Turów Coal Mine Explained

Turów coal mine
Width:280
Pushpin Map:Poland#Lower Silesian Voivodeship
Pushpin Mapsize:280
Place:Bogatynia
State/Province:Lower Silesian Voivodeship
Country:Poland
Owner:Polska Grupa Energetyczna
Products:Coal, Aggregates, Clay
Amount:27,700,000
Opening Year:1904

The Turów coal mine (Polish: Kopalnia Węgla Brunatnego Turów S.A.) or KWB Turów, is a large open pit mine in the southwest of Poland, located outside Bogatynia, Lower Silesia. It feeds the nearby Turów Power Station. In March 2024 a Warsaw court found the EIA for mining from 2026 to be invalid, but the owner is appealing. Unlike the other coal-dependant parts of Poland, a just transition for coal phase-out has not yet been planned as of 2024.[1]

Operations

Situated 55 km west of Jelenia Góra, 80 km east of Dresden, Germany, and 20 km northwest of Liberec, Czech Republic, the Turów mine forms part of an area widely known as the "Black Triangle" due to its past heavy industrial pollution, covering portions of eastern Germany, southwestern Poland and northern Czech Republic.[2] The Turów mine, operated by Polska Grupa Energetyczna, represents one of the largest lignite reserves in Poland, with an estimated reserve of 760 million tonnes of coal.[3] The annual coal production of Turów is around 27.7 million tonnes.

Lignite was found near Turasów in 1740. Between 1836 and 1869, almost 70 shafts were excavated. The owners of these mines organized the joint stock company Hercules in 1904, and three years later began strip mining. In 1925 the cap rock was dumped north of the mine. After the Second World War, in 1947, a Polish organization took the mine over from the Soviet military administration and KWB Turów came into existence.

Power Station

See main article: Turów Power Station. Nearby Turów Power Station is fuelled by lignite extracted from the Turów coal mine. The first unit of the power station was commissioned in 1962. The power station is the fifth largest source of greenhouse emissions in Poland and was the eighth least efficient power station in the EU in 2007.[4] A new 496 MW unit was brought online in May 2021.[5]

In 2022 the plant was the 9th biggest carbon emitter in the European Union, with over 11 million tCO2e.[6]

Legality

The mine's license was set to expire in April 2020, but in March 2020, the Polish government extended it by another six years. The Polish government agreed to PGE Group's wish to continue mining at the site until 2044, when its coal deposits are expected to be fully depleted.[7] Later, the Polish government announced that the mine would be shut down by 2044, claiming this to be in line with the EU's plans to cut emissions.[7] PGE Group's move to expand the mine is facing opposition from the Czech government, as nearby Czech and German communities say that the environmental impact from the mine is severely affecting their quality of life, and threatening survival of several villages close to the border by causing their wells to dry up.[8] [9] [10] According to a geological study, continued mining also risks causing soil subsidence in the German town of Zittau.[10] In February 2021, the Czech Republic sued Poland over the mine at the European Court of Justice, the first time that an EU member state had sued another one over an environmental issue.[11]

In May 2021, Poland defied an injunction by the court that ordered the immediate closure of the mine, claiming it would have an adverse impact on the country's energy system and lead to the loss of thousands of jobs.[12] The claim was refuted by studies of the renewable energy alternatives for the region, which were estimated to produce between 800 and 4,100 jobs more than the coal mine and plant while saving over 13 billion in electricity production costs over 25 years.[13]

Because Poland had not ceased lignite extraction activities at the Turów mine, on 20 September 2021, the Vice-President of the Court ordered Poland to pay the European Commission a daily penalty payment of half a million euros,[14] but the Polish continued to defy the ruling.[15] [16] After Poland settled the case with the Czech Republic in 2022, the Court in 2024 confirmed a fine of 68 million euros for the delay in compliance.[17]

In 2023 the Polish government once again renewed the plant's permit until 2044. The decision is subject to legal proceedings, with one case at Voivodship Administrative Court in Warsaw suspended in 2023 until other proceedings are resolved.[18]

