Thompson v. Trump explained

Thompson v. Trump
Court:United States District Court for the District of Columbia
Full Name:Bennie G. Thompson, et al v. Donald J. Trump et al
Citations:No. 1:21-cv-00400
Judges:Amit Mehta
Italic Title:yes

Thompson v. Trump is an ongoing federal civil case filed in February 2021 on behalf of U.S. House Representative Bennie Thompson against former U.S. president Donald Trump. The lawsuit claims that Trump and others conspired to incite the January 6 United States Capitol attack. In February 2022, District of Columbia U.S. District Court Judge Amit Mehta ruled that presidential immunity did not shield Trump from the lawsuit. In March 2022, Trump appealed Mehta's ruling to the U.S. District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals. In December 2023, the Court of Appeals upheld Mehta's ruling.

Background

On February 16, 2021, the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) filed a lawsuit on behalf of Thompson against former President Donald Trump, Rudolph Giuliani, the Proud Boys and the Oath Keepers.[1] The lawsuit centered around the 1871 Ku Klux Klan Act, designed to protect members of Congress from violent conspiracies that interfere with their official Congressional duties.[2] In an interview with The Guardian, NAACP President Derrick Johnson stated that the "former administration and Giuliani sought to disqualify our votes" and accused Trump of "operating under a white supremacist doctrine that was a derived from days of the Confederacy".[3]

On April 7, 2021, ten more Representatives joined the suit as plaintiffs. They were Steve Cohen, Karen Bass, Bonnie Watson Coleman, Veronica Escobar, Hank Johnson, Marcy Kaptur, Barbara Lee, Jerry Nadler, Pramila Jayapal, and Maxine Waters.[4] In July 2021, Representative Thompson withdrew from the suit to avoid any conflict with the January 6 House Select Committee (which he chaired), while the other plaintiffs, who were not on the Committee, moved forward.[5]

Judge Mehta consolidated Thompson v. Trump with two other suits before him—Swalwell v. Trump (brought by Representative Eric Swalwell) and Blassingame v. Trump (brought by two U.S. Capitol Police officers)—to consider whether Trump and the other defendants were immune from liability. The defendants had requested immunity on the grounds of the First Amendment, and those who were elected officials also claimed immunity based on that status. Mehta ruled in February 2022 that presidential immunity did not shield Trump from the lawsuits.[6] Trump then appealed the consolidated cases to the District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals in March 2022, claiming absolute immunity.[7] [8]

In December 2023, the Court of Appeals (with judges Gregory G. Katsas, Judith W. Rogers, and Sri Srinivasan presiding) upheld Mehta's ruling that Trump was not immune because Trump was acting "as an office-seeker not office-holder" due to his speech on January 6 being a campaign event, and as such, did not fall within the "outer perimeter" standard established in Nixon v. Fitzgerald (1982).[9] [10]

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. News: Karni . Annie . N.A.A.C.P. Sues Trump and Giuliani Over Election Fight and Jan. 6 Riot . The New York Times . February 16, 2021 . 30 January 2024 .
  2. Web site: King . Maya . NAACP sues Trump and Giuliani after Jan. 6 riots . . February 16, 2021 . October 1, 2022.
  3. Web site: Evelyn . Kenya . February 26, 2021 . We're suing to hold Trump accountable for 'treasonous acts', NAACP chief says . March 1, 2021 . The Guardian.
  4. Web site: Schneider . Jessica . 2021-04-07 . Ten more members of Congress join lawsuit against Trump and Giuliani CNN Politics . 2024-03-26 . CNN . en.
  5. Web site: Mihm . Karl . Apkon . Jacob . Venkatachalam . Sruthi . January 30, 2023 . Litigation Tracker: Pending Criminal and Civil Cases Against Donald Trump . January 8, 2024 . Just Security.
  6. News: Tau . Byron . February 18, 2022 . Judge Allows Lawsuits to Proceed Against Donald Trump, Militia Groups in Jan 6. Lawsuit . October 5, 2023 . The Wall Street Journal . News Corp.
  7. News: Cheney . Kyle . Gerstein . Josh . November 27, 2023 . Bid to hold Trump accountable for Jan. 6 violence stalls at appeals court . November 29, 2023 . . Axel Springer SE.
  8. News: Barber . C. Ryan . March 2, 2023 . Trump Can Be Sued Over Role in Jan. 6 Attack, Justice Department Says . October 5, 2023 . The Wall Street Journal . News Corp.
  9. News: Polantz . Katelyn . Lybrand . Holmes . December 1, 2023 . Trump doesn't have presidential immunity from lawsuits over January 6, appeals court rules . December 1, 2023 . CNN.
  10. News: Weiner . Rachel . Hsu . Spencer S. . December 1, 2023 . Trump can be held civilly liable in Jan. 6 riot, judges rule . December 1, 2023 . The Washington Post.