Super Bowl Ad Meter Explained

The USA Today Super Bowl Ad Meter is an annual survey taken of television commercials by USA Today in a live poll during the telecast in the United States of the Super Bowl, the annual professional American football championship game of the National Football League. The survey, which started in 1989, uses a live response on a zero-to-ten scale (zero being the worst, ten the best) of focus groups based in McLean, Virginia, the newspaper headquarters and one (or more) site(s) around the country.

Background

See main article: Super Bowl advertising. The Super Bowl became the must-see event for advertisers during the third quarter of the telecast of Super Bowl XVIII on CBS, when Apple Computer debuted a one-time-only advertisement for their Macintosh computer titled 1984, directed by Ridley Scott. As the Los Angeles Raiders routed the Washington Redskins, 38–9, the Apple commercial, not the game, was the most-talked about item around water coolers the very next day. Since then, major advertisers have used the game, paying as much as seven figures (averaging over US $5 million for one 30-second slot),[1] [2] excluding production expenses) to showcase their work and generate buzz that many people tune into television's biggest event of the year just to watch the commercials, not the actual game. For those reasons, USA Today started the Ad Meter, a poll that gives live responses per second of each commercial. According to the newspaper, ads by rule are limited to those shown during the game - from opening kickoff to the end of the game, excluding those shown at halftime or local commercials - are officially qualified for consideration in the Ad Meter survey.

A new element was added for 2012, as users of Facebook and those logging onto the USA Today website were involved in a second survey that lasted until February 7 at 6:00 pm US EST. The online element was added to the regular meter for 2013.

