2017 United Kingdom general election in Scotland explained

Election Name:2017 United Kingdom general election
Country:Scotland
Type:parliamentary
Ongoing:no
Previous Election:2015 United Kingdom general election in Scotland
Previous Year:2015
Previous Mps:List of MPs for constituencies in Scotland (2015–2017)
Next Election:2019 United Kingdom general election in Scotland
Next Year:2019
Seats For Election:All 59 Scottish seats to the House of Commons
Elected Mps:List of MPs for constituencies in Scotland (2017–2019)
Turnout:66.4%, 4.7%
Leader1:Nicola Sturgeon
Leader Since1:14 November 2014
Party1:Scottish National Party
Popular Vote1:977,569
Percentage1:36.9%
Swing1:13.1%
Last Election1:56 seats, 50.0%
Seats Before1:54
Seats1:35
Seat Change1:21
Leader2:Theresa May
Leader Since2:11 July 2016
Party2:Conservative Party (UK)
Popular Vote2:757,949
Percentage2:28.6%
Swing2:13.7%
Last Election2:1 seat, 14.9%
Seats Before2:1
Seats2:13
Seat Change2:12
Leader4:Jeremy Corbyn
Leader Since4:12 September 2015
Party4:Labour Party (UK)
Popular Vote4:717,007
Percentage4:27.1%
Swing4:2.8%
Last Election4:1 seat, 24.3%
Seats Before4:1
Seats4:7
Seat Change4:6
Leader5:Tim Farron
Leader Since5:16 July 2015
Party5:Liberal Democrats (UK)
Last Election5:1 seat, 7.5%
Popular Vote5:179,061
Percentage5:6.8%
Swing5:0.8%
Seats Before5:1
Seats5:4
Seat Change5:3

A general election was held in the United Kingdom on Thursday 8 June 2017; all 59 seats in Scotland were contested under the first-past-the-post electoral system.

The general election in Scotland was fought in the aftermath of the 2016 Scottish Parliament election, in which the Scottish National Party (SNP) won a third term in government but lost its overall majority in the Scottish Parliament. At that election, the Scottish Conservatives increased their number of MSPs, overtaking Labour as the largest opposition party. The 2016 EU referendum was held a month later on Thursday 23 June, and the final result was for the United Kingdom to leave the EU; despite Scotland voting 62.0% for 'Remain'. Negotiations were due to begin shortly since invocation of Article 50 of the Treaty on European Union in March 2017, which was expected to dominate the snap general election campaign.[1]

In line with the Fixed-term Parliaments Act 2011, an election had not been due until 7 May 2020, but a call for a snap election by Prime Minister Theresa May received the necessary two-thirds majority in a 522–13 vote in the House of Commons on 19 April 2017.[2] The Conservative Party, which has governed nationally since 2010, was defending a majority of 17[3] against the Labour Party, the official opposition. The third-largest party was the SNP, which had won 56 of the 59 Scottish seats at the 2015 general election.

The election resulted in the SNP remaining the largest single party in Scotland, despite losing 21 seats to pro-union candidates. This marked a 13% drop in support for the SNP, down to 36.9% of the vote. The Conservatives, at 28.6%, doubled their share of the vote and won 13 seats, while Labour won seven seats and the Liberal Democrats four seats. The Conservatives recorded their best result in Scotland since 1983 (in terms of seats won) or 1979 (in terms of share of the popular vote). Until this election the Conservatives had not been the second-largest party in Scotland since 1992 and had not been the largest unionist party in Scotland since 1955.

Defeated SNP MPs included: former SNP leader and former First Minister of Scotland Alex Salmond,[4] SNP Westminster leader Angus Robertson,[5] SNP Chief Whip Mike Weir;[6] as well as John Nicolson[7] and Tasmina Ahmed-Sheikh.[8] Commentators suggested that the election might reduce the SNP's case for a second referendum on Scottish independence.[9] [10] [11] Following the election, the SNP leader Nicola Sturgeon acknowledged that her party's plans for a second referendum were 'undoubtedly' a factor in the election results. The SNP also abandoned its fundraiser for a possible referendum after raising only half of its £1,000,000 target, just over a week before its preset deadline.[12]

Political context

Following a referendum held on Scottish independence in 2014 which saw 44.7% of voters in Scotland vote for Scotland to become an independent state and 55.3% vote for Scotland to remain a part of the United Kingdom, the SNP won 56 of the 59 UK Parliamentary seats in Scotland at the 2015 UK general election, campaigning on a manifesto focusing on bringing greater devolved powers to Scotland following a promise made by the three main unionist parties in Scotland to bring more devolved powers to the country should it reject independence.[13] The SNP manifesto at the 2015 general election repeatedly stated that "The SNP will always support independence - but that is not what this election is about".

