Turkic languages explained

Turkic
Region:Eurasia
Familycolor:Altaic
Protoname:Proto-Turkic
Family:One of the world's primary language families
Child1:Common Turkic
Child2:Oghuric
Iso5:trk
Glotto:turk1311
Glottorefname:Turkic
Map:Turkic Languages distribution map.png
Mapcaption:The distribution of the Turkic languages
Ethnicity:Turkic peoples
Date:2020

The Turkic languages are a language family of more than 35[1] documented languages, spoken by the Turkic peoples of Eurasia from Eastern Europe and Southern Europe to Central Asia, East Asia, North Asia (Siberia), and West Asia. The Turkic languages originated in a region of East Asia spanning from Mongolia to Northwest China, where Proto-Turkic is thought to have been spoken,[2] from where they expanded to Central Asia and farther west during the first millennium.[3] They are characterized as a dialect continuum.[4]

Turkic languages are spoken by some 200 million people.[5] The Turkic language with the greatest number of speakers is Turkish, spoken mainly in Anatolia and the Balkans; its native speakers account for about 38% of all Turkic speakers, followed by Uzbek.[3]

Characteristic features such as vowel harmony, agglutination, subject-object-verb order, and lack of grammatical gender, are almost universal within the Turkic family.[3] There is a high degree of mutual intelligibility, upon moderate exposure, among the various Oghuz languages, which include Turkish, Azerbaijani, Turkmen, Qashqai, Chaharmahali Turkic, Gagauz, and Balkan Gagauz Turkish, as well as Oghuz-influenced Crimean Tatar.[6] Other Turkic languages demonstrate varying amounts of mutual intelligibility within their subgroups as well. Although methods of classification vary, the Turkic languages are usually considered to be divided into two branches: Oghur, the only surviving member of which is Chuvash, and Common Turkic, which includes all other Turkic languages.

Turkic languages show many similarities with the Mongolic, Tungusic, Koreanic, and Japonic languages. These similarities have led some linguists (including Talât Tekin) to propose an Altaic language family, though this proposal is widely rejected by historical linguists.[7] [8] Similarities with the Uralic languages even caused these families to be regarded as one for a long time under the Ural-Altaic hypothesis.[9] [10] [11] However, there has not been sufficient evidence to conclude the existence of either of these macrofamilies. The shared characteristics between the languages are attributed presently to extensive prehistoric language contact.

Characteristics

See also: Altaic languages.

Turkic languages are null-subject languages, have vowel harmony (with the notable exception of Uzbek due to strong Persian-Tajik influence), converbs, extensive agglutination by means of suffixes and postpositions, and lack of grammatical articles, noun classes, and grammatical gender. Subject–object–verb word order is universal within the family. In terms of the level of vowel harmony in the Turkic language family, Tuvan is characterized as almost fully harmonic whereas Uzbek is the least harmonic or not harmonic at all. Taking into account the documented historico-linguistic development of Turkic languages overall, both inscriptional and textual, the family provides over one millennium of documented stages as well as scenarios in the linguistic evolution of vowel harmony which, in turn, demonstrates harmony evolution along a confidently definable trajectory[12] Though vowel harmony is a common characteristic of major language families spoken in Inner Eurasia (Mongolic, Tungusic, Uralic and Turkic), the type of harmony found in them differs from each other, specifically, Uralic and Turkic have a shared type of vowel harmony (called palatal vowel harmony) whereas Mongolic and Tungusic represent a different type.

History

See also: Proto-Turkic language, Old Turkic, Turkic peoples and Turkic migration.

Pre-history

The homeland of the Turkic peoples and their language is suggested to be somewhere between the Transcaspian steppe and Northeastern Asia (Manchuria),[13] with genetic evidence pointing to the region near South Siberia and Mongolia as the "Inner Asian Homeland" of the Turkic ethnicity.[14] Similarly several linguists, including Juha Janhunen, Roger Blench and Matthew Spriggs, suggest that modern-day Mongolia is the homeland of the early Turkic language.[15] Relying on Proto-Turkic lexical items about the climate, topography, flora, fauna, people's modes of subsistence, Turkologist Peter Benjamin Golden locates the Proto-Turkic Urheimat in the southern, taiga-steppe zone of the Sayan-Altay region.[16]

Extensive contact took place between Proto-Turks and Proto-Mongols approximately during the first millennium BC; the shared cultural tradition between the two Eurasian nomadic groups is called the "Turco-Mongol" tradition. The two groups shared a similar religion system, Tengrism, and there exists a multitude of evident loanwords between Turkic languages and Mongolic languages. Although the loans were bidirectional, today Turkic loanwords constitute the largest foreign component in Mongolian vocabulary.[17]

Italian historian and philologist Igor de Rachewiltz noted a significant distinction of the Chuvash language from other Turkic languages. According to him, the Chuvash language does not share certain common characteristics with Turkic languages to such a degree that some scholars consider it an independent Chuvash family similar to Uralic and Turkic languages. Turkic classification of Chuvash was seen as a compromise solution for the classification purposes.[18]

Some lexical and extensive typological similarities between Turkic and the nearby Tungusic and Mongolic families, as well as the Korean and Japonic families has in more recent years been instead attributed to prehistoric contact amongst the group, sometimes referred to as the Northeast Asian sprachbund. A more recent (circa first millennium BC) contact between "core Altaic" (Turkic, Mongolic, and Tungusic) is distinguished from this, due to the existence of definitive common words that appear to have been mostly borrowed from Turkic into Mongolic, and later from Mongolic into Tungusic, as Turkic borrowings into Mongolic significantly outnumber Mongolic borrowings into Turkic, and Turkic and Tungusic do not share any words that do not also exist in Mongolic.

