Treasury Select Committee Explained

The House of Commons Treasury Committee (often referred to as the Treasury Select Committee) is a select committee of the House of Commons in the Parliament of the United Kingdom. The committee is responsible for examining and scrutinizing the expenditure, administration and policy of HM Treasury. This includes its agencies and associated bodies, including HM Revenue and Customs, the Bank of England, the Prudential Regulation Authority, the Financial Conduct Authority, and the Royal Mint.

The current chair of the Treasury Select Committee is Harriett Baldwin MP, a Conservative. The position of chair is considered influential, as the holder of the office can scrutinize figures including the Chancellor of the Exchequer, the Governor of the Bank of England, as well as bank executives.[1]

History

The select committee was established in 1979 as the Treasury and Civil Service Committee.[2] Since 2010, the Treasury Committee has taken on new powers, including the right to veto appointments to the independent Office for Budget Responsibility, and has forced the Financial Services Authority to publish a detailed report into its handling of the collapse of Royal Bank of Scotland.[3]

The select committee has been described as an influential one within British politics.[4] [5] In 2016, the committee was described as among the three most powerful select committees in the House of Commons, along with the Public Accounts Committee and the Culture, Media and Sport Committee.[6]

Activities

Valuation Office Agency (VOA) Inquiry

On 1 February 2019, the Treasury Committee launched an inquiry looking into the impact of business rates and any unfairness in the system of rateable valuation operated by the Valuation Office Agency (VOA). The inquiry heard evidence from many businesses and trade organisations.[7] The findings of this inquiry outlined that the service was broken and public confidence had been eroded. In its reply to the inquiry, February 2020, the Government promised to make changes to business rates as part of a fundamental review of the VOA.[8]

Current membership

Following the 2024 United Kingdom general election, chairs and member of committees are yet to be appointed.[9]

2019-2024 Parliament

As of March 2024, the members of the committee was as follows:[10] [11] [12]

MemberPartyConstituency
Harriett Baldwin MP (Chair)Conservative
John Baron MPConservativeBasildon and Billericay
Thérèse Coffey MPConservativeSuffolk Coastal
Samantha Dixon MPLabourCity of Chester
Angela Eagle MPLabourWallasey
Stephen Hammond MPConservativeWimbledon
Drew Hendry MPScottish National Party
Danny Kruger MPConservativeDevizes
Keir Mather MPLabourSelby and Ainsty
Siobhain McDonagh MPLabourMitcham and Morden
Anne Marie Morris MPConservativeNewton Abbot

Changes since 2019

DateOutgoing member
and party
ConstituencyNew member
and party
ConstituencySource
nowrap rowspan=2 11 May 2020Liz Kendall MP (Labour)Leicester WestMike Hill MP (Labour)HartlepoolHansard
Alison McGovern MP (Labour)Wirral SouthSiobhain McDonagh MP (Labour)Mitcham and Morden
16 March 2021Mike Hill MP (Labour)HartlepoolVacantResignation of member from Parliament[13]
20 April 2021VacantEmma Hardy MP (Labour)Kingston upon Hull West and HessleHansard
nowrap 19 October 2021Steve Baker MP (Conservative)WycombeGareth Davies MP (Conservative)Grantham and StamfordHansard
nowrap 14 December 2021Felicity Buchan MP (Conservative)KensingtonKevin Hollinrake MP (Conservative)Thirsk and MaltonHansard
nowrap 26 October 2022Mel Stride MP (Chair, Conservative)Central DevonVacantHansard
nowrap rowspan=2 9 November 2022Harriett Baldwin MP (Conservative)West WorcestershireVacantHansard
VacantHarriett Baldwin MP (Chair, Conservative)West Worcestershire
21 November 2022VacantJohn Baron MP (Conservative)Basildon and BillericayHansard
Gareth Davies MP (Conservative)Grantham and StamfordDanny Kruger MP (Conservative)Devizes
Kevin Hollinrake MP (Conservative)Thirsk and MaltonAndrea Leadsom MP (Conservative)South Northamptonshire
Julie Marson MP (Conservative)Hertford and StortfordAnne Marie Morris MP (Conservative)Newton Abbot
nowrap 16 January 2023Alison Thewliss MP (SNP)Glasgow CentralDouglas Chapman MP (SNP)Dunfermline and West FifeHansard
nowrap 26 June 2023Anthony Browne MP (Conservative)South CambridgeshireJames Duddridge MP (Conservative)Rochford and Southend EastHansard
nowrap 12 September 2023Douglas Chapman MP (SNP)Dunfermline and West FifeDrew Hendry MP (SNP)Inverness, Nairn, Badenoch and StrathspeyHansard
nowrap 20 November 2023Rushanara Ali MP (Labour)Bethnal Green and BowKeir Mather MP (Labour)Selby and AinstyHansard
nowrap rowspan=2 11 December 2023Sir James Duddridge MP (Conservative)Rochford and Southend EastThérèse Coffey MP (Conservative)Suffolk CoastalHansard
Dame Andrea Leadsom MP (Conservative)South NorthamptonshireStephen Hammond MP (Conservative)Wimbledon
11 March 2024Emma Hardy MP (Labour)Kingston upon Hull West and HessleSamantha Dixon MP (Labour)City of ChesterHansard