Labour only returned a single MP at Edinburgh South; a reduction of 40 seats compared to the previous election. The party lost out heavily to the SNP in working-class areas around the Scottish Central Belt, with Scottish Labour's safest constituency (Glasgow North East) returning the largest swing at the general election for any seat in the UK with 39.3% from Labour to SNP. The party performed best in more affluent constituencies, with then-Scottish Labour leader Jim Murphy missing out in his former constituency of East Renfrewshire by just 3,718 votes. Labour's next closest result was at Edinburgh North and Leith, where they missed out to the SNP by 5,597 votes, and in East Lothian, where the SNP polled ahead of Labour by 6,803 votes.

The Scottish Liberal Democrats lost 10 of their 11 Westminster seats from 2010, with their safest seat in the UK - Orkney and Shetland - remaining as the only Liberal Democrat seat in Scotland. They marginally lost out to the SNP in East Dunbartonshire, where former Lib Dem MP Jo Swinson lost out to the SNP by 2,167 votes. Among those to lose their seat at the election were: former Liberal Democrat leader Charles Kennedy and the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, Danny Alexander. The Liberal Democrats finished in third place at Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk and West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine, seats which they had held at the previous election.

The Scottish Conservative Party had not held a majority of Scottish seats at a general election since 1955 and lost all Scottish representation at the 1997 general election. Since 2001, the party had held only one Scottish seat in the House of Commons. In 2005, following the re-organisation of Scottish constituencies, that seat was Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale, a mostly rural constituency near the Scottish Borders. In 2015, its share of the vote in Scotland decreased by 1.8% but managed to retain Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale, as its only Scottish seat. It had been reported the party could gain Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk,[14] a seat which they lost out to the Scottish National Party by a meagre 0.6% of the vote.

The SNP polled slightly under half of the votes, 49.97%, in Scotland at the 2015 general election; the largest vote share at a general election in Scotland for a party since the Conservatives won a majority of the popular vote, 50.1%, in 1955.

The impact of the 2016 EU referendum and a proposed second Scottish independence referendum was a large theme at the snap 2017 general election.[15] The SNP incorrectly predicted that many pro-union voters would switch allegiance to the party in order to remain within the European Union. Polling from YouGov suggests people moving towards independence as a result of Brexit would be offset by the number of previously pro-independence Leave voters saying they would vote against independence as a result of Brexit.[16]

A study by Electoral Calculus, published on 14 May 2017, concluded that the Conservatives could win 11 seats in Scotland.[17] [18]

Campaign events

Television debates

Like the rest of the United Kingdom, Scottish broadcasters hosted television debates. On 21 May, BBC Scotland announced that they would host a debate on 10 December, two days before the election, which was moderated by Sarah Smith. On 6 June, two days before the election, STV hosted a television debate from the Tramway theatre in Glasgow with the four main Scottish leaders.[19] It was originally due to be held the week before but this was postponed until Tuesday 6 June.[20] The debate was moderated by Bernard Ponsbury.

United Kingdom general election debates, 2017[21] [22]
DateOrganisersVenue<----> <---->
Cons.LabourSNPLib. Dem.GreenUKIP
21 MayBBC ScotlandEdinburgh
5 JuneBBC (Question Time)EdinburghNINININI
6 JuneSTVGlasgowNINI

Results

Party[23] ! colspan="5"
SeatsVotes
Total Gains LossesNet +/-% seatsTotal votes% votesChange
350212159.3977,56936.913.1
131201222.0757,94928.613.7
760611.9717,00727.12.8
43036.8179,0616.80.8
0005,8860.21.1
0005,3020.21.4
Others0006,9210.30.3
align=“right” 2,649,695align=“right” 66.4align=“right” 4.7

Description of results

At the election the SNP remained the largest party in Scotland, taking the vast majority of seats situated around the more industrial Central Belt of the country, between Balloch, Dundee, Irvine, Kilmarnock and Livingston, where the campaign in favour of Scottish independence performed best at the 2014 independence referendum.[24] The party also took the most votes and a majority of seats in three out of four major cities in Scotland (Dundee, Glasgow and Edinburgh), however Labour were within 1,200 votes of taking the most votes in Edinburgh and were within 200 votes of gaining two additional seats in Glasgow.[25] The SNP failed to win a majority of the vote in any of Scotland's 59 constituencies.[26]

