-898249-05-9.
  95. Róna-Tas, András.Hungarians and Europe in the Early Middle Ages: An Introduction to Early Hungarian History. Budapest: Central European University Press, 1999 p. 76 .
  96. Greppin. John A. C.. 1991. Some Effects of the Hurro-Urartian People and Their Languages upon the Earliest Armenians. Journal of the American Oriental Society. 3. 4. 720–730. 10.2307/603403. 603403. Even for now, however, it seems difficult to deny that the Armenians had contact, at an early date, with a Hurro-Urartian people..
  97. Book: Scarre. Chris. Human past: world prehistory and the development of human societies.. W W Norton. 2013. 978-0500290637. 3rd.
  98. Book: Van de Mieroop, Marc . A History of the Ancient Near East, ca. 3000-323 BC . Blackwell Publishing . 2007 . 215.
  99. Book: Van de Mieroop, Marc . A History of the Ancient Near East, ca. 3000-323 BC . Blackwell Publishing . 2007 . 215.
  100. [Archibald Sayce|Sayce, Archibald H]
  101. Armen Asher The Peoples of Ararat. 2009, p. 290-291. .
  102. Zimansky, Paul "Xenophon and the Urartian legacy." Dans les pas des Dix-Mille (1995): 264-265 https://www.academia.edu/1348213/Xenophon_and_the_Urartian_legacy
  103. Encyclopedia: ARMENIA and IRAN i. Armina, Achaemenid province. Encyclopædia Iranica. 2012-09-03. Schmitt. R.
  104. http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/dadarsis-old-persian-name-derived-from-darsto-dare-kent-old-persian-p DADARSIS, 2011
  105. Dandamaev, M.A. A Political History of the Achaemenid Empire, 1989
  106. Petrosyan . Armen . 2010 . The Armenian Elements in the Language and Onomastics of Urartu . ARAMAZD: Armenian Journal of Near Eastern Studies . V . 1 . 133–140.
  107. Petrosyan . Armen . 2016 . Indo-European *wel- in Armenian mythology . Journal of Indo-European Studies . 44 . 129–146 . 0092-2323.
  108. Hrach Martirosyan (2014). "Origins and Historical Development of the Armenian Language". Leiden University: 9. Retrieved 16 February 2020.https://ling.hse.ru/data/2014/09/01/1313574129/Hrach%20Martirosyan%20-%20Handout.pdf
  109. Petrosyan . Sargis . 2019 . Լույսի պաշտամունքի էթիունյան վայրերը . Sites of the Etiuni Light Cult . Shirak Centre of Armenological Studies of NAS RA . 22 . 1–2 . 5–19.
  110. Book: Gamkrelidze. Tamaz V.. Indo-European and the Indo-Europeans: A Reconstruction and Historical Analysis of a Proto-Language and Proto-Culture. Part I: The Text. Part II: Bibliography, Indexes. Ivanov. Vyacheslav. Walter de Gruyter. 1995. 978-3-11-081503-0. Tamaz V. Gamkrelidze. Vyacheslav Ivanov (philologist).

This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Urartu".

Except where otherwise indicated, Everything.Explained.Today is © Copyright 2009-2024, A B Cryer, All Rights Reserved. Cookie policy.