Past membership lists

2017–2019 Parliament

The chair was elected on 12 July 2017, with the members of the committee being announced on 11 September 2017.[14] [15]

MemberPartyConstituency
Nicky Morgan MP (Chair)ConservativeLoughborough
Rushanara Ali MPLabourBethnal Green and Bow
Charlie Elphicke MPConservativeDover
Stephen Hammond MPConservativeWimbledon
Stewart Hosie MPScottish National PartyDundee East
Alister Jack MPConservativeDumfries and Galloway
Kit Malthouse MPConservativeNorth West Hampshire
Alison McGovern MPLabour and Co-opWirral South
Catherine McKinnell MPLabourNewcastle upon Tyne North
John Mann MPLabourBassetlaw
Wes Streeting MPLabourIlford North

Changes 2017–2019

DateOutgoing member
and party
ConstituencyNew member
and party
ConstituencySource
nowrap 20 February 2018Kit Malthouse MP (Conservative)North West HampshireSimon Clarke MP (Conservative)Middlesbrough South and East ClevelandHansard
nowrap 29 October 2018Alister Jack MP (Conservative)Dumfries and GallowayColin Clark MP (Conservative)GordonHansard
nowrap 3 December 2018Stephen Hammond MP (Conservative)WimbledonSteve Baker MP (Conservative)WycombeHansard
nowrap 10 June 2019Stewart Hosie MP (SNP)Dundee EastAlison Thewliss MP (SNP)Glasgow CentralHansard
nowrap 25 July 2019Nicky Morgan MP (Conservative)LoughboroughVacantHansard
nowrap 23 October 2019VacantMel Stride MP (Conservative)Central DevonHansard

2015–2017 Parliament

The chair was elected on 18 June 2015, with members being announced on 8 July 2015.[16] [17]

MemberPartyConstituency
Andrew Tyrie MP (Chair)ConservativeChichester
Steve Baker MPConservativeWycombe
Bill Esterson MPLabourSefton Central
Mark Garnier MPConservativeWyre Forest
Helen Goodman MPLabour and Co-opBishop Auckland
Stephen Hammond MPConservativeWimbledon
George Kerevan MPScottish National PartyEast Lothian
John Mann MPLabourBassetlaw
Chris Philp MPConservativeCroydon South
Jacob Rees-Mogg MPConservativeNorth East Somerset
Wes Streeting MPLabourIlford North

Changes 2015–2017

DateOutgoing member
and party
ConstituencyNew member
and party
ConstituencySource
nowrap 26 October 2015Bill Esterson MP (Labour)Sefton CentralRachel Reeves MP (Labour)Leeds WestHansard
nowrap 31 October 2016Mark Garnier MP (Conservative)Wyre ForestKit Malthouse MP (Conservative)North West HampshireHansard

2010–2015 Parliament

The chair was elected on 10 June 2010, with members being announced on 12 July 2010.[18] [19]

MemberPartyConstituency
Andrew Tyrie MP (Chair)ConservativeChichester
John Cryer MPLabourLeyton and Wanstead
Michael Fallon MPConservativeSevenoaks
Mark Garnier MPConservativeWyre Forest
Stewart Hosie MPScottish National PartyDundee East
Andrea Leadsom MPConservativeSouth Northamptonshire
Andy Love MPLabour and Co-opEdmonton
John Mann MPLabourBassetlaw
George Mudie MPLabourLeeds East
Jesse Norman MPConservativeHereford and South Herefordshire
David Rutley MPConservativeMacclesfield
John Thurso MPLiberal DemocratsCaithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross
Chuka Umunna MPLabourStreatham