Past winners

YearSuper BowlAdvertiserAd Description
1989XXIIIAmerican ExpressActors Jon Lovitz and Dana Carvey (both starring at the time on Saturday Night Live) go to the big game with credit cards - Lovitz with Visa, Carvey with American Express.
1990XXIVNikeVarious announcers (Harry Caray among others) call a multisport event with the likes of Wayne Gretzky, Michael Jordan and Bo Jackson.
1991XXVDiet PepsiWhen Coca-Cola pulled a humorous ad in light of the First Iraqi war, Diet Pepsi scored big with Ray Charles and others (including Jerry Lewis, Tiny Tim, Vic Damone and Charo) singing their "You Got the Right One, Baby" jingle.
1992XXVINikeMichael Jordan and Bugs Bunny (calling himself "Hare Jordan") go to Mars and team up to take on an evil basketball team fielded by Marvin the Martian, with the fate of Earth at stake. The spot served as the inspiration for the film Space Jam.
1993XXVIIMcDonald'sMichael Jordan and Larry Bird play an outrageous game of H-O-R-S-E throughout Chicago for a Big Mac.
1994XXVIIIPepsi-ColaA lab chimp turns into a party animal at the beach after drinking soda.
1995XXIXPepsi-ColaA boy on the beach tries to suck the last drop of Pepsi out of a bottle with a straw, sucking so hard that the backlash pulls him through the straw and into the bottle. His little sister then yells, "Mom, he's done it again!"
1996XXXPepsi-ColaA fictional Coke driver takes a can of Pepsi and the whole shelf of cans tumbles onto the floor in a simulated security camera footage, with the Hank Williams song "Your Cheatin' Heart" in the background. This commercial was chosen as the best ever ad in the twenty-year history in a special survey of the previous poll winners in 2008.
1997XXXIPepsi-Colacomputer-animated grizzly bears do their Pepsi-inspired 1980s classics with the YMCA.
1998XXXIIPepsi-ColaA skysurfer does aerial tricks with a goose, and they share a Pepsi afterwards.
1999XXXIIIBudweiserTwo dalmatian puppies are separated at birth, and one becomes the mascot of the Clydesdale-driven beer wagon.
2000XXXIVBudweiserRex the Wonder Dog imagines chasing a Budweiser truck, only to blindly leap headfirst onto a mini-van.
2001XXXVBud LightCedric the Entertainer's dream date is ruined when he accidentally shakes a pair of Bud Light bottles which explode all over his girlfriend.
2002XXXVIBud LightA girlfriend entices her beau into bed with Bud Light, but he slides on the satin sheets and flies out the apartment window.
2003XXXVIIBudweiserSpoofing the instant replay challenge rule, a real zebra reviews a disputed call, holding up a football game between Clydesdale horses. One of the two humans watching calls the "official" a jackass, while the other, apparently oblivious to the epithet, seriously responds that it's a zebra.
2004XXXVIIIBud LightTwo dog trainers outdo one another, until one dog bites the other trainer in the groin. This came in the midst of the aftermath of the controversial halftime show that year.
2005XXXIXBud LightA frightened skydiver (Jonny Lee) making his first jump is enticed with a six-pack of beer, but it only makes the plane's pilot jump after it.
2006XLBud LightA guy stocks his refrigerator full of Bud Light, and to keep his friends from drinking it, he installs it on a turntable. However, the turntable rotates into the apartment next door, and the guys inside are extremely happy to see the "magic fridge" return, even to the point of worshiping it.
2007XLIBudweiserComputer-generated crabs idolize a cooler filled with Bud.
2008XLIIBudweiserPaying tribute to the 1976 Academy Award Best Picture Rocky, a Clydesdale is inspired by a rather unusual personal trainer to become a member of the hitch team for the iconic horse-drawn wagon: its dalmatian mascot.
2009XLIIIDoritosIn the first ever fan-generated commercial to claim top ranking, two men use a snow globe to grant their wishes. One throws it at (and breaks the glass front panel of) a vending machine and gets his wish for "free" Doritos. The other wishes for a promotion, but accidentally throws it at his boss's groin. The ad makers, Joe and David Herbert of Batesville, Indiana, won US$1 million in a promotion sponsored by Doritos owner PepsiCo.
2010XLIVSnickersOctogenarian performers Betty White and Abe Vigoda play tackle football.
2011
(tie)
XLVBud LightDog sitting. A guy sits intelligent dogs with a refrigerator full of Bud Light, and gets the intelligent dogs to cater a party for him serving said product. In a last shot, the dogs are playing cards with the guy picking up after them.
DoritosA boyfriend teases his girlfriend's pug with Doritos, closes and stands behind a glass door, causing the pug to run towards him, the pug knocks down the glass door to be on top of the boyfriend and gets the Doritos. This ad, because of the tie, was awarded $1 million from PepsiCo, the second time in three years an ad created by online users won.
2012XLVIDoritos (panel; online)Another low-budget dog ad from Doritos won the creator, Jonathan Friedman (who lives in Virginia Beach, Virginia), the third $1 million bonus offered by PepsiCo in four years by having the owner of a cat bribed by his dog with a small bag of the sponsor's product in the panel voting. Cost of the ad was $20. The online winner, announced February 7, was another fan-made Doritos ad called "Sling Baby", created by West Los Angeles resident Kevin Willson. The ad featured 17-month-old Jonah Folk, who was used by his grandmother to steal a bag of Doritos from a boy who was taunting them with the bag. They achieved this by using the baby's chair as a slingshot. The prize money of $1 million was divided among cast and crew, including Folk's father, who worked on the special effects.
2013XLVIIBudweiserA Clydesdale is born. Three years later, the Clydesdales come to town. The owner has an emotional reunion with the Clydesdale born at his farm. (The real life foal was born eighteen days before the ad aired.) The ad is set to "Landslide" by Fleetwood Mac.
2014XLVIIIBudweiserA puppy from an adoption agency runs off to a farm to play with a Clydesdale horse. Every time he does that he goes back to the adoption agency. When he is adopted by a customer, the Clydesdales run out and take the puppy and the horse owner decides to keep it. The ad is set to "Let Her Go" by Passenger.
2015XLIXBudweiserA lost puppy finds its way home and then is saved from trouble by some very powerful friends, namely some Clydesdale horses.[3]
201650HyundaiKevin Hart plays the role of a helicopter parent during his daughter's first date, using a car finder GPS app to track the Hyundai Genesis that she and her boyfriend are driving and following them wherever they go (including, at one point, from an actual helicopter). The ad is set to "Another One Bites the Dust" by Queen.[4]
2017LIKiaMelissa McCarthy plays the role of a woman sent to protect the environment, but gets involved in various calamities. The ad is set to "Holding Out for a Hero" by Bonnie Tyler.
2018LIIAmazon.comAlexa has lost her voice, and celebrities like Anthony Hopkins, Rebel Wilson and Cardi B help out. The ad features "Nobody Does It Better" by Carly Simon. It barely beat out an NFL ad starring Eli Manning and Odell Beckham Jr. that parodied the film Dirty Dancing.[5]
2019LIIINFLMarshawn Lynch knocks a football centerpiece off a cake during a gala celebrating the NFL's 100th season, prompting a fight for the ball involving over 40 current and past players.[6] [7]
2020LIVJeepPhil Connors (Bill Murray reprising his role from Groundhog Day) awakens, transported back to the 1993 Punxsutawney time loop but this time finding a Jeep Gladiator. He takes the Jeep, along with Punxsutawney Phil, to go on several off-road adventures.[8] [9] Stephen Tobolowsky also guest stars, reprising his role of insurance-selling "pest" Ned Ryerson.
2021LVRocket MortgageTracy Morgan shows a family why "pretty sure" is not a good thing, from encountering a bear to fighting Dave Bautista, while touting that "certain" is better in terms of buying a house with Rocket Mortgage.[10]
2022LVIRocket MortgageAnna Kendrick stars in an apparent commercial for a Barbie toy house, when they are faced with the grim modern realities of homebuying. However, Kendrick shows Barbie getting her Malibu home with the help of Rocket Mortgage.[11]
2023LVIIThe Farmer's DogA Chocolate Labrador grows up with a girl who grows up alongside him. The ad is set to the song "Forever" by Lee Fields.[12]
2024LVIIIState FarmA State Farm agent played by Arnold Schwarzenegger is struggling to say neighbor instead saying "neighbaaa". He then gets help from Jake from State Farm and Danny DeVito and is able to complete the line "Like A Good Neighbor, State Farm Is There".[13]