Turkic languages also show some Chinese loanwords that point to early contact during the time of Proto-Turkic.[19]

Early written records

The first established records of the Turkic languages are the eighth century AD Orkhon inscriptions by the Göktürks, recording the Old Turkic language, which were discovered in 1889 in the Orkhon Valley in Mongolia. The Compendium of the Turkic Dialects (Divânü Lügati't-Türk), written during the 11th century AD by Kaşgarlı Mahmud of the Kara-Khanid Khanate, constitutes an early linguistic treatment of the family. The Compendium is the first comprehensive dictionary of the Turkic languages and also includes the first known map of the Turkic speakers' geographical distribution. It mainly pertains to the Southwestern branch of the family.[20]

The Codex Cumanicus (12th–13th centuries AD) concerning the Northwestern branch is another early linguistic manual, between the Kipchak language and Latin, used by the Catholic missionaries sent to the Western Cumans inhabiting a region corresponding to present-day Hungary and Romania. The earliest records of the language spoken by Volga Bulgars, debatably the parent or a distant relative of Chuvash language, are dated to the 13th–14th centuries AD.[21] [22]

Geographical expansion and development

With the Turkic expansion during the Early Middle Ages (c. 6th–11th centuries AD), Turkic languages, in the course of just a few centuries, spread across Central Asia, from Siberia to the Mediterranean. Various terminologies from the Turkic languages have passed into Persian, Urdu, Ukrainian, Russian,[23] Chinese, Mongolian, Hungarian and to a lesser extent, Arabic.[24]

The geographical distribution of Turkic-speaking peoples across Eurasia since the Ottoman era ranges from the North-East of Siberia to Turkey in the West.[25] (See picture in the box on the right above.)

For centuries, the Turkic-speaking peoples have migrated extensively and intermingled continuously, and their languages have been influenced mutually and through contact with the surrounding languages, especially the Iranian, Slavic, and Mongolic languages.[26]

This has obscured the historical developments within each language and/or language group, and as a result, there exist several systems to classify the Turkic languages. The modern genetic classification schemes for Turkic are still largely indebted to Samoilovich (1922).

The Turkic languages may be divided into six branches:[27]

In this classification, Oghur Turkic is also referred to as Lir-Turkic, and the other branches are subsumed under the title of Shaz-Turkic or Common Turkic. It is not clear when these two major types of Turkic can be assumed to have diverged.[28]

With less certainty, the Southwestern, Northwestern, Southeastern and Oghur groups may further be summarized as West Turkic, the Northeastern, Kyrgyz-Kipchak, and Arghu (Khalaj) groups as East Turkic.[29]

Geographically and linguistically, the languages of the Northwestern and Southeastern subgroups belong to the central Turkic languages, while the Northeastern and Khalaj languages are the so-called peripheral languages.

Hruschka, et al. (2014)[30] use computational phylogenetic methods to calculate a tree of Turkic based on phonological sound changes.

Schema

The following isoglosses are traditionally used in the classification of the Turkic languages:[31] [27]

Additional isoglosses include:

isoglossOld TurkicTurkishTurkmenAzerbaijaniQashqaiUzbekUyghurTatarKazakhKyrgyzAltayWestern YugurFu-yü GyrgysKhakasTuvanSakha/YakutKhalajChuvash
z/r (nine)toquzdokuzdokuzdoqquzdoqquztoʻqqiztoqquztuɣïztoğyztoɣuztoɣusdohghusdoɣustoɣïstostoɣustoqquztăχăr
  • h- (foot)
adaqayakaýakayaqayaqoyoqayaqayaqaiaqayaqayaqazaqazïχazaχadaqataχhadaqura
  • VdV (foot)
adaqayakaýakayaqayaqoyoqayaqayaqaiaqayaqayaqazaqazïχazaχadaqataχhadaqura
  • (mountain)
tāɣdağ*dagdağdaɣtogʻtaghtawtautaɣdaχtaɣdaɣtıatāɣtu
suffix *-lïɣ (mountainous)tāɣlïɣdağlıdaglydağlıdaɣlïɣtogʻliktaghliqtawlïtaulytōlūtūlutaɣliɣdaɣluɣχayalaaχtullă

*In the standard Istanbul dialect of Turkish, the ğ in dağ and dağlı is not realized as a consonant, but as a slight lengthening of the preceding vowel.

Members

The following table is based mainly upon the classification scheme presented by Lars Johanson.[34] [35]

Proto-TurkicCommon TurkicSouthwestern Common Turkic
(Oghuz)
 
West Oghuz
East Oghuz
South Oghuz
(Arghu) 
Northwestern Common Turkic
(Kipchak)
West Kipchak
North Kipchak
(Volga–Ural Turkic)
South Kipchak
(Aralo-Caspian)
Eastern Kipchak
(Kyrgyz–Kipchak)[40] [41] [42]
Southeastern Common Turkic
(Karluk)
West Karluk
East Karluk
Northeastern Common Turkic
(Siberian)
North Siberian
South SiberianSayan Turkic
Altai and Yenisei Turkic
Oghuric

Vocabulary comparison

The following is a brief comparison of cognates among the basic vocabulary across the Turkic language family (about 60 words). Despite being cognates, some of the words may denote a different meaning.