Changes 2010–2015

DateOutgoing member
and party
ConstituencyNew member
and party
ConstituencySource
nowrap 29 November 2010David Rutley MP (Conservative)MacclesfieldDavid Ruffley MP (Conservative)Bury St EdmundsHansard
4 July 2011Chuka Umunna MP (Labour)StreathamTom Blenkinsop MP (Labour)Middlesbrough South and
East Cleveland
Hansard
14 November 2011Tom Blenkinsop MP (Labour)Middlesbrough South and
East Cleveland
Pat McFadden MP (Labour)Wolverhampton South EastHansard
John Cryer MP (Labour)Leyton and WansteadTeresa Pearce MP (Labour)Erith and Thamesmead
5 November 2012Michael Fallon MP (Conservative)SevenoaksBrooks Newmark MP (Conservative)BraintreeHansard
12 May 2014Andrea Leadsom MP (Conservative)South NorthamptonshireSteve Baker MP (Conservative)WycombeHansard
12 September 2014Brooks Newmark MP (Conservative)BraintreeAlok Sharma MP (Conservative)Reading WestHansard
24 November 2014Pat McFadden MP (Labour)Wolverhampton South EastRushanara Ali MP (Labour)Bethnal Green and BowHansard
George Mudie MP (Labour)Leeds EastMike Kane MP (Labour)Wythenshawe and Sale East

List of chairs of the Treasury Select Committee

ChairPartyConstituencyFirst electedMethod
Mel StrideConservativeCentral Devon23 October 2019Elected by the House of Commons[20]
Nicky MorganConservativeLoughborough12 July 2017Elected by the House of Commons[21]
Andrew TyrieConservativeChichester10 June 2010Elected by the House of Commons
John McFallLabour Co-opWest Dunbartonshire
(Dumbarton 1987–2005)
18 July 2001Elected by the select committee[22]
Giles RadiceLabourNorth Durham17 July 1997Elected by the select committee

Election results

From June 2010 chairs of select committees have been directly elected by a secret ballot of the whole House of Commons using the alternative vote system. Candidates with the fewest votes are eliminated and their votes redistributed until one remaining candidate has more than half of valid votes.[23] Elections are held at the beginning of a parliament or in the event of a vacancy.[24]

29 January 2020[25]
Candidate1st round
Votes%
Mel StrideUnopposed
Not redistributed
Valid votes
23 October 2019[26]
CandidateFirst roundSecond round
Votes%Votes%
Mel Stride23746.426352.1
Kevin Hollinrake16632.517534.7
Harriett Baldwin6212.16713.3
Mark Garnier469.0Eliminated
Not redistributed61.2
Valid votes511505
12 July 2017[27]
Candidate1st round2nd round3rd round4th round5th round
Votes%Votes%Votes%Votes%Votes%
Nicky Morgan20035.120736.422740.525446.429056.2
Jacob Rees-Mogg13623.914124.816028.617932.722643.8
Charlie Elphicke7413.08214.49817.511420.8Eliminated
Richard Bacon6511.47112.57513.4Eliminated
John Penrose6311.16812.0Eliminated
Stephen Hammond325.6Eliminated
Not redistributed10.2101.8234.0549.5
Valid votes570569560547516
17 June 2015[28]
Candidate1st round
Votes%
Andrew TyrieUnopposed
Not redistributed
Valid votes
9 June 2010[29]
Candidate1st round
Votes%
Andrew Tyrie35261.6
Michael Fallon21938.4
Not redistributed
Valid votes571