Multiple winners

External links

Notes and References

  1. Super Bowl LII: How much does an ad cost?. Sports Illustrated. February 13, 2018.
  2. Web site: Why USA Today's Ad Meter will get the Super Bowl wrong — again. Marketing Dive. en-US. 2020-05-18.
  3. Web site: Budweiser 'Lost Dog' finds way to top of Super Bowl Ad Meter . .
  4. Web site: The 5 best Super Bowl 50 commercials on Ad Meter . 8 February 2016 .
  5. Web site: Amazon edges NFL in Ad Meter Even Closer Than Super Bowl LII. usatoday.com. 5 February 2018 . February 5, 2018.
  6. Web site: Just about every past and present NFL star showed up in the NFL 100 Super Bowl ad. Yahoo! Sports. 4 February 2019 . en-US. 2019-02-04.
  7. Web site: Super Bowl 2019: See the epic 'NFL 100' ad. 2019-02-04. For The Win. en. 2019-02-04.
  8. Web site: Jeep, Bill Murray win USA Today Ad Meter with hilarious 'Groundhog Day' homage. 2020-02-03. USA Today. en. 2020-02-03.
  9. Web site: Jeep's 'Groundhog Day' commercial wins USA Today's Super Bowl Ad Meter. 2020-02-03. adage.com. en. 2020-05-18.
  10. Web site: Rocket Mortgage wins best Super Bowl commercial in USA TODAY's Ad Meter. It took second place, too.. 2021-02-08. USA Today. en. 2021-02-08.
  11. Web site: Lacques. Gabe. Anna Kendrick leads Rocket Mortgage to another Super Bowl victory in USA TODAY's Ad Meter. USA Today. February 14, 2022. February 14, 2022.
  12. Web site: Lacques. Gabe. The Farmer's Dog's emotional Super Bowl commercial earns USA TODAY Ad Meter title. USA Today. February 13, 2023. February 13, 2023.
  13. Web site: 2024-02-12 . The top 10 Super Bowl 58 commercials, according to USA TODAY Ad Meter . 2024-02-12 . USA TODAY Ad Meter . en-US.