Trotsky (TV series) explained

Genre:Biographical
Director:Alexander Kott
Konstantin Statsky
Starring:
Composer:RyanOtter
Cinematography:Sergei Trofimov
Nikolai Bogachov
Language:Russian
Country:Russia
Producer:
Company:Sreda
Network:
Num Series:1
Num Episodes:8

Trotsky (Russian: Троцкий) is a Russian biographical eight-episode television mini-series about Leon Trotsky directed by Alexander Kott and Konstantin Statsky. The series stars Konstantin Khabensky in the title role. It debuted on Channel One in Russia on 6 November 2017[1] [2] for the centenary of the Russian Revolution.[3] [4] The series is a rare high-budget artistic representation of Trotsky in post-Soviet Russia, as his name was a taboo during most of the Soviet period.

A number of professional historians have strongly criticized the mini-series for its historical inaccuracies. This includes the misrepresentation of Soviet personalities including Lenin and Trotsky along with the wider events of the Russian Revolution.[5] [6]

Plot

The series is structured as a series of flashbacks to earlier episodes in Trotsky's life, framed by events during his asylum in Mexico City (1939–1940). The first episode begins in May 1940, on the outskirts of Mexico City, when a group of Mexican Communists dressed as policemen attack Trotsky's house. After shooting into the house for nearly a quarter hour, Trotsky and his wife amazingly survive untouched. Afterwards, he reflects on his situation. Having lost almost all those close to him during his eleven years of exile from the USSR, Trotsky perceives USSR leader Stalin, will relentlessly pursue him until he is dead. Trotsky decides to leave a political testament of how a man from an oppressed minority managed to successfully overthrow the Tsarist regime and establish a new social order. He invites an ideological opponent – a Canadian journalist sympathetic to Stalin – to work with him and write that testament. Each episode of the series then explores a period in his life as an emerging leader of the Communist Revolution who then lost his new power to Stalin.

Cast and characters

Production

The proposal for the series came from Konstantin Ernst, the chief of Channel 1[7] (other series produced by the Sreda production company were offered to TV channels during the screenwriting stage).[8]

According to Elena Afanasieva, Director of Creative Channel Planning Directorate of the Channel 1, less than a year passed since the idea of the series was introduced and until the end of the shooting.[9] Subsequently, Konstantin Ernst confirmed this, saying that another TV series about the revolution that the channel planned to implement was shelved, as a result which he had to urgently appeal to Alexander Tsekalo with a proposal to shoot a series about Trotsky.[10]

Konstantin Khabensky previously portrayed Lev Trotsky in the 2005 TV series Yesenin. According to Konstantin Ernst, producer of both TV series, Khabensky played "incorrectly".[11] Khabensky himself claims that 80% of his role was cut out, and in the new television series he plays Trotsky in accordance with his first idea.[12]

Reception

Release

It premiered on 16 October 2017 at the MIPCOM in Cannes, which was the featured highlight of the "Russian Content Revolution" program.[13]

According to Mediascope, the series started on Channel One on 6 November 2017 with a rating of 4.9% and 14.8%, becoming the most popular TV series of Russian television for the period from 6 to 12 November 2017, having overtaken another series about the October Revolution Demon of the Revolution in the same time slot (rating - 3.6%, share - 9.7%) on Russia-1.[14] At the end of 2018, streaming company Netflix bought the distribution right of the series and made it available on its platform.[15]

Criticism

The series has been criticized for numerous historical inaccuracies in its depiction of Trotsky as a megalomaniacal leader who masterminded the October Revolution, invoking many of the antisemitic tropes used by the anti-communist White movement during the Russian Civil War. Among the many historical falsehoods are that he knew his assassin to be a Stalinist and invited him to write his biography for him.[16] [17] [18] The important (and final) episode of Trotsky's assassination by Ramon Mercader, the NKVD agent, ordered by Joseph Stalin, and the role of his lover Sylvia, who facilitated his admission to Trotsky's household, are totally misconstrued or downplayed. Facing the criticism, Konstantin Ernst, the general producer of the series, insisted that they were aiming to weave a fictionalized narrative around the basic facts of Trotsky's biography rather than making a documentary.[19]