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Aldrick . Philip . 2022-08-27 . Matt Hancock One of Six MPs Running for Treasury Committee Chair . 2024-01-17 . Bloomberg News.
  2. Web site: Role - Treasury Committee . 2024-01-16 . UK Parliament.
  3. Web site: Tyrie aims to bring 'Sun King' down to earth . George Parker . 26 January 2012 . . 5 May 2012 . 31 January 2012 . https://web.archive.org/web/20120131060009/http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/60bc6cfc-4826-11e1-b1b4-00144feabdc0.html . live .
  4. News: Mason . Rowena . 2017-07-07 . Conservatives battle for chairmanship of powerful Treasury committee . 2024-01-17 . The Guardian . en-GB . 0261-3077.
  5. News: 2017-07-12 . The Guardian view on select committees: chairs of power . 2024-01-17 . The Guardian . en-GB . 0261-3077.
  6. Web site: Ford . James . 2016-03-30 . The Three Most Influential Select Committees . 2024-01-17 . PLMR . en-GB.
  7. Web site: 2019-06-24 . The impact of Business Rates on business inquiry . 2024-01-16 . UK Parliament.
  8. Web site: 2020-02-27 . Government response to Treasury Committee business rates inquiry . 2024-01-17 . GOV.UK . en.
  9. Web site: kelly . Richard . 3 July 2024 . What happens in the Commons after the general election? . UK parliament.
  10. Web site: 6 July 2022 . Treasury Committee - Membership Committee . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20220516225527/https://committees.parliament.uk/committee/158/treasury-committee/membership/ . 16 May 2022 . 6 July 2022 . UK Parliament.
  11. Web site: Committees Volume 737: debated on Tuesday 12 September 2023 . . 12 September 2023 . hansard.parliament.uk . UK Hansard . 15 September 2023 . That Douglas Chapman be discharged from the Treasury Committee and Drew Hendry be added..
  12. Web site: Business without Debate Volume 742: debated on Monday 11 December 2023 . . 11 December 2023 . hansard.parliament.uk . UK Hansard . 17 December 2023 . That Sir James Duddridge and Dame Andrea Leadsom be discharged from the Treasury Committee and Dr Thérèse Coffey and Stephen Hammond be added.—(Sir Bill Wiggin, on behalf of the Committee of Selection.).
  13. News: Allegretti . Aubrey . Elgot . Jessica . Halliday . Josh . Hartlepool Labour MP Mike Hill quits, triggering red wall byelection . 16 July 2022 . The Guardian . 16 March 2021 . en.
  14. Parliament of the United Kingdom . Speaker's Statement: Select Committee Chairs . House of Commons . 12 July 2017 . 627 .
  15. Parliament of the United Kingdom . Business without Debate . House of Commons . 11 September 2017 . 628 .
  16. Parliament of the United Kingdom . Speaker's Statement . House of Commons . 18 June 2015 . 597 .
  17. Parliament of the United Kingdom . Business without Debate . House of Commons . 8 July 2015 . 598 .
  18. Parliament of the United Kingdom . Speaker's Statement . House of Commons . 10 June 2010 . 511 .
  19. Parliament of the United Kingdom . Committees . House of Commons . 12 July 2010 . 513 .
  20. News: Ex-minister Mel Stride elected as head of Treasury committee. 24 October 2019. The Times. 24 October 2019. 24 October 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20191024130642/https://www.thetimes.co.uk/edition/business/ex-minister-mel-stride-elected-as-head-of-treasury-committee-frnzcn6tq. live.
  21. News: Nicky Morgan to lead Treasury committee. BBC News. 12 July 2017. 15 April 2019. 15 April 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20190415040653/https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-40589509. live.
  22. Web site: House of Commons – Treasury – Second Special Report. publications.parliament.uk. 15 April 2019. 15 April 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20190415032252/https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200102/cmselect/cmtreasy/199/19901.htm. live.
  23. Web site: Standing Orders of the House of Commons. publications.parliament.uk. 15 April 2019. 27 March 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20190327090100/https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201314/cmstords/900/body.htm. live.
  24. Chairs of Commons select committees since 2010. Sarah. Priddy. 16 October 2018. UK Parliament. 15 April 2019. Research Briefings. 6 April 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20190406153318/https://researchbriefings.parliament.uk/ResearchBriefing/Summary/SN04400. live.
  25. Web site: Committee Chair Election Results 2020. Treasury Select Committee. 29 January 2020. House of Commons of the United Kingdom. March 7, 2020. 27 February 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20200227071611/https://www.parliament.uk/documents/commons/Results-spreadsheet-SC-Chairs-2020-a.pdf. live.
  26. Treasury Select Committee (23 October 2019) "Treasury Committee Chair Election – Result Sheet" (PDF). House of Commons of the United Kingdom. Retrieved November 11, 2019.
  27. Web site: Committee Chair Election Results . House of Commons of the United Kingdom 2017 . Treasury Select Committee . 12 July 2017 . April 15, 2019 . 12 July 2017 . https://web.archive.org/web/20170712215717/https://www.parliament.uk/documents/commons-committees/Select-Committee-Chair-Results-2017.pdf . live .
  28. Web site: Committee Chair Election Results 2015 . House of Commons of the United Kingdom . Treasury Select Committee . 17 June 2015 . April 15, 2019 . 6 May 2016 . https://web.archive.org/web/20160506102547/http://www.parliament.uk/documents/commons-committees/committee-chair-election-results.pdf . live .
  29. Web site: Committee Chair Election Results 2010 . House of Commons of the United Kingdom . Treasury Select Committee . 9 June 2010 . April 15, 2019 . 5 January 2020 . https://web.archive.org/web/20200105064112/https://www.parliament.uk/documents/commons-committees/chair-elections/Committee-Chair-Results.pdf . live .