The Federalists ran a mixed ticket consisting of 2 Federalists (Aaron Ogden and John Beatty) and 4 Democratic-Republicans (William Helms, Ebenezer Elmer, George Maxwell, and Adam Boyd), one of whom (William Helms) was also on the Democratic-Republican ticket. The Federalists capitalized on resentment over the replacement on the official Democratic-Republican ticket of Ebenezer Elmer, from South Jersey, with Thomas Newbold from Monmouth County and the retention of James Sloan. This ticket was formed too late to gain sufficient support, but the Federalists did do much better in state elections that year than they had in previous elections.[1]
| District | Incumbent | Party | First elected | Result | Candidates | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| William Helms | Democratic-Republican | 1800 | Incumbent re-elected. | √ William Helms (Democratic-Republican) 14.9% √ Thomas Newbold (Democratic-Republican) 12.4% √ Henry Southard (Democratic-Republican) 12.4% √ Ezra Darby (Democratic-Republican) 11.9% √ John Lambert (Democratic-Republican) 11.8% √ James Sloan (Democratic-Republican) 11.2% Aaron Ogden (Federalist) 5.9% Ebenezer Elmer (Democratic-Republican) 5.8% John Beatty (Federalist) 5.3% George C. Maxwell (Democratic-Republican) 3.8% Adam Boyd (Democratic-Republican) 3.4% | ||
| Ebenezer Elmer | Democratic-Republican | 1800 | Incumbent lost re-election. New member elected. Democratic-Republican hold. | |||
| Henry Southard | Democratic-Republican | 1800 | Incumbent re-elected. | |||
| Ezra Darby | Democratic-Republican | 1804 | Incumbent re-elected. | |||
| John Lambert | Democratic-Republican | 1804 | Incumbent re-elected. | |||
| James Sloan | Democratic-Republican | 1803 | Incumbent re-elected. |