Toronto Life Explained

Toronto Life
Editor Title:Editor-in-chief
Editor:Malcolm Johnston
Previous Editor:Sarah Fulford (2008-2022)
John Edward Macfarlane (1992-2007)
Publisher:Jason Maghanoy
Circulation Year:June 2015
Total Circulation:87,929[1]
Company:St. Joseph Media
Country:Canada
Based:Toronto
Language:English
Issn:0049-4194

Toronto Life is a monthly magazine about entertainment, politics and life in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Toronto Life also publishes a number of annual special interest guides about the city, including Real Estate, Stylebook, Eating & Drinking, City Home and Neighbourhoods. Established in 1966, it has been owned by St. Joseph Communications since 2002. Toronto Life has a circulation of 87,929[2] and readership of 890,000.[3] The magazine is a major winner of the Canadian National Magazine Awards, leading current publications with 110 gold awards including 3 awards for Magazine of the Year in 1985, 1989, and 2007.[4] Toronto Life also won the Magazine Grand Prix award at the 2021 National Magazine Awards, with the jury writing that it is "alert to the cultural moment, bold in its journalistic exposés, up-to-the-minute in its services reportage and smart about the platforms it uses to deliver content to readers. The issues its editorial team assembled during the pandemic showed just how relevant and useful a first-class city magazine can be."[5] It is also known for publishing an annual 50 most influential people in Toronto list.[6]

History

Established in November 1966,[7] Toronto Life was purchased by Michael de Pencier in 1972 and held until 2002, when it was sold to St. Joseph Media.[8] The publisher also owns the tourism magazine Where Canada (published in several large cities), Fashion, Wish, Wedding Bells, and several smaller magazines. The current editor-in-chief is Malcolm Johnston, who succeeded long-time editor Sarah Fulford (since 2008) in February 2022.[9]

In 2015, an article titled "Jennifer Pan’s Revenge: The inside story of a golden child, the killers she hired, and the parents she wanted dead"[10] by Karen K. Ho brought the previously relatively obscure Jennifer Pan murder case to international attention.[11] [12]

In October 2018, it was announced that Toronto Life will launch a membership program with access to Toronto Life’s events, as well as special offers from local venues.[13]

Controversies

Libel suits

Successful

In November 1987, Toronto Life published a 50,000-word article on the Reichmanns family written by Elaine Dewar. In January 1988, Paul, Albert and Ralph Reichmann sued Dewar and Toronto Life for $102 million, claiming that the article defamed their family. In 1991, after exhausting the cover of Toronto Life's libel insurance policy, an out-of-court settlement was reached between the parties that saw the article retracted and Toronto Life make “a substantial donation to four charities” designated by the Reichmanns.[14] In its apology, Toronto Life said its article "incorporated many allegations and insinuations about the Reichmann family which ... there was no reasonable basis for" and said it now realized that "none of the allegations and insinuations should ever have been raised." Stephen Trumper, the president of Toronto Life Publishing Co., said “we should have been much more rigorous in that process and more precise in our conclusions,” and that “any and all negative insinuations and allegations in the article... are totally false.”[15]

Unsuccessful

In April 2015, Canadian entrepreneur Michael Elder, the son of Jim Elder, attempted to sue the magazine to prevent publication of a feature about him.[16] Superior Court dismissed the motion for an injunction and awarded the magazine $17,000 in costs.[17]

Unlawful employment practices

In March 2014, Toronto Life was required to shut down its unpaid internship program implemented in 2009, after the Ontario Ministry of Labour declared that its longstanding practice of not paying interns was in contravention of the Employment Standards Act.[18] The magazine responded, saying "The idea that we can start paying everybody completely misunderstands the nature of the economics of the magazine industry at the moment."[19] Toronto Lifes first (unpaid) intern, Derek Finkle, started with the magazine in 1993. During his internship he wrote a cover story for the magazine for free. He weighed in on the controversy saying that he backs the decision of the Ontario Ministry of Labour.[20]