Empty cells do not necessarily imply that a particular language is lacking a word to describe the concept, but rather that the word for the concept in that language may be formed from another stem and is not cognate with the other words in the row or that a loanword is used in its place.

Also, there may be shifts in the meaning from one language to another, and so the "Common meaning" given is only approximate. In some cases, the form given is found only in some dialects of the language, or a loanword is much more common (e.g. in Turkish, the preferred word for "fire" is the Persian-derived ateş, whereas the native od is dead). Forms are given in native Latin orthographies unless otherwise noted.

Common meaningProto-TurkicOld TurkicTurkishAzerbaijaniKarakhanidQashqaiTurkmenTatarKaraimBashkirKazakhKyrgyzUzbekUyghurSakha/YakutChuvash
father, ancestor
  • ata, *kaŋ
ata, apa, qaŋbaba, atababa, ataapa, atabowa/ataataata, atay ataata, atay ataataotaata ağa atte, aśu, aşşĕ
mother
  • ana, *ög
ana, ögana, anneanaana, eneana/nänäeneana, äni anaana, inä(y)/asay anaene, ana ona, achaana iỹe anne, annü, amăşĕ
son
  • ogul
oɣuloğuloğuloɣul, ohuloğulogulul uvululul uul oʻgʻiloghul uol ıvăl, ul
man
  • ēr, *érkek
ererkekər/erkəkerkekkišierkekir ėrir, irkäk er, erkek er, erkek erkaker er ar/arśın
girl
  • kï̄ŕ
qïzkızqızqɨz qïz/qezgyzqız qɨz qıð qyz qızqizqiz kııs hĕr
person
  • kiĺi, *yạlaŋuk
kiši, yalaŋuqkişikişikiši kişikeşe kišikeşekisi kişi kishikishi kihi śın
bride
  • gélin
kelingelingəlinqalɨŋ gälingelinkilen kelinkilenkelin kelin kelinkelin kiyiit kin
mother-in-law<-- probably a late innovation --><-- no cognate form known -->kaynanaqaynanaqäynänägaýyn eneqayın ana qäynä qaıyn ene qaynene qaynonaqeyinana <-- no cognate form known -->huńama
heart
  • yürek
yürekyürekürəkjürekiräg/ürägýürekyöräk üriak, jürekyöräkjürek cürök yurakyüreksürex çĕre
blood
  • kiān
qankanqanqanqanganqan qanqan qan qanqonqanxaan yun
head
  • baĺč
bašbaşbaşbaš bašbaşbaşbašbaşbasbaşboshbashbaspuś/poś
hair
  • s(i)ač, *kïl
sač, qïlsaç, kılsaç, qılsač, qɨltik/qelsaç, gylçäç, qılčač, sač, qɨlsäs, qılshash, qylçaç, qılsoch, qilsach, qilbattax, kılśüś, hul
eye
  • göŕ
közgözgözközgez/gözgözküzkioź, gozküðközközkoʻzközxarax, köskuś/koś
eyelash
  • kirpik
kirpikkirpikkirpikkirpikkirpigkirpikkerfekkirpikkerpekkirpikkirpikkiprikkirpikkılaman, kirbiihărpăk
ear
  • kulkak
qulqaqkulakqulaqqulaq, qulqaq, qulxaq, qulɣaqqulaqgulakqolaqqulaxqolaqqulaqqulaqquloqqulaqkulgaaxhălha
nose
  • burun
burunburunburunburunburnburunborınburunmoronmurynmurunburunburunmurun, munnumurun
arm
  • kol
qolkolqolqolqolgolqulkolqulqolqolqoʻlqolхolhul
hand
  • el-ig
eligeləleligälel<-- no cognate form known --><-- no cognate form known -->alaqanalaqanilikilikiliială
finger
  • erŋek, *biarŋak
erŋekparmakbarmaqbarmaqburmaqbarmaqbarmaqbarmaxbarmaqbarmaqbarmaqbarmoqbarmaqtarbaqpürne/porńa
fingernail
  • dïrŋak
tïrŋaqtırnakdırnaqtɨrŋaq dïrnaqdyrnaktırnaqtɨrnaxtırnaqtyrnaqtırmaqtirnoqtirnaqtıngıraqçĕrne
knee
  • dīŕ, *dǖŕ
tizdizdiztizle-(to press with one's knees)dizdyzteztɨzteðtizetizetizzatiztobukçĕrśi, çerkuśśi
calf
  • baltïr
baltïrbaldırbaldırbaldɨr ballïrbaldyrbaltırbaldɨrbaltırbaltyrbaltırboldirbaldirballırpıl
foot
  • (h)adak
adaqayakayaqaδaq ayaqaýakayaqajaxayaqaıaqbut, ayaqoyoq, adoqayaqataqura
belly
  • kạrïn
qarïnkarınqarınqarɨn qarngarynqarınqarɨnqarınqarynqarınqorinqerinxarınhırăm
horse
  • (h)at
atatatatatatatatatatatotatatut/ot
cattle
  • dabar
ingek, tabarinek, davar, sığırinək, sığıringek, ingen; tavarseğersygyrsıyırsɨjɨrhıyırsiyruy, sıyır, ineksigir, inaksiyirınaxĕne
dog
  • ït, *köpek
ïtit, köpekitɨt kepägitetit´etıtit, köbökititıtyıtă
fish
  • bālïk
balïqbalıkbalıqbalɨq balïqbalykbalıqbalɨxbalıqbalyqbalıqbaliqbeliqbalıkpulă
louse
  • bït
bitbitbitbitbitbitbetbitbetbıtbitbitbitbıtpıytă/puťă
house
  • eb, *bark
eb, barqev, barkevevävöýöyüy, üvöyüıüyuyöy<-- no cognate form known -->śurt
tent
  • otag, *gerekü
otaɣ, kereküçadır, otağçadır; otaqotaɣ, kereküčadorçadyr; otagçatırodasatırshatyr; otauçatır, otoo, otoqchodir; oʻtoqchadir; otaqotuuçatăr
way
  • yōl
