Tōkai Nuclear Power Plant Explained

Tōkai Nuclear Power Plant
Image Alt:Tōkai Nuclear Power Plant
Coordinates:36.4664°N 140.6067°W
Country:Japan
Status:Out of service for
Operator:Japan Atomic Power Company
Ps Units Operational:1 × 1100 MW
Ps Units Decommissioned:1 × 166 MW
Np Reactor Type:GCR Magnox, BWR
Np Reactor Supplier:GE Hitachi Shimizu, Fuji Electric GEC
Ps Electrical Capacity:1100
Ps Annual Generation:0
Ps Electrical Cap Fac:0%

The was Japan's first commercial nuclear power plant. The first unit was built in the early 1960s to the British Magnox design, and generated power from 1966 until it was decommissioned in 1998. A second unit, built at the site in the 1970s, was the first in Japan to produce over 1000 MW of electricity.The site is located in Tokai in the Naka District in Ibaraki Prefecture, Japan and is operated by the Japan Atomic Power Company. The total site area amounts to 0.76 km2 (188 acres) with 0.33 km2, or 43% of it, being green area that the company is working to preserve.[1]

The plant has been not operational since the reactor shut down automatically due to the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami.

Reactors on site

UnitTypeAverage electric powerCapacityConstruction startedFirst criticalityCommercial operationClosure
Tōkai IMagnox (GCR) Fuji Electric, Hitachi, GEC (UK), Shimizu159 MW166 MWMarch 1, 1961November 10, 1965July 25, 1966March 31, 1998
Tōkai IIBWR/5[2] GE, GEC, Hitachi, Shimizu1060 MW1100 MWOctober 3, 1973March 13, 1978November 28, 1978Safety upgrade since March 2011

Unit 1

This reactor was built based on the British-developed Magnox technology for dual-use.[3] Unit 1 is the first full-size nuclear reactor to be decommissioned in Japan.[4] The experience in decommissioning this plant is expected to be of use in the future when more Japanese plants are decommissioned. Below is a brief time-line of the process:

Unit 2

Unit 2 is a Boiling Water Reactor and was the first nuclear reactor built in Japan to produce over 1,000 MW of electricity. By some formalities in the paperwork, the unit is technically separate from the rest of the nuclear facilities in Tokai, but it is managed with the rest of them and even shares the same front gate.

History

Tokaimura Accidents

See also: Tokaimura nuclear accidents. Two separate nuclear accidents occurred in the 90s at the Tokai plant and nearby reprocessing facility, both in . In March 1997 a fire broke out in the bituminisation facility where spent fuel is encased in molten asphalt (bitumen) for storage. The event exposed more than 20 people to radiation but there were no direct fatalities.

The second more serious accident occurred on 30 September 1999 when workers, who were not properly trained, brought too much highly enriched uranium together causing a criticality accident. A total of 119 people were exposed to radiation of which 2 were fatal cases.[5]

In 2002, an evaluation technology adopted by the Japan Society of Civil Engineers had determined that the site of the plant could experience tsunami waves as high as 4.86 metres. The government of Ibaraki prefecture published their own calculations in October 2007, where they estimated that such waves could be as high as 6 to 7 metres. Japan Atomic Power changed its wave level assumption to 5.7 meters. Reconstruction works to raise the height of the 4.9-metre protection around the plant to 6.1 meters were started in July 2009, in order to protect the seawater pumps intended to cool an emergency diesel generator. Although most of the work was completed by September 2010, cable holes in the levee were still not fully covered. This work was scheduled to be completed around May 2011. Additions to the seawall that raised it to a height of 6.1 meters were completed on 9 March, just two days before the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami.[6]

In November 2018, the NRA approved a 20-year extension. Following that, the operator will need the consent of the Ibaraki prefectural government, as well as six local municipalities, including the village of Tokai.[7]

2011 earthquake and tsunami

When the tsunami did hit the Tokai plant in March 2011, the waves were 5.3 to 5.4 metres in height, higher than earlier estimations but still 30 to 40 centimetres lower than the most recent estimation. The Tokai plant suffered a loss of external power-supply. The levee was overrun, but only one of three seawater pumps failed, and the reactors could be kept stable and safe in cold shutdown with the emergency diesel generator cooled by the two remaining seawater pumps.[8]

Following the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami, the Number 2 reactor was one of eleven nuclear reactors nationwide to be shut down automatically.[9] It was reported on 14 March that a cooling system pump for the Number 2 reactor had stopped working.[10] Japan Atomic Power Company stated that there was a second operational pump and that cooling was working, but that two of three diesel generators used to power the cooling system were out of order.[11]

Construction work on additional safety measures, including a 1.7 km sea wall to protect from possible tsunamis, was originally scheduled to be completed in March 2021.In 2020 it was announced this was delayed until December 2022.[12]

Stress tests

After the disaster in Fukushima, a stress-test was ordered by the Japanese government, since an investigation of the electrical installations of the Tokai 2 reactor revealed that they did not meet the earthquake-resistance standards set by the government.[13]

Seismic research in 2011 showed that the March 11th quake was caused by the simultaneous movement by multiple active faults off the coast of northern Japan in the Pacific Ocean, and in this way a much bigger earthquakes could be triggered, than the plants were designed to withstand at the time they were built. In March 2012, the Tokai 2 Plant in Ibaraki Prefecture and the Tomari power facility in Hokkaido, said that they could not rule out the possibility that the plants were vulnerable. Other nuclear power stations declared that the active faults near their nuclear plants would not move at the same time, and even when this would happen, the impact would be limited. NISA would look into the evaluation of active faults done by the plants.[14] [15]

In 2017 the Nuclear Regulation Authority discovered that the wrong fuel rod position data had been used in safety evaluations since the plant had been built, consequent to a change to fuel rod specifications during the design and construction process.[16]