Environmental impact

The Turów coal mine has a significant impact on surrounding areas and their ground and surface waters. An analysis of hydrologist Sylwester Kraśnicki predicts devastating effects on local rivers, including droughts, water shortage, and continued degradation of chemical compositions of the Lusatian Neisse river, among others.[19] Water shortage already causes the surrounding nature to die, while some villages lost access to running water and have to rely on firefighters to deliver water tanks.[20]

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Kulbaczewska-Figat . Małgorzata . 2024-03-21 . The Turów case comes back to court . 2024-04-10 . Cross-border Talks . en-GB.
  2. Web site: Turów Rehabilitation Project. The World's Largest CFB Repowering Project. Foster Wheeler. 2011-10-27. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20120425093344/http://fwei.com/publications/tech_papers/files/TP_CFB_05_04.pdf. 2012-04-25.
  3. Web site: References 1950-2006. Poltegor Engineering. 2010-09-28. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20120313053018/http://www.poltegor.pl/ref/lr2006a.pdf. 2012-03-13.
  4. http://assets.panda.org/downloads/european_dirty_thirty_may_2007.pdf Dirty Thirty, May 2007
  5. Web site: Nowy blok w Elektrowni Turów oddany do eksploatacji - energetyka. 2021-09-24. wnp.pl. pl.
  6. Web site: 2024-06-23. Repeat offenders: coal power plants top the EU emitters list. 2023-05-22. Ember.
  7. Web site: 2021-09-20 . Poland vows to keep coalmine open despite €500,000-a-day ECJ fine . 2021-09-22 . the Guardian . en.
  8. News: Poland prolongs Turow mine life despite international outcry . 6 May 2021 . www.euractiv.com . 30 April 2021.
  9. Web site: Czech Republic To Appeal To European Commission Over Polish Lignite Mining Complex . 14 August 2020.
  10. Web site: Turow: Vast Polish coal mine infuriates the neighbours . BBC News . 21 September 2021 . 16 June 2021.
  11. News: Taylor . Kira . Turow: the Polish coal mine at the centre of regional tensions . 6 May 2021 . www.euractiv.com . 6 May 2021.
  12. Web site: Agence France-Presse. 2021-05-25. Poland defies EU court by refusing to close major brown coalmine. 2021-05-26. the Guardian. en.
  13. Web site: Comparative analysis of the possibility of replacing conventional energy sources with renewable energy sources for the transformation of the turoszów region. Zklaster. 2020-09-28.
  14. Web site: Order of the Vice-President of the Court in Case C-121/21 R: Czech Republic v Poland. Poland is ordered to pay the European Commission a daily penalty payment of €500 000 because it has not ceased lignite extraction activities at Turów mine Such a measure appears necessary in order to strengthen the effectiveness of the interim measures decided upon in the order of 21 May 2021 and to deter that Member State from delaying bringing its conduct into line with that order. 2021-09-20.
  15. Web site: 2021-09-20. Poland vows to keep coalmine open despite €500,000-a-day ECJ fine. 2021-09-20. the Guardian. Daniel Boffey.
  16. 20 September 2021 . Poland is ordered to pay the European Commission a daily penalty payment of €500 000 because it has not ceased lignite extraction activities at Turów mine . Court of Justice of the European Union.
  17. Web site: Nikolaus J.. Kurmayer. 2024-06-23. EU court rules Poland must pay €68m bill in Turow coal mine case. 2024-05-29. www.euractiv.com.
  18. Web site: Bartosz. Sieniawski. 2024-06-23. Polish court discontinues proceedings in Turów mine case. 2023-09-01. www.euractiv.com.
  19. Web site: Kraśnicki. Sylwester. 2019. Przewidywany wpływ rozbudowy odkrywki Turów na jakość i zasoby wód podziemnych i powierzchniowych (Predicted impact of the expansion of the Turów coal mine on the quality and resource of ground and surface waters). 7 October 2021. Eko Unia.
  20. Web site: 2020. Frank Bold Foundation. 7 October 2021. Water or Coal.