yolyolyoljolyolýolyuljolyuljolcolyoʻlyolsuolśul
bridge
  • köprüg
köprügköprükörpüköprügköpriküperkiopriuküperköpirköpürökoʻprikkövrükkürpekĕper
arrow
  • ok
oqokoxoqox/tirokuqoquqoqoqoʻqoqoxuhă
fire
  • ōt
ōtod, ateş (Pers.)odotototutotutototoʻtotuotvut/vot
ash
  • kül
külkülkülkülkil/külkülkölkulkölkülkülkulkülkülkĕl
water
  • sub, *sïb
subsususuvsusuwsusuhıwsusuusuvsuuuşıv/şu
ship, boat
  • gḗmi
kemigemigəmikemigämiköymägemikämäkemekemekemakeme<-- no cognate form known -->kimĕ
lake
  • kȫl
kölgölgölkölgöl/gelkölkülgiol´külkölkölkoʻlkölküölkülĕ
sun/day
  • güneĺ, *gün
küngüneş, güngünəş, günkün, qujaš gin/güngünqoyaş, könkujašqoyaş, könkünkünquyosh, kunquyash, künkünhĕvel, kun
cloud
  • bulït
bulutbulutbuludbulutbulutbulutbolıtbulutbolotbulutbulutbulutbılıtpĕlĕt
star
  • yultuŕ
yultuzyıldızulduzjulduzulluzýyldyzyoldızjulduzyondoðjuldyzcıldızyulduzyultuzsulusśăltăr
ground, earth
  • toprak
topraqtopraktorpaqtopraq torpaqtopraktufraqtopraq, topraxtupraqtopyraqtopuraqtuproqtupraqtoburaxtăpra
hilltop
  • tepö, *töpö
töpütepetəpətepedepetübätebetübätöbedöbö, töbötepatöpetöbötüpĕ
tree/wood
  • ïgač
ïɣačağaçağacjɨɣač ağaĵagaçağaçahačağasağashbaq, daraq, cığaçyogʻochyahachmas yıvăś
god (Tengri)
  • teŋri, *taŋrï
teŋri, burqantanrıtanrıteŋri tarï/Allah/XodataňrytäñreTieńritäñretäŋiriteñirtangritengritangaratură/toră
sky
  • teŋri, *kȫk
kök, teŋrigökgöykökgey/göygökkükkökkükkökkökkoʻkkökküöxkăvak/koak
long
  • uŕïn
uzunuzunuzunuzunuzunuzynozınuzunoðonuzynuzunuzunuzunuhunvărăm
new
  • yaŋï, *yeŋi
yaŋïyeniyenijaŋɨ yeŋiýaňyyañajɨŋgɨyañıjañacañıyangiyengisañaśĕnĕ
fat
  • semiŕ
semizsemiz, şişmansəmizsemizsemizsimezsemizhimeðsemizsemizsemizsemizemissamăr
full
  • dōlï
toludoludolutoludoludolytulıtolɨtulıtolytoluq, tolu, toluu, tolotoʻlatoluqtolorutulli
white
  • āk, *ürüŋ
āq, ürüŋak, beyaz (Ar.)aqaqakaqaqaqaqaqoqaqürüñ (үрүҥ)şură
black
  • kara
qarakara, siyah (Pers.)qaraqaraqärägaraqaraqaraqaraqaraqaraqoraqaraxarahura, hora
red
  • kïŕïl
qïzïlkızıl, kırmızı (Ar.)qızılqɨzɨl qïzïlgyzylqızılqɨzɨlqıðılqyzylqızılqizilqizilkıhılhĕrlĕ
1
  • bīr
birbirbirbirbirbirberbir, bɨrberbirbirbirbirbiirpĕrre
2
  • éki
ekiikiikiẹki ikkiikiikeekyikeekiekiikkiikkiikkiikkĕ
3
  • üč
üčüçüçüčuǰ, u̇čüçöčüćösüşüčuch/u̇čüch/üçüsviśśĕ, viśĕ, viś
4
  • dȫrt
törtdörtdördtörtderd/dörddörtdürtdörtdürttörttörttoʻrttörttüörttăvattă
5
  • bēĺ(k)
béšbeşbeşbéšbäşbeşbešbišbesbeşbesh/beşbesh/beşbiespillĕk
6
  • altï
altïaltıaltıaltïaltïalty (altï)altïaltïaltïaltyaltıolti (ålti)altäaltault, ultă, ulttă
7
  • yéti
yetiyediyeddijetiyeddiýedicidejediyetejeticetiyettiyettisetteśiççe
8
  • sekiŕ
säkizsekizsəkkizsek(k)iz, sik(k)izsӓkkizsekizsigezsekizhigeðsegizsegizsäkkizsäkkizaɣïssakkăr, sakăr
9
  • tokuŕ
toquzdokuzdoqquztoquzdoġġuzdokuztugïztoɣuztuɣïðtoğyztoğuzto’qqiztoqquztoɣustăxxăr, tăxăr
10
  • ōn
ononononononunonunononoʻnonuonvunnă, vună, vun
20
  • yẹgirmi
yigirmi/yégirmiyirmiiyirmiyigirmi, yigirmeigirmi, iyirmiyigrimiyegermeyigirmiyegermejiyirmacıyırmayigirmäyigirmäsüürbeśirĕm
30
  • otuŕ
otuzotuzotuzotuzottizotuz (otuð)otuzotuzutïðotyzotuzo’ttizottuzotutvătăr
40
  • kïrk
qïrqkırkqırxqïrqġèrḫ (ɢərx)kyrk (kïrk)qırq (qïrq)kïrxqïrqqyryqqırqqirqqirqtüört uonxĕrĕx
50
  • ellig
äligelliǝlli (älli)el(l)igälli, ẹllielliilleeluelüü
60
  • altmïĺ
altmïšaltmışaltmış (altmïš)altmïšaltmïšaltmyş (altmïš)altmïšaltïmïšaltïmïšalpysaltımışoltmish (åltmiš)altmišalta uonultmăl
70
  • yẹtmiĺ
yētmiš/syetmişyetmişyetmišyetmišýetmiş (yetmiš)ǰitmešyetmiš/syetmešjetpiscetimişyetmišyätmišsette uonśitmĕl
80
  • sekiŕ ōn
säkiz onseksensǝksǝn (säksän)seksünsӓɣsensegsenseksenseksen, seksanhikhenseksenseksensakson (säksån)säksänaɣïs uonsakăr vun(ă)
90
  • dokuŕ ōn
toquz ondoksandoxsantoqsantogsantuksantoksan, toxsantukhantoqsantoqsonto'qson (tȯksån)toqsantoɣus uontăxăr vun(ă), tăxăr vunnă
100
  • yǖŕ
yüzyüzyüzjüz iz/yüzýüzyözjiz, juz, jüzyöðjüzcüzyuzyüzsüüsśĕr
1000
  • bïŋ
bïŋbinminmiŋ, menminmüň (müŋ)meŋmin, binmeŋmyñmiñming (miŋ)miŋtïhïïnčapin
Common meaningProto-TurkicOld TurkicTurkishAzerbaijaniKarakhanidQashqaiTurkmenTatarKaraimBashkirKazakhKyrgyzUzbekUyghurSakha/YakutChuvash

