Dosha Explained

Dosha (Sanskrit: दोषः, IAST: doṣa) is a central term in ayurveda originating from Sanskrit, which can be translated as "that which can cause problems" (literally meaning "fault" or "defect"), and which refers to three categories or types of substances that are believed to be present conceptually in a person's body and mind. These Dosha are assigned specific qualities and functions. These qualities and functions are affected by external and internal stimuli received by the body. Beginning with twentieth-century ayurvedic literature, the "three-dosha theory" (Sanskrit: त्रिदोषोपदेशः,) has described how the quantities and qualities of three fundamental types of substances called wind, bile, and phlegm (Sanskrit: वात, Sanskrit: पित्त, Sanskrit: कफ;,,) fluctuate in the body according to the seasons, time of day, process of digestion, and several other factors and thereby determine changing conditions of growth, aging, health, and disease.[1] [2]

Doshas are considered to shape the physical body according to a natural constitution established at birth, determined by the constitutions of the parents as well as the time of conception and other factors. This natural constitution represents the healthy norm for a balanced state for a particular individual. The particular ratio of the doshas in a person's natural constitution is associated with determining their mind-body type including various physiological and psychological characteristics such as physical appearance, physique, and personality.[3]

The ayurvedic three-dosha theory is often compared to European humorism although it is a distinct system with a separate history. The three-dosha theory has also been compared to astrology and physiognomy in similarly deriving its tenets from ancient philosophy and superstitions. Using them to diagnose or treat disease is considered pseudoscientific.[4] [5] [6]

Role in disease, Roga

Doshas are purely imaginary; their existence is not supported by any evidence.[7]

The ayurvedic notion of doshas describes how bad habits, wrong diet, overwork, etc., may cause relative deficiencies or excesses which cause them to become imbalanced in relation to the natural constitution resulting in a current condition which may potentially lead to disease. For example, an excess of is blamed for mental, nervous, and digestive disorders, including low energy and weakening of all body tissues. Similarly, excess is blamed for blood toxicity, inflammation, and infection. Excess of is blamed for increase in mucus, weight, oedema, and lung disease, etc. The key to managing all doshas is taking care of ; it is taught that this will regulate the other two.[8]

Principles

See also: Mahabhuta, Pancha Bhoota and Prana. The doshas derive their qualities from the five elements (Sanskrit: पञ्चमहाभूत;) of classical Indian philosophy.

Prana, tejas, and ojas

Yoga is a set of disciplines, some that aim to balance and transform energies of the psyche. At the roots of, and are believed to consist of its subtle counterparts called, and . Unlike the doshas, which in excess create diseases, this is believed to promote health, creativity and well-being.

Composition Characteristic
Vayu, Ākāśa Prana, the life force and healing energy of vata (air)
Agni, Jala/Āpas Tejas, inner radiance and healing energy of pitta (fire)
Pṛthvī, Jala/Āpas Ojas, the ultimate energy reserve of the body derived from kapha (water)

Ultimately, ayurveda seeks to reduce disease, particularly those that are chronic, and increase positive health in the body and mind via these three vital essences that aid in renewal and transformation. Increased is associated with enthusiasm, adaptability and creativity, all of which are considered necessary when pursuing a spiritual path in yoga and to enable one to perform. is claimed to provide courage, fearlessness and insight and to be important when making decisions. Lastly, is considered to create peace, confidence and patience to maintain consistent development and sustain continued effort. Eventually, the most important element to develop is, believed to engender physical and psychological endurance. Aims to achieve this include ayurvedic diet, tonic herbs, control of the senses, a devotion and most importantly celibacy.

Criticism

Writing in the Skeptical Inquirer, Harriet Hall likened dosha to horoscope. She found that different online dosha websites gave different results in personalized quizzes, and summarized that "Ayurveda is basically superstition mixed with a soupçon of practical health advice."[4] Professional practitioners of ayurveda in the United States are certified by the National Ayurvedic Medical Association Certification Board, which advocates for the safe and effective practice of ayurveda.[15] Alternative medicines used in ayurvedic treatments have been found to contain harmful levels of lead, mercury, and other heavy metals.[16] [17]

See also

Notes and References

  1. Book: An English translation of the Sushruta samhita, based on original Sanskrit text. Edited and published by Kaviraj Kunja Lal Bhishagratna. With a full and comprehensive introduction, translation of different readings, notes, comparative views, an index, glossary and plates. Susruta. Bhishagratna. Kunja Lal. 1907–1916. Calcutta. Gerstein - University of Toronto.
  2. Book: Wujastyk, Dominik. The Roots of Ayurveda : selections from Sankskrit medical writings. Penguin Books. 1998. 0-14-043680-4. New Delhi. 4, et passim. 38980695.
  3. Shilpa . S . Venkatesha Murthy . Cg . Understanding personality from Ayurvedic perspective for psychological assessment: A case . . 2011 . 32 . 1 . 12–19 . 10.4103/0974-8520.85716. 22131752 . 3215408 . free .
  4. Ayurveda: Ancient Superstition, Not Ancient Wisdom. Harriet. Hall. 21 November 2019. Skeptical Inquirer. 31 August 2020.
  5. Web site: What Are The Dangers Of Legitimizing Ayurveda?. Shravan. Raghavan. 21 November 2019. StateCraft. 31 August 2020.
  6. Web site: The Golden State of Pseudo-Science. Ben. Kavoussi. 10 September 2009. Science-Based Medicine. 31 August 2020.
  7. Web site: Science-Based Medicine . Novella S . Ayurvedic practitioners push for licensing in Colorado . 21 November 2019.
  8. David Frawley, Yoga and Ayurveda: Self-Healing and Self-Realization, 1999
  9. [Monier-Williams]
  10. http://www.ayurvedacollege.com/articles/drhalpern/Vata_Doshas Vata Dosha
  11. Web site: Sanskrit Dictionary. 2020-09-09. sanskritdictionary.com.
  12. Web site: Sanskrit Dictionary. 2020-09-09. sanskritdictionary.com.
  13. Web site: Sanskrit Dictionary. 2020-09-09. sanskritdictionary.com.
  14. Govindaraj. Periyasamy. Nizamuddin. Sheikh. Sharath. Anugula. Jyothi. Vuskamalla. Rotti. Harish. Raval. Ritu. Nayak. Jayakrishna. Bhat. Balakrishna K.. Prasanna. B. V.. 2015-10-29. Genome-wide analysis correlates Ayurveda Prakriti. Scientific Reports. 5. 15786. 10.1038/srep15786. 2045-2322. 4625161. 26511157.
  15. Web site: National Ayurvedic Medical Association Certification Board . 2024-02-10 . National Ayurvedic Medical Association Certification Board . en-US.
  16. Ernst . E. February 2002 . Heavy metals in traditional Indian remedies . European Journal of Clinical Pharmacology . 57. 12. 891–896. 10.1007/s00228-001-0400-y . 11936709. 1698767. 17 November 2022.
  17. Breeher . Laura . Mikulski . Marek . 6 April 2015 . A cluster of lead poisoning among consumers of Ayurvedic medicine . International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Health . 21. 4. 303–307. 10.1179/2049396715Y.0000000009 . 25843124 . 4727589 .