The Scottish Conservatives performed best in areas where the campaign in favour of remaining part of the United Kingdom performed best in at the 2014 independence referendum and in areas where the campaign to leave the European Union performed best in at the 2016 EU membership referendum.[27] The Conservatives formed the largest party in the south of the country through Dumfries and Galloway, the Scottish Borders and South Ayrshire, where they won four seats in total. They also gained the East Renfrewshire constituency, an affluent commuter suburb on the outskirts of Glasgow which was the safest Conservative constituency in Scotland before their collapse at the 1997 general election,[28] and gained the Ochil and South Perthshire and Stirling constituencies in Central Scotland, coming within 21 votes of gaining Perth and North Perthshire, the second closest result in Scotland and the third closest across the United Kingdom as a whole. Six out of seven constituencies in the North-East of Scotland voted Conservative, including former SNP party leader and First Minister of Scotland Alex Salmond's constituency of Gordon, and the SNP Westminster leader Angus Robertson's seat of Moray. Two out of three seats covering the city of Aberdeen returned Conservative MP's. In a profile of the seat of Moray for The Guardian after the election, journalist Severin Carrell summarised the result: "Moray had been an SNP seat for 30 years but... using Brexit as the basis for a second independence vote so soon after 2014 crystallised an irritation with the party brewing for several years. The Tory cry that Sturgeon needed “to get on with the day job” resonated."[29]

Scottish Labour retained their Edinburgh South constituency with a significant majority of 15,514 votes (32.4%), making it the safest constituency in Scotland. They also regained a number of previously safe Labour working-class constituencies in the Central Belt of Scotland, including Coatbridge, Chryston and Bellshill, Glasgow North East, Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath and Rutherglen and Hamilton West, gaining a further two seats in Lothian (East Lothian and Midlothian). The party were within 1,400 votes of gaining a further six seats from the SNP in Greater Glasgow.

The Liberal Democrats gained the suburban constituencies of East Dunbartonshire and Edinburgh West on the outskirts of Glasgow and Edinburgh respectively. The party also regained their former heartland of Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross, a large rural constituency covering the northernmost parts of Great Britain, with Orkney and Shetland again becoming the safest Lib Dem constituency in the UK in vote share terms, with a majority 19.6% of the vote. They lost out to the SNP in the North East Fife constituency by just 2 votes (0.0%), the closest result in the United Kingdom at a general election since the result in Winchester in 1997.[30] However, the party's vote collapsed to the Conservatives in Aberdeenshire, the Borders and in parts of the Highlands.

Target seats

Scottish Conservatives

Rank [31] Constituency Winning party 2015Swing RequiredConservatives' place 2015Result
1Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk0.3%2nd
2Dumfries & Galloway5.8%2nd
3West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine6.4%2nd
4Perth and North Perthshire9.0%2nd
5Moray9.2%2nd
6East Renfrewshire9.3%3rd
7Aberdeen South9.4%3rd
8Edinburgh South10.8%3rd
9Stirling11.3%3rd
10Edinburgh South West11.4%3rd
11East Lothian11.5%3rd
12North East Fife12.4%3rd
13Edinburgh North and Leith12.4%3rd
14Angus12.6%2nd
15Ochil and South Perthshire12.6%3rd
16Edinburgh West13.3%3rd
17East Dunbartonshire14.4%3rd
18Ayr, Carrick and Cumnock14.5%3rd
19Argyll and Bute14.7%3rd
20Banff and Buchan15.7%2nd
21Lanark and Hamilton East16.5%3rd
22Central Ayrshire17.9%3rd
23Gordon18.0%3rd

Scottish Labour

RankConstituencyWinning party 2015Swing RequiredLabour's place 2015Result
1East Renfrewshire3.3%2nd
2Edinburgh North and Leith4.8%2nd
3East Lothian5.8%2nd
4Paisley and Renfrewshire South6.2%2nd
5Aberdeen South7.5%2nd
6Edinburgh South West7.9%2nd
7Dumfries and Galloway8.4%3rd
8Rutherglen and Hamilton West8.7%2nd
9Ochil and South Perthshire8.8%2nd
10Paisley and Renfrewshire North9.1%2nd
11Lanark and Hamilton East9.1%2nd
12Dunfermline and West Fife9.3%2nd
13Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath9.4%2nd
14Edinburgh East9.7%2nd
15Glasgow Central9.8%2nd
16Airdrie and Shotts9.9%2nd
17Stirling10.1%2nd
18Midlothian10.2%2nd
19Linlithgow and Falkirk East10.5%2nd
20Ayr, Carrick and Cumnock10.8%2nd
21Coatbridge, Chryston and Bellshill11.3%2nd
22Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale11.7%3rd
23Glasgow North West11.9%2nd
24Glasgow East12.2%2nd
25Glasgow North East12.3%2nd