Azerbaijani "ǝ" and "ä": IPA /æ/

Azerbaijani "q": IPA /g/, word-final "q": IPA /x/

Turkish and Azerbaijani "ı", Karakhanid "ɨ", Turkmen "y", and Sakha "ï": IPA /ɯ/

Turkmen "ň", Karakhanid "ŋ": IPA /ŋ/

Turkish and Azerbaijani "y",Turkmen "ý" and "j" in other languages: IPA /j/

All "ş" and "š" letters: IPA /ʃ/

All "ç" and "č" letters: IPA /t͡ʃ/

Kyrgyz "c": IPA /d͡ʒ/

Kazakh "j": IPA /ʒ/

Other possible relations

The Turkic language family is currently regarded as one of the world's primary language families.[10] Turkic is one of the main members of the controversial Altaic language family, but Altaic currently lacks support from a majority of linguists. None of the theories linking Turkic languages to other families have a wide degree of acceptance at present. Shared features with languages grouped together as Altaic have been interpreted by most mainstream linguists to be the result of a sprachbund.[54]

Korean

The possibility of a genetic relation between Turkic and Korean, independently from Altaic, is suggested by some linguists.[55] [56] [57] The linguist Kabak (2004) of the University of Würzburg states that Turkic and Korean share similar phonology as well as morphology. Li Yong-Sŏng (2014) suggest that there are several cognates between Turkic and Old Korean. He states that these supposed cognates can be useful to reconstruct the early Turkic language. According to him, words related to nature, earth and ruling but especially to the sky and stars seem to be cognates.

