Travelgate (South Africa) Explained

Travelgate was one of the first major political corruption scandals in post-apartheid South Africa. It implicated over 30 Members of Parliament (MPs) as accomplices and beneficiaries in a large-scale fraud scheme, under which Parliament unknowingly recompensed MPs and private travel agencies for millions of rands in fictitious travel expenses. The Sunday Times broke the story in July 2004.[1]

The fraud itself revolved around travel vouchers which MPs were granted for covering work-related air travel expenses. These took the form of travel warrants which MPs could use to pay travel agencies for air tickets; travel agents were able to claim payment from Parliament against the warrants.[2] MPs and travel agents colluded to fill out fraudulent travel warrants and bill Parliament for air tickets that were never purchased (or that had been purchased but cancelled and refunded). The money paid by Parliament was kept by the agencies, who transferred some of it to MPs in the form of cash or bookings for car hire or luxury hotel accommodation. In the latter case, MPs were able to duplicate future expense claims to Parliament, for example by claiming mileage expenses on their vehicles while in fact using hired vehicles paid for by the travel agency.[3]

The Scorpions, an elite unit of the National Prosecuting Authority, initiated a large-scale investigation which involved questioning 135 MPs, and PricewaterhouseCoopers was contracted to assist with forensic accounting. The first criminal charges were laid against MPs in January 2005. By 2010, 31 MPs, and several travel agents, had pled guilty to charges against them; none of the cases went to trial.[4] [5] Several resigned.[6]

List of criminal convictions

The following is a partial list of the MPs who pled guilty of fraud or theft charges in connection with Travelgate. They were sentenced to fines and suspended prison sentences. The majority of the convicted MPs were from the governing African National Congress (ANC), but a handful belonged to the opposition Democratic Alliance (DA) and New National Party (NNP).[7]

Member of ParliamentPartyConvictionConviction dateFine in randsCitation
Ruth BhenguANCFraud2005/04R45,000[8]
ANCTheft2009/09R50,000[9]
Bathabile DlaminiANCFraud2006/10R120,000[10]
Beauty DlulaneANCFraud2006/10R120,000
Ndleleni DumaANCTheft2006/10R30,000
Rhoda JoematANCFraud2005/03R80,000[11]
Bruce KannemeyerANCTheft2006/10R40,000
Tsietsi LouwANCTheft2006/10R60,000
Mavis MagaziANCFraud2005/03R60,000
Douglas MaimaneANCTheft2006/10R25,000[12]
Sophie MaineANCFraud2006/10R100,000
Nono MaloyiANCFraud2006/10R60,000
Pamela MnandiANCFraud2005/03R40,000
Garth MngomezuluANCFraud2006/10R100,000
Lewele ModisenyaneANCTheft2006/10R25,000
Angie MolebatsiANCTheft2006/10R25,000
Craig MorkelDAFraud2006/12R25,000[13]
Mildred MpakaANCFraud2005/03R80,000
John NcinaneANCFraud2005/04R80,000
ANCTheft2006/12R20,000
Robert NogumlaANCFraud2006/10R90,000
Danny OliphantANCFraud2006/12R30,000
Randy PieterseANCTheft2006/10R25,000
Charles RedcliffeDAFraud2006/07R70,000[14]
Rodney RhodaNNPFraud2005/04R30,000[15]
Alice SigcawuANCTheft2006/10R50,000
Bangilizwe SoloANCFraud2006/10R100,000
Jabu SosiboANCFraud2006/12R100,000
Tseko TaabeANCFraud2005/03R40,000
Barbara ThomsonANCFraud2006/10R90,000

Notes and References

  1. News: Meldrum . Andrew . 2005-01-24 . 40 accused in South African MPs' fraud case . en-GB . The Guardian . 2023-04-01 . 0261-3077.
  2. News: 7 December 2004 . Beukes to blow the lid off 'travelgate' scam . IOL . 1 April 2023.
  3. Web site: 2006-01-27 . Travelgate: Evidence of huge new fraud . 2023-04-01 . The Mail & Guardian . en-ZA.
  4. Web site: 21 September 2010 . Last travelgate accused pleads guilty . 2023-04-01 . Sunday Times . en-ZA.
  5. News: 22 September 2010 . 'Travelgate' saga finally ends . IOL . 1 April 2023.
  6. Web site: Pressly . Donwald . 23 June 2005 . 'Travelgate' MPs resign . 2023-04-01 . News24 . en-US.
  7. Web site: 2005-09-12 . Travelgate accused appear in court again . 2023-04-01 . The Mail & Guardian . en-ZA.
  8. Web site: 4 April 2005 . Travelgate: 2 MPs plead guilty . 2023-04-01 . News24 . en-US.
  9. Web site: 2009-09-28 . Travelgate MP Booi pleads guilty to theft . 2023-04-01 . The Mail & Guardian . en-ZA.
  10. Web site: 2006-10-16 . Travelgate: 14 plead guilty . 2021-12-13 . The Mail & Guardian . en-ZA.
  11. Web site: 2005-03-18 . First MPs convicted of Travelgate fraud . 2023-04-01 . The Mail & Guardian . en-ZA.
  12. Web site: 2006-10-17 . Travelgate: 'Some less equal than others' . 2023-04-01 . The Mail & Guardian . en-ZA.
  13. Web site: 2006-12-16 . Two more MPs fined in Travelgate scam . 2023-04-01 . The Mail & Guardian . en-ZA.
  14. Web site: 2006-07-27 . Travelgate: R70 000 fine imposed . 2023-05-13 . The Mail & Guardian . en-ZA.
  15. Web site: Jordaan . Willem . 1 April 2005 . Travel scam: NNP man sentenced . 2023-05-15 . News24 . en-US.