Journalism ethics violations

In December 2014, Toronto Star published an investigation stating that in 2013, the magazine dismissed a feature about 15 women Jian Ghomeshi was dating after the protest of his PR team.[21]

In January 2018, the magazine was accused of hiding a published negative review of steakhouse BlueBlood from its website.[22] [23]

External links

Notes and References

  1. Book: Alliance for Audited Media. October 30, 2016.
  2. Book: Alliance for Audited Media. June 30, 2015.
  3. Web site: Steady as she goes: Toronto Life turns 50. October 14, 2016. Bree. Rody-Mantha. . 2019-01-20.
  4. Web site: National Magazine Awards searchable archive. 2015-12-17.
  5. Web site: 2018-06-20. Magazine Grand Prix. 2021-08-02. National Magazine Awards. en-CA.
  6. Web site: The 50 most influential Torontonians of 2018. 2018-11-15. Toronto Life. en-US. 2019-01-17.
  7. Web site: The weirdest covers from Toronto Life's first 50 years . Toronto Life . 7 November 2019 . 7 June 2016.
  8. Web site: Home Depot enters shelter category. Masthead Publishing Ltd.. 28 September 2006. 2010-10-22. Michael de Pencier, remember, was the long-time proprietor of Key Media, which was sold to St. Joseph Media in February 2002 for an estimated $36 million. Titles included Toronto Life, Fashion, Where Toronto and a stake in Gardening Life..
  9. Web site: New Toronto Life editor-in-chief Malcolm Johnston gives a taste of the 'Best New Restaurants' issue The Star. thestar.com. 15 May 2022. en. 2022-09-22.
  10. News: Jennifer Pan's Revenge: The inside story of a golden child, the killers she hired, and the parents she wanted dead. Ho. Karen K.. 22 July 2015. 9 January 2017. Toronto Life.
  11. News: Tragedy of 'golden' daughter's fall resonates with Asian immigrant children. Wang. Yanan. 27 July 2015. 9 January 2017. Washington Post.
  12. News: Is it possible to love and hate?. 15 August 2015. Northwest Asian Weekly. .
  13. Web site: Toronto Life sets sights on membership program. October 29, 2018. Catherine. Phillips. . 2019-01-20.
  14. Web site: A magazine apology Maclean's FEBRUARY 11, 1991. Deacon. James. Maclean's. en-US. 2020-04-26.
  15. News: A Magazine Apology. February 1991. Toronto Life.
  16. Web site: Toronto Life Stands Ground In Face Of $100-Million Lawsuit From Businessman. 2015-04-23. HuffPost Canada. en. 2019-01-20.
  17. Web site: Court bid against Toronto Life fails to stop publication The Star. thestar.com. 22 April 2015 . en. 2019-01-20.
  18. http://j-source.ca/article/ontario-labour-ministry-cracks-down-unpaid-internships-toronto-life-walrus "Ontario labour ministry cracks down on unpaid internships at Toronto Life, The Walrus"
  19. http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2014/03/27/unpaid-internship-crackdown-toronto-life-walrus_n_5044462.html "Unpaid Internship Crackdown At Toronto Life, The Walrus Magazines"
  20. http://www.thestoryboard.ca/unpaid-internship-conspiracy/ "The Unpaid Internship Conspiracy"
  21. Web site: How Ghomeshi's publicist worked to shut down Toronto Life story The Star. thestar.com. 19 December 2014 . en. 2019-01-20.
  22. Web site: Why Did This Magazine Take Down a Negative Restaurant Review?. Burton. Monica. 2018-01-12. Eater. 2019-01-20.
  23. Web site: Hiltz . Robert . Toronto Life Pulled Down A Critical Review Of An Advertiser's Restaurant . www.canadalandshow.com . 12 January 2018 . 7 November 2019.