The linguist Choi suggested already in 1996 a close relationship between Turkic and Korean regardless of any Altaic connections:Many historians also point out a close non-linguistic relationship between Turkic peoples and Koreans.[58] Especially close were the relations between the Göktürks and Goguryeo.[59]

Uralic

Some linguists suggested a relation to Uralic languages, especially to the Ugric languages. This view is rejected and seen as obsolete by mainstream linguists. Similarities are because of language contact and borrowings mostly from Turkic into Ugric languages. Stachowski (2015) states that any relation between Turkic and Uralic must be a contact one.[60]

See also

Further reading

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: ХРОНОЛОГИЯ ТЮРКСКИХ ЯЗЫКОВ И ЛИНГВИСТИЧЕСКИЕ КОНТАКТЫ РАННИХ ТЮРКОВ . Dybo A.V. . Chronology of Turkish Languages and Linguistic Contacts of Early Turks . 2007 . 766 . 2020-04-01 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20050311224856/http://altaica.narod.ru/LIBRARY/xronol_tu.pdf . 2005-03-11 . ru.
  2. Book: Janhunen, Juha. Shared Grammaticalization: With Special Focus on the Transeurasian Languages. https://books.google.com/books?id=3J_6U8N2Wq8C&pg=PA223. Juha Janhunen. Martine Irma Robbeets. Hubert Cuyckens. 223. Personal pronouns in Core Altaic. 2013. John Benjamins . 9789027205995. 19 April 2017. 15 January 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20230115124027/https://books.google.com/books?id=3J_6U8N2Wq8C&pg=PA223. live.
  3. Book: Katzner, Kenneth. Kenneth Katzner. Languages of the World, Third Edition. Routledge, an imprint of Taylor & Francis Books Ltd.. March 2002. 978-0-415-25004-7.
  4. Book: Grenoble, L.A.. Language Policy in the Soviet Union. Springer. 2003. 9781402012983. 10.
  5. Book: Rybatzki, Volker . Altaic Languages: Tungusic, Mongolic, Turkic . Martine Robbeets . Alexander Savelyev . The Oxford Guide to the Transeurasian Languages . 2020 . Oxford University Press . 22–28 . 10.1093/oso/9780198804628.003.0003.
  6. Web site: UCLA International Institute, Center for World Languages. Language Materials Project: Turkish. 2007-04-26. February 2007. https://web.archive.org/web/20071011180149/http://lmp.ucla.edu/Profile.aspx?menu=004&LangID=67. 11 October 2007. dead. dmy-all.
  7. Vovin . Alexander . 2005 . The end of the Altaic controversy: In memory of Gerhard Doerfer . Central Asiatic Journal . 49 . 1 . 71–132 . 41928378.
  8. Georg . Stefan . Michalove . Peter A. . Ramer . Alexis Manaster . Sidwell . Paul J. . 1999 . Telling general linguists about Altaic . Journal of Linguistics . 35 . 1 . 65–98 . 10.1017/S0022226798007312 . 4176504. 144613877 .
  9. Sinor, 1988, p.710
  10. George van DRIEM: Handbuch der Orientalistik. Volume 1 Part 10. BRILL 2001. Page 336
  11. M. A. Castrén, Nordische Reisen und Forschungen. V, St.-Petersburg, 1849
  12. Book: Artificial Life 8. 391. 9780262692816 . Standish . Russell K. . Bedau . Mark . Abbass . Hussein A. . 25 August 2023 . MIT Press .
  13. Yunusbayev . Bayazit . Metspalu . Mait . Metspalu . Ene . Valeev . Albert . Litvinov . Sergei . Valiev . Ruslan . Akhmetova . Vita . Balanovska . Elena . Balanovsky . Oleg . 3 . 2015-04-21 . The Genetic Legacy of the Expansion of Turkic-Speaking Nomads across Eurasia . PLOS Genetics . 11 . 4 . e1005068 . 10.1371/journal.pgen.1005068 . 1553-7390 . 4405460 . 25898006 . The origin and early dispersal history of the Turkic peoples is disputed, with candidates for their ancient homeland ranging from the Transcaspian steppe to Manchuria in Northeast Asia, . free .
  14. Yunusbayev . Bayazit . Metspalu . Mait . Metspalu . Ene . Valeev . Albert . Litvinov . Sergei . Valiev . Ruslan . Akhmetova . Vita . Balanovska . Elena . Balanovsky . Oleg . 3 . 2015-04-21 . The Genetic Legacy of the Expansion of Turkic-Speaking Nomads across Eurasia . PLOS Genetics . 11 . 4 . e1005068 . 10.1371/journal.pgen.1005068 . 1553-7390 . 4405460 . 25898006 . "Thus, our study provides the first genetic evidence supporting one of the previously hypothesized IAHs to be near Mongolia and South Siberia." . free .
  15. Book: Archaeology and Language II: Archaeological Data and Linguistic Hypotheses . Blench . Roger . Spriggs . Matthew . 2003 . Routledge . 9781134828692 . en . 203 . 9 April 2020 . 15 January 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230115124027/https://books.google.com/books?id=48iKiprsRMwC&pg=PA203 . live .
  16. Golden, Peter Benjamin (2011). "Ethnogenesis in the tribal zone: The Shaping of the Turks". Studies on the peoples and cultures of the Eurasian steppes. . Bucureşti: Ed. Acad. Române. pp. 35–37.
  17. Clark . Larry V. . 1980 . Turkic Loanwords in Mongol, I: The Treatment of Non-initial S, Z, Š, Č . . 24 . 1/2 . 36–59 . 41927278.
  18. Rachewiltz, Igor de. Introduction to Altaic philology: Turkic, Mongolian, Manchu / by Igor de Rachewiltz and Volker Rybatzki; with the collaboration of Hung Chin-fu. p. cm. — (Handbook of Oriental Studies = Handbuch der Orientalistik. Section 8, Central Asia; 20). — Leiden; Boston, 2010. — P. 7.