Scottish Liberal Democrats

RankConstituencyWinning party 2015Swing RequiredLiberal Democrats' place 2015Result
1East Dunbartonshire2.0%2nd
2Edinburgh West2.9%2nd
3North East Fife4.9%2nd
4Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross5.7%2nd
5Ross, Skye and Lochaber6.1%2nd
6Gordon7.5%2nd

Scottish National Party

RankConstituencyWinning party 2015Swing RequiredSNP's place 2015Result
1Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale0.8%2nd
2Orkney and Shetland1.8%2nd
3Edinburgh South2.7%2nd

Notes and References

  1. News: Brexit Set to Dominate U.K.'s Snap Election . Fidler . Stephen . 18 April 2017 . . 21 April 2017.
  2. News: Theresa May seeks general election . 18 April 2017 . . 18 April 2017.
  3. Web site: Current State of the Parties . UK Parliament . 21 April 2017.
  4. News: Results for the Gordon constituency . 2018-04-23 . BBC News.
  5. News: Results for the Moray constituency . 2018-04-23 . BBC News.
  6. News: Results for the Angus constituency . 2018-04-23 . BBC News.
  7. News: Results for the Dunbartonshire East constituency . 2018-04-23 . BBC News.
  8. News: Results for Orchil & South Perthshire constituency . 2018-04-23 . BBC News.
  9. News: Johnson . Simon . Henderson . Barney . Scotland election results: Alex Salmond defeated and SNP suffer huge losses as Tory chances boosted north of the border . . 9 June 2017 . 8 June 2017.
  10. News: General election 2017: SNP lose a third of seats amid Tory surge . 9 June 2017 . 9 June 2017.
  11. Web site: Thomas . Natalie . Dickie . Mure . Scottish election results strike blow to SNP plans for IndyRef2 . . 8 June 2017.
  12. News: SNP removes independence referendum fundraising page . BBC News . 13 June 2017.
  13. Web site: SNP Manifesto 2015. SNP. 25 June 2017. https://web.archive.org/web/20150426063840/http://votesnp.com/docs/manifesto.pdf. 26 April 2015. dead. dmy-all.
  14. Web site: The Tories could win more seats in Scotland than Labour or the Lib Dems. May2015: 2015 General Election Guide. 22 April 2017. 20 December 2016. https://web.archive.org/web/20161220002940/http://www.may2015.com/ideas/the-tories-could-win-more-seats-in-scotland-than-labour-or-the-lib-dems/. dead.
  15. Web site: Election 2017: How the battle is different in Scotland . BBC News . 2017-04-19 . 2018-04-23.
  16. Web site: Why have the polls not shown a shift towards Scottish independence? . YouGov . 2017-01-27 . 2017-06-09.
  17. Web site: Aitken. Mark. Tories tipped to oust SNP deputy leader Angus Robertson and take 11 seats in General Election. Daily Record. 16 May 2017. 14 May 2017.
  18. Web site: Baxter. Martin. Full predictions seat-by-seat (Constituency List: Scotland). Electoral Calculus. 16 May 2017.
  19. Web site: Election 2017: Scottish leaders debate on STV confirmed. Scott Macnab Email. 2017-04-27. The Scotsman. 2017-06-09.
  20. Web site: STV invites leaders to rescheduled election debate. 2017-05-30. Stv.tv. 2017-06-09.
  21. Web site: General Election 2017 TV debates: Times, dates and everything else you need to know. 12 May 2017. London Evening Standard. 14 May 2017.
  22. Web site: Sky News to host Theresa May and Jeremy Corbyn in live TV special. 15 May 2017. Sky News. 15 May 2017.
  23. Web site: Scotland Results. BBC News.
  24. Web site: Scotland Votes NO. BBC.
  25. News: Gallagher . Paul . 2017-06-09 . General election 2017: The smallest majorities of the night . . 2017-06-19.
  26. Web site: Constituency List: Scotland. Elecotral Calculus.
  27. Web site: EU Referendum. BBC.
  28. News: UK Polling Report. 24 June 2017.
  29. News: Severin Carrel . Moray: 'We are fed up with the SNP. It's as simple as that' . The Guardian . 27 June 2017 . 8 July 2021 . English . live. https://web.archive.org/web/20170627131429/https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/jun/27/moray-fed-up-with-snp-simple-as-that-scotland-election . 27 June 2017 .
  30. News: General election 2017: SNP wins Fife North East seat by just two votes . BBC . 2017-06-09 . 2017-06-15.
  31. Web site: Battleground Seats. scotlandvotes.com. 17 May 2017. https://web.archive.org/web/20150427111405/http://www.scotlandvotes.com/westminster/battleground-seats. 27 April 2015. dead. dmy-all.