Mito District Court injunction

In March 2021, the Mito District Court ordered the Tokai 2 reactor suspend operations, following the request of 224 plaintiffs. The plaintiffs, residents of Ibaraki Prefecture and the Tokyo metropolitan area, filed a lawsuit in 2012 against the operator. One of the key contentions was the appropriateness of the Japan Atomic Power's seismic ground motion figure. The operator defended its basis seismic ground motion figure as 50 percent higher than the average. The plaintiffs contended that the figure should be four times as high as the current figure.[17]

Public opinion

On 11 October 2011 Tatsuya Murakami, the mayor of the village Tokai, said in a meeting with minister Goshi Hosono, that the Tokai 2 reactor situated 110 kilometers from Tokyo should be decommissioned, because the reactor was more than 30 years old, and the people had lost confidence in the nuclear safety commission of the government.[18]

In 2011 and 2012, about 100,000 signatures against the resumption of the plant's operation which shutdown due to the 2011 earthquake, were submitted to Ibaraki Governor Masaru Hashimoto. The petition urged the prefectural government not to allow the Tokai power station to resume operation, saying, "We should not allow a recurrence of the irretrievable sacrifice and loss as experienced in the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant accident".[19]

Reprocessing plant

The Tokai nuclear complex also contained a reprocessing plant built in 1971 that operated from 1981 until 2006. In 2014 it was decided to permanently cease operations because upgrades to match the post-Fukushima safety requirements were uneconomical.[20]

See also

Notes and References

  1. JAPC Official Document (Japanese). Report of Electric Generating Plant Environmental Activities for 2010 .Page 20.
  2. Web site: Reactors in operation. 31 December 2009. IAEA. March 12, 2011.
  3. Manufacture of Pressure Vessel for Nuclear Power Reactor . Tsutomu Nakajima, Kazukiyo Okano and Atsushi Murakami . Fuji Electric Review . 11 . 1 . Fuji Electric Co . 1965 . 17 April 2014.
  4. Permanent cessation of Tokai power plant's operation . Satoh, T (Japan Atomic Power Co) . Directory of National Competent Authorities' Approval Certificates for Package Design, Special Form Material and Shipment of Radioactive Material . IAEA . INIS RN:29059902 . 1011-4289 . September 1997 . 17 April 2014.
  5. Web site: Tokaimura Criticality Accident - World Nuclear Association . 29 March 2024 . world-nuclear.org.
  6. News: ja:防波壁完成、震災2日前…東海第二原発守った . http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/science/news/20120214-OYT1T00001.htm. Yomiuri Shimbun. 2012-02-14. 2012-02-16. ja. Seawall completed 2 days before disaster, plant had protected..
  7. Web site: Aging Tokai nuclear plant outside Tokyo cleared to restart . 7 November 2018 . sightlineu3o8.com . 20 March 2021 . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20210320170259/https://sightlineu3o8.com/2018/11/aging-tokai-nuclear-plant-outside-tokyo-cleared-to-restart/ . 20 March 2021.
  8. The Mainichi Daily News (24 October 2011) New levee prevents total power loss at nuclear plant in Ibaraki
  9. News: Japan earthquake: Evacuations ordered as fears grow of radiation leak at nuclear plant; News.com.au . news.com.au . According to the industry ministry, a total of 11 nuclear reactors automatically shut down at the Onagawa plant, the Fukushima No. 1 and No. 2 plants and the Tokai No. 2 plant after the strongest recorded earthquake in the country's history . 13 March 2011 . 12 March 2011 . 25 July 2012 . https://web.archive.org/web/20120725071921/http://www.news.com.au/world/japan-earthquake-evacuations-ordered-as-fears-grow-of-radiation-leak-at-nuclear-plant/story-e6frfkyi-1226020473244 . dead .
  10. News: Cooling system pump stops at Tokai No.2 plant-Kyodo; Energy & Oil; Reuters. https://web.archive.org/web/20110315223121/http://af.reuters.com/article/energyOilNews/idAFTKG00708120110313 . dead . 15 March 2011 . af.reuters.com . 13 March 2011 . 13 March 2011.
  11. News: Tokai No.2 nuke plant cooling process working – operator | Reuters . Kiyoshi. Takenaka. uk.reuters.com . Japan Atomic Power said Monday that the cooling process was working at its Tokai No.2 nuclear power plant's reactor although two of the three diesel power generators used for cooling were out of order. . 13 March 2011 . 13 March 2011.
  12. News: Safety upgrades impact operation of Japanese units . World Nuclear News . 29 January 2020 . 31 January 2020.
  13. NHK-world (8 July 2011) Nuke plant equipment fails quake-resistance check
  14. NHK-world (1 March 2012) 2 plants to undergo checks for multiple faults
  15. JAIF (1 March 2012)Earthquake report 362: 2 plants to undergo checks for multiple faults
  16. News: Ibaraki nuclear plant used erroneous fuel rod data for over 40 years, utility says . The Japan Times . 23 January 2018 . 23 January 2018.
  17. Web site: Court orders a halt to operation of Tokai No. 2 nuclear plant . 18 March 2021 . www.asahi.com . . 20 March 2021 . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20210318142101/http://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/14280362 . 18 March 2021.
  18. JAIF (12 October 2011)Tokai mayor wants nuclear reactor decommissioned
  19. Web site: Over 100,000 signatures collected for Tokai nuclear plant scrapping . February 11, 2012 . Mainichi Daily . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20120212233147/http://mdn.mainichi.jp/mdnnews/news/20120211p2g00m0dm009000c.html . February 12, 2012 .
  20. Web site: Tokai reprocessing plant to shut - World Nuclear News.