  19. Book: The Turkic Languages. Johanson. Lars. Johanson. Éva Ágnes Csató. 2015-04-29. Routledge. 9781136825279. en. 22 November 2020. 15 January 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20230115124027/https://books.google.com/books?id=Z7i5CAAAQBAJ&q=turkic+mongolian+related&pg=PA76. live.
  20. Book: Soucek, Svat. A History of Inner Asia. registration. Cambridge University Press. March 2000. 978-0-521-65169-1.
  21. Book: The Turkic Languages . 2021 . Routledge . 9781003243809 . Johanson . Lars . 10.4324/9781003243809 . "Another Turkic people in the Volga area are the Chuvash, who, like the Tatars, regard themselves as descendants of the Volga Bulghars in the historical and cultural sense. It is clear that Chuvash belongs to the Oghur branch of Turkic, as the language of the Volga Bulghars did, but no direct evidence for diachronic development between the two has been established. As there were several distinct Oghur languages in the Middle Ages, Volga Bulghar could represent one of these and Chuvash another." . Csató . Éva Á.
  22. Agyagási . K. . 2020 . A Volga Bulgarian Classifier: A Historical and Areal Linguistic Study . University of Debrecen . en . 3 . 9 . "Modern Chuvash is the only descendant language of the Ogur branch.The ancestors of its speakers left the Khazar Empire in the 8th century and migrated to the region at the confluence of the Volga and Kama rivers, where they founded the Volga Bulgarian Empire in the 10th century. In the central Volga region three Volga Bulgarian dialects developed, and Chuvash is the descendant of the 3rd dialect of Volga Bulgarian (Agyagási 2019: 160–183). Sources refer to it as a separate language beginning with 1508".
  23. Poppe. Nicolas J.. A Survey of Studies of Turkic Loan-Words in the Russian Language. 1966. Central Asiatic Journal. 11. 4. 287–310. 41926932. 0008-9192. 28 November 2021. 28 November 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20211128225545/https://www.jstor.org/stable/41926932. live.
  24. Book: Findley, Carter V.. The Turks in World History. Oxford University Press. October 2004. 978-0-19-517726-8.
  25. http://www.ethnologue.com/show_family.asp?subid=90010 Turkic Language tree
  26. Book: Johanson . Discoveries on the Turkic linguistic map . Swedish Research Institute in Istanbul . 2001 . 91-86884-10-7 . Stockholm . 2001 . July 17, 2024.
  27. Lars Johanson, The History of Turkic. In Lars Johanson & Éva Ágnes Csató (eds), The Turkic Languages, London, New York: Routledge, 81–125, 1998.Classification of Turkic languages
  28. See the main article on Lir-Turkic.
  29. Web site: Gordon, Raymond G. Jr. . Ethnologue. Ethnologue: Languages of the World, Fifteenth edition. Language Family Trees – Turkic. 2007-03-18. 2005. 14 September 2012. https://web.archive.org/web/20120914151437/http://www.ethnologue.com/show_family.asp?subid=90010. live. The reliability of Ethnologue lies mainly in its statistics whereas its framework for the internal classification of Turkic is still based largely on Baskakov (1962) and the collective work in Deny et al. (1959–1964). A more up-to-date alternative to classifying these languages on internal comparative grounds is to be found in the work of Johanson and his co-workers.
  30. 10.1016/j.cub.2014.10.064 . 25532895 . 4291143 . Detecting Regular Sound Changes in Linguistics as Events of Concerted Evolution 10.1016/j.cub.2014.10.064 . Current Biology . 25 . 1 . 1–9 . 2015 . Hruschka . Daniel J. . Branford . Simon . Smith . Eric D. . Wilkins . Jon . Meade . Andrew . Pagel . Mark . Bhattacharya . Tanmoy .
  31. Book: Самойлович, А. Н.. Alexander Samoylovich. 1922. ru:Некоторые дополнения к классификации турецких языков. http://xn--90ax2c.xn--p1ai/catalog/000200_000018_RU_NLR_INFOCOMM15_1000117889/. ru. 19 July 2018. 19 July 2018. https://web.archive.org/web/20180719203843/http://xn--90ax2c.xn--p1ai/catalog/000200_000018_RU_NLR_INFOCOMM15_1000117889/. dead.
  32. Larry Clark, "Chuvash", in The Turkic Languages, eds. Lars Johanson & Éva Ágnes Csató (London–NY: Routledge, 2006), 434–452.
  33. Anton Antonov & Guillaume Jacques, "Turkic kümüš 'silver' and the lambdaism vs sigmatism debate", Turkic Languages 15, no. 2 (2012): 151–70.
  34. Lars Johanson, "The classification of the Turkic languages", in Martine Robbeets and Alexander Savelyev (eds.), The Oxford Guide to the Transeurasian Languages, 2020, Oxford University Press, pp. 105–114
  35. Web site: turcologica. 18 June 2021. 8 April 2011. https://web.archive.org/web/20110408063746/http://www.turkiclanguages.com/www/classification.html. live.
  36. Deviating. Historically developed from Southwestern (Oghuz) (Johanson 1998) http://www.turkiclanguages.com/www/classification.html
  37. Johanson, Lars & Éva Agnes Csató (ed.). 1998. The Turkic languages. London: Routledge. 82-83p.