The series has also been criticized by RFE/RL journalist Luke Johnson for "taking contemporary Russia’s anti-revolutionary ideology global" and for being a vehicle for Russian state propaganda, "unmistakably align[ed] with the Kremlin worldview", critical of "Western decadence" and foreign "interference" in Russian domestic affairs.[20]

Awards

The Association of Film and Television Producers in Russia awarded the series in the categories Best Sound, Best Editing, Best Makeup, Best Art Direction, Best Cinematography, Best Special Effects, Best Actress (Olga Sutulova), Best Actor (Konstantin Khabensky), Best TV series.[21] [22]

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Самая долгожданная премьера сезона, многосерийный фильм "Троцкий", на Первом канале уже сегодня. Channel One Russia. The most long-awaited premiere of the season, miniseries "Trotsky", on Channel One will air today. ru.
  2. Web site: Константин Хабенский: "Как человек Троцкий мне неинтересен!". Argumenty i Fakty. Konstantin Khabensky: "As a person, Trotsky is uninteresting to me!. ru. Sergei Yuriev. 5 November 2017 .
  3. Web site: Russian state-run TV marks revolution's centenary with surprise series recounting rise and fall of Leon Trotsky. The Independent. 2017-10-16.
  4. Putin's Russia Wrestles with the Meaning of Trotsky and Revolution. The New Yorker. Joshua Yaffa. 7 November 2017 .
  5. Web site: "Unscientific fiction": Historians about the series "Demon of the Revolution" and "Trotsky" . Кинопоиск . ru.
  6. Book: Daly . Jonathan . Trofimov . Leonid . Seven Myths of the Russian Revolution . 9 February 2023 . Hackett Publishing . 978-1-64792-106-4 . 73 . en.
  7. Web site: Russian Revolution's 'rock'n'roll star' Trotsky gets centenary TV series. The Guardian. 2017-11-03.
  8. Web site: Метод Цекало: как шоумен стал первым российским партнером Netflix. ru. Tsekalo's Method: how a showman became Russia's first Netflix partner. RBK Group.
  9. Web site: Конференция со слушателями: какие сериалы мы смотрим. ru. Conference with listeners: which series we watch. Elena Afanasieva. Echo of Moscow.
  10. Web site: Революция русского контента. Программа Russian content revolution на телевизионном рынке в Каннах. ru. Program Russian content revolution at the television market in Cannes. Elena Afanasieva. Echo of Moscow.
  11. Web site: Константин Эрнст: Троцкий – продюсер революции. Vechernyaya Moskva. ru. Konstantin Ernst: Trotsky - producer of the revolution.
  12. Вечерний Ургант. В гостях у Ивана Константин Хабенский и Ольга Сутулова.(03.11.2017). Evening Urgant. ru. Evening Urgant. Ivan's guests Konstantin Khabensky and Olga Sutulova.(03.11.2017).
  13. Web site: В Канне состоялась мировая премьера российского сериала "Троцкий". TASS. In Cannes occurred the world premiere of Russian series "Trotsky". ru.
  14. Web site: Россия (города 100 тыс.+), 06/11/2017 — 12/11/2017, программы-лидеры по жанрам, телесериалы. Mediascope.
  15. News: Trotsky coming soon to Netflix: Russian revolutionary series to go on online streaming . 25 December 2018 . Tass . 17 December 2018.
  16. Web site: Russian TV series claims Jewish Trotsky masterminded bloody 1917 revolution. Times of Israel. 2017-09-28.
  17. Web site: "Ненаучная фантастика": Историки о сериалах "Демон революции" и "Троцкий". Kinopoisk. ru. "Unscientific fiction": Historians about the series "Demon of the Revolution" and "Trotsky".
  18. Web site: A degraded spectacle of historical falsification and anti-Semitism. World Socialist Web Site. 2017-11-25.
  19. News: Guzeva . Alexandra . 4 reasons to watch 'Trotsky' on Netflix . 25 December 2018 . Russia Beyond . 21 December 2018.
  20. News: Opinion You might be binge-watching Russian propaganda on Netflix. Washington Post. en. 2019-02-21.
  21. Web site: Константин Хабенский и Ольга Сутулова завоевали премию Ассоциации продюсеров кино и ТВ. TASS.
  22. Web site: Фильм "Ким Филби. Тайная война" признан лучшей докудрамой. Rossiyskaya Gazeta. Susanna Alperina.