  38. https://glottolog.org/resource/languoid/id/urum1249 Urum
  39. https://glottolog.org/resource/languoid/id/krym1236 Krymchak
  40. Baskakov . N. A. . Nikolai Baskakov (linguist) . 1958 . La Classification des Dialectes de la Langue Turque d'Altaï . Acta Orientalia Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae . 8 . 9–15 . 0001-6446 . fr.
  41. Book: Baskakov . N. A. . Nikolai Baskakov (linguist) . Введение в изучение тюркских языков . Introduction to the study of the Turkic languages . Moscow . Nauka . ru . 1969.
  42. Encyclopedia: Алтайский язык . Altai language . Kormushin, I. V. . ru . 2018 . Большая российская энциклопедия/Great Russian Encyclopedia Online . 31 July 2021 . 27 July 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210727181345/https://bigenc.ru/linguistics/text/5199785 . live .
  43. https://glottolog.org/resource/languoid/id/ilit1241 Ili Turki
  44. Web site: The Soyot Language . Rassadin, V.I. . Endangered Languages of Indigenous Peoples of Siberia . . 2021-07-18 . 3 May 2006 . https://web.archive.org/web/20060503111550/https://lingsib.iea.ras.ru/en/languages/soiot.shtml . live .
  45. Web site: Northern Altai . . 2021-07-16 . 25 November 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20221125141836/https://www.endangeredlanguages.com/lang/3869 . live .
  46. Web site: Kumandin . . 2021-07-15 . 27 November 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20211127000834/https://www.endangeredlanguages.com/lang/10475 . live .
  47. Web site: The Kumandin Language . Bitkeeva, A.N. . Endangered Languages of Indigenous Peoples of Siberia . . 2021-07-16 . 11 July 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210711183413/https://lingsib.iea.ras.ru/en/languages/kumandy.shtml . live .
  48. Web site: The Chelkan Language . Tazranova, A.R. . Endangered Languages of Indigenous Peoples of Siberia . . 2021-07-16 . 11 July 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210711092000/https://lingsib.iea.ras.ru/en/languages/chelkan.shtml . live .
  49. Web site: The Teleut Language . Nevskaya, I.A. . Endangered Languages of Indigenous Peoples of Siberia . . 2021-07-16 . 11 July 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210711092004/https://lingsib.iea.ras.ru/en/languages/teleut.shtml . live .
  50. https://books.google.com/books?id=7XuMAgAAQBAJ&pg=PA7 Coene 2009
  51. Book: Concise Encyclopedia of Languages of the World. Keith . Brown . Sarah . Ogilvie. revised. 2010. Elsevier. 1109. 978-0080877754. 24 April 2014. 15 January 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20230115124042/https://books.google.com/books?id=F2SRqDzB50wC&pg=PA1109. live.
  52. Book: The Mainz Meeting: Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Turkish Linguistics, August 3–6, 1994. Turcologica Series. Lars. Johanson. Contributor Éva Ágnes Csató. 1998. Otto Harrassowitz Verlag. 28. 978-3447038645. 24 April 2014. 15 January 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20230115124028/https://books.google.com/books?id=cgNQdljvk70C&pg=PA28. live.
  53. In Glottolog, Western Yugur is classified as Enisei-East Siberian Turkic.
  54. Janhunen . Juha A. . 2023-01-17 . The Unity and Diversity of Altaic . Annual Review of Linguistics . en . 9 . 1 . 135–154 . 10.1146/annurev-linguistics-030521-042356 . 2333-9683. 10138/355895 . 256126714 . free .
  55. Sibata . Takesi . 1979 . Some syntactic similarities between Turkish, Korean, and Japanese . Central Asiatic Journal . 23 . 3/4 . 293–296 . 0008-9192 . 41927271.
  56. SOME STAR NAMES IN MODERN TURKIC LANGUAGES-I – Yong-Sŏng LI – Academy of Korean Studies Grant funded by the Korean Government (MEST) (AKS-2010-AGC-2101) – Seoul National University 2014
  57. Choi . Han-Woo . 1996 . A comparative study of Korean and Turkic: Is Korean Altaic? . International Journal of Central Asian Studies . 1 . 24 April 2019 . 12 December 2019 . https://web.archive.org/web/20191212190618/http://altaica.ru/LIBRARY/CHOI/choi1996.pdf . live .
  58. Babayar . Gaybullah . 2004 . On the ancient relations between the Turkic and Korean peoples . Journal of Turkic Civilization Studies . 1 . 151–155 . 24 April 2019 . 13 July 2019 . https://web.archive.org/web/20190713025335/http://journals.manas.edu.kg/mjtc/oldarchives/2004/15_779-2047-1-PB.pdf . dead .
  59. Tae-Don . Noh . 2016 . Relations between ancient Korea and Turkey: An examination of contacts between Koguryŏ and the Turkic Khaganate . Seoul Journal of Korean Studies . en . 29 . 2 . 361–369 . 10.1353/seo.2016.0017 . 10371/164838 . 151445857 . 2331-4826 . 24 April 2019 . 24 April 2019 . https://web.archive.org/web/20190424183833/https://muse.jhu.edu/article/646472 . live .
  60. Stachowski . Marek . 2015 . Turkic pronouns against a Uralic background . Iran and the Caucasus . 19 . 1 . 79–86 . 10.1163/1573384X-20150106 . 1609-8498 . 24 April 2019 . 24 November 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20211124081956/https://www.academia.edu